Diagnostic momentum in physical therapy clinical reasoning.

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Diagnostic momentum refers to ruling in a particular diagnosis without adequate evidence. As the field of physical therapy continues to transition more towards autonomous practitioners with direct access, there is a need to identify the effect of a physician diagnosis on a therapist's examination and treatment. The purpose of this study was to identify if diagnostic momentum exists in physical therapy and whether this phenomenon could affect the ability of the therapist to identify clinical red flags. METHODS: An online survey with randomized case scenarios was completed by 75 licensed practicing physical therapists. Participants received one of two scenarios: a case vignette where the patient was referred to physical therapy for left shoulder pain and presented with 'red flags' indicative of myocardial infarction, or a similar vignette with additional results from an exercise stress test that ruled out myocardial infarction. The subjects were asked if they would 'treat' or 'refer' to another healthcare provider and the reason behind their decision. Independent t-tests and χ2 analyses were conducted to understand the differences between the groups. A thematic analysis was used to explore the therapists' responses regarding the reasoning for their decision. RESULTS: There was no significant difference in clinical decision making based on age, gender, years of experience, advanced certification, primary caseload or primary practice setting. Among those who received the case without the stress test, 31.4% of participants indicated that they would refer, compared to 12.5% of the participants that had the additional stress test result included within their case. The presence of the negative stress test was indicated as the main reason for choosing to treat without referral by 65.7% of the subjects that received the additional stress test result. CONCLUSION: This study suggests that practicing physical therapists may be influenced by diagnostic decisions made by other clinicians, causing them to overlook signs and symptoms of possible myocardial infarction.

Novice Inter-Rater Reliability on the Selective Functional Movement Assessment (SFMA) After a 4-Hour Training Session.

Background: The Selective Functional Movement Assessment (SFMA) is a whole-body movement classification system that identifies non-optimal movement performance requiring further assessment. There needs to be more evidence specifying the training time required to obtain SFMA reliability for entry-level health care practitioners. Purpose: The primary intent of this study was to determine SFMA inter-rater reliability between two third-year physical therapy students following an in-person three-hour training and one-hour follow-up training with a certified SFMA physical therapist. The secondary purpose was to compare rater scores of the composite criterion 50-point checklist and rater categorization using the top-tier movements in real-time assessments of healthy participants. Study Design: Inter-rater reliability study. Methods: Two novice raters received training on assessing movement using the SFMA. Participants included non-pregnant healthy adults screened for general exercise, participants were excluded for history of orthopedic surgery within the prior six months. Three independent raters, including two novice and one SFMA-certified rater, individually assessed the top-tier movements in separate rooms in real-time. Participants were randomly assigned a start location, and raters were blinded to each other's criterion 50-point checklist and categorical scoring. Statistical analysis included a paired t-test, a repeated measures ANOVA, and a two-way, mixed absolute agreement ICC. Results: Twenty-five participants (23.4 years ± 1.9; 72% female) completed the SFMA top-tier movements. Significant differences were identified with novice raters identifying fewer non-optimal movement patterns than the certified clinician. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC2,1) was moderate (0.60, p<0.001) for all three raters on the 50-point criterion checklist scoring. Conclusion: Third year physical therapy students were able to demonstrate moderate inter-rater reliability assessing healthy individuals using the 50-point criterion checklist. Variation between novice raters may reflect the amount of previous exposure assessing movement and suggests that some may require more time learning and practicing in order to identify non-optimal movement patterns that may require further assessment. Level of Evidence: 3b©The Author(s).

The Effects of Proprioceptive Training on Balance, Strength, Agility and Dribbling in Adolescent Male Soccer Players.

The aim of the study was to determine the effects of proprioceptive training (PT) on balance, strength, agility and dribbling in adolescent soccer players. In this research, we included an experimental (n = 48) and a control (n = 48) group (CG) with 14 years old players. The experimental group (EG) participated in an 8 week PT program, with four 30 min sessions per week. The experimental program included 12 bosu ball exercises to improve balance, stability and strength which were grouped into two subprograms: the first not using the soccer ball, the second subprogram using the soccer ball. The subprograms were implemented alternately during 16 proprioceptive training sessions, on two types of firm and foam surfaces. Pre- and post-tests included the static balance [Balance Error Scoring System (BESS)], vertical, horizontal, and lateral jumping, and the completion of agility ("arrowhead") and dribbling ("short dribbling") tests. Regarding the total BESS score, the CG has demonstrated progress between the pre- and the post-test, with 0.780 ± 0.895, fewer errors, while the EG had 5.828 ± 1.017 fewer errors. The difference between the two groups was of 5.148 fewer errors for the EG who had practiced the proposed program of proprioceptive training. The highest difference registered between the pre- and the post-test was at the test "single-leg forward jump with the right leg", with a result of 1.083 ± 0.459 cm for the CG and of 3.916 ± 0. 761 cm for the EG. Through the analysis of average differences between the pre- and the post-tests, we observe that, regarding the "Agility right side test", the EG has progressed with 0.382 s in comparison with the CG; regarding the "Agility left side test", the EG has progressed with 0.233 s compared to the CG; regarding the "Agility right and left side test", the EG has progressed with 0.196 s compared to the CG; in the "Short dribbling test", the EG has progressed with 0.174 s compared to the CG. The highest progress was made at the "Agility right side test", of 0.402 s for the EG, while the CG registered 0.120 s. Most of the results in all tests for both experimental groups show an effect size ranging from small to medium. The progress made by the experimental group in all tests was statistically significant, while in the control group the progress was mostly statistically insignificant for p < 0.05. The results suggest that a PT program performed at about 14 years of age could be successfully implemented in the training regime of soccer players to improve components of fitness along with dribbling skills. The results of the study revealed that sports training on the foam surfaces determined a superior progress of the development of proprioception compared to the increased training on the firm surfaces.

Effects of global postural alignment on posture-stabilizing synergy and intermuscular coherence in bipedal standing.

Clinicians frequently assess and intervene on postural alignment; however, notions of what constitutes good postural alignment are variable. Furthermore, the majority of current evidence appeals either to population norms or defines good postural alignment as the negation of what has been observed to correlate with pathology. The purpose of this study was to identify affirmative indicators of good postural alignment in reference to motor control theory. Electromyography (anterior leg, posterior leg, and trunk muscles) and motion capture data were acquired from 13 participants during 4 min bipedal standing trials in 4 conditions: control, - 10%, + 30%, and + 60% of subject-specific anterior limits of stability. Synergistic kinematic coordination was quantified via the uncontrolled manifold framework, and correlated neural drive was quantified in posture-relevant muscle groups (anterior, posterior, and trunk) via intermuscular coherence. Multilevel models assessed the effects of sagittal plane alignment on both outcomes. We observed a within-subjects fixed effect in which kinematic synergistic coordination decreased as subjects became more misaligned. We also observed within-subjects fixed effects for middle- and high-frequency intermuscular coherence in the posterior group (increased coherence with increased misalignment) and for trunk intermuscular coherence across all frequency bands (decreased coherence with increased misalignment). Our findings indicate that it may be possible to describe healthy postural alignment in light of referent control theory. Greater misalignment with respect to vertical is associated with compromises in synergistic control of posture and increased corticospinal drive to specific muscle groups. These results suggest that postural alignment may not simply be an empirical phenomenon.

The Effect of Whole-Body Fatigue on King-Devick Test and Balance.

Purpose: Fatigue may mimic suboptimal brain functioning seen after a concussion and lead to false-positive King-Devick (K-D) scores and decreased balance. The purpose of this study was to investigate if whole-body fatigue has an effect on K-D scores or postural sway. Method: A total of 38 healthy participants (20 females; age = 23.5 ± 2.63 y; height = 170 ± 0.1 cm; mass = 75.2 ± 10.3 kg) volunteered for the study. Participants completed the King-Devick (K-D) test and the modified Clinical Test of Sensory Interaction of Balance (mCTSIB) on the Biodex BioSwayTM Portable Balance System prior to and immediately following the completion of a fatigue protocol on a Concept2 Rower. Results: Half of the participants demonstrated a positive K-D test post-fatigue. Balance scores were poorer post-fatigue. No difference was found between participants based on history of concussion. Among the participants that had a positive post-fatigue K-D test, 71% had also a worse composite sway index score (χ2 = 6.3, p = .02). Conclusions: Whole-body fatigue may negatively impact a person's ability to perform the K-D test and balance assessments. It is recommended that the athlete is allowed a period of time to accommodate for the acute effects of fatigue before administering these assessments following a suspected concussion.

The role of pre-season health characteristics as injury risk factors in female adolescent soccer players.

[Purpose] Determine if female adolescent soccer players with a history of concussion, impaired K-D scores, and pre-season subjective complaints of neck pain, dizziness, and headache were predisposed to additional risk of musculoskeletal or concussive injury during 10-weeks of competitive play. [Participants and Methods] Twenty-three female high school soccer athletes provided concussion history and reported pre-season subjective complaints. K-D testing was performed pre and postseason. During the 10-week season, all injuries, preventing participation in practice or game, were recorded. [Results] Six reported a history of concussion. Of those six, three injuries were reported, including two concussions and a hamstring strain. Baseline K-D scores were worse in athletes that had two or more pre-season subjective factors compared to those that did not have any. Moderate positive correlations were found between a history of concussion and the number of injuries and a history of concussion and K-D post-test scores. [Conclusion] Findings indicate that pre-season subjective factors of neck pain, dizziness and headache, history of concussion, and K-D potentially increased injury risk. Combining pre-season metrics both at baseline and during the course of the season may assist in better injury risk screening in-season or indicate suboptimal function due to cumulative effects.

SCORING PERFORMANCE VARIATIONS BETWEEN THE Y-BALANCE TEST, A MODIFIED Y-BALANCE TEST, AND THE MODIFIED STAR EXCURSION BALANCE TEST.

BACKGROUND: The Modified Star Excursion Balance Test (MSEBT) and the Y-Balance Test- Lower Quarter (YBT-LQ) are utilized to assess dynamic postural stability. These assessments cannot be used interchangeably secondary to kinematic variations and performance differences. A Modified Y-Balance Test-Lower Quarter (MYBT-LQ) was developed to determine if a modification allows performance scores to be directly compared to the MSEBT. PURPOSE: The purpose of this research was to determine if reach distances were similar for young, healthy individuals between three different balance tests: the YBT-LQ, the MYBT-LQ, and the MSEBT. STUDY DESIGN: Repeated measures, descriptive cohort study. METHODS: Twenty-eight participants (17 males, 11 females) were recruited from a convenience sample of young, healthy adults. Participants completed all testing within a single session and performed three trials in each direction, on each leg, for all balance tests. Scoring performance was calculated for each balance test using the average normalized reach distance in the anterior, posterolateral, and posteromedial directions. A one-way ANOVA was used to compare between-subject posteromedial and posterolateral scores, while anterior scores were analyzed using a Kruskal Wallis test. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was used to determine within-subject participant performance reliability. RESULTS: Analyses indicated significant differences in the posterolateral and posteromedial reach directions between the YBT-LQ and MSEBT and between the MYBT-LQ and MSEBT, while no significant difference was found between the YBT-LQ and MYBT-LQ in any direction. No anterior reach differences were noted between any of the tests. Within-subject ICCs showed a very strong level of agreement between right and left anterior and right posteromedial reaches between all three tests, while only the YBT-LQ and MYBT-LQ demonstrated very strong agreement in all directions. CONCLUSION: Reach performance on the MSEBT differed from the performance on the YBT-LQ and MYBT-LQ in the anterior, posteromedial and posterolateral directions in this population. These findings further support the difference in motor control strategies used during these tests. LEVELS OF EVIDENCE: 2c.

Therapeutic effects of forced exercise cycling in individuals with Parkinson's disease.

Currently there is no cure for the progressive movement disorders associated with Parkinson's Disease (PD). Pharmacological management of movement disorders in PD are associated with significant negative side effects. Exercise improves the efficacy of anti-parkinsonian medication, but does not ameliorate the side effects. Consensus on the optimal mode of exercise training or dosing to improve motor function for individuals with PD is lacking. The new concept of forced exercise is gaining traction in the literature as a mode of exercise which has the potential to improve motor function in individuals with PD. The purpose of this article is to review the effects of forced exercise on specific components of motor function that would help guide clinical decision making and exercise prescription for the PD patient population. Collectively, the evidence provided in this review suggests that forced exercise may be safely added as an ancillary therapy to the medical management of PD.

Fascial manipulation vs. standard physical therapy practice for low back pain diagnoses: A pragmatic study.

BACKGROUND: Connective tissue mobility alters motor unit recruitment, but the restoration of fascial mobility allows for optimal motor function. The Fascial Manipulation® (FM®) method is a multiplanar approach that assesses and treats the mobility of deep fascia in specific anatomical locations where motor units converge. OBJECTIVES: To assess the effects of FM® vs. standard physical therapy treatment (SPT) in patients with low back pain (LBP). DESIGN: Six-months controlled clinical trial. METHOD: 102 participants with LBP received SPT or FM®. Numeric Pain Rating Scale (NPRS), 15- point Global Rating of Change (GROC), and Oswestry Disability Index (ODI) were used to monitor progress. RESULTS: The FM® group had a significantly lower ODI (p < 0.009) and NPS scores (p < 0.0001) and significantly higher GROC scores (p < 0.003) once their means were adjusted for initial scores. When comparing the SPT to FM®, the final ODI decreased by at least 1 category in 48.9% of the SPT cases, while in 36.2% of the cases was no change. ODI minimal clinical importance difference (MCID) change of 10% decrease in scores occurred in 70.2% of the SPT group compared to 96% of the FM® group (p = 0.003). ODI MCID change of 50% decrease in scores occurred in 40% of the SPT group compared to 64.6% of the FM® group (p = 0.02) 44.7% of the participants in the SPT group had final GROC values above +5 at discharge, compared to 92% of the participants from the FM® group (p = 0.0001). The FM® subjects had almost three times the change in NPRS compared to SPT counterparts (-4.3 ±â€¯2.2 to -1.5  ± 2.4, p=0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: FM® appears to improve NPRS, GROC, and ODI more than SPT. FM® may provide an effective treatment technique for LBP.

A commentary review of the cost effectiveness of manual therapies for neck and low back pain.

BACKGROUND & PURPOSE: Neck and low back pain (NLBP) are global health problems, which diminish quality of life and consume vast economic resources. Cost effectiveness in healthcare is the minimal amount spent to obtain acceptable outcomes. Studies on manual therapies often fail to identify which manual therapy intervention or combinations with other interventions is the most cost effective. The purpose of this commentary is to sample the dialogue within the literature on the cost effectiveness of evidence-based manual therapies with a particular focus on the neck and low back regions. METHODS: This commentary identifies and presents the available literature on the cost effectiveness of manual therapies for NLBP. Key words searched were neck and low back pain, cost effectiveness, and manual therapy to select evidence-based articles. Eight articles were identified and presented for discussion. RESULTS: The lack of homogeneity, in the available literature, makes difficult any valid comparison among the various cost effectiveness studies. DISCUSSION: Potential outcome bias in each study is dependent upon the lens through which it is evaluated. If evaluated from a societal perspective, the conclusion slants toward "adequate" interventions in an effort to decrease costs rather than toward the most efficacious interventions with the best outcomes. When cost data are assessed according to a healthcare (or individual) perspective, greater value is placed on quality of life, the patient's beliefs, and the "willingness to pay."

Effects of obstructive sleep apnea on hemodynamic parameters in patients entering cardiac rehabilitation.

PURPOSE: Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is a prevalent form of sleep-disordered breathing. Evidence suggests that OSA may lead to cardiac remodeling, although the literature is equivocal. Previous literature suggests a high percentage of individuals entering a cardiac rehabilitation (CR) program also have OSA. The objective of this study was to determine whether resting hemodynamic variables were altered in OSA subjects entering CR compared with those without OSA, as determined by impedance cardiography. METHODS: Subjects entering an early outpatient CR program were screened for OSA using an at-home screening device and verified by a sleep physician. Subjects were divided into an OSA group (n = 48) or a control group (n = 25) on the basis of the screening results. Hemodynamic variables were measured during supine rest using impedance cardiography. A 6-minute walk test was performed to assess functional capacity. RESULTS: The proportion of cardiac diagnoses was similar between groups. Overall, 66% of the subjects were positive for OSA. Subject groups did not differ by age, body mass index, heart rate, diastolic blood pressure, or functional capacity. Cardiac output, cardiac index, stroke volume, contractility index, and left cardiac work index were all significantly decreased in the OSA group compared with the control group (P < .05). CONCLUSIONS: Findings suggest that OSA results in decreased cardiac function in patients entering CR, likely because of pressure and volume changes associated with apneic events. This may place those individuals at a disadvantage in recovering from their cardiac event, and place them at increased risk for secondary complications.

Reproductibility of cardiac monitoring in men using impedance cardiography during Müeller maneuver.

UNLABELLED: Obstructive sleep apnea hypopnea syndrome (OSAHS) is a form of sleep-disordered breathing highlighted by recurrent episodes of upper airway collapse during sleep. OSAHS contributes to an increased risk of cardiac arrhythmias, cardiovascular disease, and altered immune function. Measuring cardiac function in OSAHS patients can provide information that can help delineate clinical treatment efficacy. Cardiac function has been widely tested using electrical bioimpedance. AIM: The aim of this study was to determine the reproducibility of cardiac functional parameters in subjects performing Müeller maneuver. METHODS: Fifteen apparently healthy males were tested on three different days in a protocol requiring their performance of forced and sustained inspiratory efforts against a closed epiglottis (Müeller maneuver-MM). On each day, the protocol included performance of two simulated apneas of 30 seconds, with at least 3 minutes of normal breathing in between. RESULTS: Changes from a normal breathing baseline for cardiac output, heart rate and stroke volume were comparable during both MM in all three days. The coefficient of variation was similar on all three trials. CONCLUSIONS: This new contemporary bioimpedance cardiography device provided reliable measures of dynamic cardiac responses during a simulated apnea event.

Altered ventilatory responses to exercise testing in young adult men with obstructive sleep apnea.

BACKGROUND: Obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) is a disorder characterized by repetitive obstructions of the upper airway. Individuals with OSA experience intermittent hypoxia, hypercapnia, and arousals during sleep, resulting in increased sympathetic activation. Chemoreflex activation, arising from the resultant oscillatory disturbances in blood gases from OSA, exerts control over ventilation, and may induce increases in sympathetic vasoconstriction, contributing to increased long-term risks for hypertension (HTN) and cardiovascular disease (CVD). METHODS: To evaluate whether OSA elicits exaggerated ventilatory responses to exercise in young men, 14 overweight men with OSA and 16 overweight men without OSA performed maximal ramping cycle ergometer exercise tests. Oxygen consumption (VO(2)), ventilation, (V(E)), ventilatory equivalents for oxygen (V(E)/VO(2)) and carbon dioxide (V(E)/VCO(2)), and V(E)/VCO(2) slope were measured. RESULTS: The VO(2) response to exercise did not differ between groups. The V(E), V(E)/VCO(2), V(E)/VO(2) were higher (p< 0.05, 0.002, and p<0.02, respectively) in the OSA group across all workloads. The V(E)/VCO(2) slope was greater in the OSA group (p<0.05). The V(E)/VCO(2) slope and AHI were significantly correlated (r=0.56, p<0.03). Thus, young, overweight men with OSA exhibit increased ventilatory responses to exercise when compared to overweight controls. This may reflect alterations in chemoreflex sensitivity, and contribute to increased sympathetic drive and HTN risk.

Potential clinical use of cardiopulmonary exercise testing in obstructive sleep apnea hypopnea syndrome.

There is growing evidence linking obstructive sleep apnea hypopnea syndrome (OSAHS) with multiple cardiovascular and metabolic diseases. Exercise testing is generally available and routinely used to provide valuable information on cardiopulmonary function in healthy and diseased populations. This review summarizes and integrates recent findings on exercise testing in OSAHS and discusses the potential mechanisms that may contribute to the responses that seem to differentiate these patients from apparently healthy subjects and patients with other cardiopulmonary diseases. Although exercise testing is widely used in the evaluation and diagnosis of coronary artery disease patients, recent studies showed distinctive cardiopulmonary responses in OSAHS that raise the possibility of similar applications in this disorder, as well. Several studies illustrated in this review found that OSAHS patients have a reduced exercise capacity, as shown by low peak oxygen uptake achieved. Also, their exercise HR response was reported as significantly lower than in healthy peers, suggesting chronotropic incompetence. Exercise blood pressure response were atypical as well. OSAHS patients had increased systolic and diastolic BP during exercise and a persistently elevated systolic BP during the early post-exercise recovery period. Possible explanations for these responses include cardiac dysfunction, impaired muscle metabolism, chronic sympathetic over-activation, and endothelial dysfunction. Early identification of OSAHS using cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPXT) shows promise for selecting patients at risk for this disorder in the clinical setting. A uniform definition and measurement of OSAHS together with more rigorous trials are necessary to establish the utility of exercise responses in clinical settings.

Cardiac rehabilitation outcomes no different after on-pump versus off-pump coronary artery bypass surgery.

PURPOSE: Clinical evidence supports lower morbidity with off-pump coronary revascularization surgery as well as superior short- and mid-term outcomes, equivalent graft patency, and reduced cost. The purpose of this study was to compare cardiac rehabilitation (CR) outcomes between patients undergoing on-pump versus off-pump coronary artery bypass surgery. METHODS: Data were retrospectively examined for patients who participated in CR between 1996 and 2004. Two hundred ninety-five patients who underwent bypass surgery and completed at least 80% of their 36 required sessions were divided into on-pump and off-pump groups. Pre- and post-CR measures included grip strength, flexibility, energy expended during class, quality of life, and self-efficacy. RESULTS: Both groups were similar with respect to age, sex, ejection fraction, and mean number of grafts. There were no statistical differences between the on-pump and off-pump groups (P > .05) for weight, abdominal and hip circumferences, grip strength, flexibility, and total energy expenditure. In addition, there were no between-group differences regarding quality of life and self-efficacy. Grip strength, flexibility, and energy expenditure during class improved with CR regardless of the surgical procedure (P = .001). Quality of life (P = .001) and self-efficacy (P = .001) also improved. CONCLUSIONS: The present data support the concept that although there are clinical advantages to off-pump surgery, there is no benefit over on-pump surgery regarding CR. Subsequently, patients undergoing off-pump surgery should be managed similarly as their on-pump counterparts.