Funnel plots a graphical instrument for the evaluation of population performance and quality of trauma care: a blueprint of implementation.

BACKGROUND: Using patient outcomes to monitor medical centre performance has become an essential part of modern health care. However, classic league tables generally inflict stigmatization on centres rated as "poor performers", which has a negative effect on public trust and professional morale. In the present study, we aim to illustrate that funnel plots, including trends over time, can be used as a method to control the quality of data and to monitor and assure the quality of trauma care. Moreover, we aimed to present a set of regulations on how to interpret and act on underperformance or overperformance trends presented in funnel plots. METHODS: A retrospective observational cohort study was performed using the Dutch National Trauma Registry (DNTR). Two separate datasets were created to assess the effects of healthy and multiple imputations to cope with missing values. Funnel plots displaying the performance of all trauma-receiving hospitals in 2020 were generated, and in-hospital mortality was used as the main indicator of centre performance. Indirect standardization was used to correct for differences in the types of cases. Comet plots were generated displaying the performance trends of two level-I trauma centres since 2017 and 2018. RESULTS: Funnel plots based on data using healthy imputation for missing values can highlight centres lacking good data quality. A comet plot illustrates the performance trend over multiple years, which is more indicative of a centre's performance compared to a single measurement. Trends analysis offers the opportunity to closely monitor an individual centres' performance and direct evaluation of initiated improvement strategies. CONCLUSION: This study describes the use of funnel and comet plots as a method to monitor and assure high-quality data and to evaluate trauma centre performance over multiple years. Moreover, this is the first study to provide a regulatory blueprint on how to interpret and act on the under- or overperformance of trauma centres. Further evaluations are needed to assess its functionality. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Retrospective study, level III.

The Dutch nationwide trauma registry: The value of capturing all acute trauma admissions.

INTRODUCTION: Twenty years ago the Dutch trauma care system was reformed by the designating 11 level one Regional trauma centres (RTCs) to organise trauma care. The RTCs set up the Dutch National Trauma Registry (DNTR) to evaluate epidemiology, patient distribution, resource use and quality of care. In this study we describe the DNTR, the incidence and main characteristics of Dutch acutely admitted trauma patients, and evaluate the value of including all acute trauma admissions compared to more stringent criteria applied by the national trauma registries of the United Kingdom and Germany. METHODS: The DNTR includes all injured patients treated at the ED within 48 hours after trauma and consecutively followed by direct admission, transfers to another hospital or death at the ED. DNTR data on admission years 2007-2018 were extracted to describe the maturation of the registry. Data from 2018 was used to describe the incidence rate and patient characteristics. Inclusion criteria of the Trauma Audit and Research (TARN) and the Deutsche Gesellschaft für Unfallchirurgie (DGU) were applied on 2018 DNTR data. RESULTS: Since its start in 2007 a total of 865,460 trauma cases have been registered in the DNTR. Hospital participation increased from 64% to 98%. In 2018, a total of 77,529 patients were included, the median age was 64 years, 50% males. Severely injured patients with an ISS≥16, accounted for 6% of all admissions, of which 70% was treated at designated RTCs. Patients with an ISS≤ 15were treated at non-RTCs in 80% of cases. Application of DGU or TARN inclusion criteria, resulted in inclusion of respectively 5% and 32% of the DNTR patients. Particularly children, elderly and patients admitted at non-RTCs are left out. Moreover, 50% of ISS≥16 and 68% of the fatal cases did not meet DGU inclusion criteria CONCLUSION: The DNTR has evolved into a comprehensive well-structured nationwide population-based trauma register. With 80,000 inclusions annually, the DNTR has become one of the largest trauma databases in Europe The registries strength lies in the broad inclusion criteria which enables studies on the burden of injury and the quality and efficiency of the entire trauma care system, encompassing all trauma-receiving hospitals.

[Bicycle spoke injuries in children: accident details and consequences]. / Spaakverwondingen bij kinderen: toedracht en gevolgen.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the accident details and the effects of bicycle-spoke accidents on the physical and psychosocial functioning of children. DESIGN: Retrospective, descriptive. METHODS: The parents of 87 children aged between 1-12 who came to the central casualty department at the Groningen University Hospital with bicycle-spoke injuries during the period 1 January 1998 to 31 October 1999, were asked to complete a questionnaire on the accident details, the quality of life and the functional health status (behaviour) of their child in January 2000. RESULTS: Eighty-seven children fulfilled the inclusion criteria: 44 boys and 43 girls, with a mean age of 4.4 years (SD: 1.6, range: 1.4-10.2). Fifty-nine parents filled out the questionnaire (68%). A quarter of the children had been transported in a bicycle-seat (25%) and half of the children (51%) were seated on the carrier without any foot supports. Twenty-four percent of the bicycles were equipped with unbroken coat guards. The younger children (1-5 years of age) had significantly lower scores regarding motor functioning compared with the reference group (p < 0.001). The study population did not have significantly lower scores for the other quality of life domains compared with the reference groups. Eight parents (14%) attributed behavioural problems to the bicycle-spoke accident. CONCLUSION: Not all children were fully recovered one year after the bicycle-spoke accident. The sequelae included physical as well as behavioural aspects of functioning. The bicycles lacked adequate protective measures.

Brain activation during micturition in women.

Experiments in the cat have led to a concept of how the CNS controls micturition. In a previous study this concept was tested in a PET study in male volunteers. It was demonstrated that specific brainstem and forebrain areas are activated during micturition. It was unfortunate that this study did not involve women, because such results are important for understanding urge incontinence, which occurs more frequently in women than in men. Therefore, a similar study was done in 18 right-handed women, who were scanned during the following four conditions: (i) 15 min prior to micturition (urine withholding); (ii) during micturition; (iii) 15 min after micturition; and (iv) 30 min after micturition. Of the 18 volunteers, 10 were able to micturate during scanning and eight were not, despite trying vigorously. Micturition appeared to be associated with significantly increased blood flow in the right dorsal pontine tegmentum and the right inferior frontal gyrus. Decreased blood flow was found in the right anterior cingulate gyrus during urine withholding. The eight volunteers who were not able to micturate during scanning did not show significantly increased regional cerebral blood flow in the right dorsal, but did so in the right ventral pontine tegmentum. In the cat this region controls the motor neurons of the pelvic floor. In the same unsuccessful micturition group, increased blood flow was also found in the right inferior frontal gyrus. In all 18 volunteers, decreased blood flow in the right anterior cingulate gyrus was found during the period when they had to withhold their urine prior to the micturition condition. The results suggest that in women and in men the same specific nuclei exist in the pontine tegmentum responsible for the control of micturition. The results also indicate that the cortical and pontine micturition sites are more active on the right than on the left side.

A PET study on cortical and subcortical control of pelvic floor musculature in women.

The pelvic floor musculature plays an important role in behaviors such as defecation, micturition, mating behavior, and vomiting. A recent positron emission tomography (PET) study revealed that structures belonging to the emotional motor system are involved in the control of the pelvic floor during micturition. However, there also exist brain structures involved in the voluntary motor control of the pelvic floor, and the present PET study was designed to identify these structures. Six adult female volunteers were scanned with the bolus injection of H2(15)O during the following four conditions: (1) rest, (2) repetitive pelvic floor straining, (3) sustained pelvic floor straining, and (4) sustained abdominal straining. The results revealed that the superomedial precentral gyrus, the most medial portion of the motor cortex, is activated during pelvic floor contraction and the superolateral precentral gyrus during contraction of the abdominal musculature. In these conditions, significant activations were also found in the cerebellum, supplementary motor cortex, and thalamus. The right anterior cingulate gyrus was activated during sustained pelvic floor straining. No activations were found in subcortical structures belonging to the emotional motor system. The results are discussed in light of the existing literature on human control of the pelvic floor and micturition.