Influence of variability in assessment of Breslow thickness, mitotic rate and ulceration among US pathologists interpreting invasive melanoma, for the purpose of AJCC staging.

BACKGROUND: Melanoma staging has depended on depth of invasion (Breslow thickness, BT), mitotic rate (MR) and ulceration. In anticipation of the AJCC's eighth edition, variability in pathologists' assessment of these factors and consequently in tumor staging was assessed. METHODS: One-hundred and fifteen cases of invasive melanoma, established by a consensus panel, were assessed by 187 pathologists. Variation was studied in BT, the detection of mitotic figures, and ulceration. The sources of this variation and its effect on tumor staging are considered. RESULTS: On average, participant assessments closely approached consensus BT. Greater variation was identified in the classification of mitogenicity, which (like ulceration) upstages a T1 melanoma from T1a to T1b in the seventh but not eighth edition. In cases with a T1a diagnosis by the consensus panel, 15.6% of participants identified one or more mitotic figures (indicative of a false positive); and in cases diagnosed asT1b by the consensus panel, 32.0% of participants failed to find mitotic figures (false negative). CONCLUSION: Variability in the staging of T1 melanoma among pathologists when using the AJCC seventh edition criteria is closely related to the detection of mitotic figures, with BT playing a less prominent role. Decreased variability is expected after implementation of the eighth edition.

p15 Expression Differentiates Nevus from Melanoma.

Most melanomas are driven by BRAF(V600E)-activating mutations, while nevi harboring the same mutations have growth arrest. Although decreased p16 expression has been associated with melanoma formation, in recent work, p15 represented a primary effector of oncogene-induced senescence in nevomelanocytes that was diminished in melanomas. This study determined whether decreased p15 levels represent a general biomarker for the transition from nevus to melanoma. We performed p15 and p16 IHC analyses on a random series of nevi and melanomas. Staining was evaluated and graded for percentage and intensity to determine the H score. For real-time quantitative RT-PCR analysis of p15, RNA was extracted from FFPE sections from 14 nevus and melanoma samples via macrodissection. A two-sided t-test was used to evaluate between-group differences in mean H scores and qΔCt values. p15 Expression was significantly increased in melanocytic nevi compared with melanomas (mean H scores, 254.8 versus 132.3; P < 0.001). On p15 staining, the H score differential was greater than that with p16 staining [122.5 (P < 0.001) and 64.8 (P = 0.055), respectively]. Real-time quantitative RT-PCR analysis revealed a lower mean qΔCt value in melanomas, consistent with lower p15 expression (P = 0.018). Together, these data support the hypothesis that decreased p15 expression is a robust biomarker for distinguishing nevus from melanoma.