Revisiting the Reactivity of the Dismissed Hydrogen Atom Transfer Catalyst Succinimide-N-oxyl.

Phthalimide-N-oxyl (PINO) and related radicals are promising catalysts for C-H functionalization reactions. To date, only a small number of N-oxyl derivatives have demonstrated improved activities over PINO. We postulate that the lack of success in identifying superior catalysts is associated not only with challenges in the design and synthesis of new structures, but also the way catalysts are evaluated and utilized. Catalyst evaluation typically relies on the use of chemical oxidants to generate N-oxyl radicals from their parent N-hydroxy compounds. Herein we provide an example where a potential-controlled electrochemical analysis reveals that succinimide-N-oxyl (SINO) compares favorably to PINO as a hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) catalyst-in contrast to previous claims based on other approaches. Our efforts to understand the basis for the greater reactivity of SINO relative to PINO have underscored that the HAT kinetics are significantly influenced by factors beyond changes in thermodynamics. This is perhaps best illustrated by the similar reactivity of tetrachloro-PINO and SINO despite the latter engaging in substantially more exergonic reactions. The key role of HAT transition state (TS) polarization prompted the design and initial characterization of a chlorinated SINO derivative, which we found to be the most reactive N-oxyl HAT catalyst reported to date.

Non-Tertiary Alkyl Substituents Enhance High-Temperature Radical Trapping by Phenothiazine and Phenoxazine Antioxidants.

Radical-trapping antioxidants (RTAs) are an indispensable class of additive used to preserve hydrocarbon materials from oxidative degradation. Materials that are regularly subjected to elevated temperatures where autoxidation is self-initiated (i.e., >120 °C) require high concentrations of RTA for protection. Not only is this costly, but it can negatively impact material performance. Herein we show that inhibition of the autoxidation of a model hydrocarbon (n-hexadecane) by phenothiazine (PTZ) at ≥160 °C can be greatly enhanced by the incorporation of either 1° or 2° alkyl substituents in the 3- and/or 7-positions of the scaffold. Structure-reactivity studies, product analyses and computations suggest that this results from hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) from the benzylic carbon of these alkyl substituents in the PTZ-derived aminyl radical intermediate. The resultant iminoquinone methide can then undergo further radical-trapping reactions, depending on the nature of the alkyl substituent. Similar structure-reactivity relationships are observed for the phenoxazine (PNX) scaffold. These results not only have significant implications for the design and development of new high-temperature RTA technology, but also for understanding aminic RTA activity at elevated temperatures. Specifically, they suggest that a stoichiometric model better accounts for the RTA activity of aromatic amines in saturated hydrocarbons than the widely accepted catalytic model.

Attenuating N-Oxyl Decomposition for Improved Hydrogen Atom Transfer Catalysts.

The design of N-oxyl hydrogen atom transfer catalysts has proven challenging to date. Previous efforts have focused on the functionalization of the archetype, phthalimide-N-oxyl. Driven in part by the limited options for modification of this structure, this strategy has provided only modest improvements in reactivity and/or solubility. Our previous mechanistic efforts suggested that while the electron-withdrawing carbonyls of the phthalimide are necessary to maximize the O-H bond dissociation enthalpy of the HAT product hydroxylamine and overall reaction thermodynamics, they undergo nucleophilic substitution leading to catalyst decomposition. In an attempt to minimize this vulnerability, we report the characterization of N-oxyl catalysts wherein the aryl ring in PINO is replaced with the combination of a substituted heteroatom and quaternary carbon. By rendering one carbonyl carbon less electrophilic and the other less sterically accessible, the corresponding N1-aryl-hydantoin-N3-oxyl radical showed significantly higher stability than PINO as well as a modest improvement in reactivity. This proof-of-principle in new scaffold design may accelerate future HAT catalyst discovery and development.

Intrinsic and Extrinsic Limitations to the Design and Optimization of Inhibitors of Lipid Peroxidation and Associated Cell Death.

The archetype inhibitors of ferroptosis, ferrostatin-1 and liproxstatin-1, were identified via high-throughput screening of compound libraries for cytoprotective activity. These compounds have been shown to inhibit ferroptosis by suppressing propagation of lipid peroxidation, the radical chain reaction that drives cell death. Herein, we present the first rational design and optimization of ferroptosis inhibitors targeting this mechanism of action. Engaging the most potent radical-trapping antioxidant (RTA) scaffold known (phenoxazine, PNX), and its less reactive chalcogen cousin (phenothiazine, PTZ), we explored structure-reactivity-potency relationships to elucidate the intrinsic and extrinsic limitations of this approach. The results delineate the roles of inherent RTA activity, H-bonding interactions with phospholipid headgroups, and lipid solubility in determining activity/potency. We show that modifications which increase inherent RTA activity beyond that of the parent compounds do not substantially improve RTA kinetics in phospholipids or potency in cells, while modifications that decrease intrinsic RTA activity lead to corresponding erosions to both. The apparent "plateau" of RTA activity in phospholipid bilayers (kinh ∼ 2 × 105 M-1 s-1) and cell potency (EC50 ∼ 4 nM) may be the result of diffusion-controlled reactivity between the RTA and lipid-peroxyl radicals and/or the potential limitations on RTA turnover/regeneration by endogenous reductants. The metabolic stability of selected derivatives was assessed to identify a candidate for in vivo experimentation as a proof-of-concept. This PNX-derivative demonstrated stability in mouse liver microsomes comparable to liproxstatin-1 and was successfully used to suppress acute renal failure in mice brought on by tissue-specific inactivation of the ferroptosis regulator GPX4.

Temperature-dependence of radical-trapping activity of phenoxazine, phenothiazine and their aza-analogues clarifies the way forward for new antioxidant design.

The prediction and/or rationalization of diarylamine radical-trapping antioxidant (RTA) activity at the elevated temperatures where they are most useful presents a significant challenge, precluding the development of new technology. Whilst structure-activity relationships at ambient temperatures are well established, their predictive capacity at elevated temperatures is poor due to competing reactions. A striking example involves phenoxazine, which is a superior RTA relative to its sulfur analog phenothiazine at ambient temperature (e.g. k = 3.9 × 107 vs. 7.6 × 106 M-1 s-1 at 37 °C, respectively), but is demonstrably inferior at elevated temperatures. Despite being inherently less oxidizable in electrochemical experiments and high-accuracy computations, phenoxazine is more rapidly consumed than phenothiazine in autoxidations at 160 °C - a result which we attribute to a lower reorganization energy barrier to oxidation. Given these observations, we surmised that incorporation of an electronegative N-atom into the phenoxazine ring system would decrease the driving force for oxidation and 'rescue' its activity. Indeed, this was found to be the case for nitrogen incorporation at any position, regardless of the impact on the inherent RTA activity. Analogous experiments were carried out on phenothiazines into which nitrogen atoms were incorporated, revealing little benefit at 160 °C. These results suggest that for highly reactive diarylamines (i.e. those with k > 106 M-1 s-1), further enhancements in reactivity do not materially improve their ability to inhibit hydrocarbon autoxidation at elevated temperatures. Instead, their stability to one-electron oxidation determines their efficacy.

Mechanism of Electrochemical Generation and Decomposition of Phthalimide-N-oxyl.

Phthalimide N-oxyl (PINO) is a potent hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) catalyst that can be generated electrochemically from N-hydroxyphthalimide (NHPI). However, catalyst decomposition has limited its application. This paper details mechanistic studies of the generation and decomposition of PINO under electrochemical conditions. Voltammetric data, observations from bulk electrolysis, and computational studies suggest two primary aspects. First, base-promoted formation of PINO from NHPI occurs via multiple-site concerted proton-electron transfer (MS-CPET). Second, PINO decomposition occurs by at least two second-order paths, one of which is greatly enhanced by base. Optimal catalytic efficiency in PINO-catalyzed oxidations occurs in the presence of bases whose corresponding conjugate acids have pKa's in the range of ∼11-15, which strikes a balance between promoting PINO formation and minimizing its decay.

Beyond DPPH: Use of Fluorescence-Enabled Inhibited Autoxidation to Predict Oxidative Cell Death Rescue.

"Antioxidant activity" is an often invoked, but generally poorly characterized, molecular property. Several assays are available to determine antioxidant activity, the most popular of which is based upon the ability of a putative antioxidant to reduce 2,2-diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl. Here, we show that the results of this assay do not correlate with the potency of putative antioxidants as inhibitors of ferroptosis, the oxidative cell death modality associated with (phospho)lipid peroxidation. We subsequently describe our efforts to develop an approach that quantifies the reactivity of putative antioxidants with the (phospho)lipid peroxyl radicals that propagate (phospho)lipid peroxidation (dubbed FENIX [fluorescence-enabled inhibited autoxidation]). The results obtained with FENIX afford an excellent correlation with anti-ferroptotic potency, which facilitates mechanistic characterization of ferroptosis inhibitors, and reveals the importance of H-bonding interactions between antioxidant and phospholipid that underlie both the lackluster antioxidant activity of phenols under physiologically relevant conditions and the emergence of arylamines as inhibitors of choice.

Phenoxazine: A Privileged Scaffold for Radical-Trapping Antioxidants.

Diphenylamines are widely used to protect petroleum-derived products from autoxidation. Their efficacy as radical-trapping antioxidants (RTAs) relies on a balance of fast H-atom transfer kinetics and stability to one-electron oxidation by peroxidic species. Both H-atom transfer and one-electron oxidation are enhanced by substitution with electron-donating substituents, such as the S-atom in phenothiazines, another important class of RTA. Herein we report the results of our investigations of the RTA activity of the structurally related, but essentially ignored, phenoxazines. We find that the H-atom transfer reactivity of substituted phenoxazines follows an excellent Evans-Polanyi correlation spanning kinh = 4.5 × 106 M-1 s-1 and N-H BDE = 77.4 kcal mol-1 for 3-CN,7-NO2-phenoxazine to kinh = 6.6 × 108 M-1 s-1 and N-H BDE = 71.8 kcal mol-1 for 3,7-(OMe)2-phenoxazine (37 °C). The reactivity of the latter compound is the greatest of any RTA ever reported and is likely to represent a reaction without an enthalpic barrier since log A for this reaction is likely ∼8.5. The very high reactivity of most of the phenoxazines studied required the determination of their kinetic parameters by inhibited autoxidations in the presence of a very strong H-bonding cosolvent (DMSO), which slowed the observed rates by up to 2 orders of magnitude by dynamically reducing the equilibrium concentration of (free) phenoxazine as an H-atom donor. Despite their remarkably high reactivity toward peroxyl radicals, the phenoxazines were found to be comparatively stable to one-electron oxidation relative to diphenylamines and phenothiazines (E° ranging from 0.59 to 1.38 V vs NHE). Thus, phenoxazines with comparable oxidative stability to commonly used diphenylamine and phenothiazine RTAs had significantly greater reactivity (by up to 2 orders of magnitude). Computations suggest that this remarkable balance in H-atom transfer kinetics and stability to one-electron oxidation results from the ability of the bridging oxygen atom in phenoxazine to serve as both a π-electron donor to stabilize the aminyl radical and σ-electron acceptor to destabilize the aminyl radical cation. Perhaps most excitingly, phenoxazines have "non-classical" RTA activity, where they trap >2 peroxyl radicals each, at ambient temperatures.