Xenopus laevis: a possible vector of Ranavirus infection?

Frog virus 3 (FV3) or FV3-like viruses (Iridoviridae) infect a wide range of amphibian species, and they are becoming increasingly and causally associated with amphibian disease outbreaks worldwide. We have established the frog Xenopus laevis as an experimental model to study host defense and pathogenesis of FV3 infection. Although X. laevis adults usually clear FV3 infection within a few weeks, viral DNA has been detected in the kidneys several months after they had been experimentally infected; virus also has been detected in seemingly healthy nonexperimentally infected adults. Based on this information, we hypothesized that covert FV3 infection may occur in Xenopus. We first conducted a survey that detected FV3 by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in the kidneys (the main site of FV3 infection) in a significant fraction of X. laevis raised in five different locations in the United States. Asymptomatic FV3 carriers also were detected by initiation of an acute systemic FV3 infection in frogs that had been immunosupressed by sublethal gamma-irradiation. Finally, we focused on macrophages as a potential site for viral persistence, and we showed that FV3 can infect peritoneal macrophages in vitro as determined by reverse transcriptase-PCR detection of viral mRNAs. Unlike kidney cell lines that are readily killed by FV3, infected macrophages, like uninfected macrophages, survived up to 12 days. Viral transcription also was detected in macrophages from animals up to 12 days after infection. These results suggest that FV3 can become quiescent in resistant species such as Xenopus, thereby making these species potential viral reservoirs.

Generation of a long-lasting, protective, and neutralizing antibody response to the ranavirus FV3 by the frog Xenopus.

Xenopus serves as an experimental model to evaluate the contribution of adaptive immunity in host susceptibility to emerging ranaviral diseases that may contribute to amphibian population declines. It has been previously shown that following a secondary infection with the ranavirus frog virus 3 (FV3), adult Xenopus more rapidly clear FV3 and generate specific anti-FV3 IgY antibodies. We have further evaluated the potency and persistence of the Xenopus antibody response against FV3. Frogs inoculated with FV3 (without adjuvant) up to 15 months after priming produce specific, thymus-dependent anti-FV3 IgY antibodies detectable from 10 days to 8 weeks post-infection. These antisera from boosted frogs are neutralizing in vitro and provide partial passive protection to susceptible larvae when they are injected a few minutes before FV3 inoculation. These results with Xenopus suggest that other anuran amphibians are likely to develop effective long-lasting protective humoral immunity after an initial viral exposure.

Adaptive immunity and histopathology in frog virus 3-infected Xenopus.

Xenopus has been used as an experimental model to evaluate the contribution of adaptive cellular immunity in amphibian host susceptibility to the emerging ranavirus FV3. Conventional histology and immunohistochemistry reveal that FV3 has a strong tropism for the proximal tubular epithelium of the kidney and is rarely disseminated elsewhere in Xenopus hosts unless their immune defenses are impaired or developmentally immature as in larvae. In such cases, virus is found widespread in most tissues. Adults, immunocompromised by depletion of CD8+ T cells or by sub-lethal gamma-irradiation, show increased susceptibility to FV3 infection. Larvae and irradiated (but not normal) adults can be cross-infected through water by infected adult conspecifics (irradiated or not). The natural MHC class I deficiency and the absence of effect of anti-CD8 treatment on both larval CD8+ T cells and larval susceptibility to FV3 are consistent with an inefficient CD8+ T cell effector function during this developmental period.

CD91 up-regulates upon immune stimulation in Xenopus adult but not larval peritoneal leukocytes.

CD91, the endocytic receptor for alpha2-macroglobulin (alpha2M), mediates the internalization of certain heat shock proteins (hsps) and the cross-presentation of peptides they chaperone by antigen-presenting cells. The phylogenetic conservation of the immunologically active CD91 ligands, alpha2M and hsps, is consistent with the idea of an ancestral system of immune surveillance. We have further explored this hypothesis by taking advantage of the frog Xenopus, and asked how conserved is CD91 and whether the expression of CD91 is differentially modulated during immune responses of class I-positive adult and naturally class I-negative larvae. We have identified a Xenopus CD91 gene homologue that displays high sequence identity (>65%) with other CD91 homologues and contains an additional distinctive cytoplasmic NPXY motif. Phylogenetic analysis indicates that CD91 homologues branch as a monophyletic group distinct from other LDLRs; this suggests an origin of CD91 contemporary with that of metazoans. A 14-kb transcript is detected by Northern blotting in most adult and larval tissues, including lymphoid tissues. RT-PCR study reveals that CD91 is expressed in most cell types, including adult macrophages, B and T cells as well as in splenocytes and thymocytes from naturally MHC class I negative larvae. CD91 is markedly up-regulated in vivo by adult peritoneal leukocytes following bacterial and viral stimulation; it is constitutively expressed on class I-negative larval peritoneal leukocytes at high levels and cannot be further upregulated by such stimulation. These data are in agreement with a conserved role of CD91 in immunity.

Anti-tumor MHC class Ia-unrestricted CD8 T cell cytotoxicity elicited by the heat shock protein gp96.

In Xenopus as in mammals, gp96 stimulates MHC-restricted cellular immunity against chaperoned minor histocompatibility (H) antigens (Ag). In adult Xenopus, gp96 also elicits peptide-specific effectors against MHC class Ia-negative 15/0 tumors. To determine whether gp96 can generate functionally heterogeneous CD8+ effectors (CTL that kill MHC class Ia+ minor H-Ag-disparate lymphoblasts and MHC class Ia- tumor targets), LG-6 isogenetic frogs were immunized with gp96 purified either from MHC-identical but minor H-Ag-disparate LG-15 normal tissues or from the MHC class Ia-negative 15/0 tumor line (derived from LG-15 frogs). LG-15 normal liver-derived gp96 did not induce detectable CD8+ in vitro killing against 15/0 tumor cells. However, 15/0-derived gp96 did induce killing against both MHC class Ia+ LG-15 lymphoblasts and the MHC class Ia- 15/0 tumor, but not against another MHC class Ia- tumor (B3B7) or against LG-6 lymphoblasts. Tumor killing was better when 15/0 rather than normal LG-15 irradiated stimulators were used, but in vitro stimulation without prior in vivo immunization was ineffective. These data suggest that (1) 15/0-derived gp96 chaperones minor H-Ag shared with normal LG-15 lymphocytes and elicits MHC-restricted CTL, and (2) 15/0-derived gp96, but not normal liver-derived gp96, generates CD8+ effectors that kill 15/0 tumor cells in the absence of MHC class Ia expression.

Xenopus as an experimental model for studying evolution of hsp--immune system interactions.

The frog Xenopus provides a unique model system for studying the evolutionary conservation of the immunological properties of heat shock proteins (hsps). General methods for maintaining and immunizing isogenetic clones of defined MHC genotypes are presented together with more recently developed protocols for exploring hsp-mediated immune responses in vitro (proliferative and cytotoxic assays) and in vivo (adoptive cell transfer and antibody treatment) in adults and in naturally MHC class I-deficient larvae. Finally, techniques to study modalities of expression of the endoplasmic reticulum resident gp96 at the cell surface of tumor and normal lymphocytes are considered.

Development and characterization of a model system to study amphibian immune responses to iridoviruses.

The recent realization that viruses within the family Iridoviridae may contribute to the worldwide decline in amphibians makes it urgent to understand amphibian antiviral immune defenses. We present evidence that establishes the frog Xenopus laevis as an important model with which to study anti-iridovirus immunity. Adults resist high doses of FV3 infection, showing only transitory signs of pathology. By contrast, naturally MHC class-I-deficient tadpoles are highly susceptible to FV3 infection. Monitoring of viral DNA by PCR indicates a preferential localization of FV3 DNA in the kidney, with the inbred MHC homozygous J strain appearing to be more susceptible. Clearance of virus as measured by detection of FV3 DNA and also the disappearance of pathological and behavioral symptoms of infection, acceleration of viral clearance, and detection of IgY anti-FV3 antibodies after a second injection of FV3 are all consistent with the involvement of both cellular and humoral adaptive antiviral immune responses.

Bacterial stimulation upregulates the surface expression of the stress protein gp96 on B cells in the frog Xenopus.

The presence of the soluble intracellular heat shock protein gp96 (an endoplasmic reticulum resident protein) at the surface of certain cell types is an intriguing phenomenon whose physiological significance has been unclear. We have shown that the active surface expression of gp96 by some immune cells is found throughout the vertebrate phylum including the Agnatha, the only vertebrate taxon whose members (lamprey, hagfish) lack an adaptive immune system. To determine whether gp96 surface expression can be modulated by pathogens, we investigated the effects of in vitro stimulation by purified lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and the heat-killed gram-negative bacteria, Escherichia coli and Aeromonas hydrophilia. Purified Xenopus B cells are readily activated and markedly proliferate in vitro in response to the heat-killed bacteria but not to purified LPS. Furthermore, messenger ribonucleic acid, and intracellular and surface protein expressions of both gp96 and immunoglobulin were upregulated only after activation of B cells by heat-killed bacteria. These data are consistent with an ancestral immunological role of gp96 as an antigen-presenting or danger-signaling molecule, or both, interacting directly with antigen-presenting cells, T cells, or natural killer cells, (or all), to trigger or amplify immune responses.

Identification and characterization of Xenopus CD8+ T cells expressing an NK cell-associated molecule.

Growing evidence suggests that some immune responses are mediated not only by conventional and distinct NK cells and CTL, but also by T cell subsets expressing NK receptors and NK cell-associated molecules. Consistent with our previously published finding that the mAb 1F8 identifies non-T/non-B cells in Xenopus that effect NK-like killing in vitro, we now report that in vivo treatment with this mAb impairs rejection of transplanted MHC class I-negative tumor cells. However, we also find that the NK cell-associated molecule recognized by mAb 1F8 is expressed by a minor population of CD8+ T cells, in which fully rearranged TCRbeta mRNA of at least three different V families can be identified, by contrast, 1F8+/CD8- (NK) cells lack such TCRbeta message. Additionally, the expression of the NK cell-associated molecule can be induced in vitro by a transient submitogenic stimulation of naïve CD8+ T cells with PMA and ionomycin. Such induced expression of 1F8 also occurs in alloantigen-activated CTL and is coincident with a down-regulation of MHC-specific cytotoxicity. Taken together, these new data suggest that regulation of CD8+ T cell activity involving NK cell-associated molecules is a general and evolutionarily ancient phenomenon.

Minor histocompatibility antigen-specific MHC-restricted CD8 T cell responses elicited by heat shock proteins.

In mammals, the heat shock proteins (HSP) gp96 and hsp70 elicit potent specific MHC class I-restricted CD8(+) T cell (CTL) response to exogenous peptides they chaperone. We show in this study that in the adult frog Xenopus, a species whose common ancestors with mammals date back 300 million years, both hsp70 and gp96 generate an adaptive specific cellular immune response against chaperoned minor histocompatibility antigenic peptides that effects an accelerated rejection of minor histocompatibility-locus disparate skin grafts in vivo and an MHC-specific CD8(+) cytotoxic T cell response in vitro. In naturally class I-deficient but immunocompetent Xenopus larvae, gp96 also generates an antitumor immune response that is independent of chaperoned peptides (i.e., gp96 purified from normal tissue also generates a significant antitumor response); this suggests a prominent contribution of an innate type of response in the absence of MHC class I Ags.