Sustainability--the Holy Grail of telehealth?

The sustainability of a telehealth programme is one measure of its success. However, the term 'sustainable telehealth' has almost become an oxymoron. Many telehealth programmes are initiated in good faith and are based upon well founded principles. Unfortunately, the initial funding cycle is rarely long enough to enable the programme to reach maturity and become integrated into the health-care system. Telehealth does not critically depend on technology; change management is much more important and it takes time for personnel to adopt new modes of practice. In addition, a telehealth programme needs a threshold number of installations before it can be deemed fully operational. In many cases an evaluation carried out at the conclusion of the pilot phase will fail to recognize the initial goals. As a consequence, the criteria used to justify further financial support are often at odds with the original goals and aspirations of the project initiators, and this leads to dissatisfaction by all parties concerned.

Collaboration using Internet for the development of case-based teaching files: report of the Computer and Instrumentation Council Internet Focus Group.

UNLABELLED: The Internet and particularly the World-Wide-Web is becoming a useful tool for the nuclear medicine community. METHODS: The Computer and Instrumentation Council of the Society of Nuclear Medicine convened an Internet Focus group to discuss collaboration using the Internet. The prototype application considered was development of case-based teaching files using the World-Wide-Web. Teaching file cases (clinical history, images, description of findings and discussion) on World-Wide-Web servers at different institutions are integrated using the Internet. The user can navigate from case to case using point-and-click hypertext linking. RESULTS: The initial experience with collaboration has been encouraging. An etiquette to help foster collaboration has been proposed. Development of quality control mechanisms and introduction of peer review were identified as issues needing further work. CONCLUSION: The World-Wide-Web offers great potential for new forms of collaboration. There is, however, a need to learn how to make best use of this new resource.

Protocols for selection of cardiac radionuclide studies for use as a data base of normal studies and typical patterns of diseases. COST B2 Working Group II, in association with relevant working/task groups of the European Association of Nuclear Medicine and the European Society of Cardiology.

A data base of clinical studies is required for quality assurance of software used for analysis of radionuclide cardiac imaging procedures. Studies used must be rigorously validated in terms of both the clinical condition of the patient undergoing the procedure and the imaging protocol used. Selection protocols for the creation of a software phantom data base of normal studies and three typical patterns of cardiac disease--recent transmural myocardial infarction, isolated myocardial ischaemia and dilated cardiomyopathy--have been developed by the Cardiac Working Group of the European COST B2 project in association with the Cardiac Task Group of the European Association of Nuclear Medicine and the Working Group on Nuclear Cardiology of the European Society of Cardiology. These protocols include criteria for the interpretation of qualitative and quantitative non-radionuclide data. Compliance of the clinical data with the selection criteria will have to pass scrutiny by an international team for each study used as a software phantom. The radionuclide studies encompass stress and rest myocardial perfusion studies (planar and single photon emission tomography) using thallium-201 and technetium-99m methoxyisobutylisonitrile and rest gated blood pool studies. Methods for acquisition of data are defined for each type of study and for each individual study a portfolio of all clinical data is established. A pilot study is required to investigate the problems and logistics of distributing clinical radionuclide studies between a range of computers and institutes, and to ascertain the procedures necessary for analytical comparison of the results obtained.

A file format for the exchange of nuclear medicine image data: a specification of Interfile version 3.3.

Working Group 1 of the European project COST-B2 on quality assurance of nuclear medicine software has been concerned with the development of an appropriate mechanism for the transfer of nuclear medicine image data files between computer systems from different vendors. To this end a protocol based upon Report No. 10 of the American Association of Physicists in Medicine (AAPM) [1] was adopted. A previous publication [2] gave a specification (V3.2) for an intermediate file format with a list of key-value pairs for the header data associated with nuclear medicine image data files. This paper presents a revised specification for the intermediate file format and associated keys, now called V3.3, which has evolved from the experience in using the earlier version. It is hoped that the modifications proposed will improve the definition and usability of the file format as given in the earlier version.

Experience with gated cardiac software phantoms for quality control of applications programmes.

Ten gated cardiac software phantoms, representing normal and abnormal clinical conditions, were transferred to 9 different computer systems and tested with 11 cardiac programmes. Problems of inappropriate data format were encountered when analysing the phantoms on other systems. The global left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) values resulting from the different programmes were compared. Significant programme differences were found, the programmes falling generally into two groups. Few LVEF outlier values were identified. Full functional assessment of cardiac phantoms requires a set of different views which together form the phantom. Application of software phantoms for programme assessment and training requires prudence and attention to the acquired data format, frame time, and gating method for the appropriate use of phantoms.

A standard protocol for the exchange of nuclear medicine image files.

In order to meet an increasing demand for a standard file format which would facilitate the exchange of image files from one computer to another, the protocol initiated by Report #10 of the American Association of Physicists in Medicine has been adopted. This protocol uses the concept of an ASCII file in which key-value pairs are used to describe the various parameters of the image file. Keys specific to nuclear medicine image files have been established and are published here. In addition, the latest version of the keys has been placed on a list server which is accessible by electronic mail. This will facilitate the development of conversion programs which will also be placed on the same list server as they become available.

In vivo red blood cell compatibility testing using indium-113m tropolone-labeled red blood cells.

In vivo radionuclide crossmatch is a method for identifying compatible blood for transfusion when allo- or autoantibodies preclude the use of conventional crossmatching techniques. A technique for labeling small volumes of donor red blood cells with [113mIn]tropolone is reported. The use of 113mIn minimizes the accumulation of background radioactivity and the radiation dose especially so when multiple crossmatches are performed. Labeling red cells with [113mIn]tropolone is faster and easier to perform than with other radionuclides. Consistently high labeling efficiencies are obtained and minimal 113mIn activity elutes from the labeled red blood cells. A case study involving 22 crossmatches is presented to demonstrate the technique. The radiation dose equivalent from 113mIn is significantly less than with other radionuclides that may be used to label red cells.

Dependence of ejection fraction results on choice of algorithms for a cardiac phantom.

Ejection fraction results obtained from the Vanderbilt rotating cardiac phantom exhibit a strong dependence on the algorithms used to derive the time--activity curves and calculate the ejection fraction from those curves. This problem is caused because the background chamber is located behind the rotating attenuator which is used to produce the pseudo ejection fraction. As a result, the counts due to background in both the regions on the 'left ventricle' and the area assigned for background correction do not remain constant during the 'cardiac cycle'. This leads to a breakdown in the ejection fraction algorithms. Given the same data, but changing the methods by which the time--activity curves and ejection fractions are derived, ejection fraction results varying from a minimum of 45% to a maximum of 69% have been demonstrated for the 50% attenuator. Although the Vanderbilt cardiac phantom is simple to operate it must be used with caution if it is used with the intention of calibrating a particular system or comparing different protocols.

Effect of scintillation camera nonuniformity on ejection fraction measurements.

A rotating cardiac phantom with three possible ejection fraction (EF) values was used in conjunction with a scintillation camera employing energy correction and count skim arithmetic for uniformity correction. Studies were collected with and without any correction, with the energy window of the analyzer set properly, and with the camera properly tuned. The uniformity was then degraded in one experiment by off-setting the analyzer window both high and low with respect to the primary photopeak and in another experiment by de-tuning a selected photomultiplier tube. In both experiments studies were taken with no correction enabled, and then with each of the correction options enabled. The results of both experiments show that ejection fraction values could be in error when the differential uniformity using National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA) protocols exceeds 10%. If either energy correction alone, or energy correction combined with count skim correction is used, the ejection fraction values return to more acceptable values. Asymmetric windows, improper setting of the energy window or a badly tuned photomultiplier will likely result in poor analog images before the effect on ejection fraction measurements becomes evident. Uniformity correction devices do not adversely affect the numerical results obtained from these phantom studies, but should, nevertheless, be used with caution.

An interface between several cameras and two computers, using differential analog transmission.

A system has been built to allow up to four scintillation cameras to be connected in parallel with two computers, yet provide for selection of individual pairs of camera/computer combinations with the exclusion of unwanted connections. Since the distances involved were relatively long, signal drivers were used to transmit the analog signals in a differential mode over multiple twin-paired lines rather than coaxial cable. By transmitting the signals differentially, any noise induced on the signal was subtracted at the receiver. The principal features of this system, which has been installed in two institutions, are described. A problem that occurred in connection with one camera is presented (also its solution), with a suggestion concerning parameters to be assessed at the time of system acceptance.