Affinity ligands from chemical combinatorial libraries.

The above discussion provides examples of how to utilize the possibilities arising from different scenarios, related to the level of information available, to identify low molecular weight organic molecule affinity ligands to target proteins. In Table 10.1 the different published results are summarized in terms of the structure of the ligand, the target protein, and a reference to the relevant publication. Common to all reported cases of small molecule affinity ligands is a considerably lower selectivity and affinity compared to natural protein ligands. This lower affinity has to be compensated with more thorough work in the optimization of binding and elution conditions to obtain significant recoveries and purification factors.

Characterization of multimodal hydrophobic interaction chromatography media useful for isolation of green fluorescent proteins with small structural differences.

Hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC) has been developed as a powerful technique for separating and purifying proteins. In this study, we have characterized the ability of new multimodal pH-HIC media to resolve proteins with only small differences in their primary structures. This was done by determining the retention times of different green fluorescent protein (GFP) mutants prepared from Escherichia coli extracts. The mutants, modified with single or double hydrophobic amino acid substitutions in two positions, N212 and T230, could be resolved successfully, up to 2.1 column volumes in retention difference for single substitutions and 2.6 column volumes for double substitutions, at two pH and on two media with varying ligand density. The retention times also correlated well with calculated theoretical retentions (R2=0.91) using a hydrophobic descriptor. This medium can therefore be very useful in a final polishing step during purification and the protein library prepared represents a good screening set in validating and characterizing new future media due to the accessible, but yet, extremely small differences in protein structure.

Electrostatic calculations and quantitative protein retention models for ion exchange chromatography.

A novel set of protein descriptors has been developed to increase the understanding of protein behavior on chromatographic media. The protein descriptors are pH-dependent and based on electrostatic and hydrophobic properties of mainly the surface of the proteins as revealed by their three-dimensional structure. Interpretable and predictive quantitative structure property relationship (QSPR) models were then obtained for protein retention in ion exchange chromatography at different pH values. In most cases the calculated average surface potential could be directly related to retention times. Moreover, the high retention of human lactoferrin observed in cation exchange even at high pH values could be modeled by adding descriptors of the charge asymmetry.

A novel and conserved pocket of human kappa-Fab fragments: design, synthesis, and verification of directed affinity ligands.

Antibodies of type IgG may be divided into two classes, called lambda or kappa, depending on the type of light chain. We have identified a conserved pocket between the two domains CH1 and CL of human IgG kappa-Fab, which is not present in the lambda type. This pocket was used as a target docking site with the purpose of exploring the possibilities of designing affinity ligands that could function as such even after immobilization to gel. The idea of the design arose mainly from the results of the saturated transfer difference (STD-NMR) screening of 46 compounds identified by means of virtual docking of 60 K diverse compounds from the Available Chemicals Directory (ACD). Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) was used as an alternative method to monitor binding in solution. A total of 24 compounds belonging to a directed library were designed, synthesized, and screened in solution. They consist essentially of an amino acid condensed to a N,N'-methylated phenyl urea. STD-NMR results suggest that a small hydrophobic side chain in the condensed amino acid promotes binding, whereas a hydroxyl-group-containing side chain implies absence of STD-NMR signals. Three compounds of the directed library were immobilized and evaluated as chromatographic probes. In one case, using D-Pro as the condensed amino acid, columns packed with ligand-coupled Sepharose (Amersham Biosciences) retained two different monoclonal samples of kappa-Fab fragments with different variable regions, whereas a sample of monoclonal lambda-Fab fragments was not retained under similar chromatographic conditions.

Rational design, synthesis, and verification of affinity ligands to a protein surface cleft.

The structure-based design, synthesis, and screening of a glucuronic acid scaffold library of affinity ligands directed toward the catalytic cleft on porcine pancreas alpha-amylase are presented. The design was based on the simulated docking to the enzyme active site of 53 aryl glycosides from the Available Chemicals Directory (ACD) selected by in silico screening. Twenty-three compounds were selected for synthesis and screened in solution for binding toward alpha-amylase using nuclear magnetic resonance techniques. The designed molecules include a handle outside of the binding site to allow their attachment to various surfaces with minimal loss of binding activity. After initial screening in solution, one affinity ligand was selected, immobilized to Sepharose (Amersham Biosciences), and evaluated as a chromatographic probe. A column packed with ligand-coupled Sepharose specifically retained the enzyme, which could be eluted by a known inhibitor.

Structure-based discovery of a new affinity ligand to pancreatic alpha-amylase.

A ligand useful for affinity capture of porcine pancreatic alpha-amylase was found by virtual screening of the commercially available compound data base MDL Available Chemicals Directory. Hits from the virtual screening were investigated for binding by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and surface plasmon resonance. Selected compounds were tested for inhibition of the enzyme using a NMR-based assay. One of the binders found was covalently coupled to a chromatographic resin and a column, packed with this resin, could retain alpha-amylase, which subsequently was eluted by introduction of the known inhibitor acarbose to the elution buffer.

Regulation of protein binding toward a ligand on chromatographic matrixes by masking and forced-releasing effects using thermoresponsive polymer.

A novel concept of affinity regulation based on masking and forced-releasing effects using a thermoresponsive polymer was elucidated. Affinity chromatographic matrixes were prepared using either poly(glycidyl methacrylate-co-ethyleneglycol dimethacrylate) or poly(glycidyl methacrylate-co-triethyleneglycol dimethacrylate) beads immobilized with ligand molecule, Cibacron Blue F3G-A (CB), together with poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PIPAAm), a polymer with a cloud point of 32 degrees C. Two different lengths of spacer molecules were used for the immobilization of CB while maintaining the PIPAAm size constant. Chromatographic analyses using bovine serum albumin as a model protein showed a clear correlation between spacer length and binding capacity at temperatures lower than the lower critical solution temperature (LCST) of PIPAAm. The binding capacity under the LCST was significantly reduced only when the calculated spacer length was shorter than the mean size of the extended PIPAAm. Furthermore, the adsorbed protein could be desorbed (released) from the matrix surface by lowering the temperature to below the LCST while maintaining other factors such as pH and ion strength. Selective recovery of human albumin from human sera was demonstrated using this newly developed thermoresponsive affinity column.

The high specificities of Phaseolus vulgaris erythro- and leukoagglutinating lectins for bisecting GlcNAc or beta 1-6-linked branch structures, respectively, are attributable to loop B.

Despite very similar tertiary structures based upon a common framework, legume lectins exhibit an amazing variety of sugar binding specificities. While most of these lectins recognize rather discrete sugar linkages, Phaseolus vulgaris erythroagglutinating and leukoagglutinating lectins (E(4)- and L(4)-PHA) are unique in recognizing larger structures. E(4)- and L(4)-PHA are known to recognize complex type N-glycans containing bisecting GlcNAc or a beta1,6-linked branch, respectively. However, the detailed mechanisms of molecular recognition are poorly understood. In order to dissect the contributions of different portions of each lectin, we carried out region-swapping mutagenesis between E(4)- and L(4)-PHA. We prepared six chimeric lectins by exchanging different combinations of loop B and the central portion of loop C, two of four loops thought to be important for the recognition of monosaccharides (Sharma, V., and Surolia, A. (1997) J. Mol. Biol. 267, 433-445). The chimeric lectins' sugar binding activities were evaluated quantitatively by surface plasmon resonance. These comparisons indicate that the high specificities of E(4)- and L(4)-PHA toward bisecting GlcNAc and beta1,6-linked branch structures are almost solely attributable to loop B. The contribution of the central portion of loop C to the recognition of those structural motifs was found to be negligible. Instead, it modulates affinity toward LacNAc residues present at the nonreducing terminus. Moreover, some of the chimeric lectins prepared in this study showed even higher specificities/affinities than native E(4)- and L(4)-PHA toward complex sugar chains containing either a bisecting GlcNAc residue or a beta1,6-linked branch.