The quality and readability of patient information provided by ChatGPT: can AI reliably explain common ENT operations?

PURPOSE: Access to high-quality and comprehensible patient information is crucial. However, information provided by increasingly prevalent Artificial Intelligence tools has not been thoroughly investigated. This study assesses the quality and readability of information from ChatGPT regarding three index ENT operations: tonsillectomy, adenoidectomy, and grommets. METHODS: We asked ChatGPT standard and simplified questions. Readability was calculated using Flesch-Kincaid Reading Ease Score (FRES), Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level (FKGL), Gunning Fog Index (GFI) and Simple Measure of Gobbledygook (SMOG) scores. We assessed quality using the DISCERN instrument and compared these with ENT UK patient leaflets. RESULTS: ChatGPT readability was poor, with mean FRES of 38.9 and 55.1 pre- and post-simplification, respectively. Simplified information from ChatGPT was 43.6% more readable (FRES) but scored 11.6% lower for quality. ENT UK patient information readability and quality was consistently higher. CONCLUSIONS: ChatGPT can simplify information at the expense of quality, resulting in shorter answers with important omissions. Limitations in knowledge and insight curb its reliability for healthcare information. Patients should use reputable sources from professional organisations alongside clear communication with their clinicians for well-informed consent and making decisions.

Cocaine-associated Eustachian tube stenosis causing chronic 'glue ear': a rare cocaine-induced destructive lesion.

BACKGROUND: Cocaine is one of the most used recreational drugs. Whilst medical uses exist, chronic recreational nasal use of cocaine is associated with progressive destruction of the osseocartilaginous structures of the nose, sinuses and palate - termed cocaine-induced midline destructive lesions. CASE REPORT: A 43-year-old male with a history of chronic cocaine use, presented with conductive hearing loss and unilateral middle-ear effusion. Examination under anaesthesia revealed a completely stenosed left Eustachian tube orifice with intra-nasal adhesions. The adhesions were divided and the hearing loss was treated conservatively with hearing aids. Whilst intra-nasal cocaine-induced midline destructive lesions are a well-described condition, this is the first known report of Eustachian tube stenosis associated with cocaine use. CONCLUSION: This unique report highlights the importance of thorough history-taking, rhinological and otological examination, and audiometric testing when assessing patients with a history of chronic cocaine use. This paper demonstrates the complexity of managing hearing loss in such cases, with multiple conservative and surgical options available.

Consent for septoplasty: Are we meeting patients' expectations?

The requirements for informed consent were modified in 2015 following the UK Supreme Court judgment of Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board. This marked a decisive shift from the traditional paternalistic 'doctor knows best' model towards a more patient-centred approach. This study examines the current standard of consent for septoplasty and whether it complies with the law. We also report whether the 'reasonable patient' and surgeon agree about which risks should be discussed during the consent process. Ten complications were identified as common or serious via a literature search. Using questionnaires, 21 Ears, Nose and Throat surgeons were asked which of these they routinely discussed, and 103 patients were asked how seriously they regarded those complications. Results were compared using the Test of Proportions. Most surgeons routinely discuss all risks except negative change in sense of smell and numbness of upper incisors. The 'reasonable patient' regarded these two complications as serious or very serious. However, less than 70% of surgeons mentioned them. A significant proportion of Ears, Nose and Throat surgeons do not routinely mention all the risks that the 'reasonable patient' would want to know about before undergoing a septoplasty. This may result in more clinical negligence claims, as managing a patient's reasonable expectations is an important factor.

An interesting case report of delayed presentation of visual loss from an Ethmoid Mucocoele. Should we offer emergency decompression?

Paranasal sinus mucocoeles commonly involve the frontoethmoidal sinuses and can rarely present with vision changes due to expansion and invasion through the orbit. A 50-year-old female presented out of hours with an acute, 16-h history of complete left sided visual loss, on a background of 3 days of visual changes. A left ethmoid mucocoele extending into the left orbital apex causing compression of the optic nerve was diagnosed on imaging. Emergency endoscopic sinus surgery with decompression and marsupialization of the ethmoid mucocoele was performed, which resulted in improvement of vision. This case is unusual due to improvement in vision despite the length of visual loss prior to surgical intervention. This case demonstrates the importance of considering rhinological causes for vision loss, and how critical early identification and surgical intervention can be to prevent serious complications such as permanent vision loss.

Non-infective supraglottitis: two cases of unusual aetiology.

Supraglottitis is an ear, nose and throat emergency where swelling of the laryngeal structures can threaten to fatally obstruct the airway. Most cases of supraglottitis are of infective origin but other rarer causes have been documented. We present two patients who presented with stridor and were found to have supraglottic oedema on fibreoptic nasolaryngoscopy. Both patients presented with odynophagia and progressive dyspnoea and were initially medically managed to stabilise their airway. This included intravenous steroids, nebulised epinephrine and intravenous antibiotics. After this initial treatment they both required investigation and optimisation of their underlying medical conditions (rheumatoid arthritis with possible systemic lupus erythematosus and nephrotic syndrome) as more definitive management.

Paediatric subglottic stenosis - Have things changed? Our experience from a developing tertiary referral centre.

BACKGROUND: Paediatric airway disorders are common, particularly in the context of improved ventilation methods for neonates in intensive care units. Management is not standardised. OBJECTIVES: To assess the number, severity, management and outcomes of all patients diagnosed with subglottic stenosis at a developing tertiary referral centre. STUDY DESIGN: 19 month prospective longitudinal study. STUDY POPULATION: All patients who underwent microlaryngobronchoscopy (MLB) were included. Subglottic stenosis (SGS) was graded intraoperatively using the Myer-Cotton classification. RESULTS: 102 patients underwent MLB during this period. 33 of 102 patients (32.4%) were diagnosed with SGS+/-other co-pathologies. Mean and median age at diagnostic procedure were 24.7 months (SD 23.5) and 18 months, respectively. At their first MLB, 22 of 33 patients (66.7%) were found to have a Grade 1 SGS, 7 of 33 (21.2%) were Grade 2 and the remaining 4 of 33 (12.1%) were Grade 3. We had no patients with Grade 4 SGS. During this period, these patients with SGS underwent 73 MLBs+/-interventions (2.21 per patient) such as incision and balloon dilatation, tracheostomy (2 of 33) or ultimately, laryngotracheal reconstruction (LTR) (2 of 33). A further 3 patients have since undergone LTR. No significant unexpected events occurred. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that subglottic stenosis may be evolving in terms of its presentation and management. Management can more often be endoscopic and perhaps avoid tracheostomy or laryngotracheal reconstruction. Further long term prospective studies are required.

Conservative management of bilateral choanal atresia? Bilateral choanal atresia diagnosed in a 5-year-old girl.

Choanal atresia (CA) is an obliteration or blockage of the posterior nasal aperture, limiting or obstructing the nasal airway to the nasopharynx. The presentation of unilateral CA commonly occurs at a later age than those children affected by bilateral CA (BCA) and can often persist undiagnosed into adulthood. BCA, on the other hand, typically presents with respiratory obstruction within the first few days of life, or desaturations with or without cyanosis when feeding or during exertion and traditional teaching is that this is a life-threatening emergency. We present the case of a 5-year-old girl referred to our department with nasal obstruction, snoring and some mild rhinorrhoea. After investigation she was found to have a mixed bony and membranous BCA and no other craniofacial abnormalities. The BCA was subsequently repaired using urethral dilators and a drill and the child is currently asymptomatic of any restenosis. This case prompts discussion of the various presentations and options in management of CA as well as allowing us an opportunity to discuss the literature on the subject.

The eye in the neck: removal of a sewing needle from the posterior pharyngeal wall.

Foreign body ingestion is a frequent presenting complaint to most emergency departments but the finding of a sewing needle in the posterior pharynx particularly is a rare finding. We report a case of a male patient with a sewing needle lodged in the posterior pharynx despite a history suggestive of chicken bone ingestion, absent clinical features, and negative flexible endoscopic examination. The needle was only identified through cervical spine radiographs. Even subsequent pharyngoscopy, laryngoscopy, and upper oesophagoscopy all proved to be unremarkable with the patient eventually requiring a left neck exploration to remove the needle. The case outlines the importance of simple radiography in suspected foreign body ingestion, even though clinical and endoscopic findings may be unremarkable.