Value of cytology in the intraoperative assessment of ovarian tumors: a review of 402 cases and comparison with frozen section diagnosis.

BACKGROUND: Intraoperative pathological assessment is frequently requested in patients with suspected ovarian neoplasia so that optimal surgical management can be performed. In this study the accuracy of intraoperative cytology has been assessed and the results compared with frozen section diagnosis. METHODS: The study comprised 402 ovarian tumors that were submitted for intraoperative assessment in which both cytology preparations, usually scrape smears, and conventional frozen sections were examined. Each technique was evaluated independently, although the diagnosis transmitted to the surgeon was based upon the combination of the clinical, macroscopic, histological, and cytological information. The results were compared with the final pathological diagnosis in each case and cases with discordant diagnoses were reviewed. RESULTS: There were 226 benign lesions, 35 borderline epithelial neoplasms, and 141 malignant tumors according to the final pathological diagnosis. All benign lesions were accurately categorized using both frozen section and cytology. Thirty (86%) of the borderline tumors and 137 (97%) of the malignant tumors were accurately identified on frozen section, whereas the corresponding results for cytology were 23 (66%) and 131 (93%), respectively. There were no false-positive diagnoses with either technique and the overall accuracy was 97.8%. Cytological evaluation provided better morphologic detail, permitted wider tumor sampling, and directed appropriate ancillary investigations in some cases. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, frozen section was more accurate than smear preparations in this series. However, cytology has a complementary role in the intraoperative assessment of ovarian neoplasia and provides a more specific diagnosis in some cases.

Comparison of proliferation indices in primary adult-type granulosa cell tumors of the ovary and their corresponding metastases: an analysis of 14 cases.

Adult-type granulosa cell tumors (GCTs) of the ovary are generally low-grade malignancies, but late metastases are relatively common. Limited data suggest that recurrent GCTs may exhibit altered morphology and/or biologic behavior, but few studies have directly compared primary and recurrent tumors in individual patients. Fourteen GCTs in which histologic material was available from both the primary tumor and one or more metastases were reviewed, and the mitotic index (MI) and Ki-67 labelling index (KI) were evaluated using carefully specified methodology. The findings were also correlated with the time interval to tumor recurrence. The median interval to first recurrence was 6.6 years (range: 2.2 to 12.2 yr). There were only minor differences in tumor morphology between the primary and metastatic GCTs. None of the cases exhibited high-grade (sarcomatoid) transformation. There was a wide range in MI and KI in the GCTs and no consistent correlation was seen between these indices in the paired primary and recurrent neoplasms. There was also no association between the MI and the KI and the time interval to metastasis. In conclusion, metastatic GCTs generally maintain their morphologic features even after multiple recurrences over many years. Cellular proliferation in GCT is variable, and there is no uniform alteration in proliferation indices between paired primary and metastatic lesions. Therefore, data derived from the analysis of primary GCT may not always be applicable to recurrent tumors. These findings may have implications for management including the potential response of GCT to adjuvant therapies.

Intraoperative assessment of clear cell carcinoma of the ovary.

Frozen section is a reliable technique in gynecologic pathology and is widely used to guide intraoperative management in patients presenting with ovarian masses. However, there are limited data regarding the diagnostic accuracy of frozen section in specific subtypes of ovarian neoplasia. Our impression that primary clear cell carcinoma (CCC) causes disproportionate diagnostic difficulty led us to review the intraoperative and final histopathologic reports from a consecutive series of 44 CCC that were subject to frozen-section assessment and to compare the results with a similar number of primary serous and endometrioid carcinomas. The original intraoperative slides from those CCC with discordant diagnoses were also reviewed. Review of the diagnostic reports showed that CCC was less frequently specifically identified than serous or endometrioid carcinomas on frozen section (44% cases compared with 55% and 65%, respectively), although the differences were not statistically significant. Difficulties in distinguishing primary ovarian carcinoma from tumors metastatic to the ovary occurred in a minority of cases of all histologic subtypes, but was slightly more frequent in CCC. Two CCC were misdiagnosed as borderline epithelial tumors and 1 case as a dysgerminoma. Review of the frozen-section slides from the CCC with discrepant intraoperative diagnoses showed features suggestive or indicative of the correct diagnosis in 7 (39%) of 18 cases.

Intraoperative assessment of ovarian tumors: a 5-year review with assessment of discrepant diagnostic cases.

Frozen section is often requested in the intraoperative assessment of patients, presenting with ovarian masses, to provide guidance for appropriate surgical management. To assess the accuracy of frozen section and identify causes of diagnostic error, we reviewed 914 consecutive ovarian frozen sections performed over a 5-year period in 2 laboratories; one of which provides a general surgical pathology service and, the other, a specialist gynecologic pathology service. Cases, in which there were significant diagnostic discrepancies between the intraoperative and the final histological diagnoses, were reviewed. The series included 552 benign lesions (60.4%), 96 borderline (atypical proliferating) epithelial tumors (10.5%), and 266 malignancies (29.1%). The overall accuracy of frozen section diagnosis was 95.3%. There were 43 cases with diagnostic discrepancy; 20 (3.8% cases) of which were reported in the specialist laboratory and 23 (5.9% cases) in the general laboratory. Underdiagnosis of tumor type accounted for 32 of 43 discrepant cases and was most frequent in borderline mucinous tumors. The most common cause of overdiagnosis was the misinterpretation of serous cystadenofibroma as borderline serous tumor. Slide review of the 41 assessable cases indicated that sampling error, pathologist misinterpretation, and suboptimal slide preparations contributed to misdiagnoses in 17, 23, and 9 tumors, respectively (in 9 cases, 2 factors were contributory), whereas no specific error was identified in the remaining case. Technical factors and pathologist misinterpretation were more common in the general pathology laboratory. This study confirms that ovarian frozen section is a generally reliable technique, but there are problematic areas, particularly involving the assessment of borderline tumors.

Accuracy of frozen section in distinguishing primary ovarian neoplasia from tumors metastatic to the ovary.

Frozen section is widely used in the intra-operative assessment of patients with ovarian tumors. The diagnosis of malignancy is usually straightforward but in some cases it may be difficult to distinguish whether tumors are of ovarian origin or represent matastases from other sites. Recently, Seidman and colleagues presented a simple algorithm based on tumor size and unilateral versus bilateral involvement to aid in intra-operative assessment of ovarian mucinous neoplasms. In this study we have reviewed the accuracy of frozen section in distinguishing primary ovarian malignancies from tumors metastatic to the ovaries encountered in two hospitals over a 5-year period. The algorithm was also applied to our cases retrospectively irrespective of histological type. Nine hundred fourteen ovarian frozen sections were performed in the study period including 266 cases with a final diagnosis of malignancy. Thirty-seven malignancies (13.9%) were of metastatic origin (exclusing one lymphoma), 21 of which (58.8%) were correctly identified on frozen section. In 5 additional cases metastatic origin was included in the differential diagnosis while a primary ovarian tumor was favored un 11 cases (29.7%). Application of the algorithm to the metastatic tumors led to correct classification in 26/33 (78.8%) assessable cases. Conversely, 195/228 primary ovarian malignancies were correctly identified intra-operatively but the possibility of extra-ovarian malignancy was considered or not excluded in 33 cases (14.5%). Application of the algorithm to the latter problematic primary ovarian tumors overall was not helpful in distinguishing primary or metastatic origin. However if only low-grade primary adenocarcinomas were considered then 10/12 assessable cases were correctly assigned. In conclusion frozen section is only moderately successful in distinguishing primary ovarian malignancies fron tumors metastatic to the ovaries. The simple algorithm proposed by Seidman and colleagues for assessment of ovarian mucinous tumors is helpful and can be applied to low-grade adenocarcinomas of other histological types.

Superficial cervico-vaginal myofibroblastoma: a report of five cases.

AIMS: To describe the pathological and immunohistochemical features of five cases of superficial cervico-vaginal myofibroblastoma (SCVM), a recently described mesenchymal tumour affecting middle-aged and elderly females. METHODS: The histological features of five cases of SCVM arising in four patients were reviewed including one case which recurred locally 9 years after initial excision biopsy. All cases were immunostained using the streptavidin-biotin technique using antisera to vimentin, smooth muscle actin, desmin, S100 protein, cytokeratin, h-caldesmon, calponin, CD99, CD117 (c-kit), bcl-2, oestrogen receptor and progesterone receptor. RESULTS: The patients were aged from 40 to 71 years (mean 55.2 years). The tumours were situated within the vagina (four cases) and cervix (one case) and ranged from 16 to 45 mm in greatest dimension. One patient had two separate vaginal SCVM. The tumours were characterised by uniform spindle and stellate-shaped cells separated by a collagenous or myxoid stroma. No mitotic activity was identified. Characteristically the tumours were well circumscribed and separated from the surface epithelium by a rim of normal stroma. The initial and recurrent tumours in one patient were similar except for increased stromal collagen in the recurrence. All tumours were immunoreactive for vimentin, desmin, CD34, CD99, bcl-2, calponin and hormone receptors while two tumours showed focal smooth muscle actin expression. There was no expression of S100 protein, h-caldesmon, CD117 or cytokeratin. CONCLUSIONS: SCVM appears to be a relatively distinct lesion although there is some histological and immunophenotypical overlap with other mesenchymal tumours, particularly fibroepithelial polyp, leiomyoma and solitary fibrous tumour. As local recurrence developed 9 years after intial treatment in one patient, long-term clinical follow-up would seem appropriate.

Gangliocytic paraganglioma of the bronchus: a case report with follow-up and ultrastructural assessment.

We report a case of gangliocytic paraganglioma of bronchus. A 54-year-old woman underwent bronchoscopy following two episodes of right lower lobe pneumonia over the previous 5 months with unresolved chest radiographic changes. A computerized tomographic scan showed a right lower lobe endobronchial lesion, and at bronchoscopy there was a mass partly occluding the lumen of the bronchus. The biopsy and subsequent bronchoscopic resection showed a tumor with morphologic, immunohistochemical, and ultrastructural features of paragangliomatous, gangliocytic, and Schwann cell differentiation consistent with a gangliocytic paraganglioma. The lesion was treated conservatively with bronchoscopic resection and laser therapy. Histopathologic examination of recurrent tumor at 6 months showed features consistent with paraganglioma. Ten months after initial diagnosis, there was no bronchoscopic evidence of residual tumor. The occurrence of gangliocytic paraganglioma in diverse sites gives cause for the reappraisal of the histogenesis of this fascinating lesion. The variable morphology of this lesion may be an expression of the potential for divergent differentiation of a pluripotent stem cell.