Understanding the heterogeneity intrinsic to protein folding.

Relating the native fold of a protein to its amino acid sequence remains a fundamental problem in biology. While computer algorithms have demonstrated recently their prowess in predicting what structure a particular amino acid sequence will fold to, an understanding of how and why a specific protein fold is achieved remains elusive. A major challenge is to define the role of conformational heterogeneity during protein folding. Recent experimental studies, utilizing time-resolved FRET, hydrogen-exchange coupled to mass spectrometry, and single-molecule force spectroscopy, often in conjunction with simulation, have begun to reveal how conformational heterogeneity evolves during folding, and whether an intermediate ensemble of defined free energy consists of different sub-populations of molecules that may differ significantly in conformation, energy and entropy.

Mutations of evolutionarily conserved aromatic residues suggest that misfolding of the mouse prion protein may commence in multiple ways.

The misfolding of the mammalian prion protein from its α-helix rich cellular isoform to its ß-sheet rich infectious isoform is associated with several neurodegenerative diseases. The determination of the structural mechanism by which misfolding commences, still remains an unsolved problem. In the current study, native-state hydrogen exchange coupled with mass spectrometry has revealed that the N state of the mouse prion protein (moPrP) at pH 4 is in dynamic equilibrium with multiple partially unfolded forms (PUFs) capable of initiating misfolding. Mutation of three evolutionarily conserved aromatic residues, Tyr168, Phe174, and Tyr217 present at the interface of the ß2-α2 loop and the C-terminal end of α3 in the structured C-terminal domain of moPrP significantly destabilize the native state (N) of the protein. They also reduce the free energy differences between the N state and two PUFs identified as PUF1 and PUF2**. It is shown that PUF2** in which the ß2-α2 loop and the C-terminal end of α3 are disordered, has the same stability as the previously identified PUF2*, but to have a very different structure. Misfolding can commence from both PUF1 and PUF2**, as it can from PUF2*. Hence, misfolding can commence and proceed in multiple ways from structurally distinct precursor conformations. The increased extents to which PUF1 and PUF2** are populated at equilibrium in the case of the mutant variants, greatly accelerate their misfolding. The results suggest that the three aromatic residues may have been evolutionarily selected to impede the misfolding of moPrP.

Replacement of the native cis prolines by alanine leads to simplification of the complex folding mechanism of a small globular protein.

The folding mechanism of MNEI, a single-chain variant of naturally occurring double-chain monellin, is complex, with multiple parallel refolding channels. To determine whether its folding energy landscape could be simplified, the two native cis-prolines, Pro41 and Pro93, were mutated, singly and together, to Ala. The stability of P93A was the same as that of the wild-type protein, pWT; however, P41A and P41AP93A were destabilized by ∼0.9 kcal mol-1. The effects of the mutations on the very fast, fast, slow, and very slow phases of folding were studied. They showed that heterogeneity in the unfolded state arises due to cis to trans isomerization of the Gly92-Pro93 peptide bond. The Pro41 to Ala mutation abolished the very slow phase of folding, whereas surprisingly, the Pro93 to Ala mutation abolished the very fast phase of folding. Double-jump, interrupted folding experiments indicated that two sequential trans to cis proline isomerization steps, of the Gly92-Pro93 peptide bond followed by the Arg40-Pro41 peptide bond, lead to the formation of the native state. They also revealed the accumulation of a late native-like intermediate, N∗, which differs from the native state in the isomeric status of the Arg40-Pro41 bond, as well as in a few tertiary contacts as monitored by near-UV CD measurements. The Pro to Ala mutations not only eliminated the cis to trans Pro isomerization reaction in the unfolded state, but also the two trans to cis Pro isomerization reactions during folding. By doing so, and by differentially affecting the relative stabilities of folding intermediates, the mutations resulted in a simplification of the folding mechanism. The two Pro to Ala mutations together accelerate folding to such an extent that the native state forms more than 1000-fold faster than in the case of pWT.

Differentiating between the sequence of structural events on alternative pathways of folding of a heterodimeric protein.

Distinguishing between competing pathways of folding of a protein, on the basis of how they differ in their progress of structure acquisition, remains an important challenge in protein folding studies. A previous study had shown that the heterodimeric protein, double chain monellin (dcMN) switches between alternative folding pathways upon a change in guanidine hydrochloride (GdnHCl) concentration. In the current study, the folding of dcMN has been characterized by the pulsed hydrogen exchange (HX) labeling methodology used in conjunction with mass spectrometry. Quantification of the extent to which folding intermediates accumulate and then disappear with time of folding at both low and high GdnHCl concentrations, where the folding pathways are known to be different, shows that the folding mechanism is describable by a triangular three-state mechanism. Structural characterization of the productive folding intermediates populated on the alternative pathways has enabled the pathways to be differentiated on the basis of the progress of structure acquisition that occurs on them. The intermediates on the two pathways differ in the extent to which the α-helix and the rest of the ß-sheet have acquired structure that is protective against HX. The major difference is, however, that ß2 has not acquired any protective structure in the intermediate formed on one pathway, but it has acquired significant protective structure in the intermediate formed on the alternative pathway. Hence, the sequence of structural events is different on the two alternative pathways.

Evolutionarily Conserved Proline Residues Impede the Misfolding of the Mouse Prion Protein by Destabilizing an Aggregation-competent Partially Unfolded Form.

The misfolding of the prion protein has been linked to several neurodegenerative diseases. Despite extensive studies, the mechanism of the misfolding process remains poorly understood. The present study structurally delineates the role of the conserved proline residues present in the structured C-terminal domain of the mouse prion protein (moPrP) in the misfolding process. It is shown that mutation of these Pro residues to Ala leads to destabilization of the native (N) state, and also to rapid misfolding. Using hydrogen-deuterium exchange (HDX) studies coupled with mass spectrometry (MS), it has been shown that the N state of moPrP is in rapid equilibrium with a partially unfolded form (PUF2*) at pH 4. It has been shown that the Pro to Ala mutations make PUF2* energetically more accessible from the N state by stabilizing it relative to the unfolded (U) state. The apparent rate constant of misfolding is found to be linearly proportional to the extent to which PUF2* is populated in equilibrium with the N state, strongly indicating that misfolding commences from PUF2*. It has also been shown that the Pro residues restrict the boundary of the structural core of the misfolded oligomers. Overall, this study highlights how the conserved proline residues control misfolding of the prion protein by modulating the stability of the partially unfolded form from which misfolding commences.

α-Synuclein Aggregation Intermediates form Fibril Polymorphs with Distinct Prion-like Properties.

α-Synuclein (α-Syn) amyloids in synucleinopathies are suggested to be structurally and functionally diverse, reminiscent of prion-like strains. The mechanism of how the aggregation of the same precursor protein results in the formation of fibril polymorphs remains elusive. Here, we demonstrate the structure-function relationship of two polymorphs, pre-matured fibrils (PMFs) and helix-matured fibrils (HMFs), based on α-Syn aggregation intermediates. These polymorphs display the structural differences as demonstrated by solid-state NMR and mass spectrometry studies and also possess different cellular activities such as seeding, internalization, and cell-to-cell transfer of aggregates. HMFs, with a compact core structure, exhibit low seeding potency but readily internalize and transfer from one cell to another. The less structured PMFs lack transcellular transfer ability but induce abundant α-Syn pathology and trigger the formation of aggresomes in cells. Overall, the study highlights that the conformational heterogeneity in the aggregation pathway may lead to fibril polymorphs with distinct prion-like behavior.

Elongation of Fibrils Formed by a Tau Fragment is Inhibited by a Transient Dimeric Intermediate.

The formation and propagation of aggregates of the tau protein in the brain are associated with the tauopathy group of neurodegenerative diseases. Different tauopathies have been shown to be associated with structurally distinct aggregates of tau. However, the mechanism by which different structural folds arise remains poorly understood. In this study of fibril formation by the fragment tau-K18 of tau, it is shown that the Lys 280 → Glu mutation in the variant tau-K18 K280E forms fibrils that are morphologically distinct from those formed by wild-type (wt) tau-K18. The mutant fibrils appear to have two protofilaments twisted around each other, whereas the wt fibrils are straight and appear to have a single protofilament. Modeling the kinetics of seeded aggregation, using a simple Michaelis-Menten-like mechanism, reveals that the two morphologically distinct fibrils are elongated with different catalytic efficiencies. Surprisingly, when the elongation of monomeric tau-K18 is seeded with tau-K18 K280E fibrils, it is seen to be inhibited at high monomer concentrations. Such inhibition is not seen when elongation is seeded with tau-K18 fibrils. The mechanism of inhibition is shown to be describable as uncompetitive inhibition, in which a transient dimeric form of tau-K18 acts as an uncompetitive inhibitor. Importantly, a dimeric form of tau-K18 is seen to be populated to a detectable extent early during aggregation. A covalently linked tau dimer, with an inter-molecular disulphide linkage, is shown to be capable of acting as an inhibitor. In summary, a quantitative kinetic approach has provided an understanding of how the formation of distinct structural folds of tau fibrils can be modulated by mutation and how the elongation of one fibril type, but not the other, is inhibited by a transiently formed dimer.

Heterogeneity in Protein Folding and Unfolding Reactions.

Proteins have dynamic structures that undergo chain motions on time scales spanning from picoseconds to seconds. Resolving the resultant conformational heterogeneity is essential for gaining accurate insight into fundamental mechanistic aspects of the protein folding reaction. The use of high-resolution structural probes, sensitive to population distributions, has begun to enable the resolution of site-specific conformational heterogeneity at different stages of the folding reaction. Different states populated during protein folding, including the unfolded state, collapsed intermediate states, and even the native state, are found to possess significant conformational heterogeneity. Heterogeneity in protein folding and unfolding reactions originates from the reduced cooperativity of various kinds of physicochemical interactions between various structural elements of a protein, and between a protein and solvent. Heterogeneity may arise because of functional or evolutionary constraints. Conformational substates within the unfolded state and the collapsed intermediates that exchange at rates slower than the subsequent folding steps give rise to heterogeneity on the protein folding pathways. Multiple folding pathways are likely to represent distinct sequences of structure formation. Insight into the nature of the energy barriers separating different conformational states populated during (un)folding can also be obtained by resolving heterogeneity.

Native State Hydrogen Exchange-Mass Spectrometry Methods to Probe Protein Folding and Unfolding.

Native state hydrogen exchange (HX) methods provide high-resolution structural data on the rare and transient opening motions in proteins under native conditions. Mass spectrometry-based HX methods (HX-MS) have gained popularity because of their ability to delineate population distributions, which allow a direct determination of the mechanism of inter conversion of the partially folded states under native conditions. Various technological advancements have provided further impetus to the development of HX-MS-based experiments to study protein folding. Classical HX-MS studies use proteolytic digestion to produce fragments of the protein subsequent to HX in solution, in order to obtain structural data. New chemical fragmentation methods, which achieve the same result as proteolysis and cause minimal change to the HX pattern in the protein, provide an attractive alternative to proteolysis. Moreover, when used in conjunction with proteolysis, chemical fragmentation methods have significantly increased the structural resolution afforded by HX-MS studies, even bringing them at par with the single amino acid resolution observed in NMR-based measurements. Experiments based on one such chemical fragmentation method, electron transfer dissociation (ETD), are described in this chapter. The ETD HX-MS method is introduced using data from a protein which is inherently resistant to proteolytic digestion as example of how such an experiment can provide high-resolution structural data on the folding-unfolding transitions of the protein under native conditions.

Microsecond Dynamics During the Binding-induced Folding of an Intrinsically Disordered Protein.

Tau is an intrinsically disordered protein implicated in many neurodegenerative diseases. The repeat domain fragment of tau, tau-K18, is known to undergo a disorder to order transition in the presence of lipid micelles and vesicles, in which helices form in each of the repeat domains. Here, the mechanism of helical structure formation, induced by a phospholipid mimetic, sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) at sub-micellar concentrations, has been studied using multiple biophysical probes. A study of the conformational dynamics of the disordered state, using photoinduced electron transfer coupled to fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (PET-FCS) has indicated the presence of an intermediate state, I, in equilibrium with the unfolded state, U. The cooperative binding of the ligand (L), SDS, to I has been shown to induce the formation of a compact, helical intermediate (IL5) within the dead time (∼37 µs) of a continuous flow mixer. Quantitative analysis of the PET-FCS data and the ensemble microsecond kinetic data, suggests that the mechanism of induction of helical structure can be described by a U ↔ I ↔ IL5 ↔ FL5 mechanism, in which the final helical state, FL5, forms from IL5 with a time constant of 50-200 µs. Finally, it has been shown that the helical conformation is an aggregation-competent state that can directly form amyloid fibrils.

Destabilization of polar interactions in the prion protein triggers misfolding and oligomerization.

The prion protein (PrP) misfolds and oligomerizes at pH 4 in the presence of physiological salt concentrations. Low pH and salt cause structural perturbations in the monomeric prion protein that lead to misfolding and oligomerization. However, the changes in stability within different regions of the PrP prior to oligomerization are poorly understood. In this study, we have characterized the local stability in PrP at high resolution using amide temperature coefficients (TC ) measured by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The local stability of PrP was investigated under native as well as oligomerizing conditions. We have also studied the rapidly oligomerizing PrP variant (Q216R) and the protective PrP variant (A6). We report that at low pH, salt destabilizes PrP at several polar residues, and the hydrogen bonds in helices α2 and α3 are weakened. In addition, salt changes the curvature of the α3 helix, which likely disrupts α2-α3 contacts and leads to oligomerization. These results are corroborated by the TC values of rapidly oligomerizing Q216R-PrP. The poly-alanine substitution in A6-PrP stabilizes α2, which prevents oligomerization. Altogether, these results highlight the importance of native polar interactions in determining the stability of PrP and reveal the structural disruptions in PrP that lead to misfolding and oligomerization.

Structural Characterization of the Cooperativity of Unfolding of a Heterodimeric Protein using Hydrogen Exchange-Mass Spectrometry.

Little is known about how the sequence of structural changes in one chain of a heterodimeric protein is coupled to those in the other chain during protein folding and unfolding reactions, and whether individual secondary structural changes in the two chains occur in one or many coordinated steps. Here, the unfolding mechanism of a small heterodimeric protein, double chain monellin, has been characterized using hydrogen exchange-mass spectrometry. Transient structure opening, which enables HX, was found to be describable by a five state N â†” I1 â†” I2 â†” I3 â†” U mechanism. Structural changes occur gradually in the first three steps, and cooperatively in the last step. ß strands 2, 4 and 5, as well as the α-helix undergo transient unfolding during all three non-cooperative steps, while ß1 and the two loops on both sides of the helix undergo transient unfolding during the first two steps. In the absence of GdnHCl, only ß3 in chain A of the protein unfolds during the last cooperative step, while in the presence of 1 M GdnHCl, not only ß3, but also ß2 in chain B unfolds cooperatively. Hence, the extent of cooperative structural change and size of the cooperative unfolding unit increase when the protein is destabilized by denaturant. The naturally evolved two-chain variant of monellin folds and unfolds in a more cooperative manner than does a single chain variant created artificially, suggesting that increasing folding cooperativity, even at the cost of decreasing stability, may be a driving force in the evolution of proteins.

Resolving Site-Specific Heterogeneity of the Unfolded State under Folding Conditions.

Understanding the properties of the unfolded state under folding conditions is of fundamental importance for gaining mechanistic insight into folding as well as misfolding reactions. Toward achieving this objective, the folding reaction of a small protein, monellin, has been resolved structurally and temporally, with the use of the multisite time-resolved FRET methodology. The present study establishes that the initial polypeptide chain collapse is not only heterogeneous but also structurally asymmetric and nonuniform. The population-averaged size for the segments spanning parts of the ß-sheet decreases much more than that for the α-helix. Multisite measurements enabled specific and nonspecific components of the initial chain collapse to be discerned. The expanded and compact intermediate subensembles have the properties of a nonspecifically collapsed (hence, random-coil-like) and specifically collapsed (hence, globular) polymer, respectively. During subsequent folding, both the subensembles underwent contraction to varying extents at the four monitored segments, which was close to gradual in nature. The expanded intermediate subensemble exhibited an additional very slow contraction, suggestive of the presence of non-native interactions that result in a higher effective viscosity slowing down intrachain motions under folding conditions.

The Lys 280 → Gln mutation mimicking disease-linked acetylation of Lys 280 in tau extends the structural core of fibrils and modulates their catalytic properties.

Amyloid fibrillar aggregates isolated from the brains of patients with neurodegenerative diseases invariably have post-translational modifications (PTMs). The roles that PTMs play in modulating the structures and polymorphism of amyloid aggregates, and hence their ability to catalyze the conversion of monomeric protein to their fibrillar structure is, however, poorly understood. This is particularly true in the case of tau aggregates, where specific folds of fibrillar tau have been implicated in specific tauopathies. Several PTMs, including acetylation at Lys 280, increase aggregation of tau in the brain, and increase neurodegeneration. In this study, tau-K18 K280Q, in which the Lys 280 → Gln mutation is used to mimic acetylation at Lys 280, is shown, using HX-MS measurements, to form fibrils with a structural core that is longer than that of tau-K18 fibrils. Measurements of critical concentrations show that the binding affinity of monomeric tau-K18 for its fibrillar counterpart is only marginally more than that of monomeric tau-K18 K280Q for its fibrillar counterpart. Quantitative analysis of the kinetics of seeded aggregation, using a simple Michaelis-Menten-like model, in which the monomer first binds and then undergoes conformational conversion to ß-strand, shows that the fibrils of tau-K18 K280Q convert monomeric protein more slowly than do fibrils of tau-K18. In contrast, monomeric tau-K18 K280Q is converted faster to fibrils than is monomeric tau-K18. Thus, the effect of Lys 280 acetylation on tau aggregate propagation in brain cells is expected to depend on the amount of acetylated tau present, and on whether the propagating seed is acetylated at Lys 280 or not.

Mapping Distinct Sequences of Structure Formation Differentiating Multiple Folding Pathways of a Small Protein.

To determine experimentally how the multiple folding pathways of a protein differ, in the order in which the structural parts are assembled, has been a long-standing challenge. To resolve whether structure formation during folding can progress in multiple ways, the complex folding landscape of monellin has been characterized, structurally and temporally, using the multisite time-resolved FRET methodology. After an initial heterogeneous polypeptide chain collapse, structure formation proceeds on parallel pathways. Kinetic analysis of the population evolution data across various protein segments provides a clear structural distinction between the parallel pathways. The analysis leads to a phenomenological model that describes how and when discrete segments acquire structure independently of each other in different subensembles of protein molecules. When averaged over all molecules, structure formation is seen to progress as α-helix formation, followed by core consolidation, then ß-sheet formation, and last end-to-end distance compaction. Parts of the protein that are closer in the primary sequence acquire structure before parts separated by longer sequence.

Binding-induced folding under unfolding conditions: Switching between induced fit and conformational selection mechanisms.

The chemistry of protein-ligand binding is the basis of virtually every biological process. Ligand binding can be essential for a protein to function in the cell by stabilizing or altering the conformation of a protein, particularly for partially or completely unstructured proteins. However, the mechanisms by which ligand binding impacts disordered proteins or influences the role of disorder in protein folding is not clear. To gain insight into this question, the mechanism of folding induced by the binding of a Pro-rich peptide ligand to the SH3 domain of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase unfolded in the presence of urea has been studied using kinetic methods. Under strongly denaturing conditions, folding was found to follow a conformational selection (CS) mechanism. However, under mildly denaturing conditions, a ligand concentration-dependent switch in the mechanism was observed. The folding mechanism switched from being predominantly a CS mechanism at low ligand concentrations to being predominantly an induced fit (IF) mechanism at high ligand concentrations. The switch in the mechanism manifests itself as an increase in the reaction flux along the IF pathway at high ligand concentrations. The results indicate that, in the case of intrinsically disordered proteins too, the folding mechanism is determined by the concentration of the ligand that induces structure formation.

Observation of Continuous Contraction and a Metastable Misfolded State during the Collapse and Folding of a Small Protein.

To obtain proper insight into how structure develops during a protein folding reaction, it is necessary to understand the nature and mechanism of the polypeptide chain collapse reaction, which marks the initiation of folding. Here, the time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer technique, in which the decay of the fluorescence light intensity with time is used to determine the time evolution of the distribution of intra-molecular distances, has been utilized to study the folding of the small protein, monellin. It is seen that when folding begins, about one-third of the protein molecules collapse into a molten globule state (IMG), from which they relax by continuous further contraction to transit to the native state. The larger fraction gets trapped into a metastable misfolded state. Exit from this metastable state occurs via collapse to the lower free energy IMG state. This exit is slow, on a time scale of seconds, because of activation energy barriers. The trapped misfolded molecules as well as the IMG molecules contract continuously and slowly as structure develops. A phenomenological model of Markovian evolution of the polymer chain undergoing folding, incorporating these features, has been developed, which fits well the experimentally observed time evolution of distance distributions. The observation that the "wrong turn" to the misfolded state has not been eliminated by evolution belies the common belief that the folding of functional protein sequences is very different from that of a random heteropolymer, and the former have been selected by evolution to fold quickly.

Mechanistic approaches to understand the prion-like propagation of aggregates of the human tau protein.

The dynamic nature of the tau protein under physiological conditions is likely to be critical for it to perform its diverse functions inside a cell. Under some conditions, this intrinsically disordered protein assembles into pathogenic aggregates that are self-perpetuating, toxic and infectious in nature. The role of liquid-liquid phase separation in the initiation of the aggregation reaction remains to be delineated. Depending on the nature of the aggregate, its structure, and its localization, neurodegenerative disorders with diverse clinical features are manifested. The prion-like mechanism by which these aggregates propagate and spread across the brain is not well understood. Various factors (PTMs, mutations) have been strongly associated with the pathological aggregates of tau. However, little is known about how these factors modulate the pathological properties linked to aggregation. This review describes the current progress towards understanding the mechanism of propagation of tau aggregates.