Addressing a Critical Voice in Clinical Practice: Experiences of Nursing Students, Teachers, and Supervisors-A Qualitative Study.

AIM: Our goal was to explore how power asymmetry manifests within the relationships between students, teachers, and supervisors, and how it influences students' ability for critical reflection. DESIGN: This study has an explorative qualitative design. METHODS: Thirty in-depth interviews with nursing students (15), teachers (9), and supervisors (6) were conducted in addition to 16 observations of mid-term assessments during clinical practice. The analysis was conducted using Braun and Clarke's thematic analysis. RESULTS: The students described being a student as a balancing act between humility, conforming to the supervisor's expectations, and speaking their minds. The view expressed by the teachers and supervisors is that training for the nursing profession is closely linked to the students' ability to act independently. Due to the supervisors' hierarchical position, however, students are hesitant to voice any criticism regarding insufficient supervision or unsatisfactory performance of clinical tasks while at the same time being evaluated on their ability to critically reflect on their own and others' clinical performance. This study was prospectively registered with the Norwegian Centre for Research Data on the 15th of August 2017 with the registration number 54821.

The paradox of an expected level: The assessment of nursing students during clinical practice - A qualitative study.

AIM: The aim of this study is to increase knowledge about the assessment of nursing students' clinical practice, particularly concerning how teachers and clinical supervisors identify and assess the expected level of competence in mid-term evaluations and students, teachers and supervisors' experiences of mid-term assessment. Assessment is important to assure the quality of students' clinical competence and studies show that further research on this topic is required. DESIGN: This study has an explorative qualitative design. METHODS: Thirty semi-structured interviews were conducted with nursing students, teachers and clinical supervisors along with 16 observations of mid-term assessments during clinical practice, as part of a bachelor's programme in nursing. RESULTS: Two main challenges concerning establishing an expected level of competence were identified from the analysis of the interviews and observations: 1) a general formulation of learning outcomes and 2) vague expectations of what is the expected level of achievements at different points in time. Both challenges were at institutional level. Furthermore, at performance level, certain patterns were identified related to these challenges, such as teachers and supervisors needing to concretise the general formulation of learning outcomes and their discretion to set the expected level. Additionally, non-verbal language during mid-term assessment seemed to affect how the assessment situation was perceived. CONCLUSION: We suggest that the institutional guidelines need to be critically reviewed to include greater focus on clarifying what students are expected to achieve, as well as what constitutes the expected level. We have emphasised that discretion is a necessary premise to identify an expected level of clinical competence at mid-term assessment, in particular when there is lack of a clear standard and the assessment form is vague, but also when there is no clear definition of the expected level of competence at different points in time. The consequences are that the student feel insecure about how the assessment ought to be perceived, what level they are at in their learning process, and subsequently, their level in the process of developing necessary clinical competence.

Conditions Affecting the Performance of Peripheral Vein Cannulation during Hospital Placement: A Case Study.

Learning practical nursing skills is an important part of the baccalaureate in nursing. However, many newly qualified nurses lack practical skill proficiency required to ensure safe patient care. The invasive skill peripheral vein cannulation (PVC) is particularly challenging to learn and perform. This study explored conditions influencing nursing students' learning and performance of the technical implementation of a PVC during their clinical placement period. A qualitative and descriptive case study design with two students in Norway practicing PVC during their clinical placement was conducted. One student who mastered the vein cannulation was compared with one student who did not. Data were collected in late 2012 using multiple data sources: semistructured interviews, ad hoc conversations, and video recordings. Video recordings of the two students' cannula implementations were used to help clarify and validate the descriptions and to identify gaps between what students said and what they did. Thematic analysis of the transcribed text data enabled identifying themes that influenced skill performance. There were two overall themes: individual and contextual conditions influencing the technical implementation of a peripheral vein cannula. These findings were evaluated in terms of Benner's work on scientific and practical knowledge, defined as "knowing that" and "knowing how."

Defining and comparing learning actions in two simulation modalities: students training on a latex arm and each other's arms.

AIMS AND OBJECTIVES: To explore, describe and compare learning actions that nursing students used during peripheral vein cannulation training on a latex arm or each other's arms in a clinical skills centre. BACKGROUND: Simulation-based training is thought to enhance learning and transfer of learning from simulation to the clinical setting and is commonly recommended in nursing education. What students actually are doing during simulation-based training is, however, less explored. The analysis of learning actions used during simulation-based training could contribute to development and improvement of simulation as a learning strategy in nursing education. DESIGN: A qualitative explorative and descriptive research design, involving content analysis of video recordings, was used. METHODS: Video-supported observation of nine nursing students practicing vein cannulation was conducted in a clinical skills centre in late 2012. RESULTS: The students engaged in various learning actions. Students training on a latex arm used a considerably higher number of learning actions relative to those training on each other's arms. In both groups, students' learning actions consisted mainly of seeking and giving support. The teacher provided students training on each other's arms with detailed feedback regarding insertion of the cannula into the vein, while those training on a latex arm received sparse feedback from the teacher and fellow students. CONCLUSION: The teacher played an important role in facilitating nursing students' practical skill learning during simulation. The provision of support from both teachers and students should be emphasised to ensure that nursing students' learning needs are met. RELEVANCE TO CLINICAL PRACTICE: This study suggest that student nurses may be differently and inadequately prepared in peripheral vein cannulation in two simulation modalities used in the academic setting; training on a latex arm and on each other's arms.

Developing supervision skills through peer learning partnership.

Oslo University College, Faculty of Nursing places undergraduate students in peer learning partnerships: 3rd year students as tutors, and 1st year students as tutees during practical skill learning. A study was designed to investigate this peer learning project. One of the research questions in particular on the role of the tutors: How do 3rd year nursing students carry out their role as supervisors for 1st year students in the skills laboratory? The study had an exploratory design. Qualitative data was gathered by three members of a research team, using video recordings of the supervised sessions and focus group interviews with both 1st and 3rd year students. Data collection was repeated in 2006-2007-2008 in different groups of students. Four identified themes illustrate how the 3rd year students supervise during the performance of the procedures in the skills laboratory: Observe and guide, supportive attitude, identify with the patient, focus on theoretical knowledge. The results of this study indicate that apart from enhancing practical skill learning in 1st year students, the assignment in the skill laboratory also provided an arena for developing competence in supervision in third year students.