ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVES: This systematic review of qualitative studies explored interventions to improve student nurses' knowledge, attitudes or willingness to work with older people. Student nurses are likely to encounter older people in all health and aged care settings, however, research demonstrates that few have career aspirations in gerontological nursing. METHODS: Qualitative systematic review method based on the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. RESULTS: Search of Medline, Embase, PsycINFO, EBSCOhost and Scopus yielded 1841 articles which were screened to include primary research about educational interventions to improve student nurses' knowledge, attitudes and/or willingness to work with older people. Data extraction was performed on the 14 included studies, and data were analysed using directed content analysis. The Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) was used the assess the quality of the studies. CONCLUSIONS: Educational interventions included theory or practice courses, or a combination of theory and practice. While most interventions changed nursing students' negative attitudes towards older people, few increased their willingness to work with them. Practice courses had the most significant impact on willingness to work with older people. Quality assessment revealed methodical limitations. More research is needed to better understand the elements of practice interventions that enhance student nurses' knowledge, attitudes, and willingness to work with older people, so that they can be replicated.
Subject(s)
Geriatrics , Nurses , Students, Nursing , Aged , Humans , Attitude of Health Personnel , Clinical CompetenceABSTRACT
Background: This research explores the capabilities of ChatGPT-4 in passing the American Board of Family Medicine (ABFM) Certification Examination. Addressing a gap in existing literature, where earlier artificial intelligence (AI) models showed limitations in medical board examinations, this study evaluates the enhanced features and potential of ChatGPT-4, especially in document analysis and information synthesis. Objective: The primary goal is to assess whether ChatGPT-4, when provided with extensive preparation resources and when using sophisticated data analysis, can achieve a score equal to or above the passing threshold for the Family Medicine Board Examinations. Methods: In this study, ChatGPT-4 was embedded in a specialized subenvironment, "AI Family Medicine Board Exam Taker," designed to closely mimic the conditions of the ABFM Certification Examination. This subenvironment enabled the AI to access and analyze a range of relevant study materials, including a primary medical textbook and supplementary web-based resources. The AI was presented with a series of ABFM-type examination questions, reflecting the breadth and complexity typical of the examination. Emphasis was placed on assessing the AI's ability to interpret and respond to these questions accurately, leveraging its advanced data processing and analysis capabilities within this controlled subenvironment. Results: In our study, ChatGPT-4's performance was quantitatively assessed on 300 practice ABFM examination questions. The AI achieved a correct response rate of 88.67% (95% CI 85.08%-92.25%) for the Custom Robot version and 87.33% (95% CI 83.57%-91.10%) for the Regular version. Statistical analysis, including the McNemar test (P=.45), indicated no significant difference in accuracy between the 2 versions. In addition, the chi-square test for error-type distribution (P=.32) revealed no significant variation in the pattern of errors across versions. These results highlight ChatGPT-4's capacity for high-level performance and consistency in responding to complex medical examination questions under controlled conditions. Conclusions: The study demonstrates that ChatGPT-4, particularly when equipped with specialized preparation and when operating in a tailored subenvironment, shows promising potential in handling the intricacies of medical board examinations. While its performance is comparable with the expected standards for passing the ABFM Certification Examination, further enhancements in AI technology and tailored training methods could push these capabilities to new heights. This exploration opens avenues for integrating AI tools such as ChatGPT-4 in medical education and assessment, emphasizing the importance of continuous advancement and specialized training in medical applications of AI.
Subject(s)
Artificial Intelligence , Certification , Educational Measurement , Family Practice , Specialty Boards , Family Practice/education , Humans , Educational Measurement/methods , United States , Clinical Competence/standardsABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION: Nowadays, suicide represents a serious public health problem worldwide. Nurses can play a critical role in suicide prevention. Knowing risk factors and recognizing warning signs for suicide should be part of the professional background of any nurse training programs. METHODS: Our study presents the preliminary descriptive findings from an online survey in nursing staff operating in various areas (medical, surgical, critical and emergency) in the Apulia region. The survey aimed to assess the current knowledge, attitudes, behaviors and training needs of nurses regarding suicide prevention. We administered a questionnaire created with Google forms to a sample of subjects obtained through sampling a reasoned choice. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Our study highlighted the lack of perceived competence toward the suicidal patient and the need to implement specific training programs for nurses on the management of patients at risk of suicide. An adequate level of knowledge and competence regarding suicide prevention among healthcare professionals could significantly contribute to improving the quality of care provided to patients at risk for suicide, reducing the risk of suicidal events and improving the overall quality of the care pathway.
Subject(s)
Attitude of Health Personnel , Suicide Prevention , Humans , Adult , Female , Male , Surveys and Questionnaires , Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice , Middle Aged , Clinical Competence , NursesABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The transition from medical student to intern is a recognized educational gap. To help address this, the Association of American Medical Colleges developed the Core Entrustable Professional Activities for entering residency. As these metrics outline expectations for all graduating students regardless of specialty, the described procedural expectations are appropriately basic. However, in procedure-heavy specialties such as emergency medicine, the ability to perform advanced procedures continues to contribute to the disconnect between undergraduate and graduate medical education. To prepare our graduating students for their internship in emergency medicine, we developed a simulation-based mastery learning curriculum housed within a specialty-specific program. Our overall goal was to develop the students' procedural competency for central venous catheter placement and endotracheal intubation before graduation from medical school. METHODS: Twenty-five students participated in a simulation-based mastery learning procedures curriculum for ultrasound-guided internal jugular central venous catheter placement and endotracheal intubation. Students underwent baseline assessment, deliberate practice, and post-test assessments. Both the baseline and post-test assessments used the same internally developed checklists with pre-established minimum passing scores. RESULTS: Despite completing an emergency medicine rotation and a critical care rotation, none of the students met the competency standard during their baseline assessments. All twenty-five students demonstrated competency on both procedures by the end of the curriculum. A second post-test was required to demonstrate achievement of the central venous catheter and endotracheal intubation minimum passing scores by 16% and 28% of students, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Students demonstrated procedural competency for central venous catheter placement and endotracheal intubation by engaging in simulation-based mastery learning procedures curriculum as they completed their medical school training. With three instructional hours, students were able to achieve basic procedural competence for two common, high-risk procedures they will need to perform during emergency medicine residency training.
Subject(s)
Clinical Competence , Curriculum , Emergency Medicine , Internship and Residency , Simulation Training , Humans , Emergency Medicine/education , Intubation, Intratracheal , Catheterization, Central Venous , Education, Medical, Undergraduate/methods , Educational MeasurementABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: To develop a laparoscopic training course that combines a smartphone application (APP) and virtual reality (VR), and initially evaluate the feasibility and effectiveness of its implementation. METHODS: The Exploring Laparoscopy (Ex-Lap) app was developed to meet training demands. The course was designed by integrating the app with a VR simulator (LapSim®) and animal organ perfusion simulators. From January 2021 to December 2023, 91 participants were enrolled in the study and then divided into 5 separate batches to undergo the first stage of the course. The performance of the participants was evaluated by rating scale, the overall Training and Assessment of Basic Laparoscopic Techniques (TABLT) scores, and pass rates. Statistical analyses were conducted using SPSS 26.0, employing Kruskal-Wallis tests, Chi-squared analysis, and Fisher's exact test, depending on the data type. RESULTS: The Staged Training and Assessment of Laparoscopic Skills (STALS) course was developed, consisting of three stages. The overall pass rates for the first stage across the five batches ranged from 85 to 100%, with no significant difference (P = 0.387). No significant differences were found in the scale scores or TABLT scores for the training tasks among students from different batches (all P > 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The STALS course is applicable in residency training, demonstrating satisfactory teaching effectiveness and replicability.
Subject(s)
Clinical Competence , Laparoscopy , Mobile Applications , Smartphone , Virtual Reality , Laparoscopy/education , Humans , Simulation Training , Educational Measurement , Curriculum , Male , FemaleABSTRACT
Dual training in Interventional Cardiology (IC) with other cardiac subspecialties such as Advanced Heart Failure and Transplant Cardiology (AHFTC) and Critical Care Cardiology (CCC) is becoming a pathway for trainees to acquire a needed skill set to deliver comprehensive care for increasingly complex patients in the intensive care unit and catheterization laboratory settings. The makeup of these training pathways varies depending on several factors, with the resultant role of the specialist reflecting this reality. Herein, we review the merits to combined fellowship training for the Interventional Cardiologist, the ideal structure of programs to facilitate this, and how the faculty position for such a unique specialist can enhance a program.
Subject(s)
Cardiology , Humans , Cardiology/education , Cardiology/trends , Clinical Competence , Education, Medical, Graduate/methods , Heart Failure/therapy , Fellowships and Scholarships/methods , Cardiac Catheterization/methodsABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The main objectives of the study were to analyse the use of the Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) to evaluate the skills of medical students in paediatric basic life support (PBLS), to compare two resuscitation training models and to evaluate the measures to improve the teaching program. METHODS: Comparative, prospective, observation study with intervention in two hospitals, one undergoing a PILS course (Paediatric Immediate Life Support) and another PBLS. The study was performed over three phases. 1º. PBLS OSCE in 2022 three months after the resuscitation training 2. Measures to improve the training program in 2023 3. PBLS OSCE in 2023. Overall results were analysed and comparison between both sites and those for 2022 and 2023 were made. RESULTS: A total of 210 and 182 students took part in the OSCE in 2022 and 2023, respectively. The overall mean score out of 100 was 83.2 (19), 77.8 (19.8) in 2022 and 89.5 (15.9) and 2023, P < 0.001. Overall cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) effectiveness was adequate in 79.4% and 84.6% of students in 2022 and 2023, respectively. The results of hospital students undergoing a PILS course were better (86.4 (16.6) than those undergoing a PBLS. 80.2 (20.6) p < 0.001. The results from both hospitals improved significantly in 2023. CONCLUSIONS: The OSCE is a valid instrument to evaluate PBLS skills in medical students and to compare different training methods and program improvements. Medical students who receive a PILS attain better PBLS skills than those who undergo a PBLS course.
Subject(s)
Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation , Clinical Competence , Educational Measurement , Students, Medical , Humans , Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation/education , Clinical Competence/standards , Prospective Studies , Pediatrics/education , Female , Male , Education, Medical, Undergraduate/methods , Curriculum , Problem-Based LearningABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Starting the first job as a young physician is a demanding challenge. Certain skills are important to master this transformation that go beyond the theoretical knowledge and practical skills taught in medical school. Competencies such as communication, leadership and career management skills are important to develop as a young physician but are usually not sufficiently taught in medical school in a structured and comprehensive way. METHODS: We performed an online survey among final year medical students regarding how they perceive their current competency level in communication, leadership and career management skills. We also assessed how they rate the importance to acquire these competencies and the current emphasis during their medical school education regarding these topics. RESULTS: Of 450 final year medical students 80 took part in the voluntary survey and 75 complete datasets were returned (16.7%). The majority of respondents rated different communication skills, leadership skills and career management skills as important or very important for their later clinical work. However, most students felt to be poorly or very poorly prepared by the current medical school curriculum, especially for certain leadership and career management skills. Overall, 90.7% of participants expressed interest in an additional educational course that covers subjects of communication, leadership and career management skills during the later stage of medical school, preferably as a hybrid in-person session that also offers synchronous online participation. CONCLUSIONS: The results of the survey express the need to address communication, leadership and career management skills in the medical curriculum to be better prepare students for the demands of residency and their further course as physicians. An educational format during the final year of medical school may be suitable to address mentioned topics in the framework of clinical practical exposure.
Subject(s)
Communication , Curriculum , Education, Medical, Undergraduate , Leadership , Students, Medical , Humans , Students, Medical/psychology , Male , Female , Surveys and Questionnaires , Adult , Clinical Competence , Career Choice , Young Adult , Schools, MedicalABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: As healthcare professional trainees, resident physicians are expected to help with COVID-19 care in various ways. Many resident physicians worldwide have cared for COVID-19 patients despite the increased risk of burnout. However, few studies have examined the experience with COVID-19 care among resident physicians and its effects on competency achievement regarding clinical basics and COVID-19 patient care. METHOD: This nationwide, cross-sectional Japanese study used a clinical training environment questionnaire for resident physicians (PGY-1 and - 2) in 593 teaching hospitals during the General Medicine In-Training Examination in January 2021. The General Medicine In-Training Examination questions comprised four categories (medical interviews and professionalism; symptomatology and clinical reasoning; physical examination and clinical procedures; and disease knowledge) and a COVID-19-related question. We examined the COVID-19 care experience and its relationship with the General Medicine In-Training Examination score, adjusting for resident and hospital variables. RESULTS: Of the 6,049 resident physicians, 2,841 (47.0%) had no experience caring for patients with COVID-19 during 2020. Total and categorical General Medicine In-Training Examination scores were not different irrespective of the experience with COVID-19 patient care. For the COVID-19-related question, residents with experience in COVID-19 care showed a significant increase in correct response by 2.6% (95% confidence interval, 0.3-4.9%; p = 0.028). CONCLUSIONS: The resident physicians' COVID-19 care experience was associated with better achievement of COVID-19-related competency without reducing clinical basics. However, approximately half of the residents missed the critical experience of caring for patients during this unparalleled pandemic in Japan.
Subject(s)
COVID-19 , Clinical Competence , Internship and Residency , Humans , COVID-19/epidemiology , Japan , Cross-Sectional Studies , Male , Female , Surveys and Questionnaires , Adult , SARS-CoV-2 , Education, Medical, Graduate , Academic Success , General Practice/education , East Asian PeopleABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Specialty clinics can be challenging for students on the internal medicine clerkship. They often lack the specialized knowledge necessary to fully engage in the clinic and may be pushed into an observational role, rather than being afforded meaningful opportunities. These peripheral roles undermine self-efficacy, and, therefore, education and interest. We sought to improve self-efficacy of students attending non-malignant hematology clinic, as well as to enhance interest in hematology and internal medicine. METHODS: We developed a flipped visit model analogous to the flipped classroom. Students each received pre-readings accompanied and pre-assigned cases with delineated reasons for referral and learning objectives. This model allowed students to prepare the hematology content for visits prior to arrival and then focus their time in clinic on executing visits. Participating students completed pre- and post-clinic surveys. These surveys covered core concepts in self-efficacy and interest in hematology and internal medicine on a five-point Likert scale. RESULTS: Of 103 students attending hematology clinic, 38 students (37%) opted to participate. Two of the 38 did not complete the post-clinic survey. Students had a statistically significant increase in four of six measures of self-efficacy: evaluation of research relevant to patient care and practicing cost-effective care (p = 0.008 and 0.001, respectively); and creation of a differential diagnosis and treatment plan specific to hematology (both p < 0.001). While pre-clinic student responses expressed interest in more exposure to hematology or a possible career in hematology or internal medicine, this was not changed post-clinic. When comparing their experience to other clinics, 75% and 71% students rated hematology clinic slightly or much better than other medicine clinics and non-medicine clinics, respectively. The flipped visit improved self-efficacy both specific to hematology and more generally. While students rated the experience more highly than other clinics, there was no impact on career interest in hematology or internal medicine. CONCLUSION: A flipped visit approach to incorporating medical students into hematology clinic that included pre-assigned cases and readings improved self-efficacy and was preferred by students. They may be adopted easily in other ambulatory education settings.
Subject(s)
Clinical Clerkship , Internal Medicine , Self Efficacy , Students, Medical , Humans , Students, Medical/psychology , Internal Medicine/education , Hematology/education , Clinical Competence , Education, Medical, Undergraduate , Female , MaleABSTRACT
Recently, I came across a few discussions and write-ups on the dying art of clinical medicine caused by rapid advances in technology, which is replacing previously indispensable instruments such as stethoscope. Fred has interestingly termed it "Hyposkillia."1 Multiple editorials have decried the loss of clinical skills, and medical educators justify not only teaching but also using basic history-taking and physical examination skills in routine patient care.2-4 However, some skeptics suggest that emphasis on clinical skills is from a bygone era and that the availability of advanced imaging techniques and laboratory tests has supplanted ambiguous history and physical findings.5,6 Here is what I think.
Subject(s)
Clinical Medicine , Humans , Clinical CompetenceABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION: Training novice ophthalmology residents on the EyeSi® simulator increases cataract surgery safety. However, there is no consensus regarding how much training residents should perform before their first time on patients. We evaluated the French national training program through the analysis of the learning curves of novice residents. METHODS: This prospective multicentric pedagogic study was conducted with French novice residents. Each resident completed the recommended four two-hour training sessions and performed a standardized assessment simulating standard cataract surgery before the first session (A0), at the end of the first (A1), second (A2), third (A3) and fourth (A4) sessions. For each surgical step of each attempt, the following data were collected: score, odometer, completion time, posterior capsular rupture and cumulative energy delivered (ultrasounds) during phacoemulsification. A performance threshold was set at a score of 80/100 for each surgical step, 400/500 for the overall procedure. Only descriptive statistics were employed. RESULTS: Sixteen newly nominated ophthalmology residents were included. Median score progressively increased from 95 [IQR 53; 147]) at A0 to 425 [IQR 411; 451] at A4. Despite a significant progression, the "emulsification" step had the lowest A4 scores 86 [IQR 60; 94] without reduction in completion time, odometer or ultrasounds delivered. The rate of posterior capsular rupture decreased linearly from 75% at A0 to 13% at A4 during "emulsification" and from 69 to 0% during "irrigation and aspiration". At A4, only 25% [8; 53] of residents had > 80 at each step and only 75% [47; 92] had > 400/500 overall. CONCLUSION: A training program consisting of four two-hour sessions on the EyeSi simulator over four consecutive days effectively enhances the surgical skills of novice ophthalmology residents. Undergoing more training sessions may improve scores and decrease the incidence of surgical complications, particularly at the emulsification step of cataract surgery. The learning curves presented here can reassure residents who are progressing normally and help identify those who need a further personalized training program. TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials registration number: NCT05722080 (first submitted 22/12/2022, first posted 10/02/2023).
Subject(s)
Clinical Competence , Internship and Residency , Learning Curve , Ophthalmology , Simulation Training , Humans , Prospective Studies , Male , Ophthalmology/education , Female , Cataract Extraction/education , France , Adult , Phacoemulsification/education , Education, Medical, GraduateABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: We aimed to ascertain the current state of and needs for virtual reality (VR)-based simulation training in the care of adult respiratory patients. Learning to care for patients with infectious respiratory disease is crucial in nurses' practical education. Thus, studies on the state of VR-based simulation-training are required. METHODS: We used an explanatory sequential mixed-methods design. The sample included 122 new nurses at two advanced general hospitals and five educators at a nursing college. The educational needs of virtual reality-based simulation education were measured by the tool developed in this study. Research data were collected from August 31 to September 26, 2022. Quantitative data were subjected to a descriptive analysis, while qualitative data were subjected to content analysis. RESULTS: The new nurses in this study had a mean age of 24.51 years and total clinical experience of 11.18 months; 82.8% of the participants had experience in adult respiratory patient care, and 94.3% were aware of the need for this training. In the qualitative data analysis of six new nurses, all participants had experience with simulation training and were aware of its need. Moreover, all participants wanted repeated VR-based simulation training using real clinical cases. Regarding the qualitative data analysis of five nursing college educators, most of them had experience providing and receiving simulation training, and they were aware of its need in caring for respiratory patients. They reported the need for VR learning spaces that reflect the clinical environment, alongside sufficient duration and frequency of learning. Our findings could help develop simulation training programs for nursing students to assist adult respiratory patients. CONCLUSIONS: We provide a basis for developing VR-based simulation training for respiratory care by studying the current state of and demand for nurses' VR-based simulation training. The results can contribute to improving the quality of nursing for adult respiratory patients.
Subject(s)
Simulation Training , Virtual Reality , Humans , Female , Adult , Male , Young Adult , Clinical Competence , Needs Assessment , Education, NursingABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Simulation-Based Learning (SBL) is increasingly adopted in medical education across various specialties, employing realistic simulations to significantly enhance learning experiences. However, a comprehensive evaluation of its effectiveness specifically in endocrinology has not yet been conducted. The study aims to systematically review and meta-analyze the impact of SBL versus Non-Simulation-Based Learning (NSBL) on knowledge acquisition, skills, satisfaction, and interest in learning among endocrinology trainees. METHODS: This systematic review and meta-analysis adhered to the PRISMA guidelines, searching PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, Cochrane library, China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), Wanfang Data, Weipu, and Chinese Biomedical Database (CBM) until March 2024. We included randomized controlled trials comparing SBL to NSBL in endocrinology education. The quality evaluation relied on the Cochrane risk-of-bias assessment tool. The main results included evaluations from both theoretical and practical assessments. Additional measures consisted of assessing satisfaction and interest in learning. RESULTS: We identified 22 studies suitable for systematic review and 21 for meta-analysis, involving a total of 2517 participants. SBL greatly enhanced theoretical knowledge [standardized mean difference (SMD) = 1.00, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.68-1.32, P < 0.00001, I2 = 89%] and practical skills (SMD = 1.56, 95% CI: 1.11-2.01, P < 0.00001, I2 = 93%) compared to NSBL. Additionally, SBL was associated with higher satisfaction and greater interest in learning. No significant publication bias was detected, and sensitivity analysis confirmed the stability of these findings. CONCLUSIONS: SBL significantly enhances knowledge, skills, satisfaction, and interest in learning within endocrinology education compared to NSBL. These findings support the integration of high-quality SBL into endocrinology curricula to improve educational outcomes. Future research should explore the lasting effects of SBL on knowledge retention and clinical practice, as well as to evaluate its cost-effectiveness and compatibility with various educational tools in diverse settings.
Subject(s)
Clinical Competence , Endocrinology , Simulation Training , Endocrinology/education , Humans , Education, Medical/methodsABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: The operating room is a high-risk environment where proper patient positioning is crucial for minimizing injury and ensuring optimal access to surgical sites. This process requires effective collaboration among surgical team members, particularly operating room nurses who play a vital role in patient safety. Despite advancements in technology, challenges such as pressure injuries persist, with a significant incidence rate. Video-based training (VBT) emerges as a promising educational tool, enhancing knowledge retention and fostering a learner-centered approach. This study aims to evaluate the impact of VBT on adherence to surgical positioning standards, highlighting its potential to improve safety protocols in the operating room. METHODS: In this clinical trial, 62 qualified operating room nurses (50 women, 12 men, average age: 28.90 ± 3.75 years) were randomly divided into control and intervention group (n = 31 in each group). The control group only received positioning recommendations, but in the intervention group, in addition to the recommendations, video-based surgical positioning training was performed for 1 month, at least 3 times a week. The performance of nurses in both groups was evaluated through a researcher-made checklist at baseline and post-intervention. RESULTS: Based on findings, there was no significant difference between the two groups in compliance with surgical positioning standards at baseline (p = 0.07). However, after the intervention, compliance scores significantly improved in the VBT group compared to the control group (p < 0.001). The VBT group showed a mean improvement of 62.12 points, while the control group improved by 10.77 points (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: This preliminary study demonstrated a notable improvement in compliance with surgical positioning standards among operating room nurses following VBT intervention. Despite the promising results, the small sample size and preliminary nature of the research necessitate further studies to confirm these findings and assess long-term outcomes. These initial insights highlight the potential of innovative training methods in enhancing surgical practices.
Subject(s)
Operating Rooms , Patient Positioning , Video Recording , Humans , Female , Male , Adult , Patient Positioning/standards , Operating Rooms/standards , Guideline Adherence/statistics & numerical data , Operating Room Nursing/education , Operating Room Nursing/standards , Clinical Competence/standardsABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Spaced digital education applies digital tools to deliver educational content via multiple, repeated learning sessions separated by prespecified time intervals. Spaced digital education appears to promote acquisition and long-term retention of knowledge, skills, and change in clinical behavior. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this review was to assess the effectiveness of spaced digital education in improving pre- and postregistration health care professionals' knowledge, skills, attitudes, satisfaction, and change in clinical behavior. METHODS: This review followed Cochrane's methodology and PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) reporting guidelines. We searched MEDLINE, Embase, Web of Science, ERIC, PsycINFO, CINAHL, CENTRAL, and ProQuest Dissertation and Theses databases from January 1990 to February 2023. We included randomized controlled trials (RCTs), cluster RCTs, and quasi-RCTs comparing spaced digital education with nonspaced education, spaced nondigital education, traditional learning, or no intervention for pre- or postregistration health care professionals. Study selection, data extraction, study quality, and certainty of evidence were assessed by 2 independent reviewers. Meta-analyses were conducted using random effect models. RESULTS: We included 23 studies evaluating spaced online education (n=17, 74%) or spaced digital simulation (n=6, 26%) interventions. Most studies assessed 1 or 2 outcomes, including knowledge (n=15, 65%), skills (n=9, 39%), attitudes (n=8, 35%), clinical behavior change (n=8, 35%), and satisfaction (n=7, 30%). Most studies had an unclear or a high risk of bias (n=19, 83%). Spaced online education was superior to massed online education for postintervention knowledge (n=9, 39%; standardized mean difference [SMD] 0.32, 95% CI 0.13-0.51, I2=66%, moderate certainty of evidence). Spaced online education (n=3, 13%) was superior to massed online education (n=2, 9%) and no intervention (n=1, 4%; SMD 0.67, 95% CI 0.43-0.91, I2=5%, moderate certainty of evidence) for postintervention clinical behavior change. Spaced digital simulation was superior to massed simulation for postintervention surgical skills (n=2, 9%; SMD 1.15, 95% CI 0.34-1.96, I2=74%, low certainty of evidence). Spaced digital education positively impacted confidence and satisfaction with the intervention. CONCLUSIONS: Spaced digital education is effective in improving knowledge, particularly in substantially improving surgical skills and promoting clinical behavior change in pre- and postregistration health care professionals. Our findings support the use of spaced digital education interventions in undergraduate and postgraduate health profession education. Trial Registration: PROSPERO CRD42021241969. TRIAL REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42021241969; https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?RecordID=241969.
Subject(s)
Education, Distance , Health Personnel , Humans , Health Personnel/education , Education, Distance/methods , Clinical Competence/statistics & numerical data , Randomized Controlled Trials as Topic , Health Knowledge, Attitudes, PracticeABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION: Evidence from Asian studies suggests that minimally-invasive gastrectomy achieves equivalent oncological but improved perioperative outcomes compared to open surgery. Oncological gastric resections are less frequent in European countries. Index procedures may play a role for the learning curve of minimally-invasive gastrectomy. The aim of our study was to evaluate if skills acquired in bariatric surgery allow a safe and oncologically adequate implementation of minimally-invasive gastrectomy in a cohort of european patients. METHODS: In this single-center retrospective study, all patients who received primary bariatric surgery between January 2015 and December 2018 and minimally-invasive surgery for gastric cancer treated from June 2019 to January 2023 were evaluated. Primary endpoints were operation time, lymph node yield and lymph node fractions. Secondary endpoints included postoperative complications and oncological outcomes. RESULTS: Learning curves for two surgeons with 350 bariatric procedures and 44 minimally-invasive gastrectomies were analyzed. For bariatric surgery, the mean operation time decreased from initially 82 ± 27 to 45 ± 21 min and 118 ± 28 to 81 ± 36 min for sleeve gastrectomy (SG) and Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB), while the complication rate remained within the international benchmark. For laparoscopic gastrectomy (n = 30), operation times decreased but then remained stable over time. Operation times for the robotic platform were longer (302 ± 60 vs. 390 ± 48 min; p < 0.001) with the learning curve remaining incomplete after 14 procedures. R0 status was achieved in 95.5% of patients; the mean number of lymph nodes retrieved was 37 ± 14 with no differences between the groups. Complete mesogastric excision was more frequently achieved during the later laparoscopic cases whereas it occurred earlier for the robotic group (p = 0.004). Perioperative morbidity was comparable to the European benchmark. Textbook outcome was achieved in 54.4% of the cases. CONCLUSION: In summary, we could demonstrate a successful skill transfer from bariatric surgery to minimally-invasive laparoscopic oncological gastric surgery enabling safe and oncologically adequate minimally-invasive D2 gastrectomy in a central European patient collective.
Subject(s)
Bariatric Surgery , Gastrectomy , Learning Curve , Operative Time , Stomach Neoplasms , Humans , Gastrectomy/education , Gastrectomy/methods , Stomach Neoplasms/surgery , Stomach Neoplasms/pathology , Female , Male , Retrospective Studies , Middle Aged , Bariatric Surgery/education , Adult , Clinical Competence , Laparoscopy/education , Minimally Invasive Surgical Procedures/education , Aged , Robotic Surgical Procedures/educationABSTRACT
Teaching is an essential skill for future doctors. Peer-assisted learning (PAL)-where students take up a teaching role at an early stage of their training-is widely used in medical curricula. No studies have explored the long-term perceived impact of peer teaching. Therefore, we aimed to determine how former peer teachers reflected on PAL and its perceived long-term impact. In this longitudinal descriptive study, we conducted 42 semi-structured interviews with 11 former peer teachers at the University of Antwerp. Five of them were interviewed 6 months after PAL; 6 of them 9 years after PAL. This latter group was also interviewed during PAL in a previous study. We conducted secondary analyses of previously collected interviews, consistently comparing the findings with new data gathered from the current interviews. Using realist thematic analysis, topic summary themes were generated. Former peer teachers reflected on their PAL experience with a lot of satisfaction. Those meanwhile working as residents are still passionate about teaching. Peer teachers experienced a gain in clinical examination- and professional skills in the long-term, facilitating a smoother transition to their internship. Our findings suggest that PAL selects diverse but committed students. The longitudinal data demonstrate how PAL initiates or stimulates different skills in diverse students, including public speaking, teaching, time management, and self-efficacy in specific clinical skills. Regarding the chicken-and-egg question, our study encompasses both longitudinal cases illustrating the pre-existing skill theory and cases demonstrating how achieved competences were induced by PAL. Former peer teachers experienced long-term benefits of PAL, which eased their transition into the internship. PAL has the potential to ignite a lasting passion for teaching, providing diverse and unique learning opportunities not only for the most talented and 'pre-selected' medical students but also for a range of dedicated future clinicians.
Subject(s)
Clinical Competence , Interviews as Topic , Peer Group , Teaching , Humans , Longitudinal Studies , Students, Medical/psychology , Female , Male , Self Efficacy , CurriculumABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Laparoscopic surgery is associated with a prolonged learning curve for emerging surgeons, and simulation-based training (SBT) has become increasingly prominent in this context due to stringent working time regulations and heightened concerns regarding patient safety. While SBT offers a safe and ethical learning environment, the accuracy of simulators in the context of evaluating surgical skills remains uncertain. This study aims to assess the precision of a laparoscopic simulator with regard to evaluating surgical performance and to identify the instructor's role in SBT. MATERIALS AND METHODS: This retrospective study focused on surgical residents in their 1st through 5th years at the Department of Surgery of Linkou Chang Gung Memorial Hospital. The residents participated in a specially designed SBT program using the LapSim laparoscopic simulator. Following the training session, each resident was required to perform a laparoscopic procedure and received individualized feedback from an instructor. Both simulator and instructor evaluated trainees' performance on the LapSim, focusing on identifying correlations between the simulator's metrics and traditional assessments. RESULTS: Senior residents (n = 15), who employed more complex laparoscopic procedures, exhibited more significant improvements after receiving instructor feedback than did junior residents (n = 17). Notably, a stronger correlation between the simulator and instructor assessments was observed in the junior group (junior Global Operative Assessment of Laparoscopic Skills (GOALS) adjusted R2 = 0.285, p = 0.016), while no such correlations were observed among the senior group. CONCLUSION: A well-designed, step-by-step SBT can be a valuable tool in laparoscopic surgical training. LapSim simulator has demonstrated its potential in assessing surgical performances during the early stages of surgical training. However, instructors must provide intuitive feedback to ensure appropriate learning in later stages.
Subject(s)
Clinical Competence , Internship and Residency , Laparoscopy , Simulation Training , Tertiary Care Centers , Humans , Retrospective Studies , Laparoscopy/education , Clinical Competence/standards , Internship and Residency/standards , Formative Feedback , Male , Female , Adult , Educational MeasurementABSTRACT
OBJECTIVES: This study reveals the learning gained by Canadian and Rwandan nursing students from a course to enhance cross cultural clinical decision-making skills using a collaborative approach across two countries. METHODS: A qualitative descriptive study was conducted using thematic analysis. The study included analysis of end of course reflections of 94 students. RESULTS: Students became more open-minded, curious, strengthening teamwork, increasing their critical thinking, and identifying cross-cultural similarities in practice. They challenged their previous beliefs about others. CONCLUSIONS: Students achieved a transformation of previous knowledge and decision-making skills. Results indicate the value of underpinning courses with theories and being open in allowing students to develop their own means to achieve expected learning outcomes. IMPLICATIONS FOR AN INTERNATIONAL AUDIENCE: Creating learning environments designed to stimulate open mindedness and exploration of cultures among students can be achieved through online learning. Providing opportunities for students to learn across other countries about their nursing practices and health systems are critical to understanding how future patients who are immigrants and refugees from other countries differing perspectives to their health care needs.