Exome sequencing in undiagnosed congenital myopathy reveals new genes and refines genes-phenotypes correlations.

BACKGROUND: Congenital myopathies are severe genetic diseases with a strong impact on patient autonomy and often on survival. A large number of patients do not have a genetic diagnosis, precluding genetic counseling and appropriate clinical management. Our objective was to find novel pathogenic variants and genes associated with congenital myopathies and to decrease diagnostic odysseys and dead-end. METHODS: To identify pathogenic variants and genes implicated in congenital myopathies, we established and conducted the MYOCAPTURE project from 2009 to 2018 to perform exome sequencing in a large cohort of 310 families partially excluded for the main known genes. RESULTS: Pathogenic variants were identified in 156 families (50%), among which 123 families (40%) had a conclusive diagnosis. Only 44 (36%) of the resolved cases were linked to a known myopathy gene with the corresponding phenotype, while 55 (44%) were linked to pathogenic variants in a known myopathy gene with atypical signs, highlighting that most genetic diagnosis could not be anticipated based on clinical-histological assessments in this cohort. An important phenotypic and genetic heterogeneity was observed for the different genes and for the different congenital myopathy subtypes, respectively. In addition, we identified 14 new myopathy genes not previously associated with muscle diseases (20% of all diagnosed cases) that we previously reported in the literature, revealing novel pathomechanisms and potential therapeutic targets. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, this approach illustrates the importance of massive parallel gene sequencing as a comprehensive tool for establishing a molecular diagnosis for families with congenital myopathies. It also emphasizes the contribution of clinical data, histological findings on muscle biopsies, and the availability of DNA samples from additional family members to the diagnostic success rate. This study facilitated and accelerated the genetic diagnosis of congenital myopathies, improved health care for several patients, and opened novel perspectives for either repurposing of existing molecules or the development of novel treatments.

Phenotype variability and natural history of X-linked myopathy with excessive autophagy.

OBJECTIVE: X-linked myopathy with excessive autophagy (XMEA) linked to the VMA21 gene leads to autophagy failure with progressive vacuolation and atrophy of skeletal muscles. Current knowledge of this rare disease is limited. Our objective was to define the clinical, radiological, and natural history of XMEA. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective study collecting clinical, genetic, muscle imaging, and biopsy data of XMEA patients followed in France and reviewed the literature for additional cases. RESULTS: Eighteen males had genetically confirmed XMEA in France, carrying four different VMA21 variants. Mean age at disease onset was 9.4 ± 9.9 (range 1-40) years. In 14/18 patients (77.8%), onset occurred during childhood (< 15 years); however in four patients, the disease started in adulthood. Patients had anterior and medial compartment thigh muscle weakness, distal contractures (56.3%), elevated CK levels (1287.9 ± 757.8 U/l) and autophagic vacuoles with sarcolemmal features on muscle histopathology. Muscle MRI (n = 10) showed a characteristic pattern of lower limb muscle involvement. In 11 patients, outcome measures were available for an average follow-up period of 10.6 ± 9.8 years and six of them show disease progression. Mean change of functional outcomes was 0.5 ± 1.2 points for Brooke and 2.2 ± 2.5 points for Vignos score, 7/16 patients (43.8%) needed a walking aid and 3/16 (18.8%) were wheelchair-bound (median age of 40 years old, range 39-48). The variant c.164-7 T > G was associated with a later onset of symptoms. Respiratory insufficiency was common (57.1%) but cardiac involvement rare (12.5%). INTERPRETATION: XMEA has variable age of onset, but a characteristic clinical, histopathological, and muscle imaging presentation, guiding the diagnosis. Although slowly, motor disability progresses with time, and relevant genotype-phenotype correlations will help design future clinical trials.

Digenic inheritance involving a muscle-specific protein kinase and the giant titin protein causes a skeletal muscle myopathy.

In digenic inheritance, pathogenic variants in two genes must be inherited together to cause disease. Only very few examples of digenic inheritance have been described in the neuromuscular disease field. Here we show that predicted deleterious variants in SRPK3, encoding the X-linked serine/argenine protein kinase 3, lead to a progressive early onset skeletal muscle myopathy only when in combination with heterozygous variants in the TTN gene. The co-occurrence of predicted deleterious SRPK3/TTN variants was not seen among 76,702 healthy male individuals, and statistical modeling strongly supported digenic inheritance as the best-fitting model. Furthermore, double-mutant zebrafish (srpk3-/-; ttn.1+/-) replicated the myopathic phenotype and showed myofibrillar disorganization. Transcriptome data suggest that the interaction of srpk3 and ttn.1 in zebrafish occurs at a post-transcriptional level. We propose that digenic inheritance of deleterious changes impacting both the protein kinase SRPK3 and the giant muscle protein titin causes a skeletal myopathy and might serve as a model for other genetic diseases.

Objective Evaluation of Clinical Actionability for Genes Involved in Myopathies: 63 Genes with a Medical Value for Patient Care.

The implementation of high-throughput diagnostic sequencing has led to the generation of large amounts of mutational data, making their interpretation more complex and responsible for long delays. It has been important to prioritize certain analyses, particularly those of "actionable" genes in diagnostic situations, involving specific treatment and/or management. In our project, we carried out an objective assessment of the clinical actionability of genes involved in myopathies, for which only few data obtained methodologically exist to date. Using the ClinGen Actionability criteria, we scored the clinical actionability of all 199 genes implicated in myopathies published by FILNEMUS for the "National French consensus on gene Lists for the diagnosis of myopathies using next generation sequencing". We objectified that 63 myopathy genes were actionable with the currently available data. Among the 36 myopathy genes with the highest actionability scores, only 8 had been scored to date by ClinGen. The data obtained through these methodological tools are an important resource for strategic choices in diagnostic approaches and the management of genetic myopathies. The clinical actionability of genes has to be considered as an evolving concept, in relation to progresses in disease knowledge and therapeutic approaches.

Severe ACTA1-related nemaline myopathy: intranuclear rods, cytoplasmic bodies, and enlarged perinuclear space as characteristic pathological features on muscle biopsies.

Nemaline myopathy (NM) is a muscle disorder with broad clinical and genetic heterogeneity. The clinical presentation of affected individuals ranges from severe perinatal muscle weakness to milder childhood-onset forms, and the disease course and prognosis depends on the gene and mutation type. To date, 14 causative genes have been identified, and ACTA1 accounts for more than half of the severe NM cases. ACTA1 encodes α-actin, one of the principal components of the contractile units in skeletal muscle. We established a homogenous cohort of ten unreported families with severe NM, and we provide clinical, genetic, histological, and ultrastructural data. The patients manifested antenatal or neonatal muscle weakness requiring permanent respiratory assistance, and most deceased within the first months of life. DNA sequencing identified known or novel ACTA1 mutations in all. Morphological analyses of the muscle biopsy specimens showed characteristic features of NM histopathology including cytoplasmic and intranuclear rods, cytoplasmic bodies, and major myofibrillar disorganization. We also detected structural anomalies of the perinuclear space, emphasizing a physiological contribution of skeletal muscle α-actin to nuclear shape. In-depth investigations of the nuclei confirmed an abnormal localization of lamin A/C, Nesprin-1, and Nesprin-2, forming the main constituents of the nuclear lamina and the LINC complex and ensuring nuclear envelope integrity. To validate the relevance of our findings, we examined muscle samples from three previously reported ACTA1 cases, and we identified the same set of structural aberrations. Moreover, we measured an increased expression of cardiac α-actin in the muscle samples from the patients with longer lifespan, indicating a potential compensatory effect. Overall, this study expands the genetic and morphological spectrum of severe ACTA1-related nemaline myopathy, improves molecular diagnosis, highlights the enlargement of the perinuclear space as an ultrastructural hallmark, and indicates a potential genotype/phenotype correlation.

Phenotypic spectrum and genomics of undiagnosed arthrogryposis multiplex congenita.

BACKGROUND: Arthrogryposis multiplex congenita (AMC) is characterised by congenital joint contractures in two or more body areas. AMC exhibits wide phenotypic and genetic heterogeneity. Our goals were to improve the genetic diagnosis rates of AMC, to evaluate the added value of whole exome sequencing (WES) compared with targeted exome sequencing (TES) and to identify new genes in 315 unrelated undiagnosed AMC families. METHODS: Several genomic approaches were used including genetic mapping of disease loci in multiplex or consanguineous families, TES then WES. Sanger sequencing was performed to identify or validate variants. RESULTS: We achieved disease gene identification in 52.7% of AMC index patients including nine recently identified genes (CNTNAP1, MAGEL2, ADGRG6, ADCY6, GLDN, LGI4, LMOD3, UNC50 and SCN1A). Moreover, we identified pathogenic variants in ASXL3 and STAC3 expanding the phenotypes associated with these genes. The most frequent cause of AMC was a primary involvement of skeletal muscle (40%) followed by brain (22%). The most frequent mode of inheritance is autosomal recessive (66.3% of patients). In sporadic patients born to non-consanguineous parents (n=60), de novo dominant autosomal or X linked variants were observed in 30 of them (50%). CONCLUSION: New genes recently identified in AMC represent 21% of causing genes in our cohort. A high proportion of de novo variants were observed indicating that this mechanism plays a prominent part in this developmental disease. Our data showed the added value of WES when compared with TES due to the larger clinical spectrum of some disease genes than initially described and the identification of novel genes.

A recurrent RYR1 mutation associated with early-onset hypotonia and benign disease course.

The ryanodine receptor RyR1 is the main sarcoplasmic reticulum Ca2+ channel in skeletal muscle and acts as a connecting link between electrical stimulation and Ca2+-dependent muscle contraction. Abnormal RyR1 activity compromises normal muscle function and results in various human disorders including malignant hyperthermia, central core disease, and centronuclear myopathy. However, RYR1 is one of the largest genes of the human genome and accumulates numerous missense variants of uncertain significance (VUS), precluding an efficient molecular diagnosis for many patients and families. Here we describe a recurrent RYR1 mutation previously classified as VUS, and we provide clinical, histological, and genetic data supporting its pathogenicity. The heterozygous c.12083C>T (p.Ser4028Leu) mutation was found in thirteen patients from nine unrelated congenital myopathy families with consistent clinical presentation, and either segregated with the disease in the dominant families or occurred de novo. The affected individuals essentially manifested neonatal or infancy-onset hypotonia, delayed motor milestones, and a benign disease course differing from classical RYR1-related muscle disorders. Muscle biopsies showed unspecific histological and ultrastructural findings, while RYR1-typical cores and internal nuclei were seen only in single patients. In conclusion, our data evidence the causality of the RYR1 c.12083C>T (p.Ser4028Leu) mutation in the development of an atypical congenital myopathy with gradually improving motor function over the first decades of life, and may direct molecular diagnosis for patients with comparable clinical presentation and unspecific histopathological features on the muscle biopsy.

An Integrated Clinical-Biological Approach to Identify Interindividual Variability and Atypical Phenotype-Genotype Correlations in Myopathies: Experience on A Cohort of 156 Families.

Diagnosis of myopathies is challenged by the high genetic heterogeneity and clinical overlap of the various etiologies. We previously reported a Next-Generation Sequencing strategy to identify genetic etiology in patients with undiagnosed Limb-Girdle Muscular Dystrophies, Congenital Myopathies, Congenital Muscular Dystrophies, Distal Myopathies, Myofibrillar Myopathies, and hyperCKemia or effort intolerance, using a large gene panel including genes classically associated with other entry diagnostic categories. In this study, we report the comprehensive clinical-biological strategy used to interpret NGS data in a cohort of 156 pediatric and adult patients, that included Copy Number Variants search, variants filtering and interpretation according to ACMG guidelines, segregation studies, deep phenotyping of patients and relatives, transcripts and protein studies, and multidisciplinary meetings. Genetic etiology was identified in 74 patients, a diagnostic yield (47.4%) similar to previous studies. We identified 18 patients (10%) with causative variants in different genes (ACTA1, RYR1, NEB, TTN, TRIP4, CACNA1S, FLNC, TNNT1, and PAPBN1) that resulted in milder and/or atypical phenotypes, with high intrafamilial variability in some cases. Mild phenotypes could mostly be explained by a less deleterious effect of variants on the protein. Detection of inter-individual variability and atypical phenotype-genotype associations is essential for precision medicine, patient care, and to progress in the understanding of the molecular mechanisms of myopathies.

Selective loss of a LAP1 isoform causes a muscle-specific nuclear envelopathy.

The nuclear envelope (NE) separates the nucleus from the cytoplasm in all eukaryotic cells. A disruption of the NE structure compromises normal gene regulation and leads to severe human disorders collectively classified as nuclear envelopathies and affecting skeletal muscle, heart, brain, skin, and bones. The ubiquitous NE component LAP1B is encoded by TOR1AIP1, and the use of an alternative start codon gives rise to the shorter LAP1C isoform. TOR1AIP1 mutations have been identified in patients with diverging clinical presentations such as muscular dystrophy, progressive dystonia with cerebellar atrophy, and a severe multi-systemic disorder, but the correlation between the mutational effect and the clinical spectrum remains to be determined. Here, we describe a novel TOR1AIP1 patient manifesting childhood-onset muscle weakness and contractures, and we provide clinical, histological, ultrastructural, and genetic data. We demonstrate that the identified TOR1AIP1 frameshift mutation leads to the selective loss of the LAP1B isoform, while the expression of LAP1C was preserved. Through comparative review of all previously reported TOR1AIP1 cases, we delineate a genotype/phenotype correlation and conclude that LAP1B-specific mutations cause a progressive skeletal muscle phenotype, while mutations involving a loss of both LAP1B and LAP1C isoforms induce a syndromic disorder affecting skeletal muscle, brain, eyes, ear, skin, and bones.

Glycogenin-1 deficiency mimicking limb-girdle muscular dystrophy.

Glycogen storage disease type XV (GSD XV) is a recently described muscle glycogenosis due to glycogenin-1 (GYG1) deficiency characterized by the presence of polyglucosan bodies on muscle biopsy (Polyglucosan body myopathy-2, PGBM2). Here we describe a 44 year-old man with limb-girdle muscle weakness mimicking a limb-girdle muscular dystrophy (LGMD), and early onset exertional myalgia. Neurologic examination revealed a waddling gait with hyperlordosis, bilateral asymmetric scapular winging, mild asymmetric deltoid and biceps brachii weakness, and pelvic-girdle weakness involving the gluteal muscles and, to a lesser extent, the quadriceps. Serum creatine kinase levels were slightly elevated. Electrophysiological examination showed a myopathic pattern. There was no cardiac or respiratory involvement. Whole-body muscle MRI revealed atrophy and fat replacement of the tongue, biceps brachii, pelvic girdle and erector spinae. A deltoid muscle biopsy showed the presence of PAS-positive inclusions that remained non-digested with alpha-amylase treatment. Electron microscopy studies confirmed the presence of polyglucosan bodies. A diagnostic gene panel designed by the Genetic Diagnosis Laboratory of Strasbourg University Hospital (France) for 210 muscular disorders genes disclosed two heterozygous, pathogenic GYG1 gene mutations (c.304G>C;p.(Asp102His) + c.164_165del). Considering the clinical heterogeneity found in the previously described 38 GYG-1 deficient patients, we suggest that GYG1 should be systematically included in targeted NGS gene panels for LGMDs, distal myopathies, and metabolic myopathies.

Tubular aggregate myopathy and Stormorken syndrome: Mutation spectrum and genotype/phenotype correlation.

Calcium (Ca2+ ) acts as a ubiquitous second messenger, and normal cell and tissue physiology strictly depends on the precise regulation of Ca2+ entry, storage, and release. Store-operated Ca2+ entry (SOCE) is a major mechanism controlling extracellular Ca2+ entry, and mainly relies on the accurate interplay between the Ca2+ sensor STIM1 and the Ca2+ channel ORAI1. Mutations in STIM1 or ORAI1 result in abnormal Ca2+ homeostasis and are associated with severe human disorders. Recessive loss-of-function mutations impair SOCE and cause combined immunodeficiency, while dominant gain-of-function mutations induce excessive extracellular Ca2+ entry and cause tubular aggregate myopathy (TAM) and Stormorken syndrome (STRMK). TAM and STRMK are spectra of the same multisystemic disease characterized by muscle weakness, miosis, thrombocytopenia, hyposplenism, ichthyosis, dyslexia, and short stature. To date, 42 TAM/STRMK families have been described, and here we report five additional families for which we provide clinical, histological, ultrastructural, and genetic data. In this study, we list and review all new and previously reported STIM1 and ORAI1 cases, discuss the pathomechanisms of the mutations based on the known functions and the protein structure of STIM1 and ORAI1, draw a genotype/phenotype correlation, and delineate an efficient screening strategy for the molecular diagnosis of TAM/STRMK.

Clinical, histological, and genetic characterization of PYROXD1-related myopathy.

Recessive mutations in PYROXD1, encoding an oxidoreductase, were recently reported in families with congenital myopathy or limb-girdle muscular dystrophy. Here we describe three novel PYROXD1 families at the clinical, histological, and genetic level. Histological analyses on muscle biopsies from all families revealed fiber size variability, endomysial fibrosis, and muscle fibers with multiple internal nuclei and cores. Further characterization of the structural muscle defects uncovered aggregations of myofibrillar proteins, and provided evidence for enhanced oxidative stress. Sequencing identified homozygous or compound heterozygous PYROXD1 mutations including the first deep intronic mutation reinforcing a cryptic donor splice site and resulting in mRNA instability through exonisation of an intronic segment. Overall, this work expands the PYROXD1 mutation spectrum, defines and specifies the histopathological hallmarks of the disorder, and indicates that oxidative stress contributes to the pathomechanism. Comparison of all new and published cases uncovered a genotype/phenotype correlation with a more severe and early-onset phenotypic presentation of patients harboring splice mutations resulting in reduced PYROXD1 protein levels compared with patients carrying missense mutations.

Phosphoglycerate kinase deficiency: A nationwide multicenter retrospective study.

Phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) deficiency is a rare X-linked metabolic disorder caused by mutations in the PGK1 gene. Patients usually develop various combinations of nonspherocytic hemolytic anemia (NSHA), myopathy, and central nervous system disorders. In this national multicenter observational retrospective study, we recorded all known French patients with PGK deficiency, and 3 unrelated patients were identified. Case 1 was a 32-year-old patient with severe chronic axonal sensorimotor polyneuropathy resembling Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT) disease, mental retardation, microcephaly, ophthalmoplegia, pes cavus, and the new c.323G > A PGK1 hemizygous mutation. Case 2 was a 71-year-old patient with recurrent exertional rhabdomyolysis, and a c.943G > A PGK1 hemizygous mutation. Case 3 was a 48-year-old patient with NSHA, retinitis pigmentosa, mental retardation, seizures, stroke, parkinsonism, and a c.491A > T PGK1 hemizygous mutation. This study confirms that PGK deficiency is an extremely rare disorder with a wide phenotypic spectrum, and demonstrates for the first time that PGK deficiency may affect the peripheral nervous system and present as a CMT-like disorder.

X-linked myotubular myopathy: A prospective international natural history study.

OBJECTIVES: Because X-linked myotubular myopathy (XLMTM) is a rare neuromuscular disease caused by mutations in the MTM1 gene with a large phenotypic heterogeneity, to ensure clinical trial readiness, it was mandatory to better quantify disease burden and determine best outcome measures. METHODS: We designed an international prospective and longitudinal natural history study in patients with XLMTM and assessed muscle strength and motor and respiratory functions over the first year of follow-up. The humoral immunity against adeno-associated virus serotype 8 was also monitored. RESULTS: Forty-five male patients aged 3.5 months to 56.8 years were enrolled between May 2014 and May 2017. Thirteen patients had a mild phenotype (no ventilation support), 7 had an intermediate phenotype (ventilation support less than 12 hours a day), and 25 had a severe phenotype (ventilation support 12 or more hours a day). Most strength and motor function assessments could be performed even in very weak patients. Motor Function Measure 32 total score, grip and pinch strengths, and forced vital capacity, forced expiratory volume in the first second of exhalation, and peak cough flow measures discriminated the 3 groups of patients. Disease history revealed motor milestone loss in several patients. Longitudinal data on 37 patients showed that the Motor Function Measure 32 total score significantly decreased by 2%. Of the 38 patients evaluated, anti-adeno-associated virus type 8 neutralizing activity was detected in 26% with 2 patients having an inhibitory titer >1:10. CONCLUSIONS: Our data confirm that XLMTM is slowly progressive for male survivors regardless of their phenotype and provide outcome validation and natural history data that can support clinical development in this population. CLINICALTRIALSGOV IDENTIFIER: NCT02057705.

A National French consensus on gene lists for the diagnosis of myopathies using next-generation sequencing.

Next-generation sequencing (NGS) gene-panel-based analyses constitute diagnosis strategies which are adapted to the genetic heterogeneity within the field of myopathies, including more than 200 implicated genes to date. Nonetheless, important inter-laboratory diversity of gene panels exists at national and international levels, complicating the exchange of data and the visibility of the diagnostic offers available for referring neurologists. To address this issue, we here describe the initiative of the genetic diagnosis section of the French National Network for Rare Neuromuscular Diseases (Filière Nationale des Maladies Rares Neuromusculaires, FILNEMUS), which led to set up a consensual nationwide diagnostic strategy among the nine French genetic diagnosis laboratories using NGS for myopathies. The strategy is based on the determination of 13 clinical and/or histological entry-diagnosis groups, and consists for each group either in a successive NGS analysis of a "core gene list" followed in case of a negative result by the analysis of an "exhaustive gene list", or in the NGS analysis of a "unique exhaustive gene list".

A Roma founder BIN1 mutation causes a novel phenotype of centronuclear myopathy with rigid spine.

OBJECTIVE: To describe a large series of BIN1 patients, in which a novel founder mutation in the Roma population of southern Spain has been identified. METHODS: Patients diagnosed with centronuclear myopathy (CNM) at 5 major reference centers for neuromuscular disease in Spain (n = 53) were screened for BIN1 mutations. Clinical, histologic, radiologic, and genetic features were analyzed. RESULTS: Eighteen patients from 13 families carried the p.Arg234Cys variant; 16 of them were homozygous for it and 2 had compound heterozygous p.Arg234Cys/p.Arg145Cys mutations. Both BIN1 variants have only been identified in Roma, causing 100% of CNM in this ethnic group in our cohort. The haplotype analysis confirmed all families are related. In addition to clinical features typical of CNM, such as proximal limb weakness and ophthalmoplegia, most patients in our cohort presented with prominent axial weakness, often associated with rigid spine. Severe fat replacement of paravertebral muscles was demonstrated by muscle imaging. This phenotype seems to be specific to the p.Arg234Cys mutation, not reported in other BIN1 mutations. Extreme clinical variability was observed in the 2 compound heterozygous patients for the p.Arg234Cys/p.Arg145Cys mutations, from a congenital onset with catastrophic outcome to a late-onset disease. Screening of European Roma controls (n = 758) for the p.Arg234Cys variant identified a carrier frequency of 3.5% among the Spanish Roma. CONCLUSION: We have identified a BIN1 founder Roma mutation associated with a highly specific phenotype, which is, from the present cohort, the main cause of CNM in Spain.

Primary carnitine deficiency in a 57-year-old patient with recurrent exertional rhabdomyolysis.

Rhabdomyolysis is an emergency requiring rapid diagnosis and suitable aetiological treatment. We describe the case of a 57-year-old man with recurrent exertional rhabdomyolysis who was diagnosed with systemic primary carnitine deficiency (SPCD). Clinical examination was normal, creatine kinase levels were elevated, plasma free carnitine concentration was mildly decreased, muscle biopsy demonstrated lipid accumulation, carnitine uptake in cultured fibroblasts was decreased and genetic analysis identified a homozygous pathologic c.1181_1183del in the SLC22A5 gene. Rhabdomyolysis did not recur after treatment with oral L-carnitine was introduced. SPCD is a rare autosomal recessive disorder of carnitine transportation usually manifesting as an infantile (hepatic) or a childhood myopathic (cardiac) condition and rarely affecting adults. Our case indicates that SPCD should be considered in the aetiological evaluation of adult patients with recurrent exertional rhabdomyolysis, even in the absence of myopathy and cardiomyopathy.