How to think about and do successful research What you probable did not learn when you first entered the laboratory.

There is a logic to doing successful research, but graduate students and indeed postdoctoral fellows and young independent investigators often learn it apprentice style, by experience. The purpose of this essay is to provide the product of that experience and advice that I have found useful to young researchers as they begin their training and careers.

TorC1 and nitrogen catabolite repression control of integrated GABA shunt and retrograde pathway gene expression.

Despite our detailed understanding of how the lower GABA shunt and retrograde genes are regulated, there is a paucity of validated information concerning control of GAD1, the glutamate decarboxylase gene which catalyzes the first reaction of the GABA shunt. Further, integration of glutamate degradation via the GABA shunt has not been investigated. Here, we show that while GAD1 shares a response to rapamycin-inhibition of the TorC1 kinase, it does so independently of the Gln3 and Gat1 NCR-sensitive transcriptional activators that mediate transcription of the lower GABA shunt genes. We also show that GABA shunt gene expression increases dramatically in response to nickel ions. The α-ketoglutarate needed for the GABA shunt to cycle, thereby producing reduced pyridine nucleotides, derives from the retrograde pathway as shown by a similar high increase in the retrograde reporter, CIT2 when nickel is present in the medium. These observations demonstrate high integration of the GABA shunt, retrograde, peroxisomal glyoxylate cycle, and ß-oxidation pathways.

Industry and academia-a perfect match.

My career developed very differently from those of most academic researchers. After school, I worked for 6 years in industries that employed yeast to manufacture ethanol and beer. At university, I was trained as a microbiologist with very little training in molecular biology. I retrained in 1987 in molecular yeast genetics and focused on genetic engineering of industrial yeasts to minimize the production of spoilage compounds in wine and ethyl carbamate, a carcinogen, in wine. The malolactic yeast ML01 and the urea-degrading yeast were the first genetically enhanced yeasts that obtained US FDA approval for commercial applications. Apart from applied research, I was fascinated by classic molecular yeast genetic studies using sophisticated techniques such as transcriptomics, proteomics, and metabolomics. Doing research at the University of British Columbia was stimulating and exciting, we established a core microarray and metabolomics facility that was used by many scientists at UBC and hospitals in Vancouver. I also established a state-of-the-art Wine Library that was used to study aging of wines produced in British Columbia. Finally, I have been fortunate to know and collaborate with leading yeast scientists who motivated me.

From blood to stress-my life investigating cell differentiation.

This short retrospective covers more than 50 years of research. I spent most of it doing yeast genetics and genetic engineering. It has been my great privilege to be part of the international group of yeast genetics researchers. With many of them named in this retrospective, I am connected in lifelong friendships and the same is true for my students and collaborators. The question which we wanted to ask is "How does the genome of the cell and cell differentiation adapt to changing and stressful environmental conditions?" The two examples we studied were sporulation and pseudohyphal growth. Both forms of differentiation are triggered by the stress of starvation. In the pathway of regulation of pseudohyphal growth, a yeast NADPH oxidase (discovered by our group) plays a major role.

Effects of abolishing Whi2 on the proteome and nitrogen catabolite repression-sensitive protein production.

In yeast physiology, a commonly used reference condition for many experiments, including those involving nitrogen catabolite repression (NCR), is growth in synthetic complete (SC) medium. Four SC formulations, SCCSH,1990, SCCSH,1994, SCCSH,2005, and SCME, have been used interchangeably as the nitrogen-rich medium of choice [Cold Spring Harbor Yeast Course Manuals (SCCSH) and a formulation in the methods in enzymology (SCME)]. It has been tacitly presumed that all of these formulations support equivalent responses. However, a recent report concluded that (i) TorC1 activity is downregulated by the lower concentration of primarily leucine in SCME relative to SCCSH. (ii) The Whi2-Psr1/2 complex is responsible for this downregulation. TorC1 is a primary nitrogen-responsive regulator in yeast. Among its downstream targets is control of NCR-sensitive transcription activators Gln3 and Gat1. They in turn control production of catabolic transporters and enzymes needed to scavenge poor nitrogen sources (e.g., Proline) and activate autophagy (ATG14). One of the reporters used in Chen et al. was an NCR-sensitive DAL80-GFP promoter fusion. This intrigued us because we expected minimal if any DAL80 expression in SC medium. Therefore, we investigated the source of the Dal80-GFP production and the proteomes of wild-type and whi2Δ cells cultured in SCCSH and SCME. We found a massive and equivalent reorientation of amino acid biosynthetic proteins in both wild-type and whi2Δ cells even though both media contained high overall concentrations of amino acids. Gcn2 appears to play a significant regulatory role in this reorientation. NCR-sensitive DAL80 expression and overall NCR-sensitive protein production were only marginally affected by the whi2Δ. In contrast, the levels of 58 proteins changed by an absolute value of log2 between 3 and 8 when Whi2 was abolished relative to wild type. Surprisingly, with only two exceptions could those proteins be related in GO analyses, i.e., GO terms associated with carbohydrate metabolism and oxidative stress after shifting a whi2Δ from SCCSH to SCME for 6 h. What was conspicuously missing were proteins related by TorC1- and NCR-associated GO terms.

N- and C-terminal Gln3-Tor1 interaction sites: one acting negatively and the other positively to regulate nuclear Gln3 localization.

Gln3 activates Nitrogen Catabolite Repression, NCR-sensitive expression of the genes required for Saccharomyces cerevisiae to scavenge poor nitrogen sources from its environment. The global TorC1 kinase complex negatively regulates nuclear Gln3 localization, interacting with an α-helix in the C-terminal region of Gln3, Gln3656-666. In nitrogen replete conditions, Gln3 is sequestered in the cytoplasm, whereas when TorC1 is down-regulated, in nitrogen restrictive conditions, Gln3 migrates into the nucleus. In this work, we show that the C-terminal Gln3-Tor1 interaction site is required for wild type, rapamycin-elicited, Sit4-dependent nuclear Gln3 localization, but not for its dephosphorylation. In fact, truncated Gln31-384 can enter the nucleus in the absence of Sit4 in both repressive and derepressive growth conditions. However, Gln31-384 can only enter the nucleus if a newly discovered second positively-acting Gln3-Tor1 interaction site remains intact. Importantly, the N- and C-terminal Gln3-Tor1 interaction sites function both autonomously and collaboratively. The N-terminal Gln3-Tor1 interaction site, previously designated Gln3URS contains a predicted α-helix situated within an unstructured coiled-coil region. Eight of the thirteen serine/threonine residues in the Gln3URS are dephosphorylated 3-15-fold with three of them by 10-15-fold. Substituting phosphomimetic aspartate for serine/threonine residues in the Gln3 URS abolishes the N-terminal Gln3-Tor1 interaction, rapamycin-elicited nuclear Gln3 localization, and ½ of the derepressed levels of nuclear Gln3 localization. Cytoplasmic Gln3 sequestration in repressive conditions, however, remains intact. These findings further deconvolve the mechanisms that achieve nitrogen-responsive transcription factor regulation downstream of TorC1.

Carl Singer (1945-2013) - Life on a Plate: yeast genetics meetings and micromanipulators.

Micromanipulators, more than any other instrument, opened the early doors to developing the powerful genetics of yeast that underlies much of the molecular work today. The ability to separate the spores of a tetrad and analyze their phenotypes generated the genetic maps and biology upon which subsequent cloning, sequencing, cutting edge molecular and cell biology depended. This work describes the development of those micromanipulators from garage to barn to factory and the developer of the sophisticated instruments we use today. For more than 30 years Carl Singer and his family were staunch and generous supporters of the International Conferences on Yeast Genetics and Molecular Biology meetings both in Europe and America. Carl Singer's displays at meetings became a traditional fixture and engaged the appetites of many students and advanced researchers to employ a technique that many perceived as too complicated or difficult, but which he made simple and easy to learn. His experiences also document a sketch of the international yeast meetings, their venues and how they developed through the years.

Sit4 and PP2A Dephosphorylate Nitrogen Catabolite Repression-Sensitive Gln3 When TorC1 Is Up- as Well as Downregulated.

Saccharomyces cerevisiae lives in boom and bust nutritional environments. Sophisticated regulatory systems have evolved to rapidly cope with these changes while preserving intracellular homeostasis. Target of Rapamycin Complex 1 (TorC1), is a serine/threonine kinase complex and a principle nitrogen-responsive regulator. TorC1 is activated by excess nitrogen and downregulated by limiting nitrogen. Two of TorC1's many downstream targets are Gln3 and Gat1-GATA-family transcription activators-whose localization and function are Nitrogen Catabolite Repression- (NCR-) sensitive. In nitrogen replete environments, TorC1 is activated, thereby inhibiting the PTap42-Sit4 and PTap42-PP2A (Pph21/Pph22-Tpd3, Pph21,22-Rts1/Cdc55) phosphatase complexes. Gln3 is phosphorylated, sequestered in the cytoplasm and NCR-sensitive transcription repressed. In nitrogen-limiting conditions, TorC1 is downregulated and PTap42-Sit4 and PTap42-PP2A are active. They dephosphorylate Gln3, which dissociates from Ure2, relocates to the nucleus, and activates transcription. A paradoxical observation, however, led us to suspect that Gln3 control was more complex than appreciated, i.e., Sit4 dephosphorylates Gln3 more in excess than in limiting nitrogen conditions. This paradox motivated us to reinvestigate the roles of these phosphatases in Gln3 regulation. We discovered that: (i) Sit4 and PP2A actively function both in conditions where TorC1 is activated as well as down-regulated; (ii) nuclear Gln3 is more highly phosphorylated than when it is sequestered in the cytoplasm; (iii) in nitrogen-replete conditions, Gln3 relocates from the nucleus to the cytoplasm, where it is dephosphorylated by Sit4 and PP2A; and (iv) in nitrogen excess and limiting conditions, Sit4, PP2A, and Ure2 are all required to maintain cytoplasmic Gln3 in its dephosphorylated form.

More than One Way in: Three Gln3 Sequences Required To Relieve Negative Ure2 Regulation and Support Nuclear Gln3 Import in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Gln3 is responsible for Nitrogen Catabolite Repression-sensitive transcriptional activation in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae In nitrogen-replete medium, Gln3 is cytoplasmic and NCR-sensitive transcription is repressed. In nitrogen-limiting medium, in cells treated with TorC1 inhibitor, rapamycin, or the glutamine synthetase inhibitor, methionine sulfoximine (Msx), Gln3 becomes highly nuclear and NCR-sensitive transcription derepressed. Previously, nuclear Gln3 localization was concluded to be mediated by a single nuclear localization sequence, NLS1. Here, we show that nuclear Gln3-Myc13 localization is significantly more complex than previously appreciated. We identify three Gln3 sequences, other than NLS1, that are highly required for nuclear Gln3-Myc13 localization. Two of these sequences exhibit characteristics of monopartite (K/R-Rich NLS) and bipartite (S/R NLS) NLSs, respectively. Mutations altering these sequences are partially epistatic to a ure2Δ. The third sequence, the Ure2 relief sequence, exhibits no predicted NLS homology and is only necessary when Ure2 is present. Substitution of the basic amino acid repeats in the Ure2 relief sequence or phosphomimetic aspartate substitutions for the serine residues between them abolishes nuclear Gln3-Myc13 localization in response to both limiting nitrogen and rapamycin treatment. In contrast, Gln3-Myc13 responses are normal in parallel serine-to-alanine substitution mutants. These observations suggest that Gln3 responses to specific nitrogen environments likely occur in multiple steps that can be genetically separated. At least one general step that is associated with the Ure2 relief sequence may be prerequisite for responses to the specific stimuli of growth in poor nitrogen sources and rapamycin inhibition of TorC1.

What do the pictures say-snapshots of a career.

What follows are snapshots of my career in chicken eyes, yeast and Rhodospirillum rubrum, castor beans, Escherichia coli and finally yeast again. In contrast, only a few of the failures that realistically make up a career are included. It is a tale of the generosity and influences of those who shaped what I am and what I learned in a wonderful profession. The science described is only that which I was lucky enough to do or was performed in my laboratory by those who really deserve the credit for any success that I've enjoyed. Not mentioned for lack of space are the critical contributions of many impressive investigators in the field of nitrogen-responsive regulation for no scientific investigation occurs in isolation.

General Amino Acid Control and 14-3-3 Proteins Bmh1/2 Are Required for Nitrogen Catabolite Repression-Sensitive Regulation of Gln3 and Gat1 Localization.

Nitrogen catabolite repression (NCR), the ability of Saccharomyces cerevisiae to use good nitrogen sources in preference to poor ones, derives from nitrogen-responsive regulation of the GATA family transcription activators Gln3 and Gat1 In nitrogen-replete conditions, the GATA factors are cytoplasmic and NCR-sensitive transcription minimal. When only poor nitrogen sources are available, Gln3 is nuclear, dramatically increasing GATA factor-mediated transcription. This regulation was originally attributed to mechanistic Tor protein kinase complex 1 (mTorC1)-mediated control of Gln3 However, we recently showed that two regulatory systems act cumulatively to maintain cytoplasmic Gln3 sequestration, only one of which is mTorC1. Present experiments demonstrate that the other previously elusive component is uncharged transfer RNA-activated, Gcn2 protein kinase-mediated general amino acid control (GAAC). Gcn2 and Gcn4 are required for NCR-sensitive nuclear Gln3-Myc13 localization, and from epistasis experiments Gcn2 appears to function upstream of Ure2 Bmh1/2 are also required for nuclear Gln3-Myc13 localization and appear to function downstream of Ure2 Overall, Gln3 phosphorylation levels decrease upon loss of Gcn2, Gcn4, or Bmh1/2 Our results add a new dimension to nitrogen-responsive GATA-factor regulation and demonstrate the cumulative participation of the mTorC1 and GAAC pathways, which respond oppositely to nitrogen availability, in the nitrogen-responsive control of catabolic gene expression in yeast.

Multiple Targets on the Gln3 Transcription Activator Are Cumulatively Required for Control of Its Cytoplasmic Sequestration.

A remarkable characteristic of nutritional homeostatic mechanisms is the breadth of metabolite concentrations to which they respond, and the resolution of those responses; adequate but rarely excessive. Two general ways of achieving such exquisite control are known: stoichiometric mechanisms where increasing metabolite concentrations elicit proportionally increasing responses, and the actions of multiple independent metabolic signals that cumulatively generate appropriately measured responses. Intracellular localization of the nitrogen-responsive transcription activator, Gln3, responds to four distinct nitrogen environments: nitrogen limitation or short-term starvation, i.e., nitrogen catabolite repression (NCR), long-term starvation, glutamine starvation, and rapamycin inhibition of mTorC1. We have previously identified unique sites in Gln3 required for rapamycin-responsiveness, and Gln3-mTor1 interaction. Alteration of the latter results in loss of about 50% of cytoplasmic Gln3 sequestration. However, except for the Ure2-binding domain, no evidence exists for a Gln3 site responsible for the remaining cytoplasmic Gln3-Myc(13) sequestration in nitrogen excess. Here, we identify a serine/threonine-rich (Gln3477-493) region required for effective cytoplasmic Gln3-Myc(13) sequestration in excess nitrogen. Substitutions of alanine but not aspartate for serines in this peptide partially abolish cytoplasmic Gln3 sequestration. Importantly, these alterations have no effect on the responses of Gln3-Myc(13) to rapamycin, methionine sulfoximine, or limiting nitrogen. However, cytoplasmic Gln3-Myc(13) sequestration is additively, and almost completely, abolished when mutations in the Gln3-Tor1 interaction site are combined with those in Gln3477-493 cytoplasmic sequestration site. These findings clearly demonstrate that multiple individual regulatory pathways cumulatively control cytoplasmic Gln3 sequestration.

Nuclear Gln3 Import Is Regulated by Nitrogen Catabolite Repression Whereas Export Is Specifically Regulated by Glutamine.

Gln3, a transcription activator mediating nitrogen-responsive gene expression in Saccharomyces cerevisiae, is sequestered in the cytoplasm, thereby minimizing nitrogen catabolite repression (NCR)-sensitive transcription when cells are grown in nitrogen-rich environments. In the face of adverse nitrogen supplies, Gln3 relocates to the nucleus and activates transcription of the NCR-sensitive regulon whose products transport and degrade a variety of poorly used nitrogen sources, thus expanding the cell's nitrogen-acquisition capability. Rapamycin also elicits nuclear Gln3 localization, implicating Target-of-rapamycin Complex 1 (TorC1) in nitrogen-responsive Gln3 regulation. However, we long ago established that TorC1 was not the sole regulatory system through which nitrogen-responsive regulation is achieved. Here we demonstrate two different ways in which intracellular Gln3 localization is regulated. Nuclear Gln3 entry is regulated by the cell's overall nitrogen supply, i.e., by NCR, as long accepted. However, once within the nucleus, Gln3 can follow one of two courses depending on the glutamine levels themselves or a metabolite directly related to glutamine. When glutamine levels are high, e.g., glutamine or ammonia as the sole nitrogen source or addition of glutamine analogues, Gln3 can exit from the nucleus without binding to DNA. In contrast, when glutamine levels are lowered, e.g., adding additional nitrogen sources to glutamine-grown cells or providing repressive nonglutamine nitrogen sources, Gln3 export does not occur in the absence of DNA binding. We also demonstrate that Gln3 residues 64-73 are required for nuclear Gln3 export.

Premature termination of GAT1 transcription explains paradoxical negative correlation between nitrogen-responsive mRNA, but constitutive low-level protein production.

The first step in executing the genetic program of a cell is production of mRNA. In yeast, almost every gene is transcribed as multiple distinct isoforms, differing at their 5' and/or 3' termini. However, the implications and functional significance of the transcriptome-wide diversity of mRNA termini remains largely unexplored. In this paper, we show that the GAT1 gene, encoding a transcriptional activator of nitrogen-responsive catabolic genes, produces a variety of mRNAs differing in their 5' and 3' termini. Alternative transcription initiation leads to the constitutive, low level production of 2 full length proteins differing in their N-termini, whereas premature transcriptional termination generates a short, highly nitrogen catabolite repression- (NCR-) sensitive transcript that, as far as we can determine, is not translated under the growth conditions we used, but rather likely protects the cell from excess Gat1.

GATA Factor Regulation in Excess Nitrogen Occurs Independently of Gtr-Ego Complex-Dependent TorC1 Activation.

The TorC1 protein kinase complex is a central component in a eukaryotic cell's response to varying nitrogen availability, with kinase activity being stimulated in nitrogen excess by increased intracellular leucine. This leucine-dependent TorC1 activation requires functional Gtr1/2 and Ego1/3 complexes. Rapamycin inhibition of TorC1 elicits nuclear localization of Gln3, a GATA-family transcription activator responsible for the expression of genes encoding proteins required to transport and degrade poor nitrogen sources, e.g., proline. In nitrogen-replete conditions, Gln3 is cytoplasmic and Gln3-mediated transcription minimal, whereas in nitrogen limiting or starvation conditions, or after rapamycin treatment, Gln3 is nuclear and transcription greatly increased. Increasing evidence supports the idea that TorC1 activation may not be as central to nitrogen-responsive intracellular Gln3 localization as envisioned previously. To test this idea directly, we determined whether Gtr1/2- and Ego1/3-dependent TorC1 activation also was required for cytoplasmic Gln3 sequestration and repressed GATA factor-mediated transcription by abolishing the Gtr-Ego complex proteins. We show that Gln3 is sequestered in the cytoplasm of gtr1Δ, gtr2Δ, ego1Δ, and ego3Δ strains either long term in logarithmically glutamine-grown cells or short term after refeeding glutamine to nitrogen-limited or -starved cells; GATA factor-dependent transcription also was minimal. However, in all but a gtr1Δ, nuclear Gln3 localization in response to nitrogen limitation or starvation was adversely affected. Our data demonstrate: (i) Gtr-Ego-dependent TorC1 activation is not required for cytoplasmic Gln3 sequestration in nitrogen-rich conditions; (ii) a novel Gtr-Ego-TorC1 activation-independent mechanism sequesters Gln3 in the cytoplasm; (iii) Gtr and Ego complex proteins participate in nuclear Gln3-Myc(13) localization, heretofore unrecognized functions for these proteins; and (iv) the importance of searching for new mechanisms associated with TorC1 activation and/or the regulation of Gln3 localization/function in response to changes in the cells' nitrogen environment.

Nitrogen starvation and TorC1 inhibition differentially affect nuclear localization of the Gln3 and Gat1 transcription factors through the rare glutamine tRNACUG in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

A leucine, leucyl-tRNA synthetase-dependent pathway activates TorC1 kinase and its downstream stimulation of protein synthesis, a major nitrogen consumer. We previously demonstrated, however, that control of Gln3, a transcription activator of catabolic genes whose products generate the nitrogenous precursors for protein synthesis, is not subject to leucine-dependent TorC1 activation. This led us to conclude that excess nitrogen-dependent down-regulation of Gln3 occurs via a second mechanism that is independent of leucine-dependent TorC1 activation. A major site of Gln3 and Gat1 (another GATA-binding transcription activator) control occurs at their access to the nucleus. In excess nitrogen, Gln3 and Gat1 are sequestered in the cytoplasm in a Ure2-dependent manner. They become nuclear and activate transcription when nitrogen becomes limiting. Long-term nitrogen starvation and treatment of cells with the glutamine synthetase inhibitor methionine sulfoximine (Msx) also elicit nuclear Gln3 localization. The sensitivity of Gln3 localization to glutamine and inhibition of glutamine synthesis prompted us to investigate the effects of a glutamine tRNA mutation (sup70-65) on nitrogen-responsive control of Gln3 and Gat1. We found that nuclear Gln3 localization elicited by short- and long-term nitrogen starvation; growth in a poor, derepressive medium; Msx or rapamycin treatment; or ure2Δ mutation is abolished in a sup70-65 mutant. However, nuclear Gat1 localization, which also exhibits a glutamine tRNACUG requirement for its response to short-term nitrogen starvation or growth in proline medium or a ure2Δ mutation, does not require tRNACUG for its response to rapamycin. Also, in contrast with Gln3, Gat1 localization does not respond to long-term nitrogen starvation. These observations demonstrate the existence of a specific nitrogen-responsive component participating in the control of Gln3 and Gat1 localization and their downstream production of nitrogenous precursors. This component is highly sensitive to the function of the rare glutamine tRNACUG, which cannot be replaced by the predominant glutamine tRNACAA. Our observations also demonstrate distinct mechanistic differences between the responses of Gln3 and Gat1 to rapamycin inhibition of TorC1 and nitrogen starvation.