DAPTOMYCIN, its membrane-active mechanism vs. that of other antimicrobial peptides.

Over 3000 membrane-active antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) have been discovered, but only three of them have been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for therapeutic applications, i.e., gramicidin, daptomycin and colistin. Of the three approved AMPs, daptomycin is a last-line-of-defense antibiotic for treating Gram-positive infections. However its use has already created bacterial resistance. To search for its substitutes that might counter the resistance, we need to understand its molecular mechanism. The mode of action of daptomycin appears to be causing bacterial membrane depolarization through ion leakage. Daptomycin forms a unique complex with calcium ions and phosphatidylglycerol molecules in membrane at a specific stoichiometric ratio: Dap2Ca3PG2. How does this complex promote ion conduction across the membrane? We hope that biophysics of peptide-membrane interaction can answer this question. This review summarizes the biophysical works that have been done on membrane-active AMPs to understand their mechanisms of action, including gramicidin, daptomycin, and underdeveloped pore-forming AMPs. The analysis suggests that daptomycin forms transient ionophores in the target membranes. We discuss questions that remain to be answered.

Rhombohedral trap for studying molecular oligomerization in membranes: application to daptomycin.

A persistent problem in the studies of membrane-active peptides, including antimicrobial peptides and pathogenic amyloidal peptides, is the lack of methods for investigating their molecular configurations in membranes. These peptides spontaneously bind to membranes from solutions, and often form oligomers that induce changes of membrane permeability. For antimicrobials, such actions appear to relate to the antimicrobial mechanisms, but for amyloidal peptides, the oligomerization has been linked to neurodegenerative diseases. In many cases, no further understanding of such oligomerization has been achieved due to the lack of structural information. In this article, we will demonstrate a method of trapping such peptide oligomers in a rhombohedral (R) phase of lipid so that the oligomers can be subjected to 3D diffraction analysis. The conditions for forming the R phase and the electron density distribution in the rhombohedral unit cell provide information about peptide-lipid interactions and the molecular size of the trapped oligomer. Such information cannot be obtained from membranes in the planar configuration. For illustration, we apply this method to daptomycin, an FDA-approved antibiotic that attacks membranes containing phosphatidylglycerol, in the presence of calcium ions. We have successfully used the brominated phosphatidylglycerol to perform bromine-atom anomalous diffraction in the rhombohedral phase containing daptomycin and calcium ions. The preliminary results apparently exhibit diffraction data related to daptomycin oligomers. We believe that this method will also be applicable to the difficult problems related to amyloidal peptides, such as amyloid beta of Alzheimer's disease.

Comparison of the Effects of Daptomycin on Bacterial and Model Membranes.

Daptomycin is a phosphatidylglycerol specific, calcium-dependent membrane-active antibiotic that has been approved for the treatment of Gram-positive infections. A recent Bacillus subtilis study found that daptomycin clustered into fluid lipid domains of bacterial membranes and the membrane binding was correlated with dislocation of peripheral membrane proteins and depolarization of membrane potential. In particular, the study disproved the existence of daptomycin ion channels. Our purpose here is to study how daptomycin interacts with lipid bilayers to understand the observed phenomena on bacterial membranes. We performed new types of experiments using aspirated giant vesicles with an ion leakage indicator, making comparisons between daptomycin and ionomycin, performing vesicle-vesicle transfers, and measuring daptomycin binding to fluid phase versus gel phase bilayers and bilayers including cholesterol. Our findings are entirely consistent with the observations for bacterial membranes. In addition, daptomycin is found to cause ion leakage through the membrane only if its concentration in the membrane is over a certain threshold. The ion leakage caused by daptomycin is transient. It occurs only when daptomycin binds the membrane for the first time; afterward, they cease to induce ion leakage. The ion leakage effect of daptomycin cannot be transferred from one membrane to another. The level of membrane binding of daptomycin is reduced in the gel phase versus the fluid phase. Cholesterol also weakens the membrane binding of daptomycin. The combination of membrane concentration threshold and differential binding is significant. This could be a reason why daptomycin discriminates between eukaryotic and prokaryotic cell membranes.

Understanding membrane-active antimicrobial peptides.

Bacterial membranes represent an attractive target for the design of new antibiotics to combat widespread bacterial resistance to traditional inhibitor-based antibiotics. Understanding how antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) and other membrane-active agents attack membranes could facilitate the design of new, effective antimicrobials. AMPs, which are small, gene-encoded host defense proteins, offer a promising basis for the study of membrane-active antimicrobial agents. These peptides are cationic and amphipathic, spontaneously binding to bacterial membranes and inducing transmembrane permeability to small molecules. Yet there are often confusions surrounding the details of the molecular mechanisms of AMPs. Following the doctrine of structure-function relationship, AMPs are often viewed as the molecular scaffolding of pores in membranes. Instead we believe that the full mechanism of AMPs is understandable if we consider the interactions of AMPs with the whole membrane domain, where interactions induce structural transformations of the entire membrane, rather than forming localized molecular structures. We believe that it is necessary to consider the entire soft matter peptide-membrane system as it evolves through several distinct states. Accordingly, we have developed experimental techniques to investigate the state and structure of the membrane as a function of the bound peptide to lipid ratio, exactly as AMPs in solution progressively bind to the membrane and induce structural changes to the entire system. The results from these studies suggest that global interactions of AMPs with the membrane domain are of fundamental importance to understanding the antimicrobial mechanisms of AMPs.

Molecular State of the Membrane-Active Antibiotic Daptomycin.

Membrane-active antibiotics are potential alternatives to the resistance-prone conventional antibiotics. Daptomycin, a cyclic lipopeptide, is the only membrane-active antibiotic approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration so far. The drug interacts with the cytoplasmic membranes of Gram-positive pathogens, causing membrane permeabilization to ions and cell death. The antibiotic activity is calcium-ion dependent and correlates with the target membrane's content of phosphatidylglycerol (PG). For such a complex reaction with membranes, it has been difficult to uncover the molecular process that underlies its antibacterial activity. The role of the cofactor, calcium ions, has been confusing. Many have proposed that calcium ions binding to daptomycin is a precondition for membrane interaction. Here, we report our findings on the molecular state of daptomycin before and after its membrane-binding reaction, particularly at therapeutic concentrations in the low micromolar range. We were able to perform small-angle x-ray scattering at sufficiently low daptomycin concentrations to determine that the molecules are monomeric before membrane binding. By careful circular dichroism (CD) analyses of daptomycin with Ca2+ and PG-containing membranes, we found that there are only two states identifiable by CD, one before and another after membrane binding; all other CD spectra are linear combinations of the two. Before membrane binding, the molecular state of daptomycin as defined by CD is the same with or without calcium ions. We are able to determine the stoichiometric ratios of the membrane-binding reaction. The stoichiometric ratio of daptomycin to calcium is 2:3. The stoichiometric ratio of daptomycin to PG is ∼1:1 if only the PG lipids in the outer leaflets of membranes are accessible to daptomycin.

Action of Antimicrobial Peptides on Bacterial and Lipid Membranes: A Direct Comparison.

The bacterial membrane represents an attractive target for the design of new antibiotics to combat widespread bacterial resistance. Understanding how antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) and other membrane-active agents attack membranes could facilitate the design of new, effective antimicrobials. Despite intense study of AMPs on model membranes, we do not know how well the mechanism of attack translates to real biological membranes. To that end, we have characterized the attack of AMPs on Escherichia coli cytoplasmic membranes and directly compared this action to model membranes. AMPs induce membrane permeability in E. coli spheroplasts or giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) under well-defined concentrations of AMPs and fluorescent molecules. The action of AMPs on spheroplasts is unique in producing an intracellular fluorescence intensity time curve that increases in a sigmoidal fashion to a steady state. This regular pattern is reproducible by melittin, LL37, and alamethicin but not by CCCP or daptomycin, agents known to cause ion leakage. Remarkably, a similar pattern was also reproduced in GUVs. Indeed the steady-state membrane permeability induced by AMPs is quantitatively the same in spheroplasts and GUVs. There are, however, interesting dissimilarities in details that reveal differences between bacterial and lipid membranes. Spheroplast membranes are permeabilized by a wide range of AMP concentrations to the same steady-state membrane permeability. In contrast, only a narrow range of AMP concentrations permeabilized GUVs to a steady state. Tension in GUVs also influences the action of AMPs, whereas the spheroplast membranes are tensionless. Despite these differences, our results provide a strong support for using model membranes to study the molecular interactions of AMPs with bacterial membranes. As far as we know, this is the first time the actions of AMPs, on bacterial membranes and on model membranes, have been directly and quantitatively compared.

Mode of Action of Antimicrobial Peptides on E. coli Spheroplasts.

We investigated the phenomena of antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) directly attacking the cytoplasmic membranes of Escherichia coli spheroplasts. We developed a procedure for fluorescence recovery after photobleaching to examine dye leakage through bacterial membranes as AMPs in solution bound to the membranes. We found that the AMP binding did not increase the apparent membrane area of a spheroplast, contrary to the response of a lipid-bilayer vesicle, which always showed a membrane area expansion by AMP binding. The permeability through the bacterial membrane increased in a sigmoidal fashion as the AMP binding increased in time, exhibiting a cooperative behavior of AMPs. The analysis of fluorescence recovery after photobleaching showed that the fluxes of dye molecules into and out of the cell were consistent with diffusion of molecules through a number of pores that increased with binding of AMPs and then saturated to a steady level. We discovered a new, to our knowledge, experimental parameter called the flux rate that characterizes the AMP-induced permeability of dye molecules through bacterial membranes. The phenomena observed in bacterial membranes are consistent with the pore-forming activities of AMPs previously observed in lipid bilayers. The experimental value of the flux rate per pore is much smaller than a theoretical value that assumes no friction for the dye molecule's permeation through the pore. We believe that experimental studies of the flux rate will be useful for further analysis of AMPs' permeabilization mechanisms.

Comparative Study of the Condensing Effects of Ergosterol and Cholesterol.

Cholesterol, due to its condensing effect, is considered an important regulator of membrane thickness. Other sterols, due to their structural similarities to cholesterol, are often assumed to have a universal effect on membrane properties similar to the condensing effect of cholesterol, albeit possibly to different degrees. We used x-ray diffraction to investigate this assumption. By the combination of lamellar diffraction and grazing-angle scattering, we measured the membrane thickness and the tilt-angle distribution of the lipid's hydrocarbon chains. This method is sensitive to phase separation, which is important for examining the miscibility of sterols and phospholipids. Mixtures of ergosterol or cholesterol with dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine, palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylcholine, and dioleoylphosphatidylcholine were systematically studied. We found that mixing ergosterol with phospholipids into a single phase became increasingly difficult with higher sterol concentrations and also with higher concentrations of unsaturated lipid chains. The only condensing effect of ergosterol was found in dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine, although the effect was less than one-third of the effect of cholesterol. Unlike cholesterol, ergosterol could not maintain a fixed electron density profile of the surrounding lipids independent of hydration. In dioleoylphosphatidylcholine and palmitoyloleoylphosphatidylcholine, ergosterol made the membranes thinner, opposite to the effect of cholesterol. In all cases, the tilt-angle variation of the chain diffraction was consistent with the membrane thickness changes measured by lamellar diffraction, i.e., a thickening was always associated with a reduction of chain tilt angles. Our findings do not support the notion that different sterols have a universal behavior that differs only in degree.

Membrane-mediated amyloid formation of PrP 106-126: A kinetic study.

PrP 106-126 conserves the pathogenic and physicochemical properties of the Scrapie isoform of the prion protein. PrP 106-126 and other amyloidal proteins are capable of inducing ion permeability through cell membranes, and this property may represent the common primary mechanism of pathogenesis in the amyloid-related degenerative diseases. However, for many amyloidal proteins, despite numerous phenomenological observations of their interactions with membranes, it has been difficult to determine the molecular mechanisms by which the proteins cause ion permeability. One approach that has not been undertaken is the kinetic study of protein-membrane interactions. We found that the reaction time constant of the interaction between PrP 106-126 and membranes is suitable for such studies. The kinetic experiment with giant lipid vesicles showed that the membrane area first increased by peptide binding but then decreased. The membrane area decrease was coincidental with appearance of extramembranous aggregates including lipid molecules. Sometimes, the membrane area would increase again followed by another decrease. The kinetic experiment with small vesicles was monitored by circular dichroism for peptide conformation changes. The results are consistent with a molecular simulation following a simple set of well-defined rules. We deduced that at the molecular level the formation of peptide amyloids incorporated lipid molecules as part of the aggregates. Most importantly the amyloid aggregates desorbed from the lipid bilayer, consistent with the macroscopic phenomena observed with giant vesicles. Thus we conclude that the main effect of membrane-mediated amyloid formation is extraction of lipid molecules from the membrane. We discuss the likelihood of this effect on membrane ion permeability.

The Atlastin C-terminal tail is an amphipathic helix that perturbs the bilayer structure during endoplasmic reticulum homotypic fusion.

Fusion of tubular membranes is required to form three-way junctions found in reticular subdomains of the endoplasmic reticulum. The large GTPase Atlastin has recently been shown to drive endoplasmic reticulum membrane fusion and three-way junction formation. The mechanism of Atlastin-mediated membrane fusion is distinct from SNARE-mediated membrane fusion, and many details remain unclear. In particular, the role of the amphipathic C-terminal tail of Atlastin is still unknown. We found that a peptide corresponding to the Atlastin C-terminal tail binds to membranes as a parallel α helix, induces bilayer thinning, and increases acyl chain disorder. The function of the C-terminal tail is conserved in human Atlastin. Mutations in the C-terminal tail decrease fusion activity in vitro, but not GTPase activity, and impair Atlastin function in vivo. In the context of unstable lipid bilayers, the requirement for the C-terminal tail is abrogated. These data suggest that the C-terminal tail of Atlastin locally destabilizes bilayers to facilitate membrane fusion.

Physical properties of Escherichia coli spheroplast membranes.

We investigated the physical properties of bacterial cytoplasmic membranes by applying the method of micropipette aspiration to Escherichia coli spheroplasts. We found that the properties of spheroplast membranes are significantly different from that of laboratory-prepared lipid vesicles or that of previously investigated animal cells. The spheroplasts can adjust their internal osmolality by increasing their volumes more than three times upon osmotic downshift. Until the spheroplasts are swollen to their volume limit, their membranes are tensionless. At constant external osmolality, aspiration increases the surface area of the membrane and creates tension. What distinguishes spheroplast membranes from lipid bilayers is that the area change of a spheroplast membrane by tension is a relaxation process. No such time dependence is observed in lipid bilayers. The equilibrium tension-area relation is reversible. The apparent area stretching moduli are several times smaller than that of stretching a lipid bilayer. We conclude that spheroplasts maintain a minimum surface area without tension by a membrane reservoir that removes the excessive membranes from the minimum surface area. Volume expansion eventually exhausts the membrane reservoir; then the membrane behaves like a lipid bilayer with a comparable stretching modulus. Interestingly, the membranes cease to refold when spheroplasts lost viability, implying that the membrane reservoir is metabolically maintained.

Interaction of daptomycin with lipid bilayers: a lipid extracting effect.

Daptomycin is the first approved member of a new structural class of antibiotics, the cyclic lipopeptides. The peptide interacts with the lipid matrix of cell membranes, inducing permeability of the membrane to ions, but its molecular mechanism has been a puzzle. Unlike the ubiquitous membrane-acting host-defense antimicrobial peptides, daptomycin does not induce pores in the cell membranes. Thus, how it affects the permeability of a membrane to ions is not clear. We studied its interaction with giant unilamellar vesicles (GUVs) and discovered a lipid-extracting phenomenon that correlates with the direct action of daptomycin on bacterial membranes observed in a recent fluorescence microscopy study. Lipid extraction occurred only when the GUV lipid composition included phosphatidylglycerol and in the presence of Ca(2+) ions, the same condition found to be necessary for daptomycin to be effective against bacteria. Furthermore, it occurred only when the peptide/lipid ratio exceeded a threshold value, which could be the basis of the minimal inhibitory concentration of daptomycin. In this first publication on the lipid extracting effect, we characterize its dependence on ions and lipid compositions. We also discuss possibilities for connecting the lipid extracting effect to the antibacterial activity of daptomycin.

Process of inducing pores in membranes by melittin.

Melittin is a prototype of the ubiquitous antimicrobial peptides that induce pores in membranes. It is commonly used as a molecular device for membrane permeabilization. Even at concentrations in the nanomolar range, melittin can induce transient pores that allow transmembrane conduction of atomic ions but not leakage of glucose or larger molecules. At micromolar concentrations, melittin induces stable pores allowing transmembrane leakage of molecules up to tens of kilodaltons, corresponding to its antimicrobial activities. Despite extensive studies, aspects of the molecular mechanism for pore formation remain unclear. To clarify the mechanism, one must know the states of the melittin-bound membrane before and after the process. By correlating experiments using giant unilamellar vesicles with those of peptide-lipid multilayers, we found that melittin bound on the vesicle translocated and redistributed to both sides of the membrane before the formation of stable pores. Furthermore, stable pores are formed only above a critical peptide-to-lipid ratio. The initial states for transient and stable pores are different, which implies different mechanisms at low and high peptide concentrations. To determine the lipidic structure of the pore, the pores in peptide-lipid multilayers were induced to form a lattice and examined by anomalous X-ray diffraction. The electron density distribution of lipid labels shows that the pore is formed by merging of two interfaces through a hole. The molecular property of melittin is such that it adsorbs strongly to the bilayer interface. Pore formation can be viewed as the bilayer adopting a lipid configuration to accommodate its excessive interfacial area.

Membrane permeability of hydrocarbon-cross-linked peptides.

Schafmeister, Po, and Verdine (another study) introduced a method using a hydrocarbon linker (staple) to stabilize a peptide in a helical configuration. One intended goal of this scheme is to facilitate the delivery of peptide drugs into target cells. Here, we investigate whether stapled peptides are intrinsically membrane permeable, by performing a case study on a stapled 12-mer peptide named NYAD-1. We found that the native peptide CAI (an HIV-1 inhibitor) does not bind to lipid bilayers, however NYAD-1 indeed permeates through lipid bilayers even at low solution concentrations. To understand the reason for the membrane permeability, we investigated the physical properties of NYAD-1 as a function of bound peptide/lipid molar ratio P/L. We found that NYAD-1 spontaneously binds to a lipid bilayer. At low P/L, the peptide primarily binds on the polar-apolar interface with its helical axis parallel to the bilayer, which has the effect of stretching the membrane area and thinning the membrane. The membrane thinning reaches its maximum at P/L ∼1/15-1/12 in DOPC bilayers. Additional bound peptides have little thinning effect and their helical axes are normal to the plane of bilayers. Thus, the stapled peptide has a membrane interaction behavior similar to helical antimicrobial peptides, such as magainin and melittin. We emphasize that not all peptides that bind to lipid bilayers in the α-helical form behave this way.

How type II diabetes-related islet amyloid polypeptide damages lipid bilayers.

A leading hypothesis for the decimation of insulin-producing ß-cells in type 2 diabetes attributes the cause to islet amyloid polypeptide (IAPP) for its deleterious effects on the cell membranes. This idea has produced extensive investigations on human IAPP (hIAPP) and its interactions with lipid bilayers. However, it is still difficult to correlate the peptide-lipid interactions with its effects on islet cells in culture. The hIAPP fibrils have been shown to interact with lipids and damage lipid bilayers, but appear to have no effect on islet cells in culture. Thus, a modified amyloid hypothesis assumes that the toxicity is caused by hIAPP oligomers, which are not preamyloid fibrils or protofibrils. However, so far such oligomers have not been isolated or identified. The hIAPP monomers also bind to lipid bilayers, but the mode of interaction is not clear. Here, we performed two types of experiments that, to our knowledge, have not been done before. We used x-ray diffraction, in conjunction with circular dichroism measurement, to reveal the location of the peptide bound to a lipid bilayer. We also investigated the effects of hIAPP on giant unilamellar vesicles at various peptide concentrations. We obtained the following qualitative results. Monomeric hIAPP binds within the headgroup region and expands the membrane area of a lipid bilayer. At low concentrations, such binding causes no leakage or damage to the lipid bilayer. At high concentrations, the bound peptides transform to ß-aggregates. The aggregates exit the headgroup region and bind to the surface of lipid bilayers. The damage by the surface bound ß-aggregates depends on the aggregation size. The initial aggregation extracts lipid molecules, which probably causes ion permeation, but no molecular leakage. However, the initial ß-aggregates serve as the seed for larger fibrils, in the manner of the Jarrett-Lansbury seeded-polymerization model, that eventually disintegrate lipid bilayers by electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions.

A novel phase of compressed bilayers that models the prestalk transition state of membrane fusion.

The force model of protein-mediated membrane fusion hypothesizes that fusion is driven by mechanical forces exerted on the membranes, but many details are unknown. Here, we investigated by x-ray diffraction the consequence of applying compressive force on a stack of membranes against the hydration barrier. We found that as the osmotic pressure increased, the lamellar phase transformed first to a new phase of tetragonal lattice (T-phase) over a narrow range of relative humidity, and then to a phase of rhombohedral lattice. The unit cell structure changed from parallel bilayers to a bent configuration with a point contact between adjacent bilayers and then to the stalk hemifusion configuration. The T-phase is discussed as a possible transition state in the membrane merging pathway of fusion. We estimate the work required to form the T-phase and the subsequent hemifusion-stalk-resembling R-phase. The work for the formation of a stalk is compatible with the energy estimated to be released by several SNARE complexes.

Transmembrane pores formed by human antimicrobial peptide LL-37.

Human LL-37 is a multifunctional cathelicidin peptide that has shown a wide spectrum of antimicrobial activity by permeabilizing microbial membranes similar to other antimicrobial peptides; however, its molecular mechanism has not been clarified. Two independent experiments revealed LL-37 bound to membranes in the α-helical form with the axis lying in the plane of membrane. This led to the conclusion that membrane permeabilization by LL-37 is a nonpore carpet-like mechanism of action. Here we report the detection of transmembrane pores induced by LL-37. The pore formation coincided with LL-37 helices aligning approximately normal to the plane of the membrane. We observed an unusual phenomenon of LL-37 embedded in stacked membranes, which are commonly used in peptide orientation studies. The membrane-bound LL-37 was found in the normal orientation only when the membrane spacing in the multilayers exceeded its fully hydrated value. This was achieved by swelling the stacked membranes with excessive water to a swollen state. The transmembrane pores were detected and investigated in swollen states by means of oriented circular dichroism, neutron in-plane scattering, and x-ray lamellar diffraction. The results are consistent with the effect of LL-37 on giant unilamellar vesicles. The detected pores had a water channel of radius 23-33 Å. The molecular mechanism of pore formation by LL-37 is consistent with the two-state model exhibited by magainin and other small pore-forming peptides. The discovery that peptide-membrane interactions in swollen states are different from those in less hydrated states may have implications for other large membrane-active peptides and proteins studied in stacked membranes.

Adhesion and merging of lipid bilayers: a method for measuring the free energy of adhesion and hemifusion.

Lipid bilayers can be induced to adhere to each other by molecular mediators, and, depending on the lipid composition, such adhesion can lead to merging of the contacting monolayers in a process known as hemifusion. Such bilayer-bilayer reactions have never been systematically studied. In the course of our studies of membrane-active molecules, we encountered such reactions. We believe that they need to be understood whenever bilayer-bilayer interactions take place, such as during membrane fusion. For illustration, we discuss three examples: spontaneous adhesion between phospholipid bilayers induced by low pH, polymer-induced osmotic depletion attraction between lipid bilayers, and anionic lipid bilayers cross-bridged by multicationic peptides. Our purpose here is to describe a general method for studying such interactions. We used giant unilamellar vesicles, each of which was aspirated in a micropipette so that we could monitor the tension of the membrane and the membrane area changes during the bilayer-bilayer interaction. We devised a general method for measuring the free energy of adhesion or hemifusion. The results show that the energies of adhesion or hemifusion of lipid bilayers could vary over 2 orders of magnitude from -1 to -50 × 10(-5) J/m(2) in these examples alone. Our method can be used to measure the energy of transition in each step of lipid transformation during membrane fusion. This is relevant for current research on membrane fusion, which focuses on how fusion proteins induce lipid transformations.

Kinetic process of beta-amyloid formation via membrane binding.

Recently we have studied thermodynamics of membrane-mediated beta-amyloid formation in equilibrium experiments using penetratin-lipid mixtures. The results showed that penetratin bound to the membrane interface in the alpha-helical conformation when the peptide/lipid (P/L) ratios were below a lipid-dependent critical value P/L*. When P/L reached P/L*, small beta-aggregates emerged, which served as the nuclei for large beta-aggregates. Here we studied the corresponding kinetic process to understand the potential barriers for the membrane-mediated beta-amyloid formation. We performed kinetic experiments using giant unilamellar vesicles made of 7:3 DOPC/DOPG. The observed time behavior of individual giant unilamellar vesicles, although complex, exhibited the physical effects seen in equilibrium experiments. Most interestingly, a potential barrier appeared to block penetratin from translocating across the bilayer. As a result, the kinetic value for the critical threshold P/L* is roughly one-half of the value measured in equilibrium where peptides bind symmetrically on both sides of lipid bilayers. We also investigated the similarity and differences between the charged and neutral lipids in their interactions with penetratin. We reached an important conclusion that the bound states of peptides in lipid bilayers are largely independent of the charge on the lipid headgroups.

Membrane-mediated peptide conformation change from alpha-monomers to beta-aggregates.

Jarrett and Lansbury's nucleation-dependent polymerization model describes the generic process of beta-amyloid formation for a large number of diverse proteins and peptides. Here, we discuss a case of membrane-mediated nucleation that leads to beta-aggregation. We studied the membrane-mediated conformation changes of the peptide penetratin, and the results of our study led us to a free-energy description for a membrane-mediated version of the Jarrett-Lansbury model. Like the prototype beta-amyloid peptide Alzheimer's Abeta 1-40, penetratin is a random-coil monomer in solution but changes to alpha-helical or beta-like conformations in the presence of anionic lipid membranes. We measured the correlations between the membrane-bound conformation of penetratin and its effect on the bilayer thickness in four different lipids with various degrees of chain unsaturation. We found a new lipid chain effect on peptide conformation. Our results showed that the interface of a lipid bilayer provided energetically favorable binding sites for penetratin in the alpha-helical form. However, increasing the bound molecules/lipid ratio elevated the energy level of the bound states toward a higher level that favored creation of small beta-aggregates. The binding to the beta-aggregate became more energetically favorable as the aggregate grew larger. The peptide aggregates were visible on the surface of giant unilamellar vesicles. Thus, membrane binding facilitates nucleation-dependent beta-aggregation, which could be the prototype for the general membrane-mediated pathway to beta-amyloid formation.