Is there any difference between tapered titanium stems with similar geometry and hydroxyapatite coating?

PURPOSE: Several tapered stems with similar geometry and extensive hydroxyapatite coating have recently been introduced. It is not clear, however, whether they share the same design or whether they exhibit any difference that might affect their clinical performances. In this study, we analysed five tapered stems fully coated with hydroxyapatite to establish whether they exhibit similar geometric features and may therefore be used indifferently when a cementless stem is indicated. METHODS: The length of the stem, the coronal and sagittal diameters, the length of the stem shoulder and the metadiaphyseal angle were measured. The ratio between the proximal and distal coronal diameters of the stem and that between the proximal and distal cross-sectional areas were calculated as a flare index and tapered index, respectively. RESULTS: The proximal coronal diameter ranged between 24.9 and 28 mm in the smaller size and between 34 and 38.4 mm in the largest sizes. The proximal sagittal diameter ranged between 10.2 and 11.8 in the smallest size and between 14.4 and 17.2 in the largest. A significant difference was found between stems of different brands in the flare index, tapered index, length of stem shoulder and metadiaphyseal angle. CONCLUSIONS: Lookalike tapered stems with extensive HA coating actually exhibit significant differences in several geometric features potentially affecting their clinical performances. As a result, these stems should not be used indifferently, but rather they should be selected on the basis of the femoral morphology of the operated patient.

Shoulder adhesive capsulitis and hypercholesterolemia: role of APO A1 lipoprotein polymorphism on etiology and severity.

PURPOSE: Relationship between shoulder adhesive capsulitis (AC) and hypercholesterolemia is known. The connecting link might be represented by the correlation between HDL and transforming growth factor beta (TGF-ß): normally, HDLs stimulate TGF-ß expression; the latter is employed in the development of fibrous tissue. We assess whether the presence of the Apo-A1-G75A-polymorphism, which is correlated to an enhanced HDL function, could be a risk factor for the genesis and severity of AC. METHODS: Peripheral blood samples of 27 patients [7M; 20F, mean age 54.81 (41-65)] with AC and hypercholesterolemia were submitted to polymerase chain reaction in order to evaluate the Apo-A1-G75A-polymorphism. Genome database was used as control. Two categories were obtained according to AC severity: type I (active forward flexion ≥ 100°) and type II (< 100°). Data were submitted to statistics. RESULTS: The prevalence of Apo-A1-G75A-polymorphism in the studied group and in the control group was 22.2% (10AG; 1AA; 16GG) and 19% (OR 1.22, IC 0.59-2.53, p > 0.05), respectively. Patients with type I and II capsulitis were 11 [flexion 148.0° (range 100°-165°)] and 16 [flexion 82.5° (range 50°-95°)], respectively. The prevalence of Apo-A1-G75A in type I was 18.1% (2AG; 9GG) and in type II was 56.3% (8GA; 1AA; 7GG), respectively (RR 1.87, IC 1.005-3.482, p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: Apo-A1-G75A-polymorphism is not necessary for the genesis, but it is a risk factor for severity of AC. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III.

Results of primary repair of distal triceps tendon ruptures in a general population: a multicentre study.

Aims: The aim of the study was to analyze the results of primary tendon reinsertion in acute and chronic distal triceps tendon ruptures (DTTRs) in the general population. Patients and Methods: A total of 28 patients were operated on for primary DTTR reinsertions, including 21 male patients and seven female patients with a mean age of 45 years (14 to 76). Of these patients, 23 sustained an acute DTTR and five had a chronic injury. One patient had a non-simultaneous bilateral DTTR. Seven patients had DTTR-associated ipsilateral fracture or dislocation. Comorbidities were present in four patients. Surgical treatment included transosseous and suture-anchors reinsertion in 22 and seven DTTRs, respectively. The clinical evaluation was performed using Mayo Elbow Performance Score (MEPS), the modified American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons Score (m-ASES), the Quick Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder and Hand score (QuickDASH), and the Medical Research Council (MRC) Scale. Results: A total of 27 patients (28 DTTRs) were available for review at a mean of 47.5 months (12 to 204). The mean MEPS, QuickDASH, and m-ASES scores were 94 (60 to 100), 10 (0 to 52), and 94 (58 to 100), respectively. Satisfactory results were observed in 26 cases (93%). Muscle strength was 5/5 and 4/5 in 18 and ten DTTRs, respectively. One patient with chronic renal failure experienced a traumatic rerupture of distal triceps. One patient (1 DTTR) experienced mild elbow stiffness. Conclusion: Primary repair of acute and chronic DTTRs in a general population yields satisfactory results in the majority of patients with a low rerupture rate. Cite this article: Bone Joint J 2018;100-B:610-16.

Rotator cuff degeneration of the healthy shoulder in patients with unilateral arm amputation is not worsened by overuse.

PURPOSE: In order to evaluate whether overuse has a significant role in rotator cuff tear (RCT) aetiology, we evaluated both shoulders of patients with old unilateral arm amputation expecting a higher rate of RC degeneration in the healthy side. METHODS: Nineteen males and six females (mean age: 57.3 ± 10.1) with an old (>20 years) unilateral arm amputation were submitted to an MRI of both shoulders. Tendon status and muscle tropism were evaluated according to Sugaya and Fuchs classifications, respectively; the acromion humeral distance was measured. Statistical analysis was performed to verify the prevalence of Sugaya and Fuchs categories in each sides. RESULTS: A significant prevalence of Sugaya type II in the amputated side (p = 0.02) and of type I in the healthy side (p < 0.001) was found. Rotator cuff was healthy in 28 and 52% of amputated and non-amputated side, respectively. The mean acromio-humeral distances of the amputated and healthy side were 0.8 cm (SD: 0.1) and 0.9 cm (SD: 0.1), respectively, (p = 0.02). A significant prevalence of Fuchs type II category in the healthy side (p < 0.001) was found. Fuchs III/IV were observed in 40 and 12% of amputated and healthy side, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The present study resizes the role of overuse on the aetiology of RCT. Cuff tear prevalence in not amputated shoulders, inevitably submitted to functional overload, was not higher than that of coetaneous subjects with two functional upper limbs. Shoulder non-use is a risk factor for rotator cuff tear. As the prevalence of rotator cuff degeneration/tear is higher in the amputee side, non-use is a more relevant risk factor than overuse. In the daily clinical practice, patients with rotator cuff tear should be encouraged to shoulder movement because rotator cuff tendon status could be worsened by disuse. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III.

Adhesive capsulitis of the shoulder: pain intensity and distribution.

PURPOSE: Papers regarding adhesive capsulitis (AC) of the shoulder focused on etiology, epidemiology, diagnosis, and treatment; until now, information on shoulder pain characteristics is still scarce. Our aim was to analyze pain intensity and distribution in patients with AC. METHODS: The study group was composed of 278 (133M-145F) consecutive patients with AC. After diagnosis, shoulder pain distribution was assessed through an upper limb pain map and pain intensity through a visual analog scale. Patients were distinguished on the basis of gender, age, time elapsed from onset of symptoms, and severity of functional limitation. Data were submitted to statistical analysis. RESULTS: Intensity of shoulder pain caused by AC was higher in females (p < 0.05); it did not vary with the side and between patient younger and older than 55 years. Patients whose pain arose from more than 3 months suffered a lower intensity of shoulder pain. Furthermore, pain intensity was higher in the most severe form of AC (active forward flexion < 60°) (p < 0.05). Pain was localized predominantly on the anterior aspect of the shoulder (dermatomes C5-C6) and rarely extended beyond the distal third of the arm. No differences were found in pain distribution between male and female, between patients with pain from less or more than 3 months and between different levels of AC severity (p > 0.05). CONCLUSION: Shoulder pain due to AC may be influenced by gender and severity of functional limitation. AC pain distribution principally involves anterior aspect of the shoulder with downward extension of the arm until its distal third. LEVELS OF EVIDENCE: Level IV.

Preserving the PCL during the tibial cut in total knee arthroplasty.

PURPOSE: Previous studies have shown that the PCL insertion may be damaged during the tibial cut performed in total knee arthroplasty. We investigated the maximum thickness of a tibial cut that preserves the PCL insertion and to what extent the posterior slope of the tibial cut and that of the patient's tibial plateaus affect the outcome. METHODS: MR images of 83 knees were analysed. The maximum thickness of a tibial cut that preserves the PCL using a posterior slope of 0°, 3°, 5° and parallel to the patient's slope of the tibial plateau, was evaluated. Correlations between the results and the degrees of the posterior slope of the patient's tibial plateaus were also investigated. RESULTS: The maximum thickness of a tibial cut that preserves the entire PCL insertion was, on average, 5.5, 4.7, 4.2 and 3.1 mm when a posterior slope of 0°, 3°, 5° and parallel to the patients' tibial plateaus was used, respectively. When the 25th percentile was considered, the maximum thickness of a tibial cut that preserved the PCL was 4 and 3 mm with a tibial cut of 0° and 5° of posterior slope, respectively. The maximum thickness of a tibial cut that preserved the PCL was significantly greater in patients with a sagittal slope of the tibial plateaus more than 8° than in those with a sagittal slope less than 8°. CONCLUSION: In cruciate retaining implants, the PCL insertion may be spared in the majority of patients by performing a tibial cut of 4 mm, or even less when a posterior slope of 3°-5° is used. The clinical relevance of our study is that the execution of a conservative tibial cut, followed by a second tibial resection to achieve the thickness required for the tibial component to be implanted, may be an alternative technique to spare the PCL in CR TKA. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: II.

Anatomical variations of the trochlear notch angle: MRI analysis of 78 elbows.

BACKGROUND: Little is known about the anatomical variations of the trochlear notch angle, nor do we know whether the cartilaginous layer modifies the trochlear bony contour. Our aim was to assess the variability of the bony and cartilaginous trochlear notch angles. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We assessed 78 healthy elbows (39 patients, 19 females and 20 males) with a mean age of 28 years (range 21-32). High-definition MRI coronal scans at the level of the flexion-extension axis were performed. The cartilage thickness, the notch angle, and trochlear width were calculated at the level of the deepest point of the trochlear sulcus, the edge of the lateral and medial ridge. Patient height was used as indirect measurement of humerus length. Pearson correlation and Student's t tests were performed. RESULTS: Mean cartilage thickness was 1.00 mm (range 0.62-1.83), with significant differences between the medial trochlear ridge and the other landmarks. The notch angle ranged from 124° to 156° (mean 142°) with no differences between the bony and cartilage layers. Trochlear width ranged from 1.57 to 2.75 cm (mean 2.24) and correlated with humerus length. No correlation emerged between the trochlear notch angle, trochlear width, or humerus length. The only significant difference between sexes was the width value, with a wider trochlea in males. CONCLUSIONS: The trochlear notch angle varies considerably, determining anatomical variations in trochlear shape which ranges from less concave to more concave types. Moreover, the cartilaginous layer does not modify this angle at the level examined. These findings may be relevant to anatomical implant design for distal humerus hemiarthroplasty.

Sleep quality and disturbances in patients with different-sized rotator cuff tear.

INTRODUCTION: The literature is unanimous in saying that shoulder pain, due to rotator cuff tear (RCT), may be mostly at night; to our knowledge, this statement is not supported by scientific evidence. Our aim was to investigate sleep quality and disturbances in patient with RCT and in a control group. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A case-control design study was used. We enrolled 324 consecutive patients (Group A) (156M-168F, mean age ± SD: 64.94 ± 6.97; range 47-74) who underwent arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. Tear size was determined intraoperatively. The control group (Group B) included 184 subjects (80M-104F, mean age ± SD = 63.34 ± 6.26; range 44-75) with no RCT. All participants were submitted to two standardized self-reported questionnaires evaluating sleep quality and disturbances: the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) and the Epworth Sleepiness Scale (ESS). Data were submitted to statistics. RESULTS: We found no significant differences between the two groups according to both PSQI (Group A: 5.22 ± 2.59; Group B: 5.21 ± 2.39) and ESS (Group A: 2.59 ± 2.54; Group B: 5.76 ± 2.63), p > 0.05. Patients with small tears had average PSQI and ESS higher than patients with large and massive lesions (p < 0.005). Pearson's test showed that tear severity was negatively correlated with both sleep latency (r 2 = -0.35, ß = 0.069, p < 0.005) and sleep disturbances (r 2 = -0.65, ß = 0.053, p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: RCT is only one of the responsible causes for sleep disturbance in middle-aged and elderly subjects. Patients with small tears have a poorer sleep quality with respect to those with a more severe tear; particularly, they not only take more time to fall asleep, but also have a more disturbed sleep compared to patients with large and massive tears. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III.

Improving tibial component alignment in total knee arthroplasty.

PURPOSE: Tibia torsion may influence the accuracy of extramedullary instrumentations in total knee arthroplasty (TKA). This study assessed whether the effect of tibial torsion may be overcome using a surgical technique in which the extramedullary rod is aligned to reference points at the proximal tibia only. METHODS: A consecutive series of 94 knees that underwent TKA were analyzed. In the first 47 knees (group 1), a standard procedure for tibial component alignment was performed while in the second group of 47 knees, a modified surgical technique was used including the alignment of the extramedullary rod to the reference points at the proximal tibia only (group 2). Lower limb, femoral, and tibial component alignment were measured on postoperative long-leg radiographs. RESULTS: Femorotibial mechanical axes angles were similar in the two groups. Femoral component alignment also did not differ between the groups. A neutral alignment of the tibial component was achieved in 17 and 34 % of the knees in group 1 and group 2, respectively (p = 0.04). A malalignment of the tibial component >3° was found in 34 % of knees in group 1 compared with 4 % of those in group 2 (p = 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: Coronal alignment of the tibial component may improve by setting the extramedullary rod in line with anatomical references in the proximal tibia only. This technique appears to bypass the influence of tibial torsion on the alignment of the extramedullary guide at the distal tibia. The clinical relevance of the study is that using this technique, the rate of malalignment of the tibial component may be reduced compared to a standard technique in which a fixed reference is used at the ankle joint.

Factors affecting choice of open surgical techniques in elbow stiffness.

BACKGROUND: We analyzed the clinical outcomes of stiff elbow open treatment to assess factors affecting the choice of surgical procedures in a consecutive series of patients followed up prospectively. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Forty-one patients, mean aged 48 years, were evaluated. Elbow stiffness was caused by post-traumatic osteoarthritis in 32 patients, primary osteoarthritis in seven and rheumatoid arthritis in two. Stiffness was classified as mixed and extrinsic in 28 and 13 cases, respectively. Seventeen ulno-humeral arthroplasties (UHA), seven UHA with radiocapitellar replacement, six UHA with radial head replacement, ten total elbow replacement and one UHA with anconeus interposition were performed. Mayo Elbow Performance Score (MEPS), modified-American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (m-ASES) and Q-DASH scores were used for the pre- and post-operative evaluation. RESULTS: Mean follow-up was 25 months. The average increase in MEPS and m-ASES was 45 and 41, respectively. The average decrease in Q-DASH and the average increase in m-ASES pain were 43 and 21, respectively. The mean increase in flection, extension, pronation and supination was 29°, 25°, 18° and 17°, respectively. All the differences were statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: Strictly customized open surgery of elbow stiffness, by taking into account the clinical value of each patient's pathoanatomical conditions, yields satisfactory functional results in majority of cases. In particular, the degree and site of elbow cartilage wear proved to be the factors affecting the choice of treatment most. Treatment should be aimed at removing the causes of pain and at recovering range of motion.

Pigmented villonodular synovitis of the shoulder associated with massive rotator cuff tear treated by arthroscopic synovectomy and debridement.

PURPOSE: Pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS) is a rare condition. Our purpose is to describe the largest series of patients with shoulder PVNS, massive irreparable rotator cuff tear, and glenohumeral osteoarthritis treated with arthroscopic debridement and synovectomy. METHODS: We treated 9 patients with PVNS of the shoulder, irreparable rotator cuff tear, and slight glenohumeral arthropathy (group I). Patients underwent arthroscopic synovectomy and debridement. Results [constant score (CS) and subjective shoulder value (SSV)] were compared to those obtained from a control group (group II) of 20 consecutive patients undergoing arthroscopic debridement for irreparable cuff tear associated with hemorrhagic synovitis with no or slight glenohumeral arthropathy. Histologic examination was obtained in all cases to obtain the correct diagnosis. RESULTS: The preoperative shoulder function in group I was reduced with respect to group II. Upon follow-up, CS and SSV were lower in group I. Preoperatively, the differences relating to the CS value and to each item of the score were always statistically significant; instead, at follow-up, significant differences emerged in the CS, ADL, and ROM. At follow-up, significant differences emerged between CS of group I and of group II without glenohumeral arthropathy. Differences using the SSV were always statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: The poor functional outcome of patients affected by PVNS can be attributed to the coexistence of the irreparable cuff tear and to the glenohumeral arthropathy. All patients with PVNS had shoulder osteoarthritis; it cannot be simply attributed to natural history of massive irreparable cuff tears, but to the pigmented villonodular synovitis.

The impact of aging on rotator cuff tear size.

INTRODUCTION: The aim of our study was to establish if aging influences rotator cuff tear size. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We studied 586 consecutive patients (280 M, 306 F) mean age 59 years old (range 46-73) who underwent arthroscopic rotator cuff repair. Tear size was determined during surgery. For the purpose of our study, patients were divided into two groups based on age older than 60 years. A multinomial logistic regression model was applied to explore the association between age older than 60 years and tear size. We used the ANCOVA method to determine whether the aging influences the severity of the tear. All analyses were adjusted for gender. RESULTS: Age older than 60 years was associated with a twofold higher overall risk of tear occurrence (OR = 2.12, 95 % CI 1.44-3.01). While no association was detected between age older than 60 years and the probability of a small tear (OR = 0.58, 95 % CI 0.27-1.07), subjects older than 60 years were twice more likely to experience a large tear (OR = 2.29, 95 %CI 1.51-3.27) and three times more likely to experience a massive tear (OR = 3.09, 95 % CI 2.07-5.38) as opposed to younger subjects. Mean age significantly increased from small tear (53.8 years) to large tear (66.8 years) to massive tear (69.4 years) patients (ANCOVA: F(2, 437) = 16.487, p = 1.51 × 10(-7)). DISCUSSION: We found a significantly older mean age in patients with a more severe tear. Our data provide and confirm evidence that aging is a significant risk factor for the occurrence and severity of rotator cuff tears.

Thigh pain, subsidence and survival using a short cementless femoral stem with pure metaphyseal fixation at minimum 9-year follow-up.

BACKGROUND: Short femoral stems designed to spare bone stock and improve load transfer at the proximal femur level have been introduced in recent years. However, little is known on the long-term outcomes of these stems. HYPOTHESIS: Short cementless stems have low rate of thigh pain and subsidence as well as few revision needs at mid-term follow-up. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We prospectively followed 64 patients (72 hips) undergoing total hip arthroplasty with a femoral stem designed to achieve a pure metaphyseal fixation. Patients with hip fracture, femoral neck deformity and osteoporotic bone were excluded. Clinical evaluations were performed annually until the last follow-up, a minimum of 9 years after surgery. At each follow-up, implant positioning was assessed on conventional plain films with a computer assisted radiographic evaluation. RESULTS: The Harris hip score improved from 43 points (range 19-50) before surgery to 88 points (range 73-100) at the final follow-up (P=0.001), and the Womac score averaged 47 points (range 35-56 points) preoperatively and 76 points (range 63-84) at the last follow-up (P=0.001). Thigh pain was reported by five patients (8%) at the 2-year follow-up, but only in two (3%) was still present, and related to the prosthesis, at last follow-up. Computer assisted radiographic analysis showed a neutral alignment of the stem in 56% of cases, a varus-valgus alignment less than 5° in 36% and equal to 5° in 8%. Stem subsidence was observed in 12 hips but was less than 4mm in all cases (range 0-3mm). Calcar height remained unchanged over time. Adaptive bone remodelling, including proximal bone resorption and distal cortical hypertrophy were not observed at follow-up. No patients had aseptic loosening of the stem nor were radiolucent lines detectable at the level of the porous coating. Survivorship analysis showed a 100% survival rate of the stem at nine years. DISCUSSION: This study showed that a femoral stem designed to achieve a pure metaphyseal fixation may obtain, in a selected group of patients with adequate bone quality, satisfactory clinical outcomes without compromising implant stability. The limited periprosthetic bone remodelling observed after a minimum of 9 years follow-up suggests that this type of implant may improve mechanical stresses on host bone compared with standard stems requiring diaphyseal fixation. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV. Historical series.

Correlation between posterior offset of femoral condyles and sagittal slope of the tibial plateau.

The aim of this study was to address, in normal knees, the variability of posterior offset of femoral condyles and tibial slope, and the presence of any correlation between the two that might be needed to achieve an adequate joint motion in flexion. Magnetic resonance images of normal knees of 80 subjects, 45 males and 35 females, with a mean age of 38.9 years, were analysed. Measurements were performed by two independent observers using an imaging visualization software. The tibial slope averaged 8 and 7.7 °, on the medial and lateral sides, respectively (P = 0.2); the mean posterior offset of femoral condyles was 27.4 and 25.2 mm on the two sides, respectively (P = 0.0001). The variation coefficient of the condylar offset and tibial slope was 11.5 and 38%, respectively. In the medial compartment, a significant correlation was found between the femoral condylar offset and the tibial slope, while the same was not observed in the lateral compartment of the knee. Magnetic resonance imaging allows the assessment of tibial slope and femoral condylar offset in the medial and lateral side separately, taking into account any difference between the two compartments. The sagittal tibial slope exhibits a greater variability compared with the posterior offset of femoral condyles. The correlation found, in the medial compartment, between the tibial slope and femoral condylar offset suggests that the reconstitution of the proper morphology of the posterior part of the knee joint may be necessary to obtain a full range of motion in flexion after total knee replacement.

Experimental posterolateral spinal fusion with porous ceramics and mesenchymal stem cells.

Alternatives to autogenous bone graft for spinal fusion have been investigated for many years. It has been shown that osteoconductive materials alone do not give a rate of fusion which is comparable to that of autogenous bone graft. We analysed the effectiveness of porous ceramic loaded with cultured mesenchymal stem cells as a new graft material for spinal fusion in an animal model. Posterolateral fusion was carried out at the L4/L5 level in 40 White New Zealand rabbits using one of the following graft materials: porous ceramic granules plus cultured mesenchymal stem cells (group I); ceramic granules plus fresh autogenous bone marrow (group II); ceramic granules alone (group II); and autogenous bone graft (group IV). The animals were killed eight weeks after surgery and the spines were evaluated radiographically, by a manual palpation test and by histological analysis. The rate of fusion was significantly higher in group I compared with group III and higher, but not significantly, in group I compared with groups II and IV. In group I histological analysis showed newly formed bone in contact with the implanted granules and highly cellular bone marrow between the newly formed trabecular bone. In group II, thin trabeculae of newly formed bone were present in the peripheral portion of the fusion mass. In group III, there was a reduced amount of newly formed bone and abundant fibrous tissue. In group IV, there were thin trabeculae of newly formed bone close to the decorticated transverse processes and dead trabecular bone in the central portion of the fusion mass. In vitro cultured mesenchymal stem cells may be loaded into porous ceramic to make a graft material for spinal fusion which appears to be more effective than porous ceramic alone. Further studies are needed to investigate the medium- to long-term results of this procedure, its feasibility in the clinical setting and the most appropriate carrier for mesenchymal stem cells.

Recovery of motor deficits after microdiscectomy for lumbar disc herniation.

We have studied, prospectively, 116 patients with motor deficits associated with herniation of a lumbar disc who underwent microdiscectomy. They were studied during the first six months and at a mean of 6.4 years after surgery. Before operation, muscle weakness was mild (grade 4) in 67% of patients, severe (grade 3) in 21% and very severe (grade 2 or 1) in 12%. The muscle which most frequently had severe or very severe weakness was extensor hallucis longus, followed in order by triceps surae, extensor digitorum communis, tibialis anterior, and others. At the latest follow-up examination, 76% of patients had complete recovery of strength. Persistent weakness was found in 16% of patients who had had a mild preoperative deficit and in 39% of those with severe or very severe weakness. Muscle strength was graded 4 in all patients with persistent weakness, except for four with a very severe preoperative deficit affecting the L5 or S1 nerve root. They showed no significant recovery. Excluding this last group, the degree of recovery of motor function was inversely related to the preoperative severity and duration of muscle weakness. The patients' subjective functional capacity was not directly related to the degree of recovery except in those with persistent severe or very severe deficit.

Contralateral recurrent lumbar disc herniation. Results of discectomy compared with those in primary herniation.

STUDY DESIGN: The surgical outcomes of patients who underwent discectomy for contralateral recurrent herniation and primary herniation were evaluated. OBJECTIVE: To assess whether the clinical results in patients undergoing surgery for contralateral recurrent disc herniation may be as good as those reported after primary discectomy. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: No retrospective or prospective investigation has been conducted on the surgical treatment of contralateral recurrent lumbar disc herniation. METHODS: Sixteen patients who underwent surgery for recurrent disc herniation at the same level as primary disc excision, but on the opposite side, were analyzed prospectively from the recurrence of contralateral radicular pain (Group 1). All patients had reported a satisfactory results after primary discectomy. Fifty consecutive patients who underwent disc excision during the study period, who did not report recurrent radicular pain, were analyzed for comparison (Group 2). Overall patient satisfaction, pain severity, functional outcome, and work status were evaluated. RESULTS: At the 2-year follow-up, the clinical outcome was rated as satisfactory in 14 of 16 patients in Group 1 and in 45 of 50 in Group 2 (P > 0.05). Twelve patients in Group 1 and 42 in Group 2 had resumed their work or daily activities at the same level as before the operation (P > 0.05). Radicular pain was significantly improved in both groups at the 6-month and 2-year follow-ups. At the 6-month follow-up, low back pain was significantly improved only in the patients in Group 2; however, at the 2-year follow-up, low back pain was significantly improved in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical results in patients reoperated on for contralateral recurrent lumbar disc herniation compare favorably with those reported after primary discectomy. The improvement of pain in the low back and lower limbs reported by the majority of patients 2 years after reoperation suggests that fusion is not needed in this patient population.