Understanding the impact of in vitro transcription byproducts and contaminants.

The success of messenger (m)RNA-based vaccines against SARS-CoV-2 during the COVID-19 pandemic has led to rapid growth and innovation in the field of mRNA-based therapeutics. However, mRNA production, whether in small amounts for research or large-scale GMP-grade for biopharmaceutics, is still based on the In Vitro Transcription (IVT) reaction developed in the early 1980s. The IVT reaction exploits phage RNA polymerase to catalyze the formation of an engineered mRNA that depends on a linearized DNA template, nucleotide building blocks, as well as pH, temperature, and reaction time. But depending on the IVT conditions and subsequent purification steps, diverse byproducts such as dsRNA, abortive RNAs and RNA:DNA hybrids might form. Unwanted byproducts, if not removed, could be formulated together with the full-length mRNA and cause an immune response in cells by activating host pattern recognition receptors. In this review, we summarize the potential types of IVT byproducts, their known biological activity, and how they can impact the efficacy and safety of mRNA therapeutics. In addition, we briefly overview non-nucleotide-based contaminants such as RNases, endotoxin and metal ions that, when present in the IVT reaction, can also influence the activity of mRNA-based drugs. We further discuss current approaches aimed at adjusting the IVT reaction conditions or improving mRNA purification to achieve optimal performance for medical applications.

Formation of dsRNA by-products during in vitro transcription can be reduced by using low steady-state levels of UTP.

Introduction: Exogeneous messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) can be used as therapeutic and preventive medication. However, during the enzymatic production process, commonly called in vitro transcription, by-products occur which can reduce the therapeutic efficacy of mRNA. One such by-product is double-stranded RNA (dsRNA). We therefore sought to limit the generation of dsRNA by-products during in vitro transcription. Materials and methods: In vitro transcription was performed with a DNA template including a poly(A)-tail-encoding region, dinucleotide or trinucleotide cap analogs for cotranscriptional capping, and relevant nucleoside triphosphates. Concentrations of UTP or modified UTP (m1ΨTP) and GTP were reduced and fed over the course of the reaction. mRNA was analyzed for dsRNA contamination, yield of the reaction, RNA integrity, and capping efficiency before translational activity was assessed. Results: Limiting the steady-state level of UTP or m1ΨTP during the enzymatic reaction reduced dsRNA formation, while not affecting mRNA yield or RNA integrity. Capping efficiency was optimized with the use of a combined GTP and UTP or m1ΨTP feed, while still reducing dsRNA formation. Lower dsRNA levels led to higher protein expression from the corresponding mRNAs. Discussion: Low steady-state concentrations of UTP and GTP, fed in combination over the course of the in vitro transcription reaction, produce mRNA with high capping and low levels of dsRNA formation, resulting in high levels of protein expression. This novel approach may render laborious purification steps to remove dsRNA unnecessary.

Ribozyme Assays to Quantify the Capping Efficiency of In Vitro-Transcribed mRNA.

The presence of the cap structure on the 5'-end of in vitro-transcribed (IVT) mRNA determines its translation and stability, underpinning its use in therapeutics. Both enzymatic and co-transcriptional capping may lead to incomplete positioning of the cap on newly synthesized RNA molecules. IVT mRNAs are rapidly emerging as novel biologics, including recent vaccines against COVID-19 and vaccine candidates against other infectious diseases, as well as for cancer immunotherapies and protein replacement therapies. Quality control methods necessary for the preclinical and clinical stages of development of these therapeutics are under ongoing development. Here, we described a method to assess the presence of the cap structure of IVT mRNAs. We designed a set of ribozyme assays to specifically cleave IVT mRNAs at a unique position and release 5'-end capped or uncapped cleavage products up to 30 nt long. We purified these products using silica-based columns and visualized/quantified them using denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) or liquid chromatography and mass spectrometry (LC-MS). Using this technology, we determined the capping efficiencies of IVT mRNAs with different features, which include: Different cap structures, diverse 5' untranslated regions, different nucleoside modifications, and diverse lengths. Taken together, the ribozyme cleavage assays we developed are fast and reliable for the analysis of capping efficiency for research and development purposes, as well as a general quality control for mRNA-based therapeutics.

A Facile Method for the Removal of dsRNA Contaminant from In Vitro-Transcribed mRNA.

The increasing importance of in vitro-transcribed (IVT) mRNA for synthesizing the encoded therapeutic protein in vivo demands the manufacturing of pure mRNA products. The major contaminant in the IVT mRNA is double-stranded RNA (dsRNA), a transcriptional by-product that can be removed only by burdensome procedure requiring special instrumentation and generating hazardous waste. Here we present an alternative simple, fast, and cost-effective method involving only standard laboratory techniques. The purification of IVT mRNA is based on the selective binding of dsRNA to cellulose in an ethanol-containing buffer. We demonstrate that at least 90% of the dsRNA contaminants can be removed with a good, >65% recovery rate, regardless of the length, coding sequence, and nucleoside composition of the IVT mRNA. The procedure is scalable; purification of microgram or milligram amounts of IVT mRNA is achievable. Evaluating the impact of the mRNA purification in vivo in mice, increased translation could be measured for the administered transcripts, including the 1-methylpseudouridine-containing IVT mRNA, which no longer induced interferon (IFN)-α. The cellulose-based removal of dsRNA contaminants is an effective, reliable, and safe method to obtain highly pure IVT mRNA suitable for in vivo applications.

Exposure of vital cells to necrotic cell lysates induce the IRE1α branch of the unfolded protein response and cell proliferation.

Necrosis is a form of cell death that is detrimental to the affected tissue because the cell ruptures and releases its content (reactive oxygen species among others) into the extracellular space. Clusterin (CLU), a cytoprotective extracellular chaperone has been shown to be upregulated in the face of necrosis. We here show that in addition to CLU upregulation, necrotic cell lysates induce JNK/SAPK signaling, the IRE1α branch of the unfolded protein response (UPR), the MAPK/ERK1/2, and the mTOR signaling pathways and results in an enhanced proliferation of the vital surrounding cells. We name this novel response mechanism: Necrosis-induced Proliferation (NiP).

Non-secreted clusterin isoforms are translated in rare amounts from distinct human mRNA variants and do not affect Bax-mediated apoptosis or the NF-κB signaling pathway.

Clusterin, also known as apolipoprotein J, is expressed from a variety of tissues and implicated in pathological disorders such as neurodegenerative diseases, ischemia and cancer. In contrast to secretory clusterin (sCLU), which acts as an extracellular chaperone, the synthesis, subcellular localization and function(s) of intracellular CLU isoforms is currently a matter of intense discussion. By investigating human CLU mRNAs we here unravel mechanisms leading to the synthesis of distinct CLU protein isoforms and analyze their subcellular localization and their impact on apoptosis and on NF-κB-activity. Quantitative PCR-analyses revealed the expression of four different stress-inducible CLU mRNA variants in non-cancer and cancer cell lines. In all cell lines variant 1 represents the most abundant mRNA, whereas all other variants collectively account for no more than 0.34% of total CLU mRNA, even under stressed conditions. Overexpression of CLU cDNAs combined with in vitro mutagenesis revealed distinct translational start sites including a so far uncharacterized non-canonical CUG start codon. We show that all exon 2-containing mRNAs encode sCLU and at least three non-glycosylated intracellular isoforms, CLU1­449, CLU21­449 and CLU34­449, which all reside in the cytosol of unstressed and stressed HEK­293 cells. The latter is the only form expressed from an alternatively spliced mRNA variant lacking exon 2. Functional analysis revealed that none of these cytosolic CLU forms modulate caspase-mediated intrinsic apoptosis or significantly affects TNF-α-induced NF-κB-activity. Therefore our data challenge some of the current ideas regarding the physiological functions of CLU isoforms in pathologies.

Statins stimulate the production of a soluble form of the receptor for advanced glycation end products.

The beneficial effects of statin therapy in the reduction of cardiovascular pathogenesis, atherosclerosis, and diabetic complications are well known. The receptor for advanced glycation end products (RAGE) plays an important role in the progression of these diseases. In contrast, soluble forms of RAGE act as decoys for RAGE ligands and may prevent the development of RAGE-mediated disorders. Soluble forms of RAGE are either produced by alternative splicing [endogenous secretory RAGE (esRAGE)] or by proteolytic shedding mediated by metalloproteinases [shed RAGE (sRAGE)]. Therefore we analyzed whether statins influence the production of soluble RAGE. Lovastatin treatment of either mouse alveolar epithelial cells endogenously expressing RAGE or HEK cells overexpressing RAGE caused induction of RAGE shedding, but did not influence secretion of esRAGE from HEK cells overexpressing esRAGE. Lovastatin-induced secretion of sRAGE was also evident after restoration of the isoprenylation pathway, demonstrating a correlation of sterol biosynthesis and activation of RAGE shedding. Lovastatin-stimulated induction of RAGE shedding was completely abolished by a metalloproteinase ADAM10 inhibitor. We also demonstrate that statins stimulate RAGE shedding at low physiologically relevant concentrations. Our results show that statins, due to their cholesterol-lowering effects, increase the soluble RAGE level by inducing RAGE shedding, and by doing this, might prevent the development of RAGE-mediated pathogenesis.

Chapter 7: Cell protective functions of secretory Clusterin (sCLU).

Secretory clusterin (sCLU) is found as an 80-kDa glycoprotein in virtually all body fluids, in serum it is associated with high-density lipoprotein (HDL). Here, we discuss demonstrated and proposed mechanisms of the cytoprotective functions of sCLU in instances of apoptosis, necrosis, and disease. These include prevention from cell damage by lipid oxidation in blood vessels, removal of dead cell remnants in tissues undergoing various forms of cell death, and clearance of harmful extracellular molecules such as amyloid beta (Abeta) by endocytosis or transcytosis. All these functions may reflect the propensity of sCLU to bind to a wide spectrum of hydrophobic molecules on one hand and to specific cell-surface receptors on the other hand. Identified and proposed sCLU receptors are members of the LDL receptor family of endocytosis receptors. Since these receptors recently have proved to modulate cell signaling we will discuss whether sCLU due to this interaction not only targets its ligands for clearance, but may also be involved in triggering signal transduction.