Transcriptional response of the heart to vagus nerve stimulation.

Heart failure is a major clinical problem, with treatments involving medication, devices, and emerging neuromodulation therapies such as vagus nerve stimulation (VNS). Considering the ongoing interest in using VNS to treat cardiovascular disease it is important to understand the genetic and molecular changes developing in the heart in response to this form of autonomic neuromodulation. This experimental animal (rat) study investigated the immediate transcriptional response of the ventricular myocardium to selective stimulation of vagal efferent activity using an optogenetic approach. Vagal preganglionic neurons in the dorsal motor nucleus of the vagus nerve were genetically targeted to express light-sensitive chimeric channelrhodopsin variant ChIEF, and stimulated using light. RNA sequencing of left ventricular myocardium identified 294 differentially expressed genes (DEGs, false discovery rate <0.05). Qiagen Ingenuity Pathway Analysis (IPA) highlighted 118 canonical pathways that were significantly modulated by vagal activity, of which 14 had a z-score of ≥2/≤-2, including EIF-2, IL-2, Integrin, and NFAT-regulated cardiac hypertrophy. IPA revealed the effect of efferent vagus stimulation on protein synthesis, autophagy, fibrosis, autonomic signalling, inflammation, and hypertrophy. IPA further predicted that the identified DEGs were the targets of 50 upstream regulators, including transcription factors (e.g., MYC, NRF1) and microRNAs (e.g., miR-335-3p, miR-338-3p). These data demonstrate that the vagus nerve has a major impact on myocardial expression of genes involved in regulation of key biological pathways. The transcriptional response of the ventricular myocardium induced by stimulation of vagal efferents is consistent with the beneficial effect of maintained/increased vagal activity on the heart.

Sex-specific differences in cardiac function, inflammation and injury during early polymicrobial sepsis.

BACKGROUND: Sex differences in sepsis are underexplored and incompletely understood. Cardiac function in early sepsis is pivotal in determining survival; hyperdynamic left ventricular ejection fraction is associated with higher mortality. Female sex may be cardioprotective, but variable experimental findings have not controlled for hypovolaemia. Sex-specific local cardiac versus peripheral inflammation in causing cardiovascular dysfunction also remain unclear. We therefore examined whether there are sex-specific differences in cardiac function in early sepsis, controlling for volaemic status and sex-specific differences in the peripheral inflammatory response initiated by tumour necrosis factor (TNFα). METHODS: We used an experimental polymicrobial sepsis (faecal slurry) model titrated to minimise hypovolaemia as a confounding factor. We quantified cardiac function (transthoracic cardiac echocardiography) 1 week before, and 18 h after, sepsis. Cardiac injury (troponin I), inflammation and immune cell infiltration (flow cytometry) were quantified in naïve and septic female and male mice 18 h after sepsis. To evaluate the sex-specific influence of TNFα derived from peripheral leukocytes, we repeated the experiments in iRHOM2-/- mice that are unable to shed TNFα exclusively from circulating leucocytes. RESULTS: Serum troponin I increased to 1.39 ± 0.38 ng mL-1 (from undetectable levels in controls) 18 h after onset of normovolaemic sepsis to a similar extent in both sexes. Stroke volume in male mice increased by 8 µL [(3-13); p = 0.004], compared to individualised pre-sepsis values. By contrast, stroke volume remained at baseline levels in females [mean difference: 4 µL (- 1 to 9)]. Messenger RNA levels of markers for cardiac injury/inflammation after sepsis (real-time polymerase-chain reaction) were elevated in male wild-type mice compared to female wild types (n = 10/sex), with higher cardiac mRNA levels of atrial natriuretic peptide, inflammation (TNFα) and oxidative stress (superoxide dismutase-1), although serum troponin I values were similarly elevated. Flow cytometry analysis of cardiac tissue showed doubling of CD4 + leukocyte infiltration in male mice. Sex-specific cardiac physiologic differences were similar in iRHOM2-/- mice that are unable to shed TNFα exclusively from leucocytes. CONCLUSIONS: In early normovolaemic polymicrobial sepsis, a relative hyperdynamic response develops in male mice. Myocardial stress/injury after early sepsis is limited in females, with less cardiac infiltration of CD4 + leukocytes but independent of shedding of TNFα from peripheral circulating leukocytes.

Neuromodulation of innate immunity by remote ischaemic conditioning in humans: Experimental cross-over study.

Experimental animal studies on the mechanisms of remote ischaemic conditioning (RIC)-induced cardioprotection against ischaemia/reperfusion injury demonstrate involvement of both neuronal and humoral pathways. Autonomic parasympathetic (vagal) pathways confer organ protection through both direct innervation and/or immunomodulation, but evidence in humans is lacking. During acute inflammation, vagal release of acetylcholine suppresses CD11b expression, a critical ß2-integrin regulating neutrophil adhesion to the endothelium and transmigration to sites of injury. Here, we tested the hypothesis that RIC recruits vagal activity in humans and has an anti-inflammatory effect by reducing neutrophil CD11b expression. Participants (age:50 â€‹± â€‹19 years; 53% female) underwent ultrasound-guided injection of local anaesthetic within the brachial plexus before applying 3 â€‹× â€‹8 min cycles of brachial artery occlusion using a blood pressure cuff (RICblock). RIC was repeated 6 weeks later without brachial plexus block. Masked analysers quantified vagal activity (heart rate, heart rate variability (HRV)) before, and 10 â€‹min after, the last cycle of RIC. RR-interval increased after RIC (reduced heart rate) by 40 â€‹ms (95% confidence intervals (95%CI):13-66; n â€‹= â€‹17 subjects; P â€‹= â€‹0.003). RR-interval did not change after brachial plexus blockade (mean difference: 20 â€‹ms (95%CI:-11 to 50); P â€‹= â€‹0.19). The high-frequency component of HRV was reduced after RICblock, but remained unchanged after RIC (P â€‹< â€‹0.001), indicating that RIC preserved vagal activity. LPS-induced CD16+CD11b+ expression in whole blood (measured by flow cytometry) was reduced by RIC (3615 median fluorescence units (95%CI:475-6754); P = 0.026), compared with 2331 units (95%CI:-3921 to 8582); P = 0.726) after RICblock. These data suggest that in humans RIC recruits vagal cardiac and anti-inflammatory mechanisms via ischaemia/reperfusion-induced activation of sensory nerve fibres that innervate the organ undergoing RIC.

Preoperative lymphopaenia, mortality, and morbidity after elective surgery: systematic review and meta-analysis.

BACKGROUND: In the general adult population, lymphopaenia is associated with an increased risk for hospitalisation with infection and infection-related death. The quality of evidence and strength of association between perioperative lymphopaenia across different surgical procedures and mortality/morbidity has not been examined by systematic review or meta-analysis. METHODS: We searched MEDLINE, Embase, Web of Science, Google Scholar, and Cochrane databases from their inception to June 29, 2020 for observational studies reporting lymphocyte count and in-hospital mortality rate in adults. We defined preoperative lymphopaenia as a lymphocyte count 1.0-1.5×109 L-1. Meta-analysis was performed using either fixed or random effects models. Quality was assessed using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. The I2 index was used to quantify heterogeneity. The primary outcome was in-hospital mortality rate and mortality rate at 30 days. RESULTS: Eight studies met the inclusion criteria for meta-analysis, comprising 4811 patients (age range, 46-91 yr; female, 20-79%). These studies examined preoperative lymphocyte count exclusively. Studies were of moderate to high quality overall, ranking >7 using the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale. Preoperative lymphopaenia was associated with a threefold increase in mortality rate (risk ratio [RR]=3.22; 95% confidence interval [CI], 2.19-4.72; P<0.01, I2=0%) and more frequent major postoperative complications (RR=1.33; 95% CI, 1.21-1.45; P<0.01, I2=6%), including cardiovascular morbidity (RR=1.77; 95% CI, 1.45-2.15; P<0.01, I2=0%), infections (RR=1.45; 95% CI, 1.19-1.76; P<0.01, I2=0%), and acute renal dysfunction (RR=2.66; 95% CI, 1.49-4.77; P<0.01, I2=1%). CONCLUSION: Preoperative lymphopaenia is associated with death and complications more frequently, independent of the type of surgery. PROSPERO REGISTRY NUMBER: CRD42020190702.

NMDA receptor modulation of glutamate release in activated neutrophils.

BACKGROUND: Neutrophil depletion improves neurologic outcomes in experimental sepsis/brain injury. We hypothesized that neutrophils may exacerbate neuronal injury through the release of neurotoxic quantities of the neurotransmitter glutamate. METHODS: Real-time glutamate release by primary human neutrophils was determined using enzymatic biosensors. Bacterial and direct protein-kinase C (Phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate; PMA) activation of neutrophils in human whole blood, isolated neutrophils or human cell lines were compared in the presence/absence of N-Methyl-d-aspartic acid receptor (NMDAR) antagonists. Bacterial and direct activation of neutrophils from wild-type and transgenic murine neutrophils deficient in NMDAR-scaffolding proteins were compared using flow cytometry (phagocytosis, reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation) and real-time respirometry (oxygen consumption). FINDINGS: Both glutamate and the NMDAR co-agonist d-serine are rapidly released by neutrophils in response to bacterial and PMA-induced activation. Pharmacological NMDAR blockade reduced both the autocrine release of glutamate, d-serine and the respiratory burst by activated primary human neutrophils. A highly specific small-molecule inhibitor ZL006 that limits NMDAR-mediated neuronal injury also reduced ROS by activated neutrophils in a murine model of peritonitis, via uncoupling of the NMDAR GluN2B subunit from its' scaffolding protein, postsynaptic density protein-95 (PSD-95). Genetic ablation of PSD-95 reduced ROS production by activated murine neutrophils. Pharmacological blockade of the NMDAR GluN2B subunit reduced primary human neutrophil activation induced by Pseudomonas fluorescens, a glutamate-secreting Gram-negative bacillus closely related to pathogens that cause hospital-acquired infections. INTERPRETATION: These data suggest that release of glutamate by activated neutrophils augments ROS production in an autocrine manner via actions on NMDAR expressed by these cells. FUND: GLA: Academy Medical Sciences/Health Foundation Clinician Scientist. AVG is a Wellcome Trust Senior Research Fellow.

Autonomic regulation of systemic inflammation in humans: A multi-center, blinded observational cohort study.

OBJECTIVE: Experimental animal models demonstrate that autonomic activity regulates systemic inflammation. By contrast, human studies are limited in number and exclusively use heart rate variability (HRV) as an index of cardiac autonomic regulation. HRV measures are primarily dependent on, and need to be corrected for, heart rate. Thus, independent autonomic measures are required to confirm HRV-based findings. Here, the authors sought to replicate the findings of preceding HRV-based studies by using HRV-independent, exercise-evoked sympathetic and parasympathetic measures of cardiac autonomic regulation to examine the relationship between autonomic function and systemic inflammation. METHODS: Sympathetic function was assessed by measuring heart rate changes during unloaded pedaling prior to onset of exercise, divided into quartiles; an anticipatory heart rate (AHRR) rise during this period is evoked by mental stress in many individuals. Parasympathetic function was assessed by heart rate recovery (HRR) 60s after finishing cardiopulmonary exercise testing, divided into quartiles. Parasympathetic dysfunction was defined by delayed heart rate recovery (HRR) ≤12.beats.min-1, a threshold value associated with higher cardiovascular morbidity/mortality in the general population. Systemic inflammation was primarily assessed by neutrophil-lymphocyte ratio (NLR), where a ratio >4 is prognostic across several inflammatory diseases and correlates strongly with elevated plasma levels of pro-inflammatory cytokines. High-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hsCRP) was also measured. RESULTS: In 1624 subjects (65±14y; 67.9% male), lower HRR (impaired vagal activity) was associated with progressively higher NLR (p=0.004 for trend across quartiles). Delayed HRR, recorded in 646/1624 (39.6%) subjects, was associated with neutrophil-lymphocyte ratio >4 (relative risk: 1.43 (95%CI: 1.18-1.74); P=0.0003). Similar results were found for hsCRP (p=0.045). By contrast, AHRR was not associated with NLR (relative risk: 1.24 (95%CI: 0.94-1.65); P=0.14). CONCLUSIONS: Delayed HRR, a robust measure of parasympathetic dysfunction, is independently associated with leukocyte ratios indicative of systemic inflammation. These results further support a role for parasympathetic modulation of systemic inflammation in humans.

Mechanisms of CO2/H+ Sensitivity of Astrocytes.

Ventral regions of the medulla oblongata of the brainstem are populated by astrocytes sensitive to physiological changes in PCO2/[H+]. These astrocytes respond to decreases in pH with elevations in intracellular Ca2+ and facilitated exocytosis of ATP-containing vesicles. Released ATP propagates Ca2+ excitation among neighboring astrocytes and activates neurons of the brainstem respiratory network triggering adaptive increases in breathing. The mechanisms linking increases in extracellular and/or intracellular PCO2/[H+] with Ca2+ responses in chemosensitive astrocytes remain unknown. Fluorescent imaging of changes in [Na+]i and/or [Ca2+]i in individual astrocytes was performed in organotypic brainstem slice cultures and acute brainstem slices of adult rats. It was found that astroglial [Ca2+]i responses triggered by decreases in pH are preceded by Na+ entry, markedly reduced by inhibition of Na+/HCO3- cotransport (NBC) or Na+/Ca2+ exchange (NCX), and abolished in Na+-free medium or by combined NBC/NCX blockade. Acidification-induced [Ca2+]i responses were also dramatically reduced in brainstem astrocytes of mice deficient in the electrogenic Na+/HCO3- cotransporter NBCe1. Sensitivity of astrocytes to changes in pH was not affected by inhibition of Na+/H+ exchange or blockade of phospholipase C. These results suggest that in pH-sensitive astrocytes, acidification activates NBCe1, which brings Na+ inside the cell. Raising [Na+]i activates NCX to operate in a reverse mode, leading to Ca2+ entry followed by activation of downstream signaling pathways. Coupled NBC and NCX activities are, therefore, suggested to be responsible for functional CO2/H+ sensitivity of astrocytes that contribute to homeostatic regulation of brain parenchymal pH and control of breathing. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: Brainstem astrocytes detect physiological changes in pH, activate neurons of the neighboring respiratory network, and contribute to the development of adaptive respiratory responses to the increases in the level of blood and brain PCO2/[H+]. The mechanisms underlying astroglial pH sensitivity remained unknown and here we show that in brainstem astrocytes acidification activates Na+/HCO3- cotransport, which brings Na+ inside the cell. Raising [Na+]i activates the Na+/Ca2+ exchanger to operate in a reverse mode leading to Ca2+ entry. This identifies a plausible mechanism of functional CO2/H+ sensitivity of brainstem astrocytes, which play an important role in homeostatic regulation of brain pH and control of breathing.

Glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) mediates cardioprotection by remote ischaemic conditioning.

AIMS: Although the nature of the humoral factor which mediates cardioprotection established by remote ischaemic conditioning (RIc) remains unknown, parasympathetic (vagal) mechanisms appear to play a critical role. As the production and release of many gut hormones is modulated by the vagus nerve, here we tested the hypothesis that RIc cardioprotection is mediated by the actions of glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1). METHODS AND RESULTS: A rat model of myocardial infarction (coronary artery occlusion followed by reperfusion) was used. Remote ischaemic pre- (RIPre) or perconditioning (RIPer) was induced by 15 min occlusion of femoral arteries applied prior to or during the myocardial ischaemia. The degree of RIPre and RIPer cardioprotection was determined in conditions of cervical or subdiaphragmatic vagotomy, or following blockade of GLP-1 receptors (GLP-1R) using specific antagonist Exendin(9-39). Phosphorylation of PI3K/AKT and STAT3 was assessed. RIPre and RIPer reduced infarct size by ∼50%. In conditions of bilateral cervical or subdiaphragmatic vagotomy RIPer failed to establish cardioprotection. GLP-1R blockade abolished cardioprotection induced by either RIPre or RIPer. Exendin(9-39) also prevented RIPre-induced AKT phosphorylation. Cardioprotection induced by GLP-1R agonist Exendin-4 was preserved following cervical vagotomy, but was abolished in conditions of M3 muscarinic receptor blockade. CONCLUSIONS: These data strongly suggest that GLP-1 functions as a humoral factor of remote ischaemic conditioning cardioprotection. This phenomenon requires intact vagal innervation of the visceral organs and recruitment of GLP-1R-mediated signalling. Cardioprotection induced by GLP-1R activation is mediated by a mechanism involving M3 muscarinic receptors.

Molecular Mechanisms Linking Autonomic Dysfunction and Impaired Cardiac Contractility in Critical Illness.

OBJECTIVES: Molecular mechanisms linking autonomic dysfunction with poorer clinical outcomes in critical illness remain unclear. We hypothesized that baroreflex dysfunction alone is sufficient to cause cardiac impairment through neurohormonal activation of (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate oxidase dependent) oxidative stress resulting in increased expression of G-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2, a key negative regulator of cardiac function. DESIGN: Laboratory/clinical investigations. SETTING: University laboratory/medical centers. SUBJECTS: Adult rats; wild-type/nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate oxidase subunit-2-deficient mice; elective surgical patients. INTERVENTIONS: Cardiac performance was assessed by transthoracic echocardiography following experimental baroreflex dysfunction (sino-aortic denervation) in rats and mice. Immunoblots assessed G-protein-coupled receptor recycling proteins expression in rodent cardiomyocytes and patient mononuclear leukocytes. In surgical patients, heart rate recovery after cardiopulmonary exercise testing, time/frequency measures of parasympathetic variables were related to the presence/absence of baroreflex dysfunction (defined by spontaneous baroreflex sensitivity of <6 ms mm Hg). The associations of baroreflex dysfunction with intraoperative cardiac function and outcomes were assessed. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Experimental baroreflex dysfunction in rats and mice resulted in impaired cardiac contractility and upregulation of G-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2 expression. In mice, genetic deficiency of gp91 nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate oxidase subunit-2 prevented upregulation of G-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2 expression in conditions of baroreflex dysfunction and preserved cardiac function. Baroreflex dysfunction was present in 81 of 249 patients (32.5%) and was characterized by lower parasympathetic tone and increased G-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2 expression in mononuclear leukocytes. Baroreflex dysfunction in patients was also associated with impaired intraoperative cardiac contractility. Critical illness and mortality were more frequent in surgical patients with baroreflex dysfunction (relative risk, 1.66 [95% CI, 1.16-2.39]; p = 0.006). CONCLUSIONS: Reduced baroreflex sensitivity is associated with nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate oxidase subunit-2-mediated upregulation of G-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2 expression in cardiomyocytes and impaired cardiac contractility. Autonomic dysfunction predisposes patients to the development of critical illness and increases mortality.

Metabolic dysfunction in lymphocytes promotes postoperative morbidity.

Perioperative lymphopenia has been linked with an increased risk of postoperative infectious complications, but the mechanisms remain unclear. We tested the hypothesis that bioenergetic dysfunction is an important mechanism underlying lymphopenia, impaired functionality and infectious complications. In two cohorts of patients (61-82 years old) undergoing orthopaedic joint replacement (n=417 and 328, respectively), we confirmed prospectively that preoperative lymphopenia (≤1.3 x 10(9)·l(-1); <20% white cell count; prevalence 15-18%) was associated with infectious complications (relative risk 1.5 (95% confidence interval 1.1-2.0); P=0.008) and prolonged hospital stay. Lymphocyte respirometry, mitochondrial bioenergetics and function were assessed (n=93 patients). Postoperative lymphocytes showed a median 43% fall (range: 26-65%; P=0.029; n=13 patients) in spare respiratory capacity, the extra capacity available to produce energy in response to stress. This was accompanied by reduced glycolytic capacity. A similar hypometabolic phenotype was observed in lymphocytes sampled preoperatively from chronically lymphopenic patients (n=21). This hypometabolic phenotype was associated with functional lymphocyte impairment including reduced T-cell proliferation, lower intracellular cytokine production and excess apoptosis induced by a range of common stressors. Glucocorticoids, which are ubiquitously elevated for a prolonged period postoperatively, generated increased levels of mitochondrial reactive oxygen species, activated caspase-1 and mature interleukin (IL)-1ß in human lymphocytes, suggesting inflammasome activation. mRNA transcription of the NLRP1 inflammasome was increased in lymphocytes postoperatively. Genetic ablation of the murine NLRP3 inflammasome failed to prevent glucocorticoid-induced lymphocyte apoptosis and caspase-1 activity, but increased NLRP1 protein expression. Our findings suggest that the hypometabolic phenotype observed in chronically lymphopenic patients and/or acquired postoperatively increases the risk of postoperative infection through glucocorticoid activation of caspase-1 via the NLRP1 inflammasome.

Man is the new mouse: Elective surgery as a key translational model for multi-organ dysfunction and sepsis.

Translational research in critically ill human patients presents many methodological challenges. Diagnostic uncertainty, coupled with poorly defined comorbidities, make the identification of a suitable control population for case-control investigations an arguably insurmountable challenge. Healthy volunteer experiments using endotoxin infusion as an inflammatory model are methodologically robust, but fail to replicate the onset of, and diverse therapeutic interventions associated with, sepsis/trauma. Animal models are also limited by many of these issues. Major elective surgery addresses many of these shortfalls and offers a key model for exploring the human biology underlying the sepsis syndrome. Surgery triggers highly conserved features of the human inflammatory response that are common to both tissue damage and infection. Surgical patients sustain a predictable and relatively high incidence of sepsis, particularly within the 'higher risk' group. The collection of preoperative samples enables each patient to act as their own control. Thus, the surgical model offers unique and elegant experimental design features that provide an important translational bridge between the basic biological understanding afforded by animal laboratory models and the de novo presentation of human sepsis.

Uncontrolled sepsis: a systematic review of translational immunology studies in intensive care medicine.

BACKGROUND: The design of clinical immunology studies in sepsis presents several fundamental challenges to improving the translational understanding of pathologic mechanisms. We undertook a systematic review of bed-to-benchside studies to test the hypothesis that variable clinical design methodologies used to investigate immunologic function in sepsis contribute to apparently conflicting laboratory data, and identify potential alternatives that overcome various obstacles to improve experimental design. METHODS: We performed a systematic review of the design methodology employed to study neutrophil function (respiratory burst), monocyte endotoxin tolerance and lymphocyte apoptosis in the intensive care setting, over the past 15 years. We specifically focussed on how control samples were defined, taking into account age, gender, ethnicity, concomitant therapies, timing of sample collection and the criteria used to diagnose sepsis. RESULTS: We identified 57 eligible studies, the majority of which (74%) used case-control methodology. Healthy volunteers represented the control population selected in 83% of studies. Comprehensive demographic data on age, gender and ethnicity were provided in ≤48% of case control studies. Documentation of diseases associated with immunosuppression, malignancy and immunomodulatory therapies was rare. Less than half (44%) of studies undertook independent adjudication for the diagnosis of sepsis while 68% provided microbiological data. The timing of sample collection was defined by highly variable clinical criteria. By contrast, surgical studies avoided many such confounders, although only one study in surgical patients monitored the study group for development of sepsis. CONCLUSIONS: We found several important and common limitations in the clinical design of translational immunologic studies in human sepsis. Major elective surgery overcame many of these methodological limitations. The failure of adequate clinical design in mechanistic studies may contribute to the lack of translational therapeutic progress in intensive care medicine.

E2F-dependent induction of p14ARF during cell cycle re-entry in human T cells.

The ARF protein, encoded by alternate exon usage within the CDKN2A locus, provides a link between the retinoblastoma (pRb) and p53 tumor suppressor pathways. Agents that disable pRb or otherwise impinge on the E2F family of transcription factors induce expression of ARF, resulting in stabilization of p53 and activation of p53-regulated genes. However, in some cell types ARF is not induced upon cell cycle re-entry, as expected of a conventional E2F target gene, leading to the suggestion that the ARF promoter only responds to supra-physiological or aberrant levels of E2F. These properties have recently been attributed to a variant E2F binding site but attempts to map specific response elements within the ARF promoter have generally yielded confusing answers. Here we show that in IL2-dependent T-lymphocytes, ARF expression is induced as cells progress from G(0) into S phase, in parallel with other bona fide E2F target genes. This is accompanied by increased association of E2F1 with the endogenous ARF promoter. Our findings suggest that the ability of ARF to register normal proliferative cues depends on the levels of E2F generated in different settings and argue against the idea that it reacts exclusively to oncogenic signals.