ABSTRACT
Background The effect of bronchodilators is mainly assessed with forced expiratory volume in 1s (FEV1) in COPD. Their impact on oxygenation and lung periphery is less known. Objectives To compare the action of long-acting ß2-agonists (LABA-olodaterol) and muscarinic antagonists (LAMA-tiotropium) on tissue oxygenation in COPD, considering their impact on proximal and peripheral ventilation as well as lung perfusion. Methods FEV1, Helium slope (SHe) from a single-breath washout test (SHe decrease reflecting a peripheral ventilation improvement), frequency dependence of resistance (R5-R19), area under reactance (AX), lung capillary blood volume (Vc) from double diffusion (DLNO/DLCO) and transcutaneous oxygenation (TcO2) were measured before and 2 hours post-LABA (day 1) and LAMA (day 3) in 30 COPD patients (FEV1 54±18% pred; GOLD A 31%/B 48%/E 21%) after 5-7 days of washout, respectively. Results TcO2 increased more (p=0.03) after LAMA (11±12%from baseline, p<0001) compared to LABA (4±11%, p=0.06) despite a lower FEV1 increase (p=0.03) and similar SHe (p=0.98), AX (p=0.63) and R5-R19 decreases (p=0.37). TcO2 and SHe changes were negatively correlated (r=-0.47, p=0.01) after LABA, not after LAMA (r=0.10, p=0.65). DLNO/DLCO decreased and Vc increased after LAMA (p=0.04; p=0.01, respectively) but not after LABA (p=0.53; p=0.24). Conclusion LAMA significantly improved tissue oxygenation in COPD patients, while only a trend was observed with LABA. The mechanisms involved may differ between both drugs: LABA increased peripheral ventilation while LAMA increased lung capillary blood volume. Should oxygenation differences persist over time, LAMA could arguably become the first therapeutic choice in COPD.
