The role of DNA polymerase I in tolerating single-strand breaks generated at clustered DNA damage in Escherichia coli.

Clustered DNA damage, when multiple lesions are generated in close proximity, has various biological consequences, including cell death, chromosome aberrations, and mutations. It is generally perceived as a hallmark of ionizing radiation. The enhanced mutagenic potential of lesions within a cluster has been suggested to result, at least in part, from the selection of the strand with the mutagenic lesion as the preferred template strand, and that this process is relevant to the tolerance of persistent single-strand breaks generated during an attempted repair. Using a plasmid-based assay in Escherichia coli, we examined how the strand bias is affected in mutant strains deficient in different DNA polymerase I activities. Our study revealed that the strand-displacement and 5'-flap endonuclease activities are required for this process, while 3'-to-5' exonuclease activity is not. We also found the strand template that the mutagenic lesion was located on, whether lagging or leading, had no effect on this strand bias. Our results imply that an unknown pathway operates to repair/tolerate the single-strand break generated at a bi-stranded clustered damage site, and that there exist different backup pathways, depending on which DNA polymerase I activity is compromised.

Proximity Estimation and Quantification of Ionizing Radiation-induced DNA Lesions in Aqueous Media using Fluorescence Spectroscopy.

Clustered DNA damage (cluster) or a multiply damaged site, which is a region with two or more lesions within one or two helical turns, has a high mutagenic potential and causes cell death. We quantified fluorophore-labeled lesions and estimated their proximity through fluorescence anisotropy measurements depending on Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) among the fluorophores close to each other. pUC19 plasmid DNA (2,686 base pairs) dissolved in water or 0.2 M Tris-HCl buffer at a concentration of 10 µg/µL was irradiated by several ionizing radiations with varying linear energy transfers (LET, 0.2-1890 keV/µm). Electrophilic carbonyls (aldehydes and ketones) at abasic sites (APs) produced in DNA were labeled with Alexa Fluor 488 fluorescent dyes with an O-amino functional group. Regardless of the presence or absence of the buffer, AP yields (the number of APs/base pair/Gy) tended to decrease with increasing LET, and the ratio of the AP yield (in 0.2 M Tris-HCl/in water) was less than 0.1 in the LET range of 0.2-200 keV/µm. However, in a higher LET range, the ratios were greater than 0.1. At a low dose, fluorescence anisotropy decreased with increasing LET in 0.2 M Tris-HCl, whereas, in water, this LET dependence was almost insignificant. These findings suggest that 1. the damage distribution on a DNA molecule formed by indirect effects (e.g., by hydroxyl radicals) does not depend on radiation quality and 2. greater LET radiation is more likely to produce a cluster and/or to produce a cluster with shorter distances between lesions by direct effects. This FRET-based proximity estimation of DNA lesions will contribute not only to the identification of clusters and their complexity in a whole genome, but also to the study of their repair mechanism by single-molecular level fluorescence microscopy.

Formation of clustered DNA damage in vivo upon irradiation with ionizing radiation: Visualization and analysis with atomic force microscopy.

SignificanceDNA damage causes loss of or alterations in genetic information, resulting in cell death or mutations. Ionizing radiations produce local, multiple DNA damage sites called clustered DNA damage. In this study, a complete protocol was established to analyze the damage complexity of clustered DNA damage, wherein damage-containing genomic DNA fragments were selectively concentrated via pulldown, and clustered DNA damage was visualized by atomic force microscopy. It was found that X-rays and Fe ion beams caused clustered DNA damage. Fe ion beams also produced clustered DNA damage with high complexity. Fe ion beam-induced complex DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) containing one or more base lesion(s) near the DSB end were refractory to repair, implying their lethal effects.

Fluorescence anisotropy study of radiation-induced DNA damage clustering based on FRET.

A clustered DNA damage site (cluster), in which two or more lesions exist within a few helical turns, is believed to be a key factor determining the fate of a living cell exposed to a DNA damaging agent such as ionizing radiation. However, the structural details of a cluster such as the number of included lesions and their proximity are unknown. Herein, we develop a method to characterize a cluster by fluorescence anisotropy measurements based on Förster resonance energy transfer (homo-FRET). Plasmid DNA (pUC19) was irradiated with 2.0 and 0.52 MeV/u 4He2+, or 0.37 MeV/u 12C5+ ion beams (linear energy transfer: ~ 70, ~ 150, ~ 760 keV/µm, respectively) and 60Co γ-rays as a standard (~ 0.2 keV/µm) in the solid state. The irradiated DNA was labeled with an aminooxyl fluorophore (Alexa Fluor 488) to the aldehyde/ketone moieties such as apurinic/apyrimidinic sites. Homo-FRET analyses provided the apparent base separation values between lesions in a cluster produced by each ion beam track as 21.1, 19.4, and 18.7 base pairs. The production frequency of a cluster increases with increasing linear energy transfer of radiation. Our results demonstrate that homo-FRET analysis has the potential to discover the qualitative and the quantitative differences of the clusters produced not only by a variety of ionizing radiation but also by other DNA damaging agents.

Characterization of gamma irradiation-induced mutations in Arabidopsis mutants deficient in non-homologous end joining.

To investigate the involvement of the non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) pathway in plant mutagenesis by ionizing radiation, we conducted a genome-wide characterization of the mutations induced by gamma rays in NHEJ-deficient Arabidopsis mutants (AtKu70-/- and AtLig4-/-). Although both mutants were more sensitive to gamma rays than the wild-type control, the AtKu70-/- mutant was slightly more sensitive than the AtLig4-/- mutant. Single-base substitutions (SBSs) were the predominant mutations in the wild-type control, whereas deletions (≥2 bp) and complex-type mutations [i.e. more than two SBSs or short insertion and deletions (InDels) separated by fewer than 10 bp] were frequently induced in the mutants. Single-base deletions were the most frequent deletions in the wild-type control, whereas the most common deletions in the mutants were 11-30 bp. The apparent microhomology at the rejoined sites of deletions peaked at 2 bp in the wild-type control, but was 3-4 bp in the mutants. This suggests the involvement of alternative end joining and single-strand annealing pathways involving increased microhomology for rejoining DNA ends. Complex-type mutations comprising short InDels were frequently detected in the mutants, but not in the wild-type control. Accordingly, NHEJ is more precise than the backup pathways, and is the main pathway for rejoining the broken DNA ends induced by ionizing radiation in plants.

Strand with mutagenic lesion is preferentially used as a template in the region of a bi-stranded clustered DNA damage site in Escherichia coli.

The damaging potential of ionizing radiation arises largely from the generation of clustered DNA damage sites within cells. Previous studies using synthetic DNA lesions have demonstrated that models of clustered DNA damage exhibit enhanced mutagenic potential of the comprising lesions. However, little is known regarding the processes that lead to mutations in these sites, apart from the fact that base excision repair of lesions within the cluster is compromised. Unique features of the mutation frequencies within bi-stranded clusters have led researchers to speculate that the strand containing the mutagenic lesion is preferentially used as the template for DNA synthesis. To gain further insights into the processing of clustered DNA damage sites, we used a plasmid-based assay in E. coli cells. Our findings revealed that the strand containing a mutagenic lesion within a bi-stranded clustered DNA damage site is frequently used as the template. This suggests the presence of an, as yet unknown, strand synthesis process that is unrelated to base excision repair, and that this process plays an important role in mutagenesis. The length of the region of strand preference was found to be determined by DNA polymerase I.

A Simplified Cluster Analysis of Electron Track Structure for Estimating Complex DNA Damage Yields.

Complex DNA damage, defined as at least two vicinal lesions within 10-20 base pairs (bp), induced after exposure to ionizing radiation, is recognized as fatal damage to human tissue. Due to the difficulty of directly measuring the aggregation of DNA damage at the nano-meter scale, many cluster analyses of inelastic interactions based on Monte Carlo simulation for radiation track structure in liquid water have been conducted to evaluate DNA damage. Meanwhile, the experimental technique to detect complex DNA damage has evolved in recent decades, so both approaches with simulation and experiment get used for investigating complex DNA damage. During this study, we propose a simplified cluster analysis of ionization and electronic excitation events within 10 bp based on track structure for estimating complex DNA damage yields for electron and X-ray irradiations. We then compare the computational results with the experimental complex DNA damage coupled with base damage (BD) measured by enzymatic cleavage and atomic force microscopy (AFM). The computational results agree well with experimental fractions of complex damage yields, i.e., single and double strand breaks (SSBs, DSBs) and complex BD, when the yield ratio of BD/SSB is assumed to be 1.3. Considering the comparison of complex DSB yields, i.e., DSB + BD and DSB + 2BD, between simulation and experimental data, we find that the aggregation degree of the events along electron tracks reflects the complexity of induced DNA damage, showing 43.5% of DSB induced after 70 kVp X-ray irradiation can be classified as a complex form coupled with BD. The present simulation enables us to quantify the type of complex damage which cannot be measured through in vitro experiments and helps us to interpret the experimental detection efficiency for complex BD measured by AFM. This simple model for estimating complex DNA damage yields contributes to the precise understanding of the DNA damage complexity induced after X-ray and electron irradiations.

Mutagenic potential of 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine (8-oxoG) is influenced by nearby clustered lesions.

Ionizing radiation causes various different types of DNA damage. If not repaired, DNA damage can have detrimental effects. Previous studies indicate that the spatial distribution of DNA lesions induced by ionizing radiation is highly relevant to the ensuing biological effects. Clustered DNA damage, consisting of DNA lesions in close proximity, has been studied in detail, and has enhanced mutagenic potential depending on the configuration of the lesions. However, it is not known whether clustered DNA damage affects the mutagenic potential of a sufficiently separated, isolated lesion. Using synthetic damage constructs, we investigated the mutagenic potential of an isolated 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine (8-oxoG) separated by at least 7 bp from other lesions. Under the spatial distribution of DNA lesions tested in the present study, neighboring clustered DNA lesions likely retarded the processing of the isolated 8-oxoG and resulted in enhanced mutation frequency. However, the enhanced mutagenic potential was dependent on which strand the isolated 8-oxoG was located. Our results indicate that the processing of a bi-stranded cluster could affect the mutagenic outcome of a nearby isolated lesion, separated up to ∼20 bp.

New method for estimating clustering of DNA lesions induced by physical/chemical mutagens using fluorescence anisotropy.

We have developed a new method for estimating the localization of DNA damage such as apurinic/apyrimidinic sites (APs) on DNA using fluorescence anisotropy. This method is aimed at characterizing clustered DNA damage produced by DNA-damaging agents such as ionizing radiation and genotoxic chemicals. A fluorescent probe with an aminooxy group (AlexaFluor488) was used to label APs. We prepared a pUC19 plasmid with APs by heating under acidic conditions as a model for damaged DNA, and subsequently labeled the APs. We found that the observed fluorescence anisotropy (robs) decreases as averaged AP density (λAP: number of APs per base pair) increases due to homo-FRET, and that the APs were randomly distributed. We applied this method to three DNA-damaging agents, 60Co γ-rays, methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), and neocarzinostatin (NCS). We found that robs-λAP relationships differed significantly between MMS and NCS. At low AP density (λAP < 0.001), the APs induced by MMS seemed to not be closely distributed, whereas those induced by NCS were remarkably clustered. In contrast, the AP clustering induced by 60Co γ-rays was similar to, but potentially more likely to occur than, random distribution. This simple method can be used to estimate mutagenicity of ionizing radiation and genotoxic chemicals.

Efficiency of radiation-induced base lesion excision and the order of enzymatic treatment.

PURPOSE: To clarify whether initial base excision repair processes at clustered DNA damage sites comprising multiple base lesions affect subsequent excision processes via the formation of additional strand breaks by glycosylase and apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) endonuclease base excision enzymes. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Plasmid DNA (pUC18) as a model DNA molecule was exposed to high-linear-energy-transfer (LET) ionizing radiation (He2+ or C6+ ions) or low-LET ionizing radiation (X-rays) under various conditions to produce varied radical-scavenging effects. pUC18 was then treated sequentially or simultaneously with two bacterial base excision enzymes (glycosylases), namely, endonuclease III and formamidopyrimidine-DNA glycosylase, which convert pyrimidine (or abasic [AP] site) and purine (or AP site) lesions to single-strand breaks (SSB), respectively. Yields of additional SSB or double-strand breaks (DSB) as digestion products were examined after changing the order of enzymatic treatment. RESULTS: There were few differences among the enzymatic treatments, indicating that treatment order did not affect the final yields of additional SSB or DSB formed by glycosylase activity. This suggests that of the total damage, the fraction of clustered damage sites with a persistent base lesion dependent on the order of glycosylase treatment was insignificant if present. CONCLUSION: Base lesion clusters induced by high- or low-LET radiation appear three or more base pairs apart, and are promptly converted to a DSB by glycosylase, regardless of the order of enzymatic treatment.

Radiation-induced clustered DNA lesions: Repair and mutagenesis.

Clustered DNA lesions, also called Multiply Damaged Sites, is the hallmark of ionizing radiation. It is defined as the combination of two or more lesions, comprising strand breaks, oxidatively generated base damage, abasic sites within one or two DNA helix turns, created by the passage of a single radiation track. DSB clustered lesions associate DSB and several base damage and abasic sites in close vicinity, and are assimilated to complex DSB. Non-DSB clustered lesions comprise single strand break, base damage and abasic sites. At radiation with low Linear Energy Transfer (LET), such as X-rays or γ-rays clustered DNA lesions are 3-4 times more abundant than DSB. Their proportion and their complexity increase with increasing LET; they may represent a large part of the damage to DNA. Studies in vitro using engineered clustered DNA lesions of increasing complexity have greatly enhanced our understanding on how non-DSB clustered lesions are processed. Base excision repair is compromised, the observed hierarchy in the processing of the lesions within a cluster leads to the formation of SSB or DSB as repair intermediates and increases the lifetime of the lesions. As a consequence, the chances of mutation drastically increase. Complex DSB, either formed directly by irradiation or by the processing of non-DSB clustered lesions, are repaired by slow kinetics or left unrepaired and cause cell death or pass mitosis. In surviving cells, large deletions, translocations, and chromosomal aberrations are observed. This review details the most recent data on the processing of non-DSB clustered lesions and complex DSB and tends to demonstrate the high significance of these specific DNA damage in terms of genomic instability induction.

A polymerization-based method to construct a plasmid containing clustered DNA damage and a mismatch.

Exposure of biological materials to ionizing radiation often induces clustered DNA damage. The mutagenicity of clustered DNA damage can be analyzed with plasmids carrying a clustered DNA damage site, in which the strand bias of a replicating plasmid (i.e., the degree to which each of the two strands of the plasmid are used as the template for replication of the plasmid) can help to clarify how clustered DNA damage enhances the mutagenic potential of comprising lesions. Placement of a mismatch near a clustered DNA damage site can help to determine the strand bias, but present plasmid-based methods do not allow insertion of a mismatch at a given site in the plasmid. Here, we describe a polymerization-based method for constructing a plasmid containing clustered DNA lesions and a mismatch. The presence of a DNA lesion and a mismatch in the plasmid was verified by enzymatic treatment and by determining the relative abundance of the progeny plasmids derived from each of the two strands of the plasmid.

Localization estimation of ionizing radiation-induced abasic sites in DNA in the solid state using fluorescence resonance energy transfer.

Clustered DNA damage is considered an important factor in determining the biological consequences of ionizing radiation. In this study, we successfully estimated the localization of abasic sites (APs) in DNA exposed to ionizing radiation using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) without any involvement of repair enzyme functions. A linearized plasmid (pUC19 digested by Sma I) was irradiated with: (60)Co γ rays; (4)He(2+) (2.0 MeV/u) particles; and the (12)C(5+) (0.37 MeV/u) particles in the solid state. A donor or acceptor fluorescent probe with a nucleophilic O-amino group was used to label APs. The results showed that the (12)C(5+) particle likely produced close APs within a track. The apparent distance calculated from the observed FRET efficiency (E) of around 0.10 was estimated to be approximately 17 base pairs. On the other hand, E values of (60)Co γ rays and the (4)He(2+) beam were less than those of the (12)C(5+) beam, increased with increasing AP density (the average number of APs per base pair), and were slightly greater than those of randomly distributed APs. We propose that the FRET method provides a degree of localization regardless of whether an AP cluster is single-stranded or bistranded DNA damage.

Chemical repair activity of free radical scavenger edaravone: reduction reactions with dGMP hydroxyl radical adducts and suppression of base lesions and AP sites on irradiated plasmid DNA.

Reactions of edaravone (3-methyl-1-phenyl-2-pyrazolin-5-one) with deoxyguanosine monophosphate (dGMP) hydroxyl radical adducts were investigated by pulse radiolysis technique. Edaravone was found to reduce the dGMP hydroxyl radical adducts through electron transfer reactions. The rate constants of the reactions were greater than 4 × 10(8) dm(3) mol(-1) s(-1) and similar to those of the reactions of ascorbic acid, which is a representative antioxidant. Yields of single-strand breaks, base lesions, and abasic sites produced in pUC18 plasmid DNA by gamma ray irradiation in the presence of low concentrations (10-1000 µmol dm(-3)) of edaravone were also quantified, and the chemical repair activity of edaravone was estimated by a method recently developed by the authors. By comparing suppression efficiencies to the induction of each DNA lesion, it was found that base lesions and abasic sites were suppressed by the chemical repair activity of edaravone, although the suppression of single-strand breaks was not very effective. This phenomenon was attributed to the chemical repair activity of edaravone toward base lesions and abasic sites. However, the chemical repair activity of edaravone for base lesions was lower than that of ascorbic acid.

Significance of DNA polymerase I in in vivo processing of clustered DNA damage.

We examined the biological consequences of bi-stranded clustered damage sites, consisting of a combination of DNA lesions, such as a 1-nucleotide gap (GAP), an apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) site, and an 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine (8-oxoG), using a bacterial plasmid-based assay. Following transformation with the plasmid containing bi-stranded clustered damage sites into the wild type strain of Escherichia coli, transformation frequencies were significantly lower for the bi-stranded clustered GAP/AP lesions (separated by 1bp) than for either a single GAP or a single AP site. When the two lesions were separated by 10-20bp, the transformation efficiencies were comparable with those of the single lesions. This recovery of transformation efficiency for separated lesions requires DNA polymerase I (Pol I) activity. Analogously, the mutation frequency was found to depend on the distance separating lesions in a bi-stranded cluster containing a GAP and an 8-oxoG, and Pol I was found to play an important role in minimising mutations induced as a result of clustered lesions. The mutagenic potential of 8-oxoG within the bi-stranded lesions does not depend on whether it is situated on the leading or lagging strand. These results indicate that the biological consequences of clustered DNA damage strongly depend on the extent of repair of the strand breaks as well as the DNA polymerase in lesion-avoidance pathways during replication.

Chemical repair of base lesions, AP-sites, and strand breaks on plasmid DNA in dilute aqueous solution by ascorbic acid.

We quantified the damage yields produced in plasmid DNA by γ-irradiation in the presence of low concentrations (10-100 µM) of ascorbic acid, which is a major antioxidant in living systems, to clarify whether it chemically repairs radiation damage in DNA. The yield of DNA single strand breaks induced by irradiation was analyzed with agarose gel electrophoresis as conformational changes in closed circular plasmids. Base lesions and abasic sites were also observed as additional conformational changes by treating irradiated samples with glycosylase proteins. By comparing the suppression efficiencies to the induction of each DNA lesion, in addition to scavenging of the OH radicals derived from water radiolysis, it was found that ascorbic acid promotes the chemical repair of precursors of AP-sites and base lesions more effectively than those of single strand breaks. We estimated the efficiency of the chemical repair of each lesion using a kinetic model. Approximately 50-60% of base lesions and AP-sites were repaired by 10 µM ascorbic acid, although strand breaks were largely unrepaired by ascorbic acid at low concentrations. The methods in this study will provide a route to understanding the mechanistic aspects of antioxidant activity in living systems.

A methodology for estimating localization of apurinic/apyrimidinic sites in DNA using fluorescence resonance energy transfer.

We have developed a methodology for estimating localization of lesions on double-stranded DNA using fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET). We focused on apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) sites, which are typical DNA lesions induced by radiation and chemicals and produced spontaneously under physiological conditions. Donor-acceptor fluorescent probes with O-amino groups (Alexa Fluor 350-Alexa Fluor 488 dye pair) were used for selectively labeling AP sites. pUC19 plasmid subjected to heat treatment (pH 5.2, 70 °C) was used as a model double-stranded DNA containing AP sites. The results of both FRET analysis and theoretical study enabled us to prove that AP sites induced by the heat treatment are distributed almost randomly along the DNA molecule. This methodology will be useful for estimating the risk of ionizing radiation and chemicals (e.g., pollutants and anticancer agents) based on the probability of producing "clustered DNA damage sites," which are considered to be less easily repairable and, therefore, more harmful to living systems.

The mutagenic potential of 8-oxoG/single strand break-containing clusters depends on their relative positions.

The biological consequences of clusters containing a single strand break and base lesion(s) remain largely unknown. In the present study we determined the mutagenicities of two- and three-lesion clustered damage sites containing a 1-nucleotide gap (GAP) and 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine(s) (8-oxoG(s)) in Escherichia coli. The mutation frequencies (MFs) of bi-stranded two-lesion clusters (GAP/8-oxoG), especially in mutY-deficient strains, were high and were similar to those for bi-stranded clusters with 8-oxoG and base lesions/AP sites, suggesting that the GAP is processed with an efficiency similar to the efficiency of processing a base lesion or an AP site within a cluster. The MFs of tandem two-lesion clusters comprised of a GAP and an 8-oxoG on the same strand were comparable to or less than the MF of a single 8-oxoG. The mutagenic potential of three-lesion clusters, which were comprised of a tandem lesion (a GAP and an 8-oxoG) and an opposing single 8-oxoG, was higher than that of a single 8-oxoG, but was no more than that of a bi-stranded 8-oxoGs. We suggest that incorporation of a nucleotide opposite 8-oxoG is less mutagenic when a GAP is present in a cluster than when a GAP is absent. Our observations indicate that the repair of a GAP is retarded by an opposing 8-oxoG, but not by a tandem 8-oxoG, and that the extent of GAP repair determines the biological consequences.

Yield of single- and double-strand breaks and nucleobase lesions in fully hydrated plasmid DNA films irradiated with high-LET charged particles.

We measured the yield and spectrum of strand breaks and nucleobase lesions produced in fully hydrated plasmid DNA films to determine the linear energy transfer (LET) dependence of DNA damage induced by ion-beam irradiation in relation to the change in the atomic number of ions. The yield of isolated damage was revealed as a decrease in prompt SSBs with increasing LET of He(2+), C(5+,6+) and Ne(8+,10+) ions. On the other hand, the yields of prompt DSBs increased with increasing ion LET. SSBs were additionally induced in ion-irradiated DNA film by treatment with two kinds of base excision repair proteins (glycosylases), Nth and Fpg, indicating that base lesions are produced in the hydrated DNA film. This result shows that nucleobase lesions are produced via both chemical reactions with diffusible water radicals, such as OH radicals, and direct energy deposition onto DNA and the hydrated water layer. Nth-sensitive sites deduced to be pyrimidine lesions, such as 5,6-dihydrothymine (DHT), showed a relatively larger yield than Fpg-sensitive sites deduced to be purine lesions, such as 7,8-dihydro-8-oxo-2'deoxyguanine (8-oxoGua), for all ion exposures tested. The yield of SSBs or DSBs observed by enzyme treatment decreased noticeably with increasing LET for all tested ions. These results indicated that higher-LET ions preferentially produce a complex type of damage that might compromise the activities of the glycosylases used in this study. These findings are biologically important since, under cell mimicking conditions, persistent DNA damage occurs in part due to direct energy deposition on the DNA or hydrated water shell that is specifically induced by dense ionization in the track.