Impact of swab material on microbial surface sampling.

Efficient microbial sampling from surfaces for subsequent detection and quantification is crucial in fields such as food safety and hygiene monitoring. Cotton swabs are traditionally used for sample collection, but today there are numerous swabs of alternative material and different sizes available. Recovery efficiencies of swabs for different applications have been compared in several studies. However, the results are often contradictory. We have compared 15 different swabs made of cotton (n = 5), flocked nylon (n = 3) and foam (n = 7), for sampling of Listeria monocytogenes and mengovirus on small (4 cm2) and large (100 cm2) areas of window glass, ridged plastic and absorbing wood. Molecular quantification methods (qPCR and RT-qPCR) were applied, and all sampling and sample processing were standardized. Specific swabs gave higher DNA/RNA yields than others, depending on both the surface characteristics and the collected target. The highest DNA yields were achieved by applying Selefa or Puritan cotton swabs for Listeria sampling on 4 cm2 areas of window glass and ridged plastic. Certain foam swabs (Critical swab with medium head and Macrofoam) gave the highest yields when sampling Listeria on 4 cm2 areas of wood and on 100 cm2 areas of ridged plastic and wood. Most foam swabs, and especially Sigma Virocult, were advantageous for virus sampling, regardless of surface. Nylon-flocked swabs showed poor recovery regardless of surface characteristics. The recovery varied substantially between swabs made of the same material, suggesting that a single swab may not be representative for a certain swab material.

Evaluation of a commercial exogenous internal process control for diagnostic RNA virus metagenomics from different animal clinical samples.

Metagenomic next generation sequencing (mNGS) is increasingly recognized as an important complementary tool to targeted human and animal infectious disease diagnostics. It is, however, sensitive to biases and errors that are currently not systematically evaluated by the implementation of quality controls (QC) for the diagnostic use of mNGS. We evaluated a commercial reagent (Mengovirus extraction control kit, CeraamTools, bioMérieux) as an exogenous internal control for mNGS. It validates the integrity of reagents and workflow, the efficient isolation of viral nucleic acids and the absence of inhibitors in individual samples (verified using a specific qRT-PCR). Moreover, it validates the efficient generation of viral sequence data in individual samples (verified by normalized mengoviral read counts in the metagenomic analysis). We show that when using a completely random metagenomics workflow: (1) Mengovirus RNA can be reproducibly detected in different animal sample types (swine feces and sera, wild bird cloacal swabs), except for tissue samples (swine lung); (2) the Mengovirus control kit does not contain other contaminating viruses that may affect metagenomic experiments (using a cutoff of minimum 1 Kraken classified read per million (RPM)); (3) the addition of 2.17 × 106Mengovirus copies/mL of sample does not affect the virome composition of pig fecal samples or wild bird cloacal swab samples; (4) Mengovirus Cq values (using as cutoff the upper limit of the 99 % confidence interval of Cq values for a given sample matrix) allow the identification of samples with poor viral RNA extraction or high inhibitor load; (5) Mengovirus normalized read counts (cutoff RPM > 1) allow the identification of samples where the viral sequences are outcompeted by host or bacterial target sequences in the random metagenomic workflow. The implementation of two QC testing points, a first one after RNA extraction (Mengoviral qRT-PCR) and a second one after metagenomic data analysis provide valuable information for the validation of individual samples and results. Their implementation in addition to external controls validating runs or experiments should be carefully considered for a given sample type and workflow.

Efficiency evaluation of the process control virus "Mengovirus" in real time RT-PCR viral detection in the bivalve mollusc Donax sp.

There are many problems associated with extracting viral genetic material from contaminated samples of bivalve molluscs, specifically because the hepatopancreas has many PCR inhibitors. For this reason, nucleic acid extraction methods must consider a process control virus (PCV) that may help to measure extraction efficiency. In the market, there are many commercial kits to extract nucleic acid from RNA viruses, as well as others to perform one-step real time RT-PCR, but most of them have not been evaluated for bivalve molluscs. For this reason, the aim of this study was to evaluate the extraction efficiency of the PCV (Mengovirus), it was performed using 3 different RNA extraction kits and 2 one-step real time RT-PCR kits. 10 µL of Mengovirus at a concentration of 1.6 × 104 viral particles/µL was added to 29 samples of hepatopancreas of Donax sp. Sample processing was performed according to the ISO/TS 15216-2: 2013 standard. RNA was extracted from each sample with the kits: (1) BioMerieux NucliSens®system (BioMérieux SA, France), (2) PureLink™ RNA Mini Kit (Ambion-Life Technologies™, USA) and (3) Hugh Pure RNA Tissue Kit (Roche SA, Germany). Once RNA was extracted, one-step real time RT-PCR was conducted by using the following kits: (A) Ultrasense One-step qRT-PCR Kit (Invitrogen, USA) according to ISO/TS 15216-2:2013, and (B) Mengovirus@ceeramTools™ Kit (Ceeram, France) according to the manufacturer's specifications. The extraction efficiency of PCV when using the extraction kits 1, 2 and 3 combined with real time RT-PCR kit A were: 10.82, 1.90 and 0.64, respectively; and when using real time RT-PCR kit B were: 7.34, 0.97 and 0.47, respectively. It is concluded that the BioMerieux NucliSens®system RNA extraction kit was the most efficient and that the Ultrasense One-step qRT-PCR Kit performed better than the Mengovirus@ceeramTools™ RT-PCR kit.

Development of a method for direct extraction of viral RNA from bivalve molluscs.

The detection of foodborne viruses in bivalve molluscs is a challenging procedure in relation to low virus concentration and to the presence of significant RT-PCR inhibitors. The aim of this study was the development of an efficient direct extraction method for foodborne viral RNA from bivalve molluscs. Using Mengovirus as a surrogate for foodborne viruses, five extraction methods based on RNA release by Trizol were compared on clams and oysters. A procedure consisting of Trizol, PureLink RNA Mini Kit, followed by Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) treatment and LiCl precipitation was found to provide RNA with the highest extraction efficiency and negligible inhibitory effect on real-time RT-PCR. This procedure was further compared to standard extraction method (ISO 15216) using clam, mussel and oyster samples spiked with Hepatitis A virus, Norovirus (NoV) GI and GII as well as bivalve samples naturally contaminated with NoV GI or GII. Results clearly demonstrated that the developed method provided, on average, a recovery 4·3 times higher than the standard reference protocol as well as good repeatability. SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY: A direct extraction procedure was developed to recover viral RNA from shellfish with improved efficiency in comparison to reference extraction method (ISO 15216). Without the need for specific equipment, this procedure offers an alternative for performing food safety controls and for risk assessment studies. Given the inclusion in this extraction method of several steps for the efficient removal of food components inhibiting PCR reaction, this approach could serve as a general scheme for the extraction of nucleic acids of other enteric viruses and/or from other food categories.

The Fate of Mengovirus on Fiberglass Filter of Air Handling Units.

One of the most important topics that occupy public health problems is the air quality. That is the reason why mechanical ventilation and air handling units (AHU) were imposed by the different governments in the collective or individual buildings. Many buildings create an artificial climate using heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning systems. Among the existing aerosols in the indoor air, we can distinguish the bioaerosol with biological nature such as bacteria, viruses, and fungi. Respiratory viral infections are a major public health issue because they are usually highly infective. We spend about 90% of our time in closed environments such as homes, workplaces, or transport. Some studies have shown that AHU contribute to the spread and transport of viral particles within buildings. The aim of this work is to study the characterization of viral bioaerosols in indoor environments and to understand the fate of mengovirus eukaryote RNA virus on glass fiber filter F7 used in AHU. In this study, a set-up close to reality of AHU system was used. The mengovirus aerosolized was characterized and measured with the electrical low pressure impact and the scanner mobility particle size and detected with RT-qPCR. The results about quantification and the level of infectivity of mengovirus on the filter and in the biosampler showed that mengovirus can pass through the filter and remain infectious upstream and downstream the system. Regarding the virus infectivity on the filter under a constant air flow, mengovirus was remained infectious during 10 h after aerosolization.

Comparison of three extraction methods to detect noroviruses in dairy products.

Noroviruses (NoV) are currently the most common cause of viral foodborne diseases and RT-qPCR is widely used for their detection in food because of its sensitivity, specificity and rapidity. The ISO/TS (15216-1, 15216-2) procedures for detecting NoV and HAV in high-risk food categories such as shellfish, bottled water and vegetables were published in 2013. Milk products are less implicated in foodborne viral outbreaks but they can be contaminated with fruit added to these products or by the food handler. Thus, the development of sensitive and reliable techniques for the detection of NoV in dairy products is needed to ensure the safety of these products. The aim of this study was to develop a RT-qPCR based method for the detection of NoV in milk products. Three methods were tested to recover NoV from artificially contaminated milk and cottage cheese. The selected method was based on the use of proteinase K and the recovery efficiencies ranged from 54.87% to 98.87% for NoV GI, 61.16%-96.50% for NoV GII. Murine norovirus and mengovirus were used as process controls and their recovery efficiencies were respectively 60.59% and 79.23%. The described method could be applied for detecting NoV in milk products for routine diagnosis needs.

Test and validation of methods to sample and detect human virus from environmental surfaces using norovirus as a model virus.

BACKGROUND: Viruses cause a major proportion of human infections, especially gastroenteritis and respiratory infections in children and adults. Indirect transmission between humans via environmental surfaces may play a role in infections, but methods to investigate this have been sparse. AIM: To validate and test efficient and reliable procedures to detect multiple human pathogenic viruses on surfaces. METHODS: The study was divided into two parts. In Part A, six combinations of three different swabs (consisting of cotton, foamed cotton, or polyester head) and two different elution methods (direct lysis or immersion in alkaline glycine buffer before lysis) were tested for efficient recovery of human norovirus GII.7 and mengovirus from artificially contaminated surfaces. In Part B we determined the detection limit for norovirus GI.1 and GII.3 using the best procedure found in Part A linked with a commercial multiplex real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction detection assay. FINDINGS: Combining the polyester swab with direct lysis allowed recovery down to 100 and 10 genome copies/cm(2) of norovirus GI.1 and GII.3, respectively. This procedure resulted in the significant highest recovery of both norovirus and mengovirus, whereas no differences in amplification efficiencies were observed between the different procedures. CONCLUSION: The results indicate that it is possible to detect low concentrations of virus on environmental surfaces. We therefore suggest that a polyester swab, followed by direct lysis, combined with a multiplex qPCR detection assay is an efficient screening tool that merits study of different respiratory and gastrointestinal viruses on environment surfaces.

Variability in the recovery of a virus concentration procedure in water: Implications for QMRA.

Methods for analysing water for viruses are known to have variable and relatively poor recovery efficiencies. Quantitative method recovery data are needed to correct virus enumeration results so that estimates of virus concentrations in surface waters for QMRA are not too low. Obtaining quantitative data representing method recoveries for different pathogenic viruses is a significant challenge. In this study, we investigated the use of mengovirus process control data for quantifying recovery efficiency of human adenovirus (AdV) and noroviruses GI (NoVGI) and GII (NoVGII) from surface waters. Samples were collected from the inlet to a drinking water treatment plant on the Glomma River, Norway. Performance of the sample concentration procedure was quantified by comparing the virus concentrations found in concentrated and unconcentrated samples. The mean recovery of viruses (1.2%, 0.31%, 0.15% and 0.053% for mengovirus (n = 86), AdV (n = 20), NoVGI (n = 33) and NoVGII (n = 21) respectively) estimated in this study were lower than expected, and the between sample variability in estimated recovery was very high, spanning around 6 orders of magnitude for mengovirus. Within-sample correlation between the estimated recovery of mengovirus and human viruses was poor, and therefore sample specific mengovirus data could not be used to correct all human virus concentrations. Instead beta distributions were fitted to human virus-specific recovery estimates. The magnitude and variability of virus concentration when corrected for the variable recovery efficiency was orders of magnitude higher than the uncorrected concentration. Better estimates of virus concentration could be achieved if a sample-specific spiking control could be developed that mimicked closely the behaviour of human viruses in environmental samples.

Monitoring of Extraction Efficiency by a Sample Process Control Virus Added Immediately Upon Sample Receipt.

When analysing food samples for enteric viruses, a sample process control virus (SPCV) must be added at the commencement of the analytical procedure, to verify that the analysis has been performed correctly. Samples can on occasion arrive at the laboratory late in the working day or week. The analyst may consequently have insufficient time to commence and complete the complex procedure, and the samples must consequently be stored. To maintain the validity of the analytical result, it will be necessary to consider storage as part of the process, and the analytical procedure as commencing on sample receipt. The aim of this study was to verify that an SPCV can be recovered after sample storage, and thus indicate the effective recovery of enteric viruses. Two types of samples (fresh and frozen raspberries) and two types of storage (refrigerated and frozen) were studied using Mengovirus vMC0 as SPCV. SPCV recovery was not significantly different (P > 0.5) regardless of sample type or duration of storage (up to 14 days at -20 °C). Accordingly, samples can be stored without a significant effect on the performance of the analysis. The results of this study should assist the analyst by demonstrating that they can verify that viruses can be extracted from food samples even if samples have been stored.

Identification of Mengo virus T helper cell epitopes.

To identify Mengo virus-specific T cell epitopes in mice (the natural host for the virus), lymph node cells were obtained from BALB/c (H-2d) mice, previously immunized with u.v.-inactivated virus, and stimulated in vitro with each of 116 overlapping peptides (10 to 18 residues long) covering the entire capsid coding region (834 amino acids). T cell epitopes were defined on the basis of specific peptide-induced lymphocyte proliferation. Where proliferation occurred, immunological characterization showed that it was the CD4+ T helper (Th) cell subpopulation that was responsible for the Mengo virus-specific response. Surprisingly, no Mengo virus Th cell epitopes were found in capsid protein VP1 or VP4. Six peptides in VP2 (residues 1 to 15, 99 to 108, 118 to 132, 133 to 147, 227 to 236 and 247 to 256) identified the positions of separate Th cell epitopes, and two overlapping peptides (residues 173 to 182 and 178 to 192) defined an additional Th cell immunogenic sequence. Three individual peptides in VP3 (residues 46 to 58, 136 to 150 and 198 to 212) and two overlapping peptides (residues 1 to 15 and 11 to 20) also represent Th cell epitopes. Similar assays with C57BL/6 (H-2b) and SJL/J (H-2s) mice showed that the pattern of recognition of these peptides was H-2 restricted. Each of the previously identified sites of B cell antigenicity in VP2 and VP3 are associated with one Th epitope. Comparison of the experimentally determined Th epitopes with potential T cell epitopes identified by several predictive strategies revealed only a low correlation between authentic and predicted epitopes.

The virion of mengovirus contains anti-interferon activity.

Many viruses are resistant to the antiviral state induced by interferon (IFN) in certain cell lines because they produce factors having anti-IFN activity (AIA). We show here that is+, a mengovirus strain resistant to low concentrations of IFN, also produces an AIA, but that an IFN-sensitive mutant (is-1) does not. This activity was detected when is+ rescued is-1 from the antiviral state induced in mouse L cells by mouse IFN. The mengovirus AIA was found in cell lysates prepared from cells infected with is+, and in the virions of purified, inactivated is+ but not in lysates prepared from is-1-infected cells or in the is-1 virion. Also the pentameric subunits that make up the viral capsid contained AIA, whereas the individual monomeric subunits that constitute the pentamers did not. We also describe an assay system for detecting and quantitating the mengovirus AIA.

Purification of mengovirus by freon extraction and chromatography on protein-coated controlled pore glass.

Mengovirus, extracted from infected L-cell cultures with Freon 113 and concentrated from the aqueous phase with polyethyleneglycol, was chromatographed on protein-coated controlled pore glass (CPG). The covalent binding of protein to CPG is described. Further purification and concentration of mengovirus was achieved by isopycnic density gradient centrifugation in solutions of either CsCl or salts of iodinated benzoic acid derivatives. The described procedure is superior to conventional methods for the isolation and purification of large quantities of mengovirus. It yields highly purified virus preparations within a short time and a recovery of more than 50% of the starting infectivity.