Standard quantitative assays for apoptosis.

The term apoptosis refers to a peculiar morphology of cell death. It is of special interest because it can be triggered physiologically (and pathologically), and it is regulated by the actions of specific gene products. Therefore, it can in principle be activated and suppressed by medical intervention. It thus is often important to determine whether cells are dying by apoptosis (or its less regulated counterpart, necrosis) and also to quantity the effect in a population of cells. Here the classic methods of apoptosis quantitation are described; they will be of particular use to those whose laboratories are set up for standard microscopical and biochemical techniques, who do apoptosis assays infrequently but wish them to be widely accepted and reproducible. A simple microscopic observation, using blue light illumination and a pair of fluorescent dyes, is recommended for most applications.

Calpain and calpastatin regulate neutrophil apoptosis.

The average polymorphonuclear neutrophil (PMN) lives only a day and then dies by apoptosis. We previously found that the calcium-dependent protease calpain is required for apoptosis in several mouse models of cell death. Here we identify calpain, and its endogenous inhibitor calpastatin, as regulators of human neutrophil apoptosis. Cell death triggered by the translation inhibitor cycloheximide is calpain-dependent, as evidenced using either a calpain active site inhibitor (N-acetyl-leucyl-leucyl-norleucinal) or agents that target calpain's calcium binding sites (PD150606, PD151746). No significant effect on cycloheximide-triggered apoptosis was found by using inhibitors of the proteasome or of other papain-like cysteine proteases, providing further evidence that the active site calpain inhibitor prevents apoptosis via its action on calpain. In addition, we find that potentiation of calpain activity by depleting its endogenous inhibitor, calpastatin, is sufficient to cause apoptosis of neutrophils. Nevertheless, apoptosis signalled via the Fas antigen proceeds regardless of the presence of calpain inhibitor. These experiments support a growing body of work, indicating an upstream regulatory role for calpain in many, but not all, forms of apoptotic cell death. They also identify calpastatin as a participant in apoptotic cell death and suggest that for at least one cell type, a decrease in calpastatin is a sufficient stimulus to initiate calpain-dependent apoptosis.

Reovirus-induced apoptosis is preceded by increased cellular calpain activity and is blocked by calpain inhibitors.

The cellular pathways of apoptosis have not been fully characterized; however, calpain, a cytosolic calcium-activated cysteine protease, has been implicated in several forms of programmed cell death. Reoviruses induce apoptosis both in vitro and in vivo and serve as a model for studying virus-induced cell death. We investigated the potential role of calpain in reovirus-induced apoptosis in vitro by measuring calpain activity as well as evaluating the effects of calpain inhibitors. L929 cells were infected with reovirus type 3 Abney (T3A), and calpain activity, measured as cleavage of the fluorogenic calpain substrate Suc-Leu-Leu-Val-Tyr-AMC, was monitored. There was a 1.6-fold increase in calpain activity in T3A-infected cells compared to mock-infected cells; this increase was completely inhibited by preincubation with calpain inhibitor I (N-acetyl-leucyl-leucyl-norleucinal [aLLN]), an active-site inhibitor. Both aLLN and PD150606, a specific calpain inhibitor that interacts with the calcium-binding site, inhibited reovirus-induced apoptosis in L929 cells by 54 to 93%. Apoptosis induced by UV-inactivated reovirus was also reduced 65 to 69% by aLLN, indicating that inhibition of apoptosis by calpain inhibitors is independent of effects on viral replication. We conclude that calpain activation is a component of the regulatory cascade in reovirus-induced apoptosis.

Selective induction of apoptosis in mouse and human lung epithelial cell lines by the tert-butyl hydroxylated metabolite of butylated hydroxytoluene: a proposed role in tumor promotion.

Butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) causes lung injury in mice and promotes tumor formation. Hydroxylation of a tert-butyl group on BHT to yield the metabolite, 6-tert-butyl-2-[2'-(2'-hydroxymethyl)-propyl]-4-methylphenol (BHTOH), may be required. BHTOH is more potent than BHT on an equimolar basis in causing lung damage, enhancing lung tumor development, killing isolated bronchiolar non-ciliated Clara cells, and inhibiting lung epithelial gap junctional intercellular communication. One mechanism proposed for tumor promoting agents is selective cytotoxicity; killing normal cells allows uninhibited clonal expansion of neighboring initiated cells. We compared the abilities of BHT, BHTOH, and other BHT metabolites to kill non-tumorigenic and tumorigenic mouse and human lung cell lines, and examined the contribution of apoptosis to this cytotoxicity. These cells lack the cytochrome P450 2B isozyme necessary for converting BHT to BHTOH. BHTOH and 4-hydroperoxy-4-methyl-2,6-di-tert-butyl-2,5-cyclohex-adienone+ ++ (BHTOOH) were most toxic, BHT and 2,6-di-tert-butyl-1,4-benzoquinone (BHTQu) were less potent, and 4-methyl BHT metabolites that are not pneumotoxic were ineffective. BHTOH most strongly induced apoptosis, based on nuclear condensation and transmission electron microscopy. Non-tumorigenic cells were as susceptible to cell death as the neoplastic cell lines when apoptosis and necrosis are not distinguished, but more sensitive to BHTOH-induced apoptosis. An apoptotic mechanism may underlie the lung tumor promoting actions of BHTOH.

Calpain, an upstream regulator of thymocyte apoptosis.

Apoptosis is the common phenotype of programmed or physiologic cell death, the process used to remove excess or defunct cells during normal tissue maintenance. One of the most studied cell types with respect to apoptosis is the immature T cell from the thymus, which activates its death program in response to an enormous variety of agents. Previously, our group implicated the calcium-dependent cytosolic protease calpain as a participant in thymocyte apoptosis initiated by glucocorticoids or irradiation. We found that the calpain inhibitors N-acetyl-leu-leu-norleucinal (calpain inhibitor I) and carbenzoxy-val-phe-H (MDL 28,170) prevented dexamethasone-induced apoptosis of thymocytes; in this study, we show that two additional calpain active site inhibitors, L-3-carboxy-trans-2,3-epoxypropionyl-leu-amido-(4-guanidinio )butane ethyl ester (E64d) and carbenzoxy-leu-leu-tyr-CHN2 (ZLLY-CHN2), also prevent apoptosis in this model. Three compounds that inhibit lysosomal cysteine proteases, carbenzoxy-tyr-ala-CHN2 (ZYA-CHN2), ammonium chloride, and chloroquine, do not block apoptosis, indicating that the effect of the calpain inhibitors is not due to cross-inhibition of lysosomal proteases. In addition, I-benzyl-CH=C(SH)COOH (PD150606), a calpain inhibitor directed toward the calcium binding sites of calpain, also prevents apoptosis. Calpain is necessary for other models of programmed cell death that require new gene expression (induction models), those following treatment of thymocytes with the calcium ionophore A23187, ionomycin, or forskolin. However, two models of thymocyte apoptosis that do not require new gene expression (transduction models), those triggered by heat shock and by valinomycin, are calpain independent, as is calcium-triggered DNA fragmentation in isolated thymocyte nuclei. These experiments suggest an upstream regulatory role for calpain in a pathway to thymocyte apoptosis common to several inducers.

Linkage between reovirus-induced apoptosis and inhibition of cellular DNA synthesis: role of the S1 and M2 genes.

The mammalian reoviruses are capable of inhibiting cellular DNA synthesis and inducing apoptosis. Reovirus strains type 3 Abney (T3A) and type 3 Dearing (T3D) inhibit cellular DNA synthesis and induce apoptosis to a substantially greater extent than strain type 1 Lang (T1L). We used T1L x T3A and T1L x T3D reassortant viruses to identify viral genes associated with differences in the capacities of reovirus strains to elicit these cellular responses to viral infection. We found that the S1 and M2 genome segments determine differences in the capacities of both T1L x T3A and T1L x T3D reassortant viruses to inhibit cellular DNA synthesis and to induce apoptosis. These genes encode viral outer-capsid proteins that play important roles in viral attachment and disassembly. To extend these findings, we used field isolate strains of reovirus to determine whether the strain-specific differences in inhibition of cellular DNA synthesis and induction of apoptosis are also associated with viral serotype, a property determined by the S1 gene. In these experiments, type 3 field isolate strains were found to inhibit cellular DNA synthesis and to induce apoptosis to a greater extent than type 1 field isolate strains. Statistical analysis of these data indicate a significant correlation between the capacity of T1L x T3A and T1L x T3D reassortant viruses and field isolate strains to inhibit cellular DNA synthesis and to induce apoptosis. These findings suggest that reovirus-induced inhibition of cellular DNA synthesis and induction of apoptosis are linked and that both phenomena are induced by early steps in the viral replication cycle.

Calpain and cell death.

Neither the early nor the late steps in apoptosis have been defined biochemically. Several different signalling pathways have been implicated, and these are familiar from other signalling paradigms. In what way could they lead to cell death, when under the usual conditions they are involved in reversible activation events? A possible role for proteolysis is suggested, because the cleavage of a peptide bond is one of the few irreversible processes in cellular metabolism, and death, after all, is an irreversible outcome. In this review we discuss the calcium-dependent neutral protease calpain, a member of the papain family of cysteine proteases quite distinct from the ICE family. Calpain has been shown to play an essential role in several important examples of physiologic apoptosis. It seems to play its part after the various 'private' pathways have been invoked, but before the final common pathway.

Differences in the capacity of reovirus strains to induce apoptosis are determined by the viral attachment protein sigma 1.

Reoviruses are important models for studies of viral pathogenesis; however, the mechanisms by which these viruses produce cytopathic effects in infected cells have not been defined. In this report, we show that murine L929 (L) cells infected with prototype reovirus strains type 1 Lang (TIL) and type 3 Dearing (T3D) undergo apoptosis and that T3D induces apoptosis to a substantially greater extent than T1L. Using T1L x T3D reassortant viruses, we found that differences in the capacity of T1L and T3D to induce apoptosis are determined by the viral S1 gene segment, which encodes the viral attachment protein sigma 1 and the non-virion-associated protein sigma 1s. Apoptosis was induced by UV-inactivated, replication-incompetent reovirus virions, which do not contain sigma 1s and do not mediate its synthesis in infected cells. Additionally, T3D-induced apoptosis was inhibited by anti-reovirus monoclonal antibodies that inhibit T3D cell attachment and disassembly. These results indicate that sigma 1, rather than sigma 1s, is required for induction of apoptosis by the reovirus and suggest that interaction of virions with cell surface receptors is an essential step in this mechanism of cell killing.

Apoptosis in leukocytes.

All cells of the hematopoietic system have finite life spans, shorter by far than that of the host. They end their lives by committing a form of cellular suicide or programmed cell death. The morphology of this process is considerably different from that of necrosis and is called apoptosis. Apoptotic cells undergo a stereotyped sequence of changes, including shrinkage and nuclear collapse. The cell is quickly recognized and eaten by a phagocyte, without the elicitation of an inflammatory response. Although most cells have specific triggers of apoptosis, the killer T cell seems able to induce apoptosis in any cell it recognizes. The process of apoptosis is regulated by cytokines, and may be modulated both in vitro and in vivo.

Cell-mediated cytotoxic mechanisms.

There are two competing, but probably really complementary, models for the mechanism of cell-mediated cytotoxicity. One depends upon contact-mediated transmembrane signaling, and the other on the exocytosis of toxic materials by the killer cell. There is exciting news on both fronts. Transmembrane signaling has been shown to involve the surface molecule Fas/APO-1 on targets and its ligand on cytotoxic T cells. The Fas ligand has been cloned, and is a member of the tumor necrosis factor family. The major cytolytic molecule in the exocytosis pathway is perforin; perforin knock-out mice have been produced, and they display many intriguing abnormalities. It has been a bumper year for cytotoxicologists.

Calpain activation in apoptosis.

Programmed cell death is an active process wherein the cell initiates a sequence of events culminating in the fragmentation of its DNA, nuclear collapse, and disintegration of the cell into small, membrane-bound apoptotic bodies. Examination of the death program in various models has shown common themes, including a rise in cytoplasmic calcium, cytoskeletal changes, and redistribution of membrane lipids. The calcium-dependent neutral protease calpain has putative roles in cytoskeletal and membrane changes in other cellular processes; this fact led us to test the role of calpain in a well-known model of apoptotic cell death, that of thymocytes after treatment with dexamethasone. Assays for calcium-dependent proteolysis in thymocyte extracts reveal a rise in activity with a peak at about 1 hr of incubation with dexamethasone, falling to background at approximately 2 hr. Western blots indicate autolytic cleavage of the proenzyme precursor to the calpain I isozyme, providing additional evidence for calpain activation. We have also found that apoptosis in thymocytes, whether induced by dexamethasone or by low-level irradiation, is blocked by specific inhibitors of calpain. Apoptosis of metamyelocytes incubated with cycloheximide is also blocked by calpain inhibitors. These studies suggest a required role for calpain in both "induction" and "release" models of apoptotic cell death.