Comparative analysis of gnathostome Otx gene expression patterns in the developing eye: implications for the functional evolution of the multigene family.

We have performed a detailed analysis of the expression pattern of the three gnathostome Otx classes in order to gain new insights into their functional evolution. Expression patterns were examined in the developing eye of a chondrichthyan, the dogfish, and an amniote, the chick, and compared with the capacity of paralogous proteins to induce a pigmented phenotype in cultured retina cells in cooperation with the bHLH-leucine zipper protein Mitf. This analysis indicates that each Otx class is characterized by highly specific and conserved expression features in the presumptive RPE, where Otx1 and Otx2, but not Otx5, are transcribed at optic vesicle stages, in the differentiating neural retina, where Otx2 and Otx5 show a conserved dynamic expression pattern, and in the forming ciliary process, a major site of Otx1 expression. Furthermore, the paralogous proteins of the dogfish and the mouse do not display any significant difference in their capacity to induce a pigmented phenotype, suggesting a functional equivalency in the specification and differentiation of the RPE. These data indicate that specific functions selectively involving each Otx orthology class were fixed prior to the gnathostome radiation and highlight the prominent role of regulatory changes in the functional diversification of the multigene family.

Expression patterns of an Otx2 and an Otx5 orthologue in the urodele Pleurodeles waltl: implications on the evolutionary relationships between the balancers and cement gland in amphibians.

We report the characterization of an Otx2 and an Otx5 orthologue in the urodele Pleurodeles waltl. These two genes, termed PwOtx2 and PwOtx5, share highly conserved expression domains with their gnathostome counterparts at tailbud stages, like the developing forebrain ( PwOtx2), or the embryonic eye and epiphysis ( PwOtx5). As in Xenopus laevis, both are also transcribed in the dorsal lip of the blastopore during gastrulation and in anterior parts of the neural plate during neurulation. In addition, PwOtx5 displays a prominent expression in the developing balancers and the lateral non-neural ectoderm during neurulation, from which they derive. By contrast, PwOtx2 expression remains undetectable in the balancers and their presumptive territory. These data suggest that PwOtx5, but not PwOtx2, may be involved in the differentiation and early specification of balancers. Comparisons of Otx5 expression patterns in P. waltland X. laevis embryos suggest that, as previously shown for Otx2, changes in the regulatory mechanisms controlling Otx5 early expression in the non-neural ectoderm may occur frequently among amphibians. These changes may be related to the rise of cement glands in anurans and of balancers in urodeles. This hypothesis could account for some similarities between the two organs, but does not support a homology relationship between them.

Structure and expression of three Emx genes in the dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula: functional and evolutionary implications.

We report the characterization of three Emx genes in a chondrichthyan, the dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula. Comparisons of these genes with their osteichthyan counterparts indicate that the gnathostome Emx genes belong to three distinct orthology classes, each containing one of the dogfish genes and either the tetrapod Emx1 genes (Emx1 class), the osteichthyan Emx2 genes (Emx2 class) or the zebrafish Emx1 gene (Emx3 class). While the three classes could be retrieved from the pufferfish genome data, no indication of an Emx3-related gene in tetrapods could be found in the databases, suggesting that this class may have been lost in this taxon. Expression pattern comparisons of the three dogfish Emx genes and their osteichthyan counterparts indicate that not only telencephalic, but also diencephalic Emx expression territories are highly conserved among gnathostomes. In particular, all gnathostomes share an early, dynamic phase of Emx expression, spanning presumptive dorsal diencephalic territories, which involves Emx3 in the dogfish, but another orthology class, Emx2, in tetrapods. In addition, the dogfish Emx2 gene shows a highly specific expression domain in the cephalic paraxial mesoderm from the end of gastrulation and throughout neurulation, which suggests a role in the segmentation of the cephalic mesoderm.

Structure and expression of an Otx5-related gene in the dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula: evidence for a conserved role of Otx5 and Crxgenes in the specification of photoreceptors.

We report the full-length coding sequence and the expression pattern during neurulation and early organogenesis of ScOtx5, a novel member of the Otx gene family in the dogfish Scyliorhinus canicula. Phylogenetic analyses confirm that ScOtx5 is closely related to the Xenopus XlOtx5/ 5bgenes, and also to the Crx genes characterized in mammals and zebrafish. This supports the hypothesis that these genes define a third gnathostome Otx orthology class. During neurulation, ScOtx5 transcripts are detected in the foregut diverticulum and the anterior neuroectoderm. At the onset of organogenesis, ScOtx5 is transcribed over a broad domain spanning the whole prosencephalon and mesencephalon, albeit with a much lower signal intensity than its paralogues Otx1 and Otx2. At later stages, four major expression sites are observed: the developing eye and epiphysis, the olfactory placodes and a broad epidermal domain in the dorsal part of the head. In the embryonic eye, the signal is first detected in the presumptive pigmented retina and slightly later in the adjacent outer layer of the neural retina, fated to photoreceptors. The comparison of this expression pattern with those of osteichthyan Otx genes suggests that a role in the specification of photoreceptors may correspond to a functional specialization of Otx5and Crx genes, fixed early in the gnathostome lineage, prior to the splitting of chondrichthyans and osteichthyans. In contrast, the roles played by ScOtx5 in the retinal pigmented epithelium or in the olfactory placodes may be fulfilled by different combinations of paralogous genes in other gnathostome taxa.