Assessing Surgical Task Load and Performance: A Comparison of Simulation and Maritime Operation.

INTRODUCTION: This study examined the effects of simulated and actual vessel motion at high seas on task load and surgical performance. METHODS: This project was performed in phases. Phase I was a feasibility study. Phase II utilized a motion base simulator to replicate vessel motion. Phase III was conducted aboard the U.S. Naval Ship Brunswick. After performing surgical tasks on a surgical simulation mannequin, participants completed the Surgical Task Load Index (TLX) designed to collect workload data. Simulated surgeries were evaluated by subject matter experts. RESULTS: TLX scores were higher in Phase III than Phase II, particularly at higher sea states. Surgical performance was not significantly different between Phase II (84%) and Phase III (89%). Simulated motions were comparable in both phases. CONCLUSIONS: Simulated motion was not associated with a significant difference in surgical performance or deck motion, suggesting that this simulator replicates the conditions experienced during surgery at sea on the U.S. Naval Ship Brunswick. However, Surgical TLX scores were dramatically different between the two phases, suggesting increased workload at sea, which may be the result of time at sea, the stress of travel, or other factors. Surgical performance was not affected by sea state in either phase.

Lung-sparing techniques are associated with improved outcome compared with anatomic resection for severe lung injuries.

BACKGROUND: Pulmonary tractotomy was introduced in 1994 as a novel concept for lung salvage after penetrating wounds. Recently, tractotomy has been suggested to increase morbidity and, thus, its practice has been challenged. The purpose of this study was to compare the morbidity and mortality associated with nonanatomic and anatomic lung resection in the management of severe pulmonary injuries. METHODS: Using our trauma registry, patients admitted to an urban Level I trauma center during an 11-year period with thoracic injuries requiring thoracotomy and pulmonary operation were identified. A chart review was performed with attention to patient demographics, operative treatment, and outcome. Pulmonary operations performed were classified as either nonanatomic (wedge resection and tractotomy) or anatomic resection (lobectomy and pneumonectomy). Statistical analysis was performed using Student's test, Fisher's exact test, and logistic regression as appropriate. RESULTS: There were 34 men and 2 women, with a mean age of 29 +/- 2 years. Mechanism of injury was predominantly penetrating, with 26 (72%) gunshot wounds and 8 (22%) stab wounds. Intraoperative blood loss and early red blood cell transfusion requirement were lower in patients undergoing nonanatomic resection (3.85 L vs. 11.90 L and 17.4 U vs. 27.9 U, respectively; p < 0.05). Mortality was 4% in the nonanatomic resection group versus 77% in the anatomic resection group. CONCLUSION: Nonanatomic resection is associated with an improved morbidity and mortality compared with anatomic resection in the management of severe lung injuries. Although not a randomized study, these findings encourage the continued application of lung-sparing procedures when feasible.

Treatment-related outcomes from blunt cerebrovascular injuries: importance of routine follow-up arteriography.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the impact of routine follow-up arteriography on the management and outcome of patients with acute blunt cerebrovascular injuries (BCVI). SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: During the past 5 years there has been increasing recognition of BCVI, but the management of these lesions remains controversial. The authors previously proposed a grading system for BCVI, with grade-specific management guidelines. The authors have noted that a significant number of injuries evolve within 7 to 10 days, warranting alterations in therapy. METHODS: A prospective database of a regional trauma center's experience with BCVI has been maintained since 1990. A policy of arteriographic screening for BCVI based on injury mechanism (e.g., cervical hyperextension) and injury patterns (e.g., cervical and facial fractures) was instituted in 1996. A grading system was devised to develop management protocols: I = intimal irregularity; II = dissection/flap/thrombus; III = pseudoaneurysm; IV = occlusion; V = transection. RESULTS: From June 1990 to October 2001, 171 patients (115 male, age 36 +/- 1 years) were diagnosed with BCVI. Mean injury severity score was 28 +/- 1; associated injuries included brain (57%), spine (44%), chest (43%), and face (34%). Mechanism was motor vehicle crash in 50%, fall in 11%, pedestrian struck in 11%, and other in 29%. One hundred fourteen patients had 157 carotid artery injuries (43 bilateral), and 79 patients had 97 vertebral artery injuries (18 bilateral). The breakdown of injury grades was 137 grade I, 52 grade II, 32 grade III, 25 grade IV, and 8 grade V. One hundred fourteen (73%) carotid and 65 (67%) vertebral arteries were restudied with arteriography 7 to 10 days after the injury. Eight-two percent of grade IV and 93% of grade III injuries were unchanged. However, grade I and II lesions changed frequently. Fifty-seven percent of grade I and 8% of grade II injuries healed, allowing cessation of therapy, whereas 8% of grade I and 43% of grade II lesions progressed to pseudoaneurysm formation, prompting interventional treatment. There was no significant difference in healing or in progression of injuries whether treated with heparin or antiplatelet therapy or untreated. However, heparin may improve the neurologic outcome in patients with ischemic deficits and may prevent stroke in asymptomatic patients. CONCLUSIONS: Routine follow-up arteriography is warranted in patients with grade I and II BCVIs because most of these patients (61% in this series) will require a change in management. A prospective randomized trial will be necessary to identify the optimal treatment of BCVI.

The Outreach Trauma Program: a model for survival of the academic trauma center.

BACKGROUND: In the current health care climate, trauma centers face particular economic challenges. Statewide trauma systems provide a network for referral of critically injured patients to academic Level I trauma centers, but favorable reimbursement in states such as Colorado results in intense competition for patients. We hypothesized that a comprehensive Outreach Trauma Program would facilitate our mission as a key resource facility in our trauma system, and would increase referrals of critically injured patients to our center from outside our metropolitan area. METHODS: The Colorado statewide trauma system was formalized in 1995; our Outreach program-including providing visiting trauma call, continuing medical education lectures, 24-hour/7-day immediate consultation and transfers, and public relations/marketing-was fully implemented in 1997. We audited our trauma registry from January 1994 to July 2001 to determine the impact on patient volume and acuity as well as academic productivity. RESULTS: Annual overall trauma admissions have remained stable. Since 1997, high-acuity patients (i.e., Injury Severity Score > 15, intensive care unit admissions, those requiring surgery) have increased 27% to 51%, attributable largely to an approximately 300% increase in high-acuity Outreach patients. In 2000, Outreach patients constituted 8% of our total trauma admissions, but 21% of intensive care unit trauma admissions; notably, they accounted for 25% of our center's trauma charges. Meanwhile, our group's academic productivity has not suffered; in fact, we had 57 publications in 2000, compared with an average of 35 per year from 1993 through 1997. CONCLUSION: The Outreach Trauma Program has proven clinically, academically, and financially rewarding. Our program may serve as a model whereby academic trauma centers, through a demonstrated commitment to serving the clinical and educational needs of their referral base, can satisfy their mission while ensuring their survival.