Outcomes and costs with the introduction of robotic-assisted thoracic surgery in public hospitals.

Robotic-assisted thoracic surgery (RATS) is an effective treatment of non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) but the effects of its implementation in university hospital networks has not been described. We analyzed the early clinical outcomes, estimated costs, and revenues associated with three robotic systems implemented in the Paris Public Hospital network. A retrospective study included patients who underwent RATS for NSCLC in 2019 and 2020. Ninety-day morbidity, mortality, hospital costs, and hospital revenues were described. Economic analyses were conducted either from the hospital center or from the French health insurance system perspectives. Cost drivers were tested using univariate and multivariable analyses. Sensitivity analyses were performed to assess uncertainty over in-hospital length of stay (LOS), number of robotic surgeries per year, investment cost, operating room occupancy time, maintenance cost, and commercial discount. The study included 188 patients (65.8 ± 9.3 years; Charlson 4.1 ± 1.4; stage I 76.6%). Median in-hospital LOS was 6 days [5-9.5], 90-day mortality was 1.6%. Mean hospital expenses and revenues were €12,732 ± 4914 and €11,983 ± 5708 per patient, respectively. In multivariable analysis, factors associated with hospital costs were body mass index, DLCO, major complications, and transfer to intensive care unit. Sensitivity analyses showed that in-hospital LOS (€11,802-€15,010) and commercial discounts on the list price (€11,458-€12,732) had an important impact on costs. During the first 2 years following the installation of three robotic systems in Paris Public Hospitals, the clinical outcomes of RATS for NSCLC have been satisfactory. Without commercial discount, hospital expenses would have exceeded hospital revenues.Clinical registration number CNIL, N°2221601, CERC-SFCTCV-2021-07-20-Num17_MOPI_robolution.

[Robots set up in the operating theater]. / Les robots s'installent au bloc opératoire.

"Robots set up in the operating theater. The patient's benefit after a minimally invasive approach stimulated the robotic approach of abdominal and thoracic surgical procedures. Although much more expensive, the robots improve the vision of the operating field, the precision of the gestures with a faster training course for the surgeon who operates more comfortably. Surgeons eager for technological progress quickly adopted this technique in urology and gynecology and then in thoracic and digestive procedures. In France, the support for this innovation by academic and medical institutions is limited by several factors including the supremacy of Intuitive which imposes its prices, the absence of scientifically proven superiority, the absence of surveys under the responsibility of scientific societies and the lack of criteria concerning the surgeon training."

"Les robots s'installent au bloc opératoire. Les bénéfices de l'approche mini-invasive abdominale et thoracique ont stimulé l'approche robotique. Bien que beaucoup plus coûteux, les robots améliorent la vision du champ opératoire, la précision des gestes avec un apprentissage plus rapide pour le chirurgien qui opère plus confortablement. Les chirurgiens avides de progrès technologiques s'emparent rapidement de cette technique en urologie et en gynécologie puis en thoracique et en digestif. Le monopole imposé par la société Intuitive qui impose ses prix, l'absence de supériorité démontrée scientifiquement, de registres sous la responsabilité de sociétés scientifiques et de critères concernant la formation des chirurgiens à cette nouvelle technique ne favorise pas le soutien des institutions françaises pour accompagner cette innovation."

Use of 3-dimensional computed tomography for planning a complex sleeve bronchoplasty with total parenchyma-sparing resection of a carcinoid tumour in the right main bronchus.

Bronchoplasty is frequently required for radical resection of central typical carcinoid tumours. As sleeve bronchoplasty can be a complex procedure, an accurate evaluation of the tumour location is mandatory. Although the endobronchial part of the tumour can be easily evaluated by bronchoscopy, the exo-bronchial part is difficult to analyse with a standard computed tomography (CT) scan. A three-dimensional (3D) CT scan could be used to identify this exo-bronchial component of the tumour when planning a reconstruction. Herein, we present a case of a 59-year-old woman with a typical central carcinoid tumour of the right main bronchus. After 3D modelling, we successfully performed a total parenchyma-sparing resection with an intermedius bronchus reimplantation into the carina associated with the right upper bronchus anastomosis in the lateral trachea. The follow-up was uneventful. An endoscopy at 3 months showed excellent results.