RESUMEN
Immune responses counteract infections but also cause collateral damage to hosts. Oligoadenylate synthetase 1 (OAS1) binds double-stranded RNA from invading viruses and produces 2'-5' linked oligoadenylate (2-5A) to activate ribonuclease L (RNase L), which cleaves RNA to inhibit virus replication. OAS1 can also undergo autoactivation by host RNAs, a potential trade-off to antiviral activity. We investigated functional variation in primate OAS1 as a model for how immune pathways evolve to mitigate costs and observed a surprising frequency of loss-of-function variation. In gorillas, we identified a polymorphism that severely decreases catalytic function, mirroring a common variant in humans that impairs 2-5A synthesis through alternative splicing. OAS1 loss-of-function variation is also common in monkeys, including complete loss of 2-5A synthesis in tamarins. The frequency of loss-of-function alleles suggests that costs associated with OAS1 activation can be so detrimental to host fitness that pathogen-protective effects are repeatedly forfeited.