Reflections on Henry G Kunkel as a mentor in clinical investigation.

Henry Kunkel spent nearly his entire professional life doing basic and clinical research at Rockefeller University. Many believe that he deserved to be a Nobel Laureate, not for one line of investigation, but for several in entirely distinct areas of medicine. Many of the leaders in immunology research during the last 50 years, especially research on systemic lupus erythematosus, received their research training in Henry Kunkel's laboratory. In this article, I attempt to illustrate his genius as a mentor from recollections of his scientific style and approach when I was a fellow in his laboratory almost 30 years ago. Henry Kunkel's legacy as a mentor continues today through the continuing contributions of his Fellows and their own trainees in immunological research.

Psychological determinants of fibromyalgia and related syndromes.

Fibromyalgia and other chronic pain and fatigue syndromes constitute an increasingly greater societal burden that currently is not being approached effectively by traditional Western medicine. Although the hallmarks of fibromyalgia--chronic widespread pain, fatigue, and multiple other somatic symptoms--have neurophysiologic and endocrinologic underpinnings, these biological aspects derive primarily from psychological variables. Female gender, adverse experiences during childhood, psychological vulnerability to stress, and a stressful, often frightening environment and culture are important antecedents of fibromyalgia. To understand fibromyalgia and related syndromes and to provide optimum care requires a biopsychosocial, not a biomedical, viewpoint.

Pain in fibromyalgia.

Just as our caveman forebears were frail in the face of predatory animals, we are frail in today's society of childhood neglect or abuse, bumper-to-bumper traffic, frustration at work, and multiple daily hassles. The same neuroendocrine systems and pain regulatory mechanisms that protected early man during acute stress are still encoded in our genome, but may be maladaptive in psychologically and physiologically vulnerable people faced with chronic stress. Many patients with fibromyalgia become vulnerable because of the long-lasting psychological and neurophysiological effects of negative experiences in childhood. Ill-equipped with positive cognitive, emotional, and behavioral skills as adults, they display maladaptive coping strategies, low self-efficacy, and negative mood when confronted with the inevitable stressors of life. Psychological distress ensues, which reduces thresholds for pain perception and tolerance (already relatively low in women) even further. Converging lines of psychological and neurobiological evidence strongly suggest that chronic stress-related blunting of the HPA, sympathetic, and other axes of the stress response together with associated alterations in pain regulatory mechanisms may finally explain the pain and fatigue of fibromyalgia. Vulnerable people who can be classified by the ACR criteria as having fibromyalgia do not have a discrete disease. They are simply the most ill in a continuum of distress, chronic pain, and painful tender points in the general population.

CD45 and Src-related protein tyrosine kinases regulate the T cell response to phorbol esters.

Protein kinase C (PKC)-dependent activation of the Ras signal transduction cascade is essential for induction of the IL-2 promoter during stimulation of T lymphocytes via the T cell receptor (TCR). In this study, the effects of PKC-activating phorbol myristate acetate (PMA) on Ras-dependent activation of transcription from the ets/AP-1 Ras-responsive promoter element were examined in human T cells. Pretreatment of Jurkat cells with the Src-family PTK inhibitor herbimycin A resulted in a 50% inhibition of transactivation of the reporter following incubation with PMA. Evidence was also obtained to suggest the participation of the leukocyte-specific protein tyrosine phosphatase CD45, a regulator of Src-like PTKs, in the PMA-induced activation of the Ras/Raf pathway. First, PMA-induced transactivation of ets/AP-1 is diminished 75% in CD45-negative variants, compared with CD45-positive cells. Second, engagement of CD45 by monoclonal antibodies suppresses the PMA response from the reporter construct. Taken together, these data suggest that Src-related proteins mediate PKC-dependent activation of the Ras/Raf pathway and implicate CD45 in the TCR-independent activation of T lymphocytes induced by agents such as PMA.

Autoantibodies that stabilize the molecular interaction of Ku antigen with DNA-dependent protein kinase catalytic subunit.

DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK) consists of a DNA binding subunit (Ku autoantigen), and a catalytic subunit (DNA-PKcs). In the present study, human autoantibodies that recognize novel antigenic determinants of DNA-PK were identified. One type of autoantibody stabilized the interaction of DNA-PKcs with Ku and recognized the DNA-PKcs -Ku complex, but not bio-chemically purified DNA-PKcs. Another type recognized purified DNA-PKcs. Autoantibodies to Ku (p70/p80 heterodimer), 'stabilizing' antibodies, and antibodies to DNA-PKcs comprise a linked autoantibody set, since antibodies recognizing purified DNA-PKcs were strongly associated with stabilizing antibodies, whereas stabilizing antibodies were strongly associated with anti-Ku. This hierarchical pattern of autoantibodies specific for components of DNA-PK (anti-Ku > stabilizing antibodies > anti-DNA-PKcs) may have implications for the pathogenesis of autoimmunity to DNA-PK and other chromatin particles. The data raise the possibility that altered antigen processing and/or stabilization of the DNA-PKcs-Ku complex due to autoantibody binding could play a role in spreading autoimmunity from Ku to the weakly associated antigen DNA-PKcs.

Cell-type specificity of anti-CD45 autoantibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the specificity of anti-CD45 autoantibodies in systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) for native CD45 and for CD45 expressed by T cells and B cells, and at different stages of cellular activation. METHODS: CD45 purified from different types of lymphocytes was examined by immunoblotting with sera from patients with SLE. Indirect immunofluorescence experiments were performed with purified anti-CD45 autoantibodies. RESULTS: IgM anti-CD45 autoantibodies in SLE recognize native CD45 expressed on the surface membrane of viable lymphocytes and CD45 purified from activated peripheral T cells and certain T cell lines, but not CD45 purified from B cells or resting peripheral T cells. The presence or absence of reactivity is independent of the individual isoforms expressed. CONCLUSION: Recognition of CD45 by IgM antilymphocyte autoantibodies in SLE varies with the lineage and state of activation of the lymphocyte target. This pattern of reactivity is consistent with autoantibody specificities involving CD45 glycoforms, rather than CD45 isoforms.

The 8.5-kb PstI allele of the stress protein gene, Hsp70-2: an independent risk factor for systemic lupus erythematosus in African Americans?

SLE is dramatically more prevalent in persons of African descent than in other populations. Several genes in the class III region of the MHC have been considered as potential susceptibility loci for this disorder, but the primary association(s) remains unknown. The stress protein gene, hsp70-2, is of special interest in this regard because it encodes a protein functionally relevant to antigen processing and presentation and has itself been identified as a putative susceptibility locus in organ-specific autoimmune diseases in Caucasians. To clarify the relationship of the hsp70-2 gene to SLE in African Americans, genomic DNA from 46 patients and 42 appropriately matched control subjects was analyzed for an RFLP of the hsp70-2 gene using the probe pH2.3 and the restriction endonuclease PstI, which identifies alleles of 8.5 and 9.0 kb. The 8.5-kb hsp70-2 allele was associated with SLE in this population (X2 = 8.2473, p = 0.0044). This association was not due to linkage disequilibrium with the C4A deletion or with HLA-DR3, as has been reported in Caucasians with IDDM. These data suggest that the 8.5-kb hsp70-2 allele may be an independent susceptibility marker for SLE in African Americans.

Autoregulation of Tcr V region epitopes in autoimmune disease.

Normal individuals possess low levels of autoantibodies specific for certain peptide defined regions of T-cell receptor (Tcr) variable regions, particularly CDR1 and Fr3. These regions are predicted to be exposed on the surface of the native molecule and, by analogy and comparison with immunoglobulins, correspond to public idiotype determinants. The anti-Tcr idiotype antibodies appear to be ubiquitous and we propose that they play a role in the regulation of T-cell function. To delineate the parameters of expression of these antibodies, we characterized anti-Tcr antibody activity in normal individuals, in those suffering from the autoimmune diseases rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), and in patients with non-autoimmune arthritis (osteoarthritis) as a disease control. There were significant increases in autoantibody levels in the autoimmune patients. There was also variation in isotype and the particular variable regions recognized. IgM autoantibodies directed against a few peptide defined determinants were elevated in RA, whereas SLE patient sera showed high levels of IgG binding to a broad spectrum of Tcr peptides.

"Anticardiolipin" autoantibodies recognize beta 2-glycoprotein I in the absence of phospholipid. Importance of Ag density and bivalent binding.

"Anticardiolipin" autoantibodies (aCL) bind to anionic phospholipids only in the presence of beta 2-glycoprotein I (beta 2GPI), a phospholipid-binding plasma protein. The exact role of beta 2GPI in the antigenic specificity of these autoantibodies is unclear, however. Experiments were performed to determine whether aCL recognize beta 2GPI in the absence of phospholipid or neo-Ags formed as a consequence of the beta 2GPI-phospholipid interaction. Although aCL+ IgG fractions did not bind to beta 2GPI alone in ELISAs that used standard polystyrene immunoassay plates, significant specific binding was detected when beta 2GPI was coated on gamma-irradiated ("high binding") polystyrene plates. This difference was associated with the greater density of beta 2GPI immobilized on the gamma-irradiated plates. Fab' fragments of patient IgG demonstrated little or no binding to immobilized beta 2GPI in ELISA, indicating a critical role for Ab bivalency. Inhibition studies of three aCL+ IgG fractions confirmed their specificity for beta 2GPI and demonstrated low affinity binding to fluid-phase beta 2GPI (Kd values of approximately 10(-5) M). aCL binding to beta 2GPI was not a result of phospholipid contamination of the assays, as determined by microphosphate assay and by lipid extraction of IgG and beta 2GPI preparations. In summary, these experiments indicate that IgG aCL are intrinsically low affinity Abs to beta 2GPI. Ab binding to beta 2GPI on a microtiter plate or anionic phospholipid membrane is dependent upon the marked increase in avidity provided by engagement of both Ag binding sites of a given IgG molecule. The data support the hypothesis that phospholipid-bound beta 2GPI is the physiologic target of aCL.

Synthetic autoantigens of immunoglobulins and T-cell receptors: their recognition in aging, infection, and autoimmunity.

Immunoglobulins and their close relatives, the antigen-specific T-cell receptors, are recognition proteins that express structures which readily serve as self-immunogens. Healthy humans can produce antibodies against variable region-defined recognition structures termed idiotypes, as well as against constant region structures, and the levels of these can increase markedly in autoimmune disease; e.g., rheumatoid factors are autoantibodies directed against a conformational determinant of the gamma heavy chain. More recent analyses employing synthetic peptide technologies and construction of recombinant T-cell receptors document that autoantibodies directed against both variable and constant region markers of the alpha/beta T-cell receptor occur in healthy individuals. Alterations in levels of antibody, usage of IgM or IgG isotypes, and specificity for particular peptide-defined regions vary with natural physiological processes (aging, pregnancy), with artificial allografting, with retroviral infection, and with the inception and progression of autoimmune disease (e.g., rheumatoid arthritis, systemic lupus erythematosus). Two of the major autoimmunogeneic regions of the Tcr alpha/beta are "constitutive" markers inasmuch as all individuals tested produce antibodies against these regions. The most frequently observed autoantibodies are against Tcr V beta CDR1 and Fr3 markers. It is hypothesized that these are normally involved in immunoregulation. Autoantibodies usually are not detected against CDR2 region determinants, or the "private idiotypes" defined by the CDR3 region, or the highly conserved FR4 segment specified by the joining gene segment. However, autoantibodies against the CDR2 of the Tcr alpha chain occur in some SLE patients, and healthy pregnant women produce antibodies against the common peptide determinant expressed by the joining gene and the beginning of the C alpha or C beta domain. Although the precise role of the naturally occurring autoantibodies in immunoregulation remains to be determined, modification of the course of autoimmune diseases in experimental rodent models (experimental allergic encephalomyelitis) has been successfully carried out by immunization with synthetic peptides corresponding to the CDR2 and Fr3/CDR3 segments, and immunization of humans with synthetic V beta CDR2 segments may prove helpful in multiple sclerosis. Moreover, infusion of intravenous immunoglobulins has been successful in the treatment of many autoimmune diseases, including examples where levels of T cells bearing particular V beta gene subsets were elevated. The recent knowledge gained from T-cell receptor structural analysis and antigenic modeling holds promise for determining the roles of particular variable domain structures in antigen recognition MHC-restriction and immunoregulation, and in the development of synthetic and recombinant reagents for modulation of autoimmune and infectious diseases.

IgG autoantibodies to "switch peptide" determinants of TCR alpha/beta in human pregnancy.

The fetus is a natural allograft that is protected from immunologic rejection by a complex set of structural and regulatory mechanisms. We determined whether healthy pregnant women differed significantly from healthy non-pregnant controls in their capacity to produce autoantibodies to defined antigenic determinants of the alpha/beta T-cell receptor. Although controls and pregnant women expressed comparable levels of autoantibodies against an intact recombinant T-cell receptor containing the complete V alpha/V beta structures, analysis of comparative reactivity against individual peptide segments of the molecules, indicated enhanced reactivity to regions corresponding to the CDR1 of the alpha chain and to the Fr3 of the variable region of the beta chain. A major difference was noted by increased reactivity of IgG autoantibodies of pregnant women to peptides corresponding to the "switch" region joining the variable and constant domains. This was noted with both the Tcr alpha and beta chains and was directed against highly conserved determinants within these molecules. Antibodies to this region are lacking in the non-pregnant controls. It is possible that autoantibodies directed against conserved regions of the T-cell receptor might function in the suppression of T-cell reactivity of fetal determinants.

Onset of polymyositis with autoantibodies to threonyl-tRNA synthetase during pregnancy.

A 24-year-old black woman developed polymyositis with autoantibodies to threonyl-tRNA synthetase in the 2nd trimester of her 3rd pregnancy. This was complicated by fetal loss and the development of severe relapsing myositis resistant to corticosteroid and azathioprine therapy. These features were also common in other cases in the literature. Antisynthetase antibodies had not been reported in myositis occurring during pregnancy and may be of interest regarding the pathogenesis of inflammatory myopathy complicating pregnancy.

Carbohydrate specificity of IgM autoantibodies to CD45 in systemic lupus erythematosus.

Patients with SLE develop IgM autoantibodies to different isoforms of CD45, the major surface membrane protein tyrosine phosphatase on lymphocytes and other nucleated hemopoietic cells. Because such autoantibodies could have a potential role in the development of immune dysfunction in this disorder, we performed a series of experiments to characterize their antigenic specificity further. Blots of recombinant E. coli fusion proteins encoded by exons 3-7 of the p220 and p180 isoforms were uniformly non-reactive with SLE IgM, suggesting that anti-CD45 autoantibodies in SLE are directed against conformational and/or carbohydrate epitopes, rather than linear polypeptide epitopes. This issue was examined further using chemically and enzymatically modified CD45 purified from T cells by lectin affinity chromatography as substrates. Treatment of CD45 with 25 mM sodium-m-periodate, sufficient to abrogate binding to various lectins, abolished the reactivity with SLE anti-CD45 autoantibodies. On the other hand, digestion of CD45 with neuraminidase enhanced the binding of anti-CD45 autoantibodies from some of the SLE sera. This result probably reflects decreased steric hindrance or charge repulsion because the binding of mouse monoclonal antibodies directed against linear polypeptide epitopes of CD45 was similarly enhanced. Digestion of CD45 with N-glycosidase F had no effect on autoantibody staining. Taken together, these data suggest that IgM anti-CD45 autoantibodies in SLE recognize non-sialylated carbohydrate determinants in the highly O-glycosylated polymorphic domains of CD45.