Vision on gyrate atrophy: why treat the eye?

In the April issue of this Journal, Boffa and coworkers put forward a new therapeutic approach for Gyrate Atrophy of the Choroid and Retina (GACR; OMIM 258870) (Boffa et al, 2023). The authors propose to apply gene therapy to the liver for GACR, a metabolic disease primarily affecting eyesight due to retinal degeneration. Their vision is enthusiastically supported by a News and Views comment in the same issue (Seker Yilmaz and Gissen, 2023). However, based on disease pathology, patient's needs, ethical considerations, therapeutic developmental time lines, and current state of the art of gene therapy for liver and eye, we have a different view on this issue: We argue below that local treatment of the eye is the preferred option for GACR.

Clinical characteristics of gyrate atrophy compared with a gyrate atrophy-like retinal phenotype.

INTRODUCTION: Gyrate atrophy (GA) is a rare retinal dystrophy due to biallelic pathogenic variants in the ornithine aminotransferase (OAT) gene, causing a 10-fold increase in plasma ornithine levels. It is characterized by circular patches of chorioretinal atrophy. However, a GA-like retinal phenotype (GALRP) without elevated ornithine levels has also been reported. The aim of this study is to compare the clinical characteristics of GA and GALRP and to identify possible discriminators. METHODS: A multicenter, retrospective chart review was performed at three German referral centres on patient records between 01/01/2009 and 31/12/2021. Records were screened for patients affected by GA or GALRP. Only patients with examination results for plasma ornithine levels and / or genetic testing of the OAT gene were included. Further clinical data was gathered where available. RESULTS: Ten patients (5 female) were included in the analysis. Three suffered from GA, while seven had a GALRP. Mean age (± SD) at onset of symptoms was 12.3 (± 3.5) years for GA compared with 46.7 (± 14.0) years for GALRP patients (p = 0.002). Mean degree of myopia was higher in GA (-8.0 dpt. ± 3.6) compared to GALRP patients (-3.8 dpt. ± 4.8, p = 0.04). Interestingly, all GA patients showed macular oedema, while only one GALRP patient did. Only one patient with GALRP had a positive family history, while two were immunosuppressed. DISCUSSION: Age of onset, refraction and presence of macular cystoid cavities appear to be discriminators between GA and GALRP. GALRP may encompass both genetic and non-genetic subtypes.

Clinical, biochemical and molecular analysis in a cohort of individuals with gyrate atrophy.

BACKGROUND: Gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina is a rare autosomal recessive metabolic disorder caused by biallelic variants in the OAT gene, encoding the enzyme ornithine δ-aminotransferase. Impaired enzymatic activity leads to systemic hyperornithinaemia, which in turn underlies progressive chorioretinal degeneration. In this study, we describe the clinical and molecular findings in a cohort of individuals with gyrate atrophy. METHODS: Study participants were recruited through a tertiary UK clinical ophthalmic genetic service. All cases had a biochemical and molecular diagnosis of gyrate atrophy. Retrospective phenotypic and biochemical data were collected using electronic healthcare records. RESULTS: 18 affected individuals from 12 families (8 male, 10 female) met the study inclusion criteria. The median age at diagnosis was 8 years (range 10 months - 33 years) and all cases had hyperornithinaemia (median: 800 micromoles/L; range: 458-1244 micromoles/L). Common features at presentation included high myopia (10/18) and nyctalopia (5/18). Ophthalmic findings were present in all study participants who were above the age of 6 years. One third of patients had co-existing macular oedema and two thirds developed pre-senile cataracts. Compliance with dietary modifications was suboptimal in most cases. A subset of participants had extraocular features including a trend towards reduced fat-free mass and developmental delay. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings highlight the importance of multidisciplinary care in families with gyrate atrophy. Secondary ophthalmic complications such as macular oedema and cataract formation are common. Management of affected individuals remains challenging due to the highly restrictive nature of the recommended diet and the limited evidence-base for current strategies.

Foveoschisis associated with gyrate atrophy in ornithine aminotransferase deficiency: A case report.

Ornithine aminotransferase (OAT) deficiency is an autosomal recessive disease characterized by elevated serum ornithine levels caused by mutations in genes encoding for ornithine aminotransferase, a vitamin B6-dependent mitochondrial matrix enzyme. Gyrate atrophy (GA) is characteristic findings in OAT that characterized by sharply demarcated circular, pigmentary, brain-like areas of chorioretinal atrophy in the peripheral retina. This case report presents rare assosiation between OAT and GA and describes the characteristic imaging findings of this unique, not fully understood clinical entity. The coexistence of GA and foveoschisis is extremely rare in OAT deficiency. We report a case of foveoschisis in a patient with OAT, and we will discuss the possible mechanisms that lead to it. A 24-year-old male patient presented with complaints of decreased vision and nictalopia for 1 year. The patient, who was diagnosed with oat 6 years ago, had typical gyrate atrophy in his Fundus floresein angiography and foveoschisis in his Optical coherence tomography. He was diagnosed with gyrate atrophy and foveoschisis. GA caused by OAT deficiency may present with macular involvement in the form of foveoschisis causing central visual impairment. Ophthalmologists should not ignore detailed fundus examination in children and young patients with visual impairment and should be aware of possible systemic diseases.

Biochemical and Bioinformatic Studies of Mutations of Residues at the Monomer-Monomer Interface of Human Ornithine Aminotransferase Leading to Gyrate Atrophy of Choroid and Retina.

Deficit of human ornithine aminotransferase (hOAT), a mitochondrial tetrameric pyridoxal-5'-phosphate (PLP) enzyme, leads to gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina (GA). Although 70 pathogenic mutations have been identified, only few enzymatic phenotypes are known. Here, we report biochemical and bioinformatic analyses of the G51D, G121D, R154L, Y158S, T181M, and P199Q pathogenic variants involving residues located at the monomer-monomer interface. All mutations cause a shift toward a dimeric structure, and changes in tertiary structure, thermal stability, and PLP microenvironment. The impact on these features is less pronounced for the mutations of Gly51 and Gly121 mapping to the N-terminal segment of the enzyme than those of Arg154, Tyr158, Thr181, and Pro199 belonging to the large domain. These data, together with the predicted ΔΔG values of monomer-monomer binding for the variants, suggest that the proper monomer-monomer interactions seem to be correlated with the thermal stability, the PLP binding site and the tetrameric structure of hOAT. The different impact of these mutations on the catalytic activity was also reported and discussed on the basis of the computational information. Together, these results allow the identification of the molecular defects of these variants, thus extending the knowledge of enzymatic phenotypes of GA patients.

Liver-directed gene therapy for ornithine aminotransferase deficiency.

Gyrate atrophy of choroid and retina (GACR) is a chorioretinal degeneration caused by pathogenic variants in the gene encoding ornithine aminotransferase (OAT), an enzyme mainly expressed in liver. Affected patients have increased ornithine concentrations in blood and other body fluids and develop progressive constriction of vision fields leading to blindness. Current therapies are unsatisfactory and better treatments are highly needed. In two mouse models of OAT deficiency that recapitulates biochemical and retinal changes of GACR, we investigated the efficacy of an intravenously injected serotype 8 adeno-associated (AAV8) vector expressing OAT under the control of a hepatocyte-specific promoter. Following injections, OAT-deficient mice showed reductions of ornithine concentrations in blood and eye cups compared with control mice injected with a vector expressing green fluorescent protein. AAV-injected mice showed improved electroretinogram response and partial restoration of retinal structure up to one-year post-injection. In summary, hepatic OAT expression by AAV8 vector was effective at correction of hyperornithinemia and improved function and structure of the retina. In conclusion, this study provides proof-of-concept of efficacy of liver-directed AAV-mediated gene therapy of GACR.

A possible ocular biomarker for response to hyperornithinemia in gyrate atrophy: the effect of pyridoxine, lysine, and arginine-restricted diet in a patient with advanced disease.

BACKGROUND: Loss of function variants in the ornithine aminotransferase (OAT) gene cause accumulation of ornithine levels, leading to gyrate atrophy. The benefit of ornithine-lowering therapies has been documented in a mouse model and young patients, however, the effect in adults with advanced disease has not been well described. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Case report of an adult patient with advanced gyrate atrophy, who underwent treatment with pyridoxine and an arginine-restricted diet for four years. RESULTS: A 51-year-old female with advanced chorioretinal degeneration presented with hyperornithinemia (961 vs. normal 18-135 µmol/L) and compound heterozygous pathogenic variants in OAT (p.Tyr299* and p.Ala270Pro). Treatment with pyridoxine and arginine-diet restriction yielded a maximal reduction in ornithine levels by 71% (275 µmol/L). Optical coherence tomography (OCT) showed a reduction in ellipsoid zone (EZ) thickness that correlated with lower ornithine levels and reversed with higher ornithine levels. While her best-corrected visual acuity remained unchanged, the progressive decline in her visual fields appeared to stabilize during a one-year period when ornithine levels were below 500 µmol/L. CONCLUSIONS: In this report, we demonstrate that chorioretinal degeneration appears to stabilize in an adult patient with gyrate atrophy in association with a partial reduction in ornithine levels. We also observed a correlation with reduced EZ thickness on OCT and propose this may be a novel biomarker for ornithine reduction therapies. Our case study characterizes the potential retinal structure-function benefits of ornithine-lowering treatments even in cases of advanced chorioretinal degeneration. Thus, we recommend a low threshold for treating all patients with gyrate atrophy.

Regression of treatment-resistant gyrate atrophy-associated intraretinal cystic spaces using long-term diet restriction: A case report.

PURPOSE: Gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina (GA) is a rare genetic ophthalmologic condition which primarily manifests in childhood. It is characterized by hyperornithinemia and progressive chorioretinal atrophy. Patients may develop macular intraretinal cystic spaces (ICS) for which various treatment modalities have been reported. We report a patient who failed to demonstrate visual or anatomic improvement following multiple treatments for GA-associated ICS but showed improvement following prolonged dietary modification and vitamin supplementation. CASE DESCRIPTION: A 6-year-old male patient presented with previously undiagnosed GA associated with ICS. He received 6 consecutive monthly intravitreal bevacizumab injections as well as topical nepafenac and dorzolamide for treatment of ICS without significant change detected by optical coherence tomography (OCT) following treatment. He was also maintained on an arginine restricted diet with vitamin B6 supplementation. Over the course of the ensuing year, the patient was lost to follow-up due to the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic. When he returned, his vision was stable, and OCT showed regression of the ICS. His mother reported that he had continued only on dietary restriction and vitamin B6 supplementation with no other medications or interventions. Plasma ornithine level measurement confirmed dietary compliance. Further follow-up showed continued stabilization of the condition. CONCLUSION: In addition to retarding progressive chorioretinal atrophy, prolonged dietary modifications may result in improvement of treatment-resistant GA-associated ICS. Parents' education on the value of dietary modifications for patients with GA is highly recommended.

[Gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina with ornithinemia and foveoschisis (clinical observation)]. / Atrofiya girate khorioidei i setchatki s ornitinemiei i foveoshizisom (klinicheskoe nablyudenie).

Gyrate chorioretinal atrophy (GCA) is a rare hereditary disease with certain complications; one extremely rare complication of GCA is foveoschisis. For the first time in Russian ophthalmology, a 10-year-old female child has been described to have genetically verified GCA associated with the OAT gene in combination with ornithinemia and foveoschisis. The diagnosis was made on the basis of fundus examination, perimetry data, autofluorescence, optical coherence tomography, fluorescence angiography, electroretinography, mass spectrometry with confirmation by molecular genetic research. The presented clinical case illustrates the need for an interdisciplinary approach to the diagnosis of GCA with diagnostic algorithm involving various examination methods and doctors of different specialties.

First reported case of pregnancy in a patient with ornithine aminotransferase deficiency.

Ornithine aminotransferase deficiency is a rare autosomalrecessive human inborn error of the metabolism resulting in hyperornithinemia and progressive chorioretinal degeneration (gyrate atrophy) with blindness. There are few reports in the literature and none, to our knowledge, that address this condition during pregnancy. We report on a novel case of ornithine aminotransferase deficiency during pregnancy that was managed actively with arginine and protein restriction with serial amino acid and fetal growth monitoring, resulting in an uncomplicated term live birth.

Gyrate Atrophy of the Choroid and Retina: A Review.

Gyrate atrophy (GA) of the choroid and retina is a rare autosomal recessive genetic condition characterized by elevation of the plasma level of the amino acid ornithine due to deficiency of the enzyme ornithine ketoacid aminotransferase. Accumulation of ornithine occurs in various body tissues but leads primarily to characteristic ophthalmic manifestations including myopia, cataract, progressive chorioretinal atrophy, and macular changes. Patients usually present with night blindness that starts in the first decade of life followed by visual field constriction and eventually diminution of the central visual acuity and blindness. The condition has been reported worldwide and its differential diagnosis is broad and includes choroideremia and retinitis pigmentosa. Treatment currently depends on life-long dietary modifications including restriction of the amino acid arginine in diet. This article describes in detail the pathogenesis, clinical features, multimodal imaging findings, and treatment options for GA of the choroid and retina and its complications.

A Case of Foveoschisis Associated with Ornithine Aminotransferase Deficiency and Gyrate Atrophy.

Gyrate atrophy is a metabolic disorder characterised by typical progressive circular chorioretinal atrophy, myopia and early developmental cataract. The disease is caused by deficiency of ornithine aminotransferase (OAT) enzyme. Although OAT is expressed in most tissues of the body, but the main target of the disease appears to be the retina. A case is presented here of a 21-year woman, who came to our clinic with the complaint of decline in central vision for eight months. She had progressive poor night vision and was diagnosed with OAT deficiency five years ago. Her systemic history was unremarkable, except for femoral deep vein thrombosis (DVT) which occurred two years ago. Laboratory tests performed at that time had revealed elevated serum ornithine and low serum lysin levels. Optic coherence tomography (OCT) scans showed foveoschisis bilaterally. In summary, gyrate atrophy may present as macular involvement in the form of foveoschisis and may lead to impaired central vision. Key Words: Foveoschisis, Gyrate atrophy, Ornithine aminotransferase.

A review of treatment modalities in gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina (GACR).

Gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina (GACR) is a rare inborn error of amino acid metabolism caused by bi-allelic variations in OAT. GACR is characterised by vision decline in early life eventually leading to complete blindness, and high plasma ornithine levels. There is no curative treatment for GACR, although several therapeutic modalities aim to slow progression of the disease by targeting different steps within the ornithine pathway. No international treatment protocol is available. We systematically collected all international literature on therapeutic interventions in GACR to provide an overview of published treatment effects. METHODS: Following the PRISMA guidelines, we conducted a systematic review of the English literature until December 22nd 2020. PubMed and Embase databases were searched for studies related to therapeutic interventions in patients with GACR. RESULTS: A total of 33 studies (n = 107 patients) met the inclusion criteria. Most studies were designed as case reports (n = 27) or case series (n = 4). No randomised controlled trials or large cohort studies were found. Treatments applied were protein-restricted diets, pyridoxine supplementation, creatine or creatine precursor supplementation, l-lysine supplementation, and proline supplementation. Protein-restricted diets lowered ornithine levels ranging from 16.0-91.2%. Pyridoxine responsiveness was reported in 30% of included mutations. Lysine supplementation decreased ornithine levels with 21-34%. Quality assessment showed low to moderate quality of the articles. CONCLUSIONS: Based primarily on case reports ornithine levels can be reduced by using a protein restricted diet, pyridoxine supplementation (variation-dependent) and/or lysine supplementation. The lack of pre-defined clinical outcome measures and structural follow-up in all included studies impeded conclusions on clinical effectiveness. Future research should be aimed at 1) Unravelling the OAT biochemical pathway to identify other possible pathologic metabolites besides ornithine, 2) Pre-defining GACR specific clinical outcome measures, and 3) Establishing an international historical cohort.

Ultrawide field imaging to document the progression of gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina over 5 years.

A family of three siblings affected with gyrate atrophy of the choroid and retina is presented. Ultrawide field fundus imaging was used to monitor the progression of the disease objectively over 5 years.

Autosomal Dominant Gyrate Atrophy-Like Choroidal Dystrophy Revisited: 45 Years Follow-Up and Association with a Novel C1QTNF5 Missense Variant.

We present a long-term follow-up in autosomal dominant gyrate atrophy-like choroidal dystrophy (adGALCD) and propose a possible genotype/phenotype correlation. Ophthalmic examination of six patients from two families revealed confluent areas of choroidal atrophy resembling gyrate atrophy, starting in the second decade of life. Progression continued centrally, reaching the fovea at about 60 years of age. Subretinal deposits, retinal pigmentation or choroidal neovascularization as seen in late-onset retinal degeneration (LORD) were not observed. Whole genome sequencing revealed a novel missense variant in the C1QTNF5 gene (p.(Q180E)) which was found in heterozygous state in all affected subjects. Haplotype analysis showed that this variant found in both families is identical by descent. Three-dimensional modeling of the possible supramolecular assemblies of C1QTNF5 revealed that the p.(Q180E) variant led to the destabilization of protein tertiary and quaternary structures, affecting both the stability of the single protomer and the entire globular head, thus exerting detrimental effects on the formation of C1QTNF5 trimeric globular domains and their interaction. In conclusion, we propose that the p.(Q180E) variant causes a specific phenotype, adGALCD, that differs in multiple clinical aspects from LORD. Disruption of optimal cell-adhesion mechanisms is expected when analyzing the effects of the point mutation at the protein level.

Partial regression of foveoschisis following vitamin B6 supplementary therapy for gyrate atrophy in a Chinese girl.

BACKGROUND: To report a case of genetically confirmed gyrate atrophy (GA) of choroid and retina, who showed partial regression of foveoschisis following vitamin B6 supplementary therapy. CASE PRESENTATION: A 6-year-old Chinese girl complained about night blindness and progressive decreased vision in both eyes. Her best corrected visual acuity (BCVA) was 20/63 OD and 20/100 OS. Fundus examination showed bilateral multiple, sharply demarcated, scallop-shaped chorioretinal atrophy areas in the midperipheral and peripheral of the fundus. Spectral domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) showed increased central macular thickness (CMT) with multiple intraretinal cystic spaces in the both eyes. There was no leakage or staining in the macular area in late phase of fluorescein angiography (FA). Blood tests confirmed hyperornithinemia and genetic analysis revealed two heterozygous mutations on ornithine aminotransferase (OAT) gene. Based on clinical presentation and genetic test, the patient was diagnosed as GA of the choroid and retina and further treated with vitamin B6 supplementary for three weeks. Her serum ornithine levels did not change but CMT on SD-OCT declined with partial regression of intraretinal cystic spaces. Then, the patient discontinued the drug because of severe muscle pain, and foveoschisis increased to initial level a month later. CONCLUSIONS: Foveoschisis is a rare complication of GA. Vitamin B6 supplementation may alleviate foveoschisis, but its effort for reducing serum ornithine level might be limited. Potential drug adverse effects should be noted in pediatric patients.