ABSTRACT
PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to compare morphologic assessment and relaxometry of patellar hyaline cartilage between conventional sequences (fast spin-echo [FSE] T2-weighted fat-saturated and T2-mapping) and synthetic T2 short-TI inversion recovery (STIR) and T2 maps at 1.5T magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). METHOD: The MRI examinations of the knee obtained at 1.5T in 49 consecutive patients were retrospectively studied. There were 21 men and 28 women with a mean age of 45±17.7 (SD) years (range: 18-88 years). Conventional and synthetic acquisitions were performed, including T2-weighted fat-saturated and T2-mapping sequences. Two radiologists independently compared patellar cartilage T2-relaxation time on conventional T2-mapping and synthetic T2-mapping images. A third radiologist evaluated the patellar cartilage morphology on conventional and synthetic T2-weighted images. The presence of artifacts was also assessed. Interobserver agreement for quantitative variables was assessed using intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). RESULTS: In vitro, conventional and synthetic T2 maps yielded similar mean T2 values 58.5±2.3 (SD) ms and 58.8±2.6 (SD) ms, respectively (P=0.414) and 6% lower than the expected experimental values (P=0.038). Synthetic images allowed for a 15% reduction in examination time compared to conventional images. On conventional sequences, patellar chondropathy was identified in 35 patients (35/49; 71%) with a mean chondropathy grade of 4.8±4.8 (SD). On synthetic images, 28 patients (28/49; 57%) were diagnosed with patellar chondropathy, with a significant 14% difference (P=0.009) and lower chondropathy scores (3.7±4.9 [SD]) compared to conventional images. Motion artifacts were more frequently observed on synthetic images (18%) than on conventional ones (6%). The interobserver agreement was excellent for both conventional and synthetic T2 maps (ICC>0.83). Mean cartilage T2 values were significantly greater on synthetic images (36.2±3.8 [SD] ms; range: 29-46ms) relative to conventional T2 maps (31.8±4.1 [SD] ms; range: 26-49ms) (P<0.0001). CONCLUSION: Despite a decrease in examination duration, synthetic images convey lower diagnostic performance for chondropathy, greater prevalence of motion artifacts, and an overestimation of T2 values compared to conventional MRI sequences.