Standardization of Fluorescent Reporter Assays in Synthetic Biology across the Visible Light Spectrum.

In synthetic biology, Fluorescent reporters are frequently used to characterize the expression levels obtained from both genetic parts such as promoters and ribosome binding sites as well as from complex genetic circuits. To this end, plate readers offer an easy and high-throughput way of characterizing both the growth and fluorescence expression levels of cell cultures. However, despite the similar mode of action used in different devices, their output is not comparable due to intrinsic differences in their setup. Additionally, the generated output is expressed using arbitrary units, limiting reliable comparison of results to measurements taken within one single experiment using one specific plate reader, hampering the transferability of data across different plate readers and laboratories. This article presents an easy and accessible calibration method for transforming the device-specific output into a standardized output expressing the amount of fluorescence per well as a known equivalent fluorophore concentration per cell for fluorescent reporters spanning the visible light spectrum. This calibration method follows a 2-fold approach determining both the estimated number of cells and the equivalent chemical fluorophore concentration per well. It will contribute to the comparison of plate reader experiments between different laboratories across the world and will therefore greatly improve the reliability and exchange of both results and genetic parts between research groups.

Molecular mechanisms of regulation by a ß-alanine-responsive Lrp-type transcription factor from Acidianus hospitalis.

The leucine-responsive regulatory protein (Lrp) family of transcriptional regulators is widespread among prokaryotes and especially well-represented in archaea. It harbors members with diverse functional mechanisms and physiological roles, often linked to the regulation of amino acid metabolism. BarR is an Lrp-type regulator that is conserved in thermoacidophilic Thermoprotei belonging to the order Sulfolobales and is responsive to the non-proteinogenic amino acid ß-alanine. In this work, we unravel molecular mechanisms of the Acidianus hospitalis BarR homolog, Ah-BarR. Using a heterologous reporter gene system in Escherichia coli, we demonstrate that Ah-BarR is a dual-function transcription regulator that is capable of repressing transcription of its own gene and activating transcription of an aminotransferase gene, which is divergently transcribed from a common intergenic region. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) visualization reveals a conformation in which the intergenic region appears wrapped around an octameric Ah-BarR protein. ß-alanine causes small conformational changes without affecting the oligomeric state of the protein, resulting in a relief of regulation while the regulator remains bound to the DNA. This regulatory and ligand response is different from the orthologous regulators in Sulfolobus acidocaldarius and Sulfurisphaera tokodaii, which is possibly explained by a distinct binding site organization and/or by the presence of an additional C-terminal tail in Ah-BarR. By performing site-directed mutagenesis, this tail is shown to be involved in ligand-binding response.

Structural basis of DNA binding by YdaT, a functional equivalent of the CII repressor in the cryptic prophage CP-933P from Escherichia coli O157:H7.

YdaT is a functional equivalent of the CII repressor in certain lambdoid phages and prophages. YdaT from the cryptic prophage CP-933P in the genome of Escherichia coli O157:H7 is functional as a DNA-binding protein and recognizes a 5'-TTGATTN6AATCAA-3' inverted repeat. The DNA-binding domain is a helix-turn-helix (HTH)-containing POU domain and is followed by a long α-helix (α6) that forms an antiparallel four-helix bundle, creating a tetramer. The loop between helix α2 and the recognition helix α3 in the HTH motif is unusually long compared with typical HTH motifs, and is highly variable in sequence and length within the YdaT family. The POU domains have a large degree of freedom to move relative to the helix bundle in the free structure, but their orientation becomes fixed upon DNA binding.

Unlocking the bacterial domain for industrial biotechnology applications using universal parts and tools.

Synthetic biology can play a major role in the development of sustainable industrial biotechnology processes. However, the development of economically viable production processes is currently hampered by the limited availability of host organisms that can be engineered for a specific production process. To date, standard hosts such as Escherichia coli and Saccharomyces cerevisiae are often used as starting points for process development since parts and tools allowing their engineering are readily available. However, their suboptimal metabolic background or impaired performance at industrial scale for a desired production process, can result in increased costs associated with process development and/or disappointing production titres. Building a universal and portable gene expression system allowing genetic engineering of hosts across the bacterial domain would unlock the bacterial domain for industrial biotechnology applications in a highly standardized manner and, doing so, render industrial biotechnology processes more competitive compared to the current polluting chemical processes. This review gives an overview of a selection of bacterial hosts highly interesting for industrial biotechnology based on both their metabolic and process optimization properties. Moreover, the requirements and progress made so far to enable universal, standardized, and portable gene expression across the bacterial domain is discussed.

In Vivo Screening Method for the Identification and Characterization of Prokaryotic, Metabolite-Responsive Transcription Factors.

In prokaryotes, transcription factors (TFs) are of uttermost importance for the regulation of gene expression. However, the majority of TFs are not characterized today, which hampers both the understanding of fundamental processes and the development of TF-based applications, such as biosensors, used in metabolic engineering, synthetic biology, diagnostics, etc. One way of analyzing TFs is through in vivo screening, enabling the study of TF-promoter interactions, ligand inducibility, and ligand specificity in a high-throughput fashion. Here, an approach is described for the selection and cloning of TF-promoter pairs, the development of a reporter system, and the measurement and analysis of fluorescent reporter assays. Furthermore, the importance of a suitable inducible plasmid system is illustrated together with prospective adaptations to modify a reporter system's output signal. The given approach can be used for the investigation of native, heterologous, or even artificially created TFs in Escherichia coli, and can be extended toward use in other microorganisms.

Separation and Characterization of Protein-DNA Complexes by EMSA and In-Gel Footprinting.

In-gel footprinting enables the precise identification of protein binding sites on the DNA after separation of free and protein-bound DNA molecules by gel electrophoresis in native conditions and subsequent digestion by the nuclease activity of the 1,10-phenanthroline-copper ion [(OP)2-Cu+] within the gel matrix. Hence, the technique combines the resolving power of protein-DNA complexes in the electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) with the precision of target site identification by chemical footprinting. This approach is particularly well suited to characterize distinct molecular assemblies in a mixture of protein-DNA complexes and to identify individual binding sites within composite operators, when the concentration-dependent occupation of binding sites, with a different affinity, results in the generation of complexes with a distinct stoichiometry and migration velocity in gel electrophoresis.

Engineering transcriptional regulation in Escherichia coli using an archaeal TetR-family transcription factor.

Synthetic biology requires well-characterized biological parts that can be combined into functional modules. One type of biological parts are transcriptional regulators and their cognate operator elements, which enable to either generate an input-specific response or are used as actuator modules. A range of regulators has already been characterized and used for orthogonal gene expression engineering, however, previous efforts have mostly focused on bacterial regulators. This work aims to design and explore the use of an archaeal TetR family regulator, FadRSa from Sulfolobus acidocaldarius, in a bacterial system, namely Escherichia coli. This is a challenging objective given the fundamental difference between the bacterial and archaeal transcription machinery and the lack of a native TetR-like FadR regulatory system in E. coli. The synthetic σ70-dependent bacterial promoter proD was used as a starting point to design hybrid bacterial/archaeal promoter/operator regions, in combination with the mKate2 fluorescent reporter enabling a readout. Four variations of proD containing FadRSa binding sites were constructed and characterized. While expressional activity of the modified promoter proD was found to be severely diminished for two of the constructs, constructs in which the binding site was introduced adjacent to the -35 promoter element still displayed sufficient basal transcriptional activity and showed up to 7-fold repression upon expression of FadRSa. Addition of acyl-CoA has been shown to disrupt FadRSa binding to the DNA in vitro. However, extracellular concentrations of up to 2 mM dodecanoate, subsequently converted to acyl-CoA by the cell, did not have a significant effect on repression in the bacterial system. This work demonstrates that archaeal transcription regulators can be used to generate actuator elements for use in E. coli, although the lack of ligand response underscores the challenge of maintaining biological function when transferring parts to a phylogenetically divergent host.

From macro to micro: a combined bioluminescence-fluorescence approach to monitor bacterial localization.

Bacterial bioluminescence is widely used to study the spatiotemporal dynamics of bacterial populations and gene expression in vivo at a population level but cannot easily be used to study bacterial activity at the level of individual cells. In this study, we describe the development of a new library of mini-Tn7-lux and lux::eyfp reporter constructs that provide a wide range of lux expression levels, and which combine the advantages of both bacterial bioluminescence and fluorescent proteins to bridge the gap between macro- and micro-scale imaging techniques. We demonstrate that a dual bioluminescence-fluorescence approach using the lux operon and eYFP can be used to monitor bacterial movement in plants both macro- and microscopically and demonstrate that Pseudomonas syringae pv phaseolicola can colonize the leaf vascular system and systemically infect leaves of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris). We also show that bacterial bioluminescence can be used to study the impact of plant immune responses on bacterial multiplication, viability and spread within plant tissues. The constructs and approach described in this study can be used to study the spatiotemporal dynamics of bacterial colonization and to link population dynamics and cellular interactions in a wide range of biological contexts.

Regulation of arginine biosynthesis, catabolism and transport in Escherichia coli.

Already very early, the study of microbial arginine biosynthesis and its regulation contributed significantly to the development of new ideas and concepts. Hence, the term "repression" was proposed by Vogel (The chemical basis of heredity, The John Hopkins Press, Baltimore, 1957) (in opposition to induction) to describe the relative decrease in acetylornithinase production in Escherichia coli cells upon arginine supplementation, whereas the term "regulon" was coined by Maas and Clark (J Mol Biol 8:365-370, 1964) for the ensemble of arginine biosynthetic genes dispersed over the E. coli chromosome but all subjected to regulation by the trans-acting argR gene product. Since then, unraveling of the molecular mechanisms controlling arginine biosynthesis, catabolism, and transport in and out the cell, have revealed moonlighting activities of enzymes and transcriptional regulators that generate unexpected interconnections between at first sight totally unrelated cellular processes, and have continued to replenish scientific knowledge and stimulated creative thinking. Furthermore, arginine is much more than just a common amino acid for protein synthesis. It may also be used as sole source of nitrogen by E. coli and a source of nitrogen, carbon and energy by many other bacteria. It is a substrate for the synthesis of polyamines, and important for the extreme acid resistance of E. coli. Furthermore, the guanidino group of arginine is well suited to engage in multiple interactions involving hydrogen bonds and ionic interactions with proteins and nucleic acids. Here, we combine major historical discoveries with current state of the art knowledge on arginine biosynthesis, catabolism and transport, and especially the regulation of these processes in E. coli, with reference to other microorganisms.

Competitive Repression of the artPIQM Operon for Arginine and Ornithine Transport by Arginine Repressor and Leucine-Responsive Regulatory Protein in Escherichia coli.

Two out of the three major uptake systems for arginine in Escherichia coli are encoded by the artJ-artPIQM gene cluster. ArtJ is the high-affinity periplasmic arginine-specific binding protein (ArgBP-I), whereas artI encodes the arginine and ornithine periplasmic binding protein (AO). Both ArtJ and ArtI are supposed to combine with the inner membrane-associated ArtQMP2 transport complex of the ATP-binding cassette-type (ABC). Transcription of artJ is repressed by arginine repressor (ArgR) and the artPIQM operon is regulated by the transcriptional regulators ArgR and Leucine-responsive regulatory protein (Lrp). Whereas repression by ArgR requires arginine as corepressor, repression of P artP by Lrp is partially counteracted by leucine, its major effector molecule. We demonstrate that binding of dimeric Lrp to the artP control region generates four complexes with a distinct migration velocity, and that leucine has an effect on both global binding affinity and cooperativity in the binding. We identify the binding sites for Lrp in the artP control region, reveal interferences in the binding of ArgR and Lrp in vitro and demonstrate that the two transcription factors act as competitive repressors in vivo, each one being a more potent regulator in the absence of the other. This competitive behavior may be explained by the partial steric overlap of their respective binding sites. Furthermore, we demonstrate ArgR binding to an unusual position in the control region of the lrp gene, downstream of the transcription initiation site. From this unusual position for an ArgR-specific operator, ArgR has little direct effect on lrp expression, but interferes with the negative leucine-sensitive autoregulation exerted by Lrp. Direct arginine and ArgR-dependent repression of lrp could be observed with a 25-bp deletion mutant, in which the ArgR binding site was artificially moved to a position immediately downstream of the lrp transcription initiation site. This finding is reminiscent of a previous observation made for the carAB operon encoding carbamoylphosphate synthase, where ArgR bound in overlap with the downstream promoter P2 does not block transcription initiated 67 bp upstream at the P1 promoter, and further supports the hypothesis that ArgR does not act as an efficient roadblock.

Transcription Regulators in Archaea: Homologies and Differences with Bacterial Regulators.

The fitness and survival of prokaryotic microorganisms depends on their ability to adequately respond to environmental changes, sudden stress conditions and metabolic shifts. An important mechanism underlying this response is the regulation of gene expression mediated by transcription factors that are responsive to small-molecule ligands or other intracellular signals. Despite constituting a distinct domain of life from bacteria and harboring a eukaryotic-like basal transcription apparatus, it is well established that archaea have similar transcription factors pointing to the existence of shared ancestral proteins and to the occurrence of inter-domain horizontal gene transfer events. However, while global structural features of bacterial and archaeal transcription factors are indeed similar, other characteristics imply that archaeal regulators have undergone independent evolution. Here, we discuss the characteristics of Lrp/AsnC, MarR, ArsR/SmtB and TrmB families of transcription factors, which are the dominant families that constitute the transcription factor repertoire in archaea. We exemplify the evolutionary expansion of these families in archaeal lineages by emphasizing homologies and differences with bacterial counterparts in terms of ligand or signal response, physiological functions and mechanistic principles of regulation. As such, we aim to define future research approaches that enable further characterization of the functions and mechanisms of archaeal transcription factors.

Diversity, versatility and complexity of bacterial gene regulation mechanisms: opportunities and drawbacks for applications in synthetic biology.

Gene expression occurs in two essential steps: transcription and translation. In bacteria, the two processes are tightly coupled in time and space, and highly regulated. Tight regulation of gene expression is crucial. It limits wasteful consumption of resources and energy, prevents accumulation of potentially growth inhibiting reaction intermediates, and sustains the fitness and potential virulence of the organism in a fluctuating, competitive and frequently stressful environment. Since the onset of studies on regulation of enzyme synthesis, numerous distinct regulatory mechanisms modulating transcription and/or translation have been discovered. Mostly, various regulatory mechanisms operating at different levels in the flow of genetic information are used in combination to control and modulate the expression of a single gene or operon. Here, we provide an extensive overview of the very diverse and versatile bacterial gene regulatory mechanisms with major emphasis on their combined occurrence, intricate intertwinement and versatility. Furthermore, we discuss the potential of well-characterized basal expression and regulatory elements in synthetic biology applications, where they may ensure orthogonal, predictable and tunable expression of (heterologous) target genes and pathways, aiming at a minimal burden for the host.

A sigma factor toolbox for orthogonal gene expression in Escherichia coli.

Synthetic genetic sensors and circuits enable programmable control over timing and conditions of gene expression and, as a result, are increasingly incorporated into the control of complex and multi-gene pathways. Size and complexity of genetic circuits are growing, but stay limited by a shortage of regulatory parts that can be used without interference. Therefore, orthogonal expression and regulation systems are needed to minimize undesired crosstalk and allow for dynamic control of separate modules. This work presents a set of orthogonal expression systems for use in Escherichia coli based on heterologous sigma factors from Bacillus subtilis that recognize specific promoter sequences. Up to four of the analyzed sigma factors can be combined to function orthogonally between each other and toward the host. Additionally, the toolbox is expanded by creating promoter libraries for three sigma factors without loss of their orthogonal nature. As this set covers a wide range of transcription initiation frequencies, it enables tuning of multiple outputs of the circuit in response to different sensory signals in an orthogonal manner. This sigma factor toolbox constitutes an interesting expansion of the synthetic biology toolbox and may contribute to the assembly of more complex synthetic genetic systems in the future.

A novel and versatile dual fluorescent reporter tool for the study of gene expression and regulation in multi- and single copy number.

To unravel intricate mechanisms of gene regulation it is imperative to work in physiologically relevant conditions and therefore preferentially in single copy constructs, which are not always easy to manipulate. Such in vivo studies are generally based on enzymatic assays, microarrays, RNA-seq, qRT-PCR, or multicopy reporter gene systems, frequently with ß-galactosidase, luciferase or a fluorescent protein as reporter. Each method has its advantages and shortcomings and may require validation. Enzyme assays are generally reliable but may be quite complex, time consuming, and require a (expensive) substrate. Microarrays and RNA-seq provide a genome wide view of gene expression but may rapidly become expensive and time consuming especially for detailed studies with large numbers of mutants, different growth conditions and multiple time points. Multicopy reporter gene systems are handy to generate numerous constructs but may not provide accurate information due to titration effects of trans-acting regulatory elements. Therefore and in spite of the existence of various reporter systems, there is still need for an efficient and user-friendly tool for detailed studies and high throughput screenings. Here we develop and validate a novel and versatile fluorescent reporter tool to study gene regulation in single copy mode that enables real-time measurement. This tool bears two independent fluorescent reporters that allow high throughput screening and standardization, and combines modern efficient cloning methods (multicopy, in vitro manipulation) with classical genetics (in vivo homologous recombination with a stable, self-transmissible episome) to generate multi- and single copy reporter systems. We validate the system with constitutive and differentially regulated promoters and show that the tool can equally be used with heterologous transcription factors. The flexibility and versatility of this dual reporter tool in combination with an easy conversion from a multicopy plasmid to a stable, single copy reporter system makes this system unique and attractive for a variety of applications. Examples are in vivo studies of DNA-binding transcription factors (single copy) or screening of promoter and RBS libraries (multicopy) for synthetic biology purposes.

Differential protein-DNA contacts for activation and repression by ArgP, a LysR-type (LTTR) transcriptional regulator in Escherichia coli.

ArgP is a LysR-type transcriptional regulator (LTTR) that operates with two effector molecules, lysine and arginine, to differentially regulate gene expression. Effector-free ArgP stimulates transcription of all investigated regulon members, except argO, whereas lysine abolishes this effect. Activation of argO, encoding an exporter for arginine and canavanine, is strictly dependent on arginine-bound ArgP. Lysine counteracts this effect and even though lysine-bound ArgP stimulates RNA polymerase recruitment at the argO promoter, the complex is non-productive. It is presently unclear what distinguishes argO from other ArgP targets and how binding of arginine and lysine translates in antagonistic effects on promoter activity. Here we generate high resolution contact maps of effector-free and effector-bound ArgP-DNA interactions and identify the sequence 5'-CTTAT as the consensus recognition motif for ArgP binding. argO is the only operator at which ArgP binding overlaps the -35 promoter element and binding of arginine results in a repositioning of the promoter proximal bound ArgP-arg subunits. This effect was mimicked by the generation of a 10bp insertion mutant (ins-10) in the argO operator that renders its activation by ArgP arginine-independent. ArgP-induced DNA bending of the argO operator by approximately 60° was found to be effector independent. An ArgP:DNA binding stoichiometry of 4:1 indicates binding of four ArgP subunits even to DNA constructs that are truncated for one binding subsite (ΔABS). These results provide insight into the molecular mechanisms of ArgP-mediated regulation and a molecular explanation for the unique arginine-dependence of argO activation that distinguishes this particular ArgP target from all others.

Ligand binding specificity of RutR, a member of the TetR family of transcription regulators in Escherichia coli.

RutR is a member of the large family of TetR transcriptional regulators in Escherichia coli. It was originally discovered as the regulator of the rutABCDEFG operon encoding a novel pathway for pyrimidine utilization, but its highest affinity target is the control region of the carAB operon, encoding carbamoylphosphate synthase. Unlike most other TetR-like regulators, RutR exerts both positive and negative effects on promoter activity. Furthermore, RutR exhibits a very narrow ligand binding specificity, unlike the broad effector specificity that characterizes some of the well-studied multidrug resistance regulators of the family. Here we focus on ligand binding and ligand specificity of RutR. We construct single alanine substitution mutants of amino acid residues of the ligand-binding pocket, study their effect on in vitro DNA binding in absence and presence of potential ligands, and analyse their effect on positive regulation of the carP1 promoter and negative autoregulation in vivo. Although RutR structures have been determined previously, they were deposited in the Protein Data Bank without accompanying publications. All of them have uracil bound in the effector-binding site, representing the inactive form of the regulator. We determined the crystal structure of an unliganded mutant RutR protein and provide a structural basis for the use of uracil as sole effector molecule and the exclusion of the very similar thymine from the ligand-binding pocket.

The protein-DNA contacts in RutR•carAB operator complexes.

Pyrimidine-specific regulation of the upstream carP1 promoter of the carbamoylphosphate synthase operon of Escherichia coli requires numerous trans-acting factors: the allosteric transcription regulator RutR, the nucleoid-associated protein integration host factor, and the trigger enzymes aminopeptidase A and PyrH (UMP-kinase). RutR, a TetR family member, binds far upstream of carP1. Here, we establish a high-resolution contact map of RutR•carP1 complexes for backbone and base-specific contacts, analyze DNA bending, determine the DNA sequence specificity of RutR binding by saturation mutagenesis, demonstrate that uracil but not thymine is the physiologically relevant ligand that inhibits the DNA binding capacity of RutR and build a model of the RutR·operator DNA complex based on the crystal structures of RutR and of the DNA-bound family member QacR. Finally, we test the validity of this model with site-directed mutagenesis of the helix-turn-helix DNA binding motif and in vitro binding studies with the cognate purified mutant RutR proteins.