ABSTRACT
Many aspects of thyroid nodule evaluation and management remain controversial. Widespread application of ultrasonography has resulted in frequent discovery of incidental nodules in the general population which has created a management dilemma for physicians. In this paper we have introduced a novel approach for evaluation of solid nodules, using an index derived from ultrasonographic and cytologic studies. Briefly thyroid nodules were classified ultrasonographically into four grades, with increasing score numbers (1-4) as progression to malignantly suspicious lesions was present. Similarly, four grades of a cytologic classification of fine needle biopsy aspirates were introduced with scores of 1-6 (benign to malignant diagnosis). The sum of the ultrasonographic and cytologic scores were the basis of a diagnostic index: benign (2-4), doubtful (5), suspicious (6) and malignant (7-10). Sixty patients with an index equal or higher than 6 were submitted to thyroidectomy and the prevalence of thyroid cancer (n = 46) in the excised nodules was 76.6%. Most series report a 10% to 30% incidence of malignancy in excised nodules with suspicious diagnosis. We concluded that using an index derived from combined ultrasonographic and cytologic studies will result in a better patient selection for surgery.