Use of the threshold of toxicological concern (TTC) approach as an alternative tool for regulatory purposes: A case study with an inert ingredient used in pesticide products.

This study investigates the potential of the Threshold of Toxicological Concern (TTC) as an alternative to traditional animal testing in pesticide regulatory risk assessments. The TTC is a principle that establishes exposure threshold values for chemicals with certain structural features, below which there is no appreciable risk to human health. A case study was conducted with α-terpineol, an inert ingredient proposed to be used at low concentrations in pesticide products, to compare a conventional risk assessment using animal data with one using the TTC method. For the conventional risk assessment, animal data showed that there was no toxicity endpoint of concern, which resulted in a qualitative assessment and no risks of concern identified. For the risk assessment using the TTC method, a 5th percentile no-observed-effect level (NOEL) selected based on α-terpineol's Cramer classification was used as a point of departure (POD) for a quantitative risk assessment that resulted in no risks of concern identified. Therefore, the same conclusion was reached with both approaches and α-terpineol is considered safe for use in pesticide products at low concentrations. A comparative analysis was also performed to determine the applicability of the TTC method in calculating potential dietary risk from common pesticide use patterns for chemicals that fall within different Cramer classes. Results showed that use of the TTC method may be feasible for inert ingredient risk assessments when chemicals are used in a pesticide product at concentrations below 1%. This research underscores the TTC as a valuable and robust tool for assessing the potential hazards from inert ingredient use in pesticide formulations, considering factors such as chemical properties and the concentrations at which a chemical may be used in pesticide products. These findings contribute to the ongoing efforts by the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to reduce animal testing in chemical safety assessments. The TTC method presents a viable alternative for risk evaluations of chemicals used at low concentrations, with anticipated low exposure, and with a predicted low toxicity potential.

Reducing the need for animal testing while increasing efficiency in a pesticide regulatory setting: Lessons from the EPA Office of Pesticide Programs' Hazard and Science Policy Council.

As part of EPA's commitment to reducing animal testing, the Office of Pesticide Programs (OPP) created the Hazard and Science Policy Council (HASPOC). This group considers requests for waiving animal study requirements for human health risk assessments and makes recommendations based on a weight-of-the-evidence approach. Since its inception in 2012, the HASPOC has evaluated over one thousand requests to waive animal studies required by default for pesticide evaluation. Here, the number of studies waived, and the types of studies represented were analyzed to determine the impact of the HASPOC decisions in terms of animal and monetary savings. Overall, the waiving of studies by HASPOC resulted in over 200 thousand animals saved. There were also savings of over $300 million in study costs and over $6 million in study review costs as well as less time spent in study processing and review by EPA staff. Thus, the HASPOC has built significant efficiencies into the risk assessment process while continuing to protect human health.

A weight of evidence approach to investigate potential common mechanisms in pesticide groups to support cumulative risk assessment: A case study with dinitroaniline pesticides.

In 2016, the United States Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) Office of Pesticide Programs published guidelines for establishing candidate common mechanism groups (CMGs) for cumulative risk assessment (CRA) weight-of-evidence-based screenings. A candidate CMG is a group of chemicals that may share similar structure, apical endpoints, and/or mechanistic data that suggest the potential for a common mechanism of toxicity among them. Here, a weight-of-evidence approach is presented to establish candidacy of a CMG for a group of nine dinitroaniline pesticides. This approach involves review of available in vivo toxicity information and literature to determine mode of action, along with analyses of in vitro toxicity data and chemical structure. Despite structural similarity among some dinitroanilines and some shared target organs identified through toxicity observed in in vivo studies, there were no consistencies among groups, suggesting lack of a common mechanism when all analyses are considered together. For example, two structurally similar compounds with thyroid/liver in vivo effects were not found active in any Toxicity Forecaster (ToxCast) in vitro assays. The weight-of-evidence is insufficient to support the testable hypothesis that dinitroanilines could form a CMG, and highlights the importance of establishing a consensus among multiple lines of evidence prior to CRA.

Skin sensitization testing needs and data uses by US regulatory and research agencies.

United States regulatory and research agencies may rely upon skin sensitization test data to assess the sensitization hazards associated with dermal exposure to chemicals and products. These data are evaluated to ensure that such substances will not cause unreasonable adverse effects to human health when used appropriately. The US Consumer Product Safety Commission, the US Environmental Protection Agency, the US Food and Drug Administration, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, and the US Department of Defense are member agencies of the Interagency Coordinating Committee on the Validation of Alternative Methods (ICCVAM). ICCVAM seeks to identify opportunities for the use of non-animal replacements to satisfy these testing needs and requirements. This review identifies the standards, test guidelines, or guidance documents that are applicable to satisfy each of these agency's needs; the current use of animal testing and flexibility for using alternative methodologies; information needed from alternative tests to fulfill the needs for skin sensitization data; and whether data from non-animal alternative approaches are accepted by these US federal agencies.

The relationship between chemical-induced kidney weight increases and kidney histopathology in rats.

The kidney is a major site of chemical excretion, which results in its propensity to exhibit chemically-induced toxicological effects at a higher rate than most other organs. Although the kidneys are often weighed in animal toxicity studies, the manner in which these kidney weight measurements are interpreted and the value of this information in predicting renal damage remains controversial. In this study we sought to determine whether a relationship exists between chemically-induced kidney weight changes and renal histopathological alterations. We also examined the relative utility of absolute and relative (kidney-to-body weight ratio) kidney weight in the prediction of renal toxicity. For this, data extracted from oral chemical exposure studies in rats performed by the National Toxicology Program were qualitatively and quantitatively evaluated. Our analysis showed a statistically significant correlation between absolute, but not relative, kidney weight and renal histopathology in chemically-treated rats. This positive correlation between absolute kidney weight and histopathology was observed even with compounds that statistically decreased terminal body weight. Also, changes in absolute kidney weight, which occurred at subchronic exposures, were able to predict the presence or absence of kidney histopathology at both subchronic and chronic exposures. Furthermore, most increases in absolute kidney weight reaching statistical significance (irrespective of the magnitude of change) were found to be relevant for the prediction of histopathological changes. Hence, our findings demonstrate that the evaluation of absolute kidney weight is a useful method for identifying potential renal toxicants.

Using quantitative structure-activity relationship modeling to quantitatively predict the developmental toxicity of halogenated azole compounds.

Developmental toxicity is a relevant endpoint for the comprehensive assessment of human health risk from chemical exposure. However, animal developmental toxicity data remain unavailable for many environmental contaminants due to the complexity and cost of these types of analyses. Here we describe an approach that uses quantitative structure-activity relationship modeling as an alternative methodology to fill data gaps in the developmental toxicity profile of certain halogenated compounds. Chemical information was obtained and curated using the OECD Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship Toolbox, version 3.0. Data from 35 curated compounds were analyzed via linear regression to build the predictive model, which has an R(2) of 0.79 and a Q(2) of 0.77. The applicability domain (AD) was defined by chemical category and structural similarity. Seven halogenated chemicals that fit the AD but are not part of the training set were employed for external validation purposes. Our model predicted lowest observed adverse effect level values with a maximal threefold deviation from the observed experimental values for all chemicals that fit the AD. The good predictability of our model suggests that this method may be applicable to the analysis of qualifying compounds whenever developmental toxicity information is lacking or incomplete for risk assessment considerations.

Involvement of the mRNA binding protein CRD-BP in the regulation of metastatic melanoma cell proliferation and invasion by hypoxia.

We have previously shown that the mRNA binding protein CRD-BP is overexpressed in human melanomas, where it promotes cell survival and resistance to chemotherapy. The present study investigates the role of hypoxia, a common characteristic of the tumor microenvironment, in the regulation of CRD-BP expression and melanoma cell responses. We found that hypoxia increases CRD-BP levels in metastatic melanoma cell lines but not in melanocytes or primary melanoma cells. Hypoxic stimulation transcriptionally regulates CRD-BP by facilitating the acetylation of histones within the CRD-BP gene and by modulating the extent of HIF1α binding to the CRD-BP promoter. Hypoxia significantly enhances the proliferative and invasive potential of metastatic melanoma cells but not that of normal or primary melanoma cells. Furthermore, inhibition of CRD-BP impairs the ability of metastatic cells to proliferate and invade in response to hypoxia. These findings identify CRD-BP as a novel effector of hypoxic responses that is relevant for the selection of metastatic cells. This work also describes a previously unknown role for CRD-BP in the regulation of melanoma cell invasion and highlights the importance of the hypoxic microenvironment in determining cell fate.

Inhibition of coding region determinant binding protein sensitizes melanoma cells to chemotherapeutic agents.

We previously reported that malignant melanomas express high levels of the mRNA binding protein coding region determinant binding protein (CRD-BP). This molecule is important for the activation of anti-apoptotic pathways, a mechanism often linked to insensitivity to therapeutics. However, it is not known whether CRD-BP plays a role in the resistance of melanomas to anti-cancer treatment. Here we demonstrate that knockdown of CRD-BP with a specific sh-RNA enhances the effect of dacarbazine, temozolomide, vinblastine, and etoposide on both primary and metastatic melanoma cell lines. CRD-BP down-regulation contributes to cell sensitization by increasing apoptosis and diminishing melanoma cell growth in response to chemotherapeutic agents. Furthermore, inhibition of CRD-BP decreases microphthalmia-associated transcription factor (MITF) expression and reintroduction of MITF partially compensates for the absence of CRD-BP. These findings suggest that high expression of CRD-BP in melanoma cells confers resistance to chemotherapy and that these CRD-BP responses are mediated, at least in part, by MITF.

The cytoplasmic domain of TGFßR3 through its interaction with the scaffolding protein, GIPC, directs epicardial cell behavior.

The epicardium is a major contributor of the cells that are required for the formation of coronary vessels. Mice lacking both copies of the gene encoding the Type III Transforming Growth Factor ß Receptor (TGFßR3) fail to form the coronary vasculature, but the molecular mechanism by which TGFßR3 signals coronary vessel formation is unknown. We used intact embryos and epicardial cells from E11.5 mouse embryos to reveal the mechanisms by which TGFßR3 signals and regulates epicardial cell behavior. Analysis of E13.5 embryos reveals a lower rate of epicardial cell proliferation and decreased epicardially derived cell invasion in Tgfbr3(-/-) hearts. Tgfbr3(-/-) epicardial cells in vitro show decreased proliferation and decreased invasion in response to TGFß1 and TGFß2. Unexpectedly, loss of TGFßR3 also decreases responsiveness to two other important regulators of epicardial cell behavior, FGF2 and HMW-HA. Restoring full length TGFßR3 in Tgfbr3(-/-) cells rescued deficits in invasion in vitro in response TGFß1 and TGFß2 as well as FGF2 and HMW-HA. Expression of TGFßR3 missing the 3 C-terminal amino acids that are required to interact with the scaffolding protein GIPC1 did not rescue any of the deficits. Overexpression of GIPC1 alone in Tgfbr3(-/-) cells did not rescue invasion whereas knockdown of GIPC1 in Tgfbr3(+/+) cells decreased invasion in response to TGFß2, FGF2, and HMW-HA. We conclude that TGFßR3 interaction with GIPC1 is critical for regulating invasion and growth factor responsiveness in epicardial cells and that dysregulation of epicardial cell proliferation and invasion contributes to failed coronary vessel development in Tgfbr3(-/-) mice.

TGFß2-mediated production of hyaluronan is important for the induction of epicardial cell differentiation and invasion.

In the developing heart, the epicardium is a major source of progenitor cells that contribute to the formation of the coronary vessel system. These epicardial progenitors give rise to the different cellular components of the coronary vasculature by undergoing a number of morphological and physiological changes collectively known as epithelial to mesenchymal transformation (EMT). However, the specific signaling mechanisms that regulate epicardial EMT are yet to be delineated. In this study we investigated the role of TGFß2 and hyaluronan (HA) during epicardial EMT and how signals from these two molecules are integrated during this important process. Here we show that TGFß2 induces MEKK3 activation, which in turn promotes ERK1/2 and ERK5 phosphorylation. TGFß2 also increases Has2 expression and subsequent HA production. Nevertheless, inhibition of MEKK3 kinase activity, silencing of ERK5 or pharmacological disruption of ERK1/2 activation significantly abrogates this response. Thus, TGFß2 promotes Has2 expression and HA production through a MEKK3/ERK1/2/5-dependent cascade. Furthermore, TGFß2 is able to induce epicardial cell invasion and differentiation but not proliferation. However, inhibition of MEKK3-dependent pathways, degradation of HA by hyaluronidases or blockade of CD44, significantly impairs the biological response to TGFß2. Taken together, these findings demonstrate that TGFß2 activation of MEKK3/ERK1/2/5 signaling modulates Has2 expression and HA production leading to the induction of EMT events. This is an important and novel mechanism showing how TGFß2 and HA signals are integrated to regulate changes in epicardial cell behavior.

Involvement of the MEKK1 signaling pathway in the regulation of epicardial cell behavior by hyaluronan.

During embryonic development, cells comprising the outermost layer of the heart or epicardium play a critical role in the formation of the coronary vasculature. Thus, uncovering the molecular mechanisms that govern epicardial cell behavior is imperative to better understand the etiology of cardiovascular diseases. In this study, we investigated the function of hyaluronan (HA), a major component of the extracellular matrix, in the modulation of epicardial signaling. We show that stimulation of epicardial cells with high molecular weight HA (HMW-HA) promotes the association of MEKK1 with the HA receptor CD44 and induces MEKK1 phosphorylation. This leads to the activation of two distinct pathways, one ERK-dependent and another NFkappaB-dependent. Furthermore, HMW-HA stimulates epicardial cells to differentiate and invade, as suggested by increased vimentin expression and enhanced invasion through a collagen matrix. Blockade of CD44, transfection with a kinase-inactive MEKK1 construct or the use of ERK1/2 and NFkappaB inhibitors significantly abrogates the invasive response to HMW-HA. Together, these findings suggest an important role for HA in the regulation of epicardial cell fate via activation of MEKK1 signaling cascades.

Size-dependent regulation of Snail2 by hyaluronan: its role in cellular invasion.

Hyaluronan (HA) induces changes in cellular behavior that are crucial during both embryonic development and cancer progression. However, the biological effects of varying sizes of HA and the signal transduction mechanisms that these polymers may activate remain unclear. In this study, we demonstrate that pulse stimulation of mouse embryonic fibroblasts with high-molecular-weight (HMW) HA, but not HA of lower molecular sizes, leads to increases in Snail2 protein which are dependent on NFkappaB activity. Involvement of CD44, the main HA receptor, in these responses was determined by use of a CD44 blocking antibody and CD44 siRNA. Both the blockade and silencing of CD44 significantly abrogate the increases in nuclear factor kappaB (NFkappaB) activity and Snail2 protein following HMW-HA stimulation. Furthermore, we show that HMW-HA induces cellular invasion and that inhibition of CD44, Snail2, or NFkappaB significantly decreases this response. These studies elucidate a novel HA/Snail2 functional connection through CD44 and NFkappaB that is important for the induction of cellular invasion and is dependent on HA size.

MAP3Ks as central regulators of cell fate during development.

The cytoplasmic serine/threonine kinases transduce extracellular signals into regulatory events that impact cellular responses. The induction of one kinase triggers the activation of several downstream kinases, leading to the regulation of transcription factors to affect gene function. This arrangement allows for the kinase cascade to be amplified, and integrated according to the cellular context. An upstream mitogen or growth factor signal initiates a module of three kinases: a mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinase kinase kinase (MAPKKK; e.g., Raf) that phosphorylates and activates a MAP kinase kinase (MAPKK; e.g., MEK) and finally activation of MAP kinase (MAPK; e.g., ERK). Thus, this MAP3K-MAP2K-MAPK module represents critical effectors that regulate extracellular stimuli into cellular responses, such as differentiation, proliferation, and apoptosis all of which function during development. There are 21 characterized MAP3Ks that activate known MAP2Ks, and they function in many aspects of developmental biology. This review summarizes known transduction routes linked to each MAP3K and highlights mouse models that provide clues to their physiological functions. This perspective reveals that some of these MAP3K effectors may have redundant functions, and also serve as unique nexus depending on the context of the signaling pathway.