Addressing Unmet Surgical Needs in an Underserved Nigerian Community: Report of a 'Town and Gown' Initiative.

BACKGROUND: Access to quality and timely care prevents unnecessary deaths and morbidity from potentially curable surgical diseases. This study describes the magnitude of unmet surgical needs in a Nigerian community and describes the experiences garnered during a surgical outreach organized by a tertiary institution in an underserved community. METHODS: This is a descriptive study highlighting details of a surgical outreach to a community in south-Western part of Nigeria. The project was based on a collaboration between a University Teaching Hospital (gown) and the community (town). Details of the patients' demographic and disease characteristics as well as barriers to seeking medical care were obtained. The operational workflow, treatment offered, and outcomes are highlighted. Results are presented as descriptive statistics. RESULTS: Over a two-day period, 83 out of 3,056 patients who were screened had surgically treatable conditions (2.7%), predominantly hernias (37, 46.6%), goitres (13, 15.7%) and soft tissue swellings (9, 10.8%). The majority were adults (56, 67.5%) while 27 (32.5%) were in the paediatric age group. The mean duration of symptoms was 8.64 months ± 9.5 months. About half of the patients (46.9%) had never visited a medical facility on account of their index illnesses. Lack of funds was cited by many patients as the main reason for having not presented at a hospital. Sixty-three surgical operations were performed with no peri-operative adverse events. CONCLUSION: Lack of financial access was the major barrier to surgical care in the sampled community. Moving from 'gown to town' helped address a significant proportion of the unmet needs over a relatively short period. Tertiary hospitals can provide surgical oversight to communities within their jurisdiction using this approach.

CONTEXTE: L'accès à des soins de qualité et en temps opportun permet d'éiter les décès et la morbidité inutiles dus à des maladies chirurgicales potentiellement curables. Cette étude décrit l'ampleur des besoins chirurgicaux non satisfaits dans une communauté nigériane et décrit les expériences recueillies au cours d'une action chirurgicale organisée par une institution tertiaire dans une communauté mal desservie. MÉTHODES: Il s'agit d'une étude descriptive mettant en évidence les détails d'une action chirurgicale dans une communauté du sud-ouest du Nigeria. Le projet était basé sur une collaboration entre un hôpital universitaire (ville) et la communauté (ville). Les détails des caractéristiques démographiques et pathologiques des patients ainsi que les obstacles à la recherche de soins médicaux ont été obtenus. Le déroulement des opérations, le traitement proposé et les résultats sont mis en évidence. Les résultats sont présentés sous forme de statistiques descriptives. RÉSULTATS: Sur une période de deux jours, 83 des 3056 patients examinés présentaient des affections pouvant être traitées chirurgicalement (2,7 %), principalement des hernies (37, 46,6 %), des goitres (13, 15,7 %) et des tuméfactions des tissus mous (9, 10,8 %). La majorité des patients étaient des adultes (56, 67,5 %), tandis que 27 (32,5 %) appartenaient au groupe d'âge pédiatrique. La durée moyenne des symptômes était de 8,64 mois ±9,5 mois. Environ la moitié des patients (46,9 %) ne s'étaient jamais rendus dans un établissement médical en raison de leurs maladies index. Le manque de moyens financiers a été cité par de nombreux patients comme la principale raison pour laquelle ils ne s'étaient pas présentés à l'hôpital. Soixante-trois opérations chirurgicales ont été réalisées sans aucun événement indésirable périopératoire. CONCLUSION: Le manque d'accès financier était le principal obstacle aux soins chirurgicaux dans la communauté échantillonnée. Le passage de la ville à l'hôpital a permis de répondre à une proportion importante des besoins non satisfaits sur une période relativement courte. Les hôpitaux tertiaires peuvent fournir une supervision chirurgicale aux communautés de leur juridiction en utilisant cette approche. Mots clés: Chirurgie, Besoins non satisfaits, Nigeria, Communauté mal desservie.

Treatment of Brodie's abscess: excellent results from curettage, bone grafting and antibiotics.

INTRODUCTION: Brodie's abscess is not a common variant of subacute osteomyelitis; however, when it does occur, the presentation is atypical and usually late. This study aimed to describe the mode of presentation of Brodie's abscess and evaluate the results of surgical treatment in a resource-poor setting. METHOD: Over a five-year period, we retrospectively reviewed 20 patients who presented to two tertiary health institutions in south western Nigeria with clinical and radiological features of Brodie's abscess. RESULTS: Brodie's abscess accounted for just 2 percent of all patients with osteomyelitis. Most patients were adults (mean age 21.5 +/- 7.8 years) and males (75 percent). In the series, the tibia was involved in 50 percent of the cases, the femur in 30 percent, and the radius and fibula each in 10 percent. The diaphyseal part of the long bones was affected in 65 percent of the patients and the metaphysis, in the remaining patients. The average size of the cavities was 3.0 +/- 0.8 cm. 65 percent of the isolates yielded Staphylococcus aureus. All patients were treated by curettage of the abscess cavities, cancellous bone grafting and antibiotics. All patients had satisfactory outcomes, with complete incorporation of the grafts and new bone formation in the cavities. No patient reported any recurrence. CONCLUSION: Patients with Brodie's abscess respond well to surgical curettage of the abscess, cancellous bone grafting and antibiotic therapy.

Ponseti clubfoot management: changing surgical trends in Nigeria.

BACKGROUND: Congenital clubfoot treatment continues to be controversial particularly in a resource-constrained country. Comparative evaluation of clubfoot surgery with Ponseti methods has not been reported in West Africa. OBJECTIVES: To determine the effects of Ponseti techniques on clubfoot surgery frequency and patterns in Nigeria. METHODS: This was a prospective hospital-based intention-to-treat comparative study of clubfoot managed with Ponseti methods (PCG) and extensive soft tissue surgery (NPCG). The first step was a nonselective double-blind randomization of clubfoot patients into two groups using Excel software in a university teaching hospital setting. The control group was the NPCG patients. The patients' parents gave informed consent, and the medical research and ethics board approved the study protocol. Biodata was gathered, clubfoot patterns were analyzed, Dimeglio-Bensahel scoring was done, the number of casts applied was tallied, and patterns of surgeries were documented. The cost of care, recurrence and outcomes were evaluated. Kruskal-Wallis analysis and Mann-Whitney U technique were used, and an alpha error of < 0.05 at a CI of 95% were taken to be significant. RESULTS: We randomized 153 clubfeet (in 105 clubfoot patients) into two treatment groups. Fifty NPCG patients (36.2%) underwent manipulation and extensive soft tissue surgery and 55 PCG patients (39.9%) were treated with Ponseti methods. Fifty-two patients of the Ponseti group had no form of surgery (94.5% vs. 32%, p<0.000). Extensive soft tissue surgery was indicated in 17 (34.0%) of the NPCG group, representing 8.9% of the total of 191 major orthopaedic surgeries within the study period. Thirty-five patients (70.0%) from the NPCG group required more than six casts compared to thirteen patients (23.6%) of the PCG (p<0.000). The mean care cost was high within the NPCG when compared to the Ponseti group (48% vs. 14.5%, p<0.000). The Ponseti-treated group had fewer treatment complications (p<0.003), a lower recurrence rate (p<0.000) and satisfactory early outcome (p<0.000). CONCLUSION: Major clubfoot surgery was not commonly indicated among patients treated with the Ponseti method. The Ponseti clubfoot technique has reduced total care costs, cast utilization, clubfoot surgery frequency and has also changed the patterns of surgery performed for clubfoot in Nigeria.

Perception and knowledge of mothers on causes and treatment of rickets associated knee deformity in Ile-Ife, Osun State, Nigeria.

This descriptive cross-sectional community-based study was carried out in Ile-Ife, Nigeria to assess the knowledge of mother's on the aetiology of rickets associated knee deformities and the cultural perception of its treatment. Data collection was done using interviewer based semi structured questionnaires. A total of 464 questionnaires were administered with a response rate of 86.9%. Over half (59.8%; N=241) and 36.5% (147) of the mothers were aware of children with knee deformity and rickets, respectively. Ninety-one (22.6%) mothers had the correct knowledge and perception of the true meaning of rickets. Rickets associated knee deformity aetiology was wrongly perceived to be mainly hereditary (53.8%), cancer (50.9%) and bone infection (48.1%). Very low proportions of mothers had correct knowledge on the causes of rickets such as inadequate exposure to sunshine (21.3%) or inadequate intake of calcium (21.1%). The knowledge of aetiology of rickets was influenced by education (P<0.02), skilled occupation (P<0.0001) and the previous birth of a child with knee deformity from rickets (P<0.001). The mother's cultural perceptions of treatment for childhood rickets associated knee deformities was significantly affected by age (P<0.001), education, (P<0.001), skilled occupation (P<0.000), history of knee deformity (P<0.04) and mothers with children diagnosed to have knee deformity (P<0.004). Lack of finance, poor compliance to treatment, too long treatment periods, lack of information on where to seek for treatment and unaffordable treatment were among the important factors affecting completeness of treatment of knee deformity due to rickets. In conclusion, the awareness of mothers about rickets in Nigeria is still very low. It is a major reason for late presentation or complete failure to seek for adequate treatment of the knee deformity due to rickets. Increase and sustain public health enlightenment programmes are necessary for prevention. Health policy should incorporate free surgical fees for the established knee deformity to encourage community participation in the management of the condition.

Direct integration of government funding and family support for musculoskeletal tumor care in a resource-constrained country.

BACKGROUND: Malignant musculoskeletal tumor (MMST) outcome reflects the level of supportive care provided. In Nigeria, the supportive care available to patients with MMST is limited by a lack of funding. Patients often present late, and receive only orthodox care as psychosocial care is not available. We evaluated the effect of direct incorporation of government funding and family support on MMST patient acceptance and completion of treatment. METHODS: A 3-year prospective multicenter intention-to-treat study was undertaken in a tertiary care setting. The first step was a nonselective randomization of MMST patients into 2 groups, Wesley Guilds Hospital Firm A (WGHFA) and Wesley Guilds Hospital Firm B (WGHFB) using the computer software Excel. The control group was WGHFA, which consisted of patients who self-financed their oncology care. The WGHFB patients' governments (local or state) provided funds according to medical reports and the patients had relatives who offered psychosocial support. The second step entailed treatment (surgery, chemotherapy and radiotherapy) and follow-up. Outcome measures were the interval between presentation at hospital and surgical intervention, acceptability of limb amputation, completeness of treatment courses, duration of hospital stay and mortality. The reproducibility of the methodology was reappraised at the Federal Medical Center. Kruskal-Wallis analysis was used, and an alpha error of <0.05 at a CI of 95% was taken to be significant. RESULTS: A total of 112 cases of MMST were managed during the study period. Seventy-one (63.4%; 37 WGHFA; 34 WGHFB) met the inclusion criteria. Age, sex, tribe, religion, comorbid factors and mean weekly income were not significant factors influencing improved MMST care among the WGHFB patients. 32 WGHFB versus 7 WGHFA patients accepted the treatment plan. The mean duration of hospital stay before surgery (p < 0.001), discharge against medical advice (p < 0.000), limb salvage (21 vs. 2, p < 0.001), limb amputation (3 vs. 12, p < 0.05, 95% CI 8.3-37.9), completeness of treatment (33 vs. 7, p < 0.05), mean duration of hospital stay, in days (23 vs. 39, p < 0.05) and mortality at 1-year follow-up (13 vs. 28, p < 0.02) were significant. CONCLUSION: The cost of cancer care is a challenge for patients with MMST in a resource-constrained country such as Nigeria. Direct integration of the government and family into MMST care will serve as a link between the cancer patient and the source of funds. It raises the possibility of an effective psychosocial approach to improve patient outcome through enhanced treatment acceptability and completion, and so reduce morbidity and short-term mortality.

Motorcycle crash characteristics in Nigeria: implication for control.

Despite being the second most common cause of road traffic injuries (RTIs) in Nigeria, no study had examined the peculiarities of motorcycle crash site characteristics in Nigeria. We examined and interviewed 363 motorcycle RTI patients in three tertiary hospitals in southwest Nigeria. All the motorcycles are small with capacities between 80 and 125cm3. 68.9% of the patients sustained their injuries while working or going to work and 23.4% on their way to school. 176 (48.5%) of the crashes were with moving vehicles and in 83 (22.3%) cases, either the motorcycle or the other vehicle is moving against the traffic. 37.8% of all crashes occurred at junctions with no roundabout versus 5% at junctions with roundabout. Some risky practices of the patient included carrying more than 2 persons (15.02%), travelling without headlight at night (31.7%) and not wearing helmets (96.5%). This study showed that risky behavior among motorcycle riders, chaotic traffic and road design faults accounted for most of the motorcycle crashes. The implications for the prevention and control of motorcycle injuries were discussed.

Therapeutic decision in chronic osteomyelitis: sinus track culture versus intraoperative bone culture.

BACKGROUND: The ideal specimen for identification of the etiologic agents in chronic osteomyelitis for best antibiotic decision remains controversial. OBJECTIVE: To assess the concordance of sinus track culture (STC) with that of intraoperative bone culture (IBC) to guide antibiotic therapy in chronic osteomyelitis. METHODS: A prospective comparative study of chronic osteomyelitis patients seen in our centre from January 2004 to December 2006. Specimens from the depths of sinus track and intraoperative bone biopsy were obtained from each patient and subjected to microbiologic examination and their concordance determined. RESULTS: In STCs Staphylococcus aureus has the highest sensitivity (60.5%), specificity (45.0%) and positive predictive value (72.2%). The overall sensitivity (50.9%), specificity (20%) and predictive value (47.5%) of sinus track specimens were very low. Antibiotic decision based on IBC showed 106 patients (82.8%) had resolution of chronic osteomyelitis at mean of 2 years follow-up. CONCLUSION: IBC appears to predict more reliably the complete etiologic organisms than STCs in chronic osteomyelitis.

Perception and knowledge of mothers on causes and treatment of rickets associated knee deformity in Ile-Ife, Osun State, Nigeria

This descriptive cross-sectional community-based study was carried out in Ile-Ife; Nigeria to assess the knowledge of mother's on the aetiology of rickets associated knee deformities and the cultural perception of its treatment. Data collection was done using interviewer based semi structured questionnaires. A total of 464 questionnaires were administered with a response rate of 86.9. Over half (59.8; N=241) and 36.5(147) of the mothers were aware of children with knee deformity and rickets; respectively. Ninety-one (22.6) mothers had the correct knowledge and perception of the true meaning of rickets. Rickets associated knee deformity aetiology was wrongly perceived to be mainly hereditary (53.8); cancer (50.9) and bone infection (48.1). Very low proportions of mothers had correct knowledge on the causes of rickets such as inadequate exposure to sunshine (21.3) or inadequate intake of calcium (21.1). The knowledge of aetiology of rickets was influenced by education (P0.02); skilled occupation (P0.0001) and the previous birth of a child with knee deformity from rickets (P0.001). The mother's cultural perceptions of treatment for childhood rickets associated knee deformities was significantly affected by age (P0.001); education; (P0.001); skilled occupation (P0.000); history of knee deformity (P0.04) and mothers with children diagnosed to have knee deformity (P0.004). Lack of finance; poor compliance to treatment; too long treatment periods; lack of information on where to seek for treatment and unaffordable treatment were among the important factors affecting completeness of treatment of knee deformity due to rickets. In conclusion; the awareness of mothers about rickets in Nigeria is still very low. It is a major reason for late presentation or complete failure to seek for adequate treatment of the knee deformity due to rickets. Increase and sustain public health enlightenment programmes are necessary for prevention. Health policy should incorporate free surgical fees for the established knee deformity to encourage community participation in the management of the condition

Factors influencing the outcome of elective paediatric orthopaedic operations in Ile-Ife, Nigeria.

There is a paucity of published data on the types of paediatric orthopaedic conditions that require surgery and factors influencing their outcome in most parts of Sub-Saharan Africa. This is a necessary audit to improve paediatric orthopaedic practice. We carried out an audit of all elective orthopaedic operations performed in children at Awolowo University Teaching Hospitals Complex in Ile-Ife, Nigeria from January 2000 through December 2005. The aim was to document the clinical outcomes and the factors that influence them. This is with a view to instituting necessary measures to improve paediatric orthopaedic practice in the area. A total of 146 children who had elective operations on 210 limbs were included in the study. Their mean age was 75.6 +/- 66.8 months (range 0.3-396 months). The commonest indications for surgery were angular knee deformities (from Blount's disease and rickets) and club foot. The mean hospital stay before surgery was 12 +/- 8.8 days (range 1-38 days). The mean duration of operation was 78.4 +/- 36 min. (range 30-195 min). The total length of hospitalization was 34.97 +/- 19.91 days in males and 41.97 +/- 25.15 days in females. Wound infection was the commonest postoperative complication (8.2%). The patient's age (P = 0.002), indication for surgery (P = 0.008), length of preoperative hospital stay (P = 0.048), length of operation (P < 0.001) and intraoperative blood loss above 200ml (P < 0.001) were found to be statistically significant factors adversely affecting the surgical wound outcome. We conclude that most of the factors that predicted poor outcome in this study were patient and environment-related and are preventable. There is need to upgrade facilities in health institutions in Nigeria.

Pupillary changes among Nigerian adults following the instillation of Garcinia kola nut extracts: multicentric studies.

BACKGROUND: A multi-centre, open, within-patient controlled study was performed on 106 adult volunteers to investigate the effects of Garcinia kolanut extracts on the pupillary sizes. STUDY DESIGN: 106 participants in three Nigerian Ophthalmic Centres with no pupillary defects and associated ocular or systemic co-morbidities had their pupillary diameters measured at 0, 15, 30 and 45 minutes respectively with a pupillometer (Neuroptics model # 586009). Using the left eyes as control, Garcinia kolanut extract was instilled into the right eyes at 15 minutes intervals. RESULTS: There were 63 females and 43 males ranging in age from 18 to 58 years with the mean age of 34.9 years. Average pupillary diameter measured among participants was 4.1 - 8.4 mm with the mean value of 6.0 mm prior to garcinia kola nut extract instillation. There was a gradual reduction in the baseline pupillary size with age in years at 0.2mm per decade without garcinia extract instillation. There was a significant higher baseline pupillary diameter in males than females with males and females mean values of 6.29mm (6.00 - 6.56mm) and 5.85mm (5.60 - 6.11mm) in the right eye (p=0.026) and mean pupillary diameters 6.16mm (5.90 - 6.42mm) and 5.80mm (5.56 - 6.04mm) in the left eyes (p=0.05) respectively. There were consistent significant miosis in the right eyes with instilled Garcinia kola nut extract compared to the left eyes at 15, 30 and 45 minutes (p=0.0000). CONCLUSION: 4% Garcinia kola nut extract drop has a transient miotic effect on human pupils not sustainable for more than 45 minutes.

Factors Infuencing the Outcome of Elective Paediatric Orthopaedic Operations in Ile-Ife; Nigeria

There is a paucity of published data on the types of paediatric orthopaedic conditions that require surgery and factors infl uencing their outcome in most parts of Sub-Saharan Africa. This is a necessary audit to improve paediatric orthopaedic practice. We carried out an audit of all elective orthopaedic operations performed in children at Awolowo University Teaching Hospitals Complex in Ile-Ife, Nigeria from January 2000 through December 2005. The aim was to document the clinical outcomes and the factors that infl uence them. This is with a view to instituting necessary measures to improve paediatric orthopaedic practice in the area. A total of 146 children who had elective operations on 210 limbs were included in the study. Their mean age was 75.6±66.8 months (range 0.3-396 months). The commonest indications for surgery were angular knee deformities (from Blount/'s disease and rickets) and club foot. The mean hospital stay before surgery was 12±8.8 days (range 1-38days). The mean duration of operation was 78.4±36min. (range 30-195 min). The total length of hospitalization was 34.97±19.91 days in males and 41.97±25.15 days in females. Wound infection was the commonest postoperative complication (8.2%). The patient/'s age (P=0.002), indication for surgery (P=0.008), length of preoperative hospital stay (P=0.048), length of operation (P<0.001) and intraoperative blood loss above 200ml (P<0.001) were found to be statistically signifi cant factors adversely affecting the surgical wound outcome. We conclude that most of the factors that predicted poor outcome in this study were patient and environment-related and are preventable. There is need to upgrade facilities in health institutions in Nigeria

Predictive factors for birth trauma in southwestern Nigeria

Birth trauma is a significant cause of neonatal morbidity and mortality. This prospective study determined the predictive factors for birth trauma as seen in a Nigerian university teaching hospital. This was a prospective descriptive evaluation of birth trauma at Wesley Guilds Hospital, Ilesa over three years. Semi-structured questionnaire was used to collect data on the age, gender, pattern of presentation, place and mode of delivery, level of birth attendants, and treatment offered. Outcome measures were factors predisposing to birth trauma. A total of 137 neonatal hospital admissions with birth related complaints were recorded between 10th December, 2002 and 9th December 2005, out of which 119(86.8%) patients had 121 birth injuries (Males: Females= 1.4: 1). The mean age was 6 ± 4.1 (range: 1-31) day. Non skeletal injuries included cephalohaematoma 30(24.8%), genital bruises/abrasion 4(3.3%), subconjuctiva haemorrhage 2(1.7%), subdural haemorrhage 1 (0.8%), nasal necrosis 1(0.8%), Erb`s`palsy 31(25.6%) and Klumpke`s palsy 2(1.7%). Skeletal injuries were mainly bone fractures 50(41.3%)with 2(1.7%)mortality. Ante natal care/delivery, level of birth attendants, mode of delivery, fetal distress, and emergency caesarian section were among the factors that determined birth trauma. The prevalence of birth trauma is high in southwestern Nigeria. The predictive factors are easily identifiable in the perinatal period; early recognition could reduce significantly birth trauma

Causes of limb amputations in Nigerian children.

BACKGROUND: Most reports on amputations in Nigeria have been on adults. Few published data exist on the causes of amputations in children. METHODS: A retrospective analysis of all children who had limb amputations from January 1998 to December 2004 at the Obafemi Awolowo University Teaching Hospitals Complex, Ile-Ife was made. RESULTS: Thirty five (32.7%) out of 107 patients who had major limb amputations were children. The mean age was 9.9 years. Trauma accounted for 74.3% of the amputations, 92.3% of which had developed gangrene from treatment of simple fractures by traditional bone setters. Fifty one point four percent of the amputations were in the upper limbs. The most common complications were anaemia (88.6%) and wound infection (68.6%). One patient had tetanus while one died from septicaemia. Only two patients had prosthetic fitting following amputation. CONCLUSION: Most amputations in Nigerian children are due to traditional bone setters who manage simple, straight forward fractures in children causing gangrene of the limbs.

Predictive factors for primary amputation in trauma patients in a Nigerian university teaching hospital.

BACKGROUND: The decision to attempt salvage or to amputate a severely injured limb is among the most difficult decision that the orthopaedist must face. OBJECTIVE: To determine possible predictive factors that could become guides in taking decision for primary amputation as a first line treatment for trauma patients. DESIGN: A prospective study of post-traumatic primary limb amputations. SETTING: The Obafemi Awolowo University Teaching Hospital Ile-Ife, Nigeria from January, 2000 to December, 2004. SUBJECTS: Sixty six trauma patients admitted through the Accident and Emergency Unit from January 2000 to December 2004. RESULTS: Sixty six traumatised patient limbs were primarily amputated during the study period. The male: female ratio was 3.7:1 and means age was 28.6 years +/- 16.6(range: 4-71 years). 80.3% of the patients were below forty years. All the patients had a single limb amputation. The mean MESS score was 9.4 +/- 1.3 (range: 7.0-12.0). The main predictive factors in trauma at the emergency unit for primary amputation include age, sex, occupation, limb ischaemia, gangrene, severe open fracture, source or nature of injury, presence of shock, delay in hospital presentation, and MESS. CONCLUSION: Immediate amputation is often viewed by the patient and family as a result of the injury. Conversely, a delayed amputation may be viewed as a failure of treatment. Identified predictive factors for primary amputation will reduce trauma associated morbidity and mortality.