Synthetic chiral molecular nanographenes: the key figure of the racemization barrier.

Chirality is one of the most intriguing concepts of chemistry, involving living systems and, more recently, materials science. In particular, the bottom-up synthesis of molecular nanographenes endowed with one or several chiral elements is a current challenge for the chemical community. The wilful introduction of defects in the sp2 honeycomb lattice of molecular nanographenes allows the preparation of chiral molecules with tuned band-gaps and chiroptical properties. There are two requirements that a system must fulfill to be chiral: (i) lack of inversion elements (planes or inversion centres) and (ii) to be configurationally stable. The first condition is inherently established by the symmetry group of the structure, however, the limit between conformational and configurational isomers is not totally clear. In this feature article, the chirality and dynamics of synthetic molecular nanographenes, with special emphasis on their racemization barriers and, therefore, the stability of their chiroptical properties are discussed. The general features of nanographenes and their bottom-up synthesis, including the main defects inducing chirality in molecular nanographenes are firstly discussed. In this regard, the most common topological defects of molecular NGs as well as the main techniques used for determining their energy barriers are presented. Then, the manuscript is structured according to the dynamics of molecular nanographenes, classifying them in four main groups, depending on their respective isomerization barriers, as flexible, detectable, isolable and rigid nanographenes. In these sections, the different strategies used to increase the isomerization barrier of chiral molecular nanographenes that lead to configurationally stable nanographenes with defined chiroptical properties are discussed.

Chiral Molecular Carbon Nanostructures.

Chirality is a fascinating property present in naturally occurring and artificial molecules and materials, observable as chiroptical behavior. The emerging area of carbon nanostructures has undergone tremendous development, with a wide variety of carbon nanoforms reported over the last two decades. However, despite interest in merging chirality and nanocarbons, this has been successfully achieved only in empty fullerenes, whereas in other kinds of fullerenes or carbon nanostructures such as carbon nanotubes, graphene, and graphene quantum dots (GQDs), to name the most popular systems, it is almost unknown. Therefore, controlling chirality in carbon nanostructures currently represents a major challenge for the chemical community. In this Account, we show our progress in the synthesis of chiral molecular carbon nanostructures, namely, metallofullerenes, endohedral fullerenes, GQDs, and curved molecular nanographenes, by using asymmetric catalysis and both top-down and bottom-up chemical approaches. Furthermore, we bring in a new family of lesser-known molecular chiral bilayer nanographenes, where chirality is introduced from the starting helicene moiety and a single enantiomer of the nanographene is synthesized. Some important landmarks in the development of chiral molecular carbon nanostructures shown in this Account are the application of synthesis-tailored, enantiomerically pure metallofullerenes as catalysts for hydrogen transfer reactions and the use of endohedral fullerenes to determine the effect of the incarcerated molecule in the carbon cage on the cis-trans stereoisomerization of optically active pendent moieties. Furthermore, the first top-down synthesis of chiral GQDs by functionalization with chiral alcohols is also presented. An emerging alternative to GQDs, when the desire for purity and atomistic control outweighs the cost of multistep synthesis, is the bottom-up approach, in which molecular nanographenes are formed in precise sizes and shapes and enantiomeric control is feasible. In this regard, a singular and amazing example is given by our synthesis of a single enantiomer of the first chiral bilayer nanographene, which formally represents a new family of molecular nanographenes with chirality controlled and maintained throughout their syntheses. The aforementioned synthetic chiral nanostructures represent groundbreaking nanocarbon systems where chirality is a further dimension of structural control, paving the way to a new scenario for carbon nanoforms in which chirality selection determines the properties of these novel carbon-based materials. Fine-tuning of such properties is envisioned to impact biomedical and materials science applications.

Site-selective Synthesis of ß-[70]PCBM-like Fullerenes: Efficient Application in Perovskite Solar Cells.

We report on the site-selective synthesis of PCBM-like [70]fullerene site-isomers, where the elusive ß-site-isomers are, for the first time, the major product in a (cyclo)addition chemical reaction involving [70]fullerene. The reaction involves an straightforward cyclopropanation of [70]fullerene from sulfonium salts, affording a mixture of α and ß site-isomers in good yields. Amazingly, the preference for the α- or ß-site-isomer can be efficiently controlled by means of the solvent polarity! DFT theoretical calculations (DMF and toluene) nicely predict that, although the formation of the α-adduct is, as expected, thermodynamically favored, the selectivity of the process is determined by the energy difference of the respective transition states. Furthermore, the employ of α or/and ß site-isomers, as pure materials or as a mixture of them, used as templating agent, has been evaluated in perovskite solar cells. The positive influence of the [70]fullerenes by passivating the voids/pin-holes and/or deep slits, is reflected in highly efficient and stable bulk heterojunction perovskite solar cells, whose performance (around 20 %) is slightly but consistently depending on the isomeric fullerene composition. These experimental findings pave the way to investigate a new reactivity on C70 and to explore the properties of the less-known ß-derivatives.

Stereocontrolled Photoinduced Electron Transfer in Metal-Fullerene Hybrids.

Photoinduced electron transfer in transition-metal complexes linked to a fullerene moiety is of increasing interest. Recently, several stereoisomers of an Ir-complex exhibiting configurational stability at metal center, which does not undergo epimerization have been synthesized (Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017, 56, 2136). The presence of multiple electron donor and acceptor sites located at opposite ends with respect to the metallic center creates the prerequisites for the formation of entirely different charge transfer (CT) states. Here we report the results of quantum mechanical calculations and detailed analysis of excited-state properties for all stereoisomers of the junction. We found that the stereoisomers demonstrate clearly different CT properties by photoexcitation. The found photo-stereospecific effects can be used to design new hybrids with a different type of photoinduced CT state, exhibiting dissimilar activity in photocatalysis.

Reversible Stereodivergent Cycloaddition of Racemic Helicenes to [60]Fullerene: A Chiral Resolution Strategy.

[60]Fullerene and its rarely explored reversible covalent chemistry have been harnessed as an efficient alternative for the chiral resolution of racemates. By using only catalytic amounts of chiral agents, stereodivergent 1,3-dipolar cycloadditions of racemic helicenes onto [60]fullerene were carried out. The formed helicene/fullerene diastereomers were easily separated by conventional chromatography, and afterward, a simple catalyzed 1,3-dipolar retro-cycloaddition afforded helicene starting materials in high optical purity.

On the regioselectivity of the Diels-Alder cycloaddition to C60 in high spin states.

Controlling the regioselectivity in the exohedral functionalization of fullerenes and endohedral metallofullerenes is essential to produce specific desired fullerene derivatives. In this work, using density functional theory (DFT) calculations, we show that the regioselectivity of the Diels-Alder (DA) cycloaddition of cyclopentadiene to 2S+1C60 changes from the usual [6,6] addition in the singlet ground state to the [5,6] attack in high spin states of C60. Changes in the aromaticity of the five- and six-membered rings when going from singlet to high spin C60 provide a rationale to understand this regioselectivity change. Experimentally, however, we find that the DA cycloaddition of isoindene to triplet C60 yields the usual [6,6] adduct. Further DFT calculations and computational analysis give an explanation to this unanticipated experimental result by showing the presence of an intersystem crossing close to the formed triplet biradical intermediate.

Effect of incarcerated HF on the exohedral chemical reactivity of HF@C60.

The first chemical modification on the brand new endohedral HF@C60 is reported. In particular, the isomerization from optically pure (2S,5S)-cis-pyrrolidino[3,4:1,2][60]fullerene 2b to (2S,5R)-trans-pyrrolidino[3,4:1,2][60]fullerene 2b has been studied and compared with empty C60 (2a) and endohedral H2O@C60 (3). The comparative study shows a kinetic order for the isomerization process of H2O@C60 > HF@C60 > C60, thus confirming the effect of the incarcerated species on the zwitterionic intermediate stability.

Catalytic Stereodivergent Synthesis of Steroid-Fulleropyrrolidine Hybrids.

The diastereoselective synthesis of cis and trans steroid-fulleropyrrolidines hybrids by reaction of N-metalated azomethine ylides [Cu(II) or Ag(I)] with the appropriate chiral ligand and C60 is described. The experimental findings reveal that the azomethine ylide stabilized by an allylic group cycloadds to [60]fullerene in an efficient manner and with a good diastereomeric excess. Furthermore, the new generated stereocenters are fully controlled by the catalytic systems used without being influenced by the chirality of the steroid. Interestingly, by this synthetic methodology the each one of the four possible stereoisomers have efficiently been obtained and characterized by CD spectra.

Fullerenes for catalysis: metallofullerenes in hydrogen transfer reactions.

[60]Fullerene hybrids have successfully been used as catalysts in hydrogen transfer reactions, namely ketone reduction and N-alkylation with alcohols. Due to their poor solubility in polar solvents, these hybrids behave as homogeneous/heterogeneous catalysts that can be mechanically separated and reused several times while the final products do not need chromatographic separation.

Stereodivergent-at-Metal Synthesis of [60]Fullerene Hybrids.

Chiral fullerene-metal hybrids with complete control over the four stereogenic centers, including the absolute configuration of the metal atom, have been synthesized for the first time. The stereochemistry of the four chiral centers formed during [60]fullerene functionalization is the result of both the chiral catalysts employed and the diastereoselective addition of the metal complexes used (iridium, rhodium, or ruthenium). DFT calculations underpin the observed configurational stability at the metal center, which does not undergo an epimerization process.

Photochemical site-selective synthesis of [70]methanofullerenes.

Methanofullerenes such as the well-known [70]PCBM are commonly synthesized under harsh conditions to obtain the product as a mixture of site-isomers (namely α, ß and minor γ) due to the D5h symmetry of the C70 cage. We report the first site-selective synthesis of [70]methanofullerenes under light irradiation and low temperatures, thus avoiding time-consuming and highly expensive HPLC separations. Pure major site-isomers α-[70]PCBM and α-[70]DPM have been thus efficiently prepared including the crystal structure of 5b. Photovoltaic preliminary results revealed a slightly beneficial performance for α-pure [70]PCBM site-isomer devices.

Cyclobuteno[60]fullerenes as Efficient n-Type Organic Semiconductors.

Cyclobuteno[3,4:1,2][60]fullerenes have been prepared in a straightforward manner by a simple reaction between [60]fullerene and readily available allenoates or alkynoates as organic reagents under basic and mild conditions. The chemical structure of the new modified fullerenes has been determined by standard spectroscopic techniques and confirmed by X-ray diffraction analysis. Some of these new fullerene derivatives exhibit a remarkable intrinsic electron mobility (determined by using flash-photolysis time-resolved microwave conductivity (FP-TRMC) measurements), which surpasses that of the well-known phenyl-C61-butyric acid methyl ester, thus behaving as promising n-type organic semiconductors.

Reaction of diazocompounds with C70: unprecedented synthesis and characterization of isomeric [5,6]-fulleroids.

The synthesis of a variety of PCBM-type [5,6]-fulleroids and their further highly selective photoisomerization to the respective [6,6]-methanofullerenes is presented. Interestingly, the chemical reactivity of [5,6]-fulleroids reveals the same trend (a > b > c > d) to that observed for pristine C70 (α > ß > γ > δ).

Competitive retro-cycloaddition reactions in heterocyclic fullerene bis-adducts ions: selective removal of the heterocyclic moieties.

RATIONALE: We have investigated the fragmentation reactions of ions from bis-adducts containing isoxazolino-, pyrrolidino- and methanofullerene moieties. METHODS: The fragmentation reactions induced by collision-induced dissociation (CID) of ions generated under electrospray ionization (ESI) in positive and negative modes of detection using an ion-trap spectrometer have been investigated. RESULTS: The competitive retro-cycloaddition process between isoxazoline and pyrrolidine rings fused to [60]fullerene reveals that it is strongly dependent on the experimental negative or positive ESI experimental conditions. Thus, whereas retro-cycloaddition reaction is favored in the pyrrolidine ring under negative conditions, the protonation occurring on the nitrogen atom of the pyrrolidine ring under positive conditions precludes its retro-cycloaddition and, therefore, only the isoxazoline ring undergoes the retro-cycloaddition process. The obtained experimental results are different from those reported when the reaction is carried out under thermal conditions. Competitive retro-cycloaddition reactions of isoxazolino- and methanofullerenes show that the heterocyclic ring undergoes cycloelimination, leaving the methanofullerene moiety unchanged. In this case, the same selectivity is observed under thermal and gas-phase conditions. CONCLUSIONS: The observed selectivity in the heterocyclic removal in these [60]fullerene derivatives is reversed from negative conditions (radical anions) to positive conditions (protonated molecules). Moreover, the retro-cycloaddition reaction behaves differently under spectrometric and thermal conditions.

Charge transport in C60-based dumbbell-type molecules: mechanically induced switching between two distinct conductance states.

Single molecule charge transport characteristics of buckminsterfullerene-capped symmetric fluorene-based dumbbell-type compound 1 were investigated by scanning tunneling microscopy break junction (STM-BJ), current sensing atomic force microscopy break junction (CS-AFM-BJ), and mechanically controlled break junction (MCBJ) techniques, under ambient conditions. We also show that compound 1 is able to form highly organized defect-free surface adlayers, allowing the molecules on the surface to be addressed specifically. Two distinct single molecule conductance states (called high G(H)(1) and low G(L)(1)) were observed, depending on the pressure exerted by the probe on the junction, thus allowing molecule 1 to function as a mechanically driven molecular switch. These two distinct conductance states were attributed to the electron tunneling through the buckminsterfullerene anchoring group and fully extended molecule 1, respectively. The assignment of conductance features to these configurations was further confirmed by control experiments with asymmetrically designed buckminsterfullerene derivative 2 as well as pristine buckminsterfullerene 3, both lacking the G(L) feature.

Enantiospecific cis-trans isomerization in chiral fulleropyrrolidines: hydrogen-bonding assistance in the carbanion stabilization in H2O@C60.

The stereochemical outcome of cis-trans isomerization of optically pure [60], [70], and endohedral H2O@C60 fulleropyrrolidines reveals that the electronic nature of substituents, fullerene size, and surprisingly the incarcerated water molecule plays a crucial role in this rearrangement process. Theoretical DFT calculations are in very good agreement with the experimental findings. On the basis of the experimental results and computational calculations, a plausible reaction mechanism involving the hydrogen-bonding assistance of the inner water molecule in the carbanion stabilization of endofullerene is proposed.

Organocatalysis for new chiral fullerene-based materials.

The cycloaddition reaction of 3-alkynoates to fullerenes has been studied under different experimental conditions and phosphines in the presence of a base which is responsible for the previous isomerization to the corresponding allenoate. The versatility of this reaction allows chiral fullerenes to be obtained at will, thus opening up a new avenue in the use of enantiomerically pure carbon nanostructures in materials science.

Chiral fullerenes from asymmetric catalysis.

Fullerenes are among the most studied molecules during the last three decades, and therefore, a huge number of chemical reactions have been tested on these new carbon allotropes. However, the aim of most of the reactions carried out on fullerenes has been to afford chemically modified fullerenes that are soluble in organic solvents or even water in the search for different mechanical, optical, or electronic properties. Therefore, although a lot of effort has been devoted to the chemical functionalization of these molecular allotropes of carbon, important aspects in the chemistry of fullerenes have not been properly addressed. In particular, the synthesis of chiral fullerenes at will in an efficient manner using asymmetric catalysis has not been previously addressed in fullerene science. Thus, despite the fact that the chirality of fullerenes has always been considered a fundamental issue, the lack of a general stereoselective synthetic methodology has restricted the use of enantiopure fullerene derivatives, which have usually been obtained only after highly expensive HPLC isolation on specific chiral columns or prepared from a pool of chiral starting materials. In this Account, we describe the first stereodivergent catalytic enantioselective syntheses in fullerene science, which have allowed the highly efficient synthesis of enantiomerically pure derivatives with total control of the stereochemical result using metallic catalysts and/or organocatalysts under very mild conditions. Density functional theory calculations strongly support the experimental findings for the assignment of the absolute configuration of the new stereocenters, which has also been ascertained by application of the sector rule and single-crystal X-ray diffraction. The use of the curved double bond of fullerene cages as a two-π-electron component in a variety of stereoselective cycloaddition reactions represents a challenging goal considering that, in contrast to most of the substituted olefins used in these reactions, pristine fullerene is a noncoordinating dipolarophile. The aforementioned features make the study of stereoselective 1,3-dipolar cycloadditions onto fullerenes a unique scenario to shed light onto important mechanistic aspects. On the other hand, the availability of achiral starting materials as well as the use of nonexpensive asymmetric catalysts should provide access to chiral fullerenes and their further application in a variety of different fields. In this regard, in addition to biomedical applications, chiral fullerenes are of interest in less-studied areas such as materials science, organic electronics, and nanoscience, where control of the order and morphology at the nanometer scale are critical issues for achieving better device efficiencies.

Small molecule BHJ solar cells based on DPP(TBFu)2 and diphenylmethanofullerenes (DPM): linking morphology, transport, recombination and crystallinity.

The effect of alkyl chains in substituted diphenylmethano[70]fullerenes (C70-DPM) on the device characteristics of DPP(TBFu)2 small molecule-based bulk heterojunction (BHJ) organic solar cell devices is investigated. By measuring charge carrier mobilities as well as the morphology and crystallinity of each device we have been able to understand and explain the differences found between solar cells made with the different C70-DPM fullerenes despite the general lack of simple relationships between the molecular structure, orbital level positioning and power conversion efficiency. Our study then concludes with some general rules for the future design of acceptors for DPP(TBFu)2 containing photoactive layers in the search for efficient organic solar cells.

Does a cyclopropane ring enhance the electronic communication in dumbbell-type C60 dimers?

Two C60 dumbbell molecules have been synthesized containing either cyclopropane or pyrrolidine rings connecting two fullerenes to a central fluorene core. A combination of spectroscopic techniques reveals that the cyclopropane dumbbell possesses better electronic communication between the fullerenes and the fluorene. This observation is underpinned by DFT transport calculations, which show that the cyclopropane dumbbell gives a higher calculated single-molecule conductance, a result of an energetically lower-lying LUMO level that extends deeper into the backbone. This strengthens the idea that cyclopropane behaves as a quasi-double bond.