Using 2D-IR Spectroscopy to Measure the Structure, Dynamics, and Intermolecular Interactions of Proteins in H2O.

ConspectusInfrared (IR) spectroscopy probes molecular structure at the level of the chemical bond or functional group. In the case of proteins, the most informative band in the IR spectrum is the amide I band, which arises predominantly from the C═O stretching vibration of the peptide link. The folding of proteins into secondary and tertiary structures leads to vibrational coupling between peptide units, generating specific amide I spectral signatures that provide a fingerprint of the macromolecular conformation. Ultrafast two-dimensional IR (2D-IR) spectroscopy allows the amide I band of a protein to be spread over a second frequency dimension in a way that mirrors 2D-NMR methods. This means that amide I 2D-IR spectroscopy produces a spectral map that is exquisitely sensitive to protein structure and dynamics and so provides detailed insights that cannot be matched by IR absorption spectroscopy. As a result, 2D-IR spectroscopy has emerged as a powerful tool for probing protein structure and dynamics over a broad range of time and length scales in the solution phase at room temperature. However, the protein amide I band coincides with an IR absorption from the bending vibration of water (δHOH), the natural biological solvent. To circumvent this problem, protein IR studies are routinely performed in D2O solutions because H/D substitution shifts the solvent bending mode (δDOD) to a lower frequency, revealing the amide I band. While effective, this method raises fundamental questions regarding the impact of the change in solvent mass on the structural or solvation dynamics of the protein and the removal of the energetic resonance between solvent and solute.In this Account, a series of studies applying 2D-IR to study the spectroscopy and dynamics of proteins in H2O-rich solvents is reviewed. A comparison of IR absorption spectroscopy and 2D-IR spectroscopy of protein-containing fluids is used to demonstrate the basis of the approach before a series of applications is presented. These range from measurements of fundamental protein biophysics to recent applications of machine learning to gain insight into protein-drug binding in complex mixtures. An outlook is presented, considering the potential for 2D-IR measurements to contribute to our understanding of protein behavior under near-physiological conditions, along with an evaluation of the obstacles that still need to be overcome.

Understanding the [NiFe] Hydrogenase Active Site Environment through Ultrafast Infrared and 2D-IR Spectroscopy of the Subsite Analogue K[CpFe(CO)(CN)2] in Polar and Protic Solvents.

The [CpFe(CO)(CN)2]- unit is an excellent structural model for the Fe(CO)(CN)2 moiety of the active site found in [NiFe] hydrogenases. Ultrafast infrared (IR) pump-probe and 2D-IR spectroscopy have been used to study K[CpFe(CO)(CN)2] (M1) in a range of protic and polar solvents and as a dry film. Measurements of anharmonicity, intermode vibrational coupling strength, vibrational relaxation time, and solvation dynamics of the CO and CN stretching modes of M1 in H2O, D2O, methanol, dimethyl sulfoxide, and acetonitrile reveal that H-bonding to the CN ligands plays an important role in defining the spectroscopic characteristics and relaxation dynamics of the Fe(CO)(CN)2 unit. Comparisons of the spectroscopic and dynamic data obtained for M1 in solution and in a dry film with those obtained for the enzyme led to the conclusion that the protein backbone forms an important part of the bimetallic active site environment via secondary coordination sphere interactions.

Biomolecular infrared spectroscopy: making time for dynamics.

Time resolved infrared spectroscopy of biological molecules has provided a wealth of information relating to structural dynamics, conformational changes, solvation and intermolecular interactions. Challenges still exist however arising from the wide range of timescales over which biological processes occur, stretching from picoseconds to minutes or hours. Experimental methods are often limited by vibrational lifetimes of probe groups, which are typically on the order of picoseconds, while measuring an evolving system continuously over some 18 orders of magnitude in time presents a raft of technological hurdles. In this Perspective, a series of recent advances which allow biological molecules and processes to be studied over an increasing range of timescales, while maintaining ultrafast time resolution, will be reviewed, showing that the potential for real-time observation of biomolecular function draws ever closer, while offering a new set of challenges to be overcome.

Optical Screening and Classification of Drug Binding to Proteins in Human Blood Serum.

Protein-drug interactions in the human bloodstream are important factors in applications ranging from drug design, where protein binding influences efficacy and dose delivery, to biomedical diagnostics, where rapid, quantitative measurements could guide optimized treatment regimes. Current measurement approaches use multistep assays, which probe the protein-bound drug fraction indirectly and do not provide fundamental structural or dynamic information about the in vivo protein-drug interaction. We demonstrate that ultrafast 2D-IR spectroscopy can overcome these issues by providing a direct, label-free optical measurement of protein-drug binding in blood serum samples. Four commonly prescribed drugs, known to bind to human serum albumin (HSA), were added to pooled human serum at physiologically relevant concentrations. In each case, spectral changes to the amide I band of the serum sample were observed, consistent with binding to HSA, but were distinct for each of the four drugs. A machine-learning-based classification of the serum samples achieved a total cross-validation prediction accuracy of 92% when differentiating serum-only samples from those with a drug present. Identification on a per-drug basis achieved correct drug identification in 75% of cases. These unique spectroscopic signatures of the drug-protein interaction thus enable the detection and differentiation of drug containing samples and give structural insight into the binding process as well as quantitative information on protein-drug binding. Using currently available instrumentation, the 2D-IR data acquisition required just 1 min and 10 µL of serum per sample, and so these results pave the way to fast, specific, and quantitative measurements of protein-drug binding in vivo with potentially invaluable applications for the development of novel therapies and personalized medicine.

Tuning of B12 photochemistry in the CarH photoreceptor to avoid radical photoproducts.

Time-resolved infrared spectroscopy reveals the flow of electron density through coenzyme B12 in the light-activated, bacterial transcriptional regulator, CarH. The protein stabilises a series of charge transfer states that result in a photoresponse that avoids reactive, and potentially damaging, radical photoproducts.

Modulation of IL-17 backbone dynamics reduces receptor affinity and reveals a new inhibitory mechanism.

Knowledge of protein dynamics is fundamental to the understanding of biological processes, with NMR and 2D-IR spectroscopy being two of the principal methods for studying protein dynamics. Here, we combine these two methods to gain a new understanding of the complex mechanism of a cytokine:receptor interaction. The dynamic nature of many cytokines is now being recognised as a key property in the signalling mechanism. Interleukin-17s (IL-17) are proinflammatory cytokines which, if unregulated, are associated with serious autoimmune diseases such as psoriasis, and although there are several therapeutics on the market for these conditions, small molecule therapeutics remain elusive. Previous studies, exploiting crystallographic methods alone, have been unable to explain the dramatic differences in affinity observed between IL-17 dimers and their receptors, suggesting there are factors that cannot be fully explained by the analysis of static structures alone. Here, we show that the IL-17 family of cytokines have varying degrees of flexibility which directly correlates to their receptor affinities. Small molecule inhibitors of the cytokine:receptor interaction are usually thought to function by either causing steric clashes or structural changes. However, our results, supported by other biophysical methods, provide evidence for an alternate mechanism of inhibition, in which the small molecule rigidifies the protein, causing a reduction in receptor affinity. The results presented here indicate an induced fit model of cytokine:receptor binding, with the more flexible cytokines having a higher affinity. Our approach could be applied to other systems where the inhibition of a protein-protein interaction has proved intractable, for example due to the flat, featureless nature of the interface. Targeting allosteric sites which modulate protein dynamics, opens up new avenues for novel therapeutic development.

Temperature-Induced Effects on the Structure of Gramicidin S.

We report on the structure of Gramicidin S (GS) in a model membrane mimetic environment represented by the amphipathic solvent 1-octanol using one-dimensional (1D) and two-dimensional (2D) IR spectroscopy. To explore potential structural changes of GS, we also performed a series of spectroscopic measurements at differing temperatures. By analyzing the amide I band and using 2D-IR spectral changes, results could be associated to the disruption of aggregates/oligomers, as well as structural and conformational changes happening in the concentrated solution of GS. The ability of 2D-IR to enable differentiation in melting transitions of oligomerized GS structures is attributed to the sensitivity of the technique to vibrational coupling. Two melting transition temperatures were identified; at Tm1 in the range 41-47 °C where the GS aggregates/oligomers disassemble and at Tm2 = 57 ± 2 °C where there is significant change involving GS ß-sheet-type hydrogen bonds, whereby it is proposed that there is loss of interpeptide hydrogen bonds and we are left with mainly intrapeptide ß-sheet and ß-turn hydrogen bonds of the smaller oligomers. Further analysis with quantum mechanical/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) simulations and second derivative results highlighted the participation of active GS side chains. Ultimately, this work contributes toward understanding the GS structure and the formulation of GS analogues with improved bioactivity.

2D-IR spectroscopy of proteins in H2O-A Perspective.

The form of the amide I infrared absorption band provides a sensitive probe of the secondary structure and dynamics of proteins in the solution phase. However, the frequency coincidence of the amide I band with the bending vibrational mode of H2O has necessitated the widespread use of deuterated solvents. Recently, it has been demonstrated that ultrafast 2D-IR spectroscopy allows the detection of the protein amide I band in H2O-based fluids, meaning that IR methods can now be applied to study proteins in physiologically relevant solvents. In this perspective, we describe the basis of the 2D-IR method for observing the protein amide I band in H2O and show how this development has the potential to impact areas ranging from our fundamental appreciation of protein structural dynamics to new applications for 2D-IR spectroscopy in the analytical and biomedical sciences. In addition, we discuss how the spectral response of water, rather than being a hindrance, now provides a basis for new approaches to data pre-processing, standardization of 2D-IR data collection, and signal quantification. Ultimately, we visualize a direction of travel toward the creation of 2D-IR spectral libraries that can be linked to advanced computational methods for use in high-throughput protein screening and disease diagnosis.

Measuring proteins in H2O using 2D-IR spectroscopy: pre-processing steps and applications toward a protein library.

The ability of two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectroscopy to measure the amide I band of proteins in H2O rather than D2O-based solvents by evading the interfering water signals has enabled in vivo studies of proteins under physiological conditions and in biofluids. Future exploitation of 2D-IR in analytical settings, from diagnostics to protein screening, will, however, require comparisons between multiple datasets, necessitating control of data collection protocols to minimize measurement-to-measurement inconsistencies. Inspired by analytical spectroscopy applications in other disciplines, we describe a workflow for pre-processing 2D-IR data that aims to simplify spectral cross-comparisons. Our approach exploits the thermal water signal that is collected simultaneously with, but is temporally separated from the amide I response to guide custom baseline correction and spectral normalization strategies before combining them with Principal Component noise reduction tools. Case studies show that application of elements of the pre-processing workflow to previously published data enables improvements in quantification accuracy and detection limits. We subsequently apply the complete workflow in a new pilot study, testing the ability of a prototype library of 2D-IR spectra to quantify the four major protein constituents of blood serum in a single, label-free measurement. These advances show progress toward the robust data handling strategies that will be necessary for future applications of 2D-IR to pharmaceutical or biomedical problems.

Metasurface-enhanced mid-infrared spectroscopy in the liquid phase.

Vibrational spectroscopy is an important tool in chemical and biological analysis. A key issue when applying vibrational spectroscopy to dilute liquid samples is the inherently low sensitivity caused by short interaction lengths and small extinction coefficients, combined with low target molecule concentrations. Here, we introduce a novel type of surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy based on the resonance of a dielectric metasurface. We demonstrate that the method is suitable for probing vibrational bands of dilute analytes with a range of spectral linewidths. We observe that the absorption signal is enhanced by 1-2 orders of magnitude and show that this enhancement leads to a lower limit of detection compared to attenuated total reflection (ATR). Overall, the technique provides an important addition to the spectroscopist's toolkit especially for probing dilute samples.

Ultrafast 2D-IR spectroscopy of [NiFe] hydrogenase from E. coli reveals the role of the protein scaffold in controlling the active site environment.

Ultrafast two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectroscopy of Escherichia coli Hyd-1 (EcHyd-1) reveals the structural and dynamic influence of the protein scaffold on the Fe(CO)(CN)2 unit of the active site. Measurements on as-isolated EcHyd-1 probed a mixture of active site states including two, which we assign to Nir-SI/II, that have not been previously observed in the E. coli enzyme. Explicit assignment of carbonyl (CO) and cyanide (CN) stretching bands to each state is enabled by 2D-IR. Energies of vibrational levels up to and including two-quantum vibrationally excited states of the CO and CN modes have been determined along with the associated vibrational relaxation dynamics. The carbonyl stretching mode potential is well described by a Morse function and couples weakly to the cyanide stretching vibrations. In contrast, the two CN stretching modes exhibit extremely strong coupling, leading to the observation of formally forbidden vibrational transitions in the 2D-IR spectra. We show that the vibrational relaxation times and structural dynamics of the CO and CN ligand stretching modes of the enzyme active site differ markedly from those of a model compound K[CpFe(CO)(CN)2] in aqueous solution and conclude that the protein scaffold creates a unique biomolecular environment for the NiFe site that cannot be represented by analogy to simple models of solvation.

Reversible Glutamate Coordination to High-Valent Nickel Protects the Active Site of a [NiFe] Hydrogenase from Oxygen.

NAD+-reducing [NiFe] hydrogenases are valuable biocatalysts for H2-based energy conversion and the regeneration of nucleotide cofactors. While most hydrogenases are sensitive toward O2 and elevated temperatures, the soluble NAD+-reducing [NiFe] hydrogenase from Hydrogenophilus thermoluteolus (HtSH) is O2-tolerant and thermostable. Thus, it represents a promising candidate for biotechnological applications. Here, we have investigated the catalytic activity and active-site structure of native HtSH and variants in which a glutamate residue in the active-site cavity was replaced by glutamine, alanine, and aspartate. Our biochemical, spectroscopic, and theoretical studies reveal that at least two active-site states of oxidized HtSH feature an unusual architecture in which the glutamate acts as a terminal ligand of the active-site nickel. This observation demonstrates that crystallographically observed glutamate coordination represents a native feature of the enzyme. One of these states is diamagnetic and characterized by a very high stretching frequency of an iron-bound active-site CO ligand. Supported by density-functional-theory calculations, we identify this state as a high-valent species with a biologically unprecedented formal Ni(IV) ground state. Detailed insights into its structure and dynamics were obtained by ultrafast and two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy, demonstrating that it represents a conformationally strained state with unusual bond properties. Our data further show that this state is selectively and reversibly formed under oxic conditions, especially upon rapid exposure to high O2 levels. We conclude that the kinetically controlled formation of this six-coordinate high-valent state represents a specific and precisely orchestrated stereoelectronic response toward O2 that could protect the enzyme from oxidative damage.

Detection of paracetamol binding to albumin in blood serum using 2D-IR spectroscopy.

Binding of drugs to blood serum proteins can influence both therapeutic efficacy and toxicity. The ability to measure the concentrations of protein-bound drug molecules quickly and with limited sample preparation could therefore have considerable benefits in biomedical and pharmaceutical applications. Vibrational spectroscopies provide data quickly but are hampered by complex, overlapping protein amide I band profiles and water absorption. Here, we show that two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectroscopy can achieve rapid detection and quantification of paracetamol binding to serum albumin in blood serum at physiologically-relevant levels with no additional sample processing. By measuring changes to the amide I band of serum albumin caused by structural and dynamic impacts of paracetamol binding we show that drug concentrations as low as 7 µM can be detected and that the availability of albumin for paracetamol binding is less than 20% in serum samples, allowing identification of paracetamol levels consistent with a patient overdose.

Combining steady state and temperature jump IR spectroscopy to investigate the allosteric effects of ligand binding to dsDNA.

Changes in the structural dynamics of double stranded (ds)DNA upon ligand binding have been linked to the mechanism of allostery without conformational change, but direct experimental evidence remains elusive. To address this, a combination of steady state infrared (IR) absorption spectroscopy and ultrafast temperature jump IR absorption measurements has been used to quantify the extent of fast (∼100 ns) fluctuations in (ds)DNA·Hoechst 33258 complexes at a range of temperatures. Exploiting the direct link between vibrational band intensities and base stacking shows that the absolute magnitude of the change in absorbance caused by fast structural fluctuations following the temperature jump is only weakly dependent on the starting temperature of the sample. The observed fast dynamics are some two orders of magnitude faster than strand separation and associated with all points along the 10-base pair duplex d(GCATATATCC). Binding the Hoechst 33258 ligand causes a small but consistent reduction in the extent of these fast fluctuations of base pairs located outside of the ligand binding region. These observations point to a ligand-induced reduction in the flexibility of the dsDNA near the binding site, consistent with an estimated allosteric propagation length of 15 Å, about 5 base pairs, which agrees well with both molecular simulation and coarse-grained statistical mechanics models of allostery leading to cooperative ligand binding.

Differentiation of bacterial spores via 2D-IR spectroscopy.

Ultrafast 2D-IR spectroscopy is a powerful tool for understanding the spectroscopy and dynamics of biological molecules in the solution phase. A number of recent studies have begun to explore the utility of the information-rich 2D-IR spectra for analytical applications. Here, we report the application of ultrafast 2D-IR spectroscopy for the detection and classification of bacterial spores. 2D-IR spectra of Bacillus atrophaeus and Bacillus thuringiensis spores as dry films on CaF2 windows were obtained. The sporulated nature of the bacteria was confirmed using 2D-IR diagonal and off-diagonal peaks arising from the calcium dipicolinate CaDP·3H2O biomarker for sporulation. Distinctive peaks, in the protein amide I region of the spectrum were used to differentiate the two types of spore. The identified marker modes demonstrate the potential for the use of 2D-IR methods as a direct means of spore classification. We discuss these new results in perspective with the current state of analytical 2D-IR measurements, showing that the potential exists to apply 2D-IR spectroscopy to detect the spores on surfaces and in suspensions as well as in dry films. The results demonstrate how applying 2D-IR screening methodologies to spores would enable the creation of a library of spectra for classification purposes.

Detection of Glycine as a Model Protein in Blood Serum Using 2D-IR Spectroscopy.

Glycine (Gly) is used as a model system to evaluate the ability of ultrafast two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectroscopy to detect and quantify the low-molecular-weight proteinaceous components of blood serum. Combining data acquisition schemes to suppress absorption bands of H2O that overlap with the protein amide I band with analysis of peak patterns appearing in the off-diagonal region of the 2D-IR spectrum allows separation of the Gly spectral signature from that of the dominant protein fraction of serum in a transmission-mode 2D-IR measurement without any sample manipulation, e.g., filtration or drying. 2D-IR spectra of blood serum samples supplemented with varying concentrations of Gly were obtained, and a range of data analysis methods compared, leading to a detection limit of ∼3 mg/mL for Gly. The reported methodology provides a platform for a critical assessment of the sensitivity of 2D-IR for measuring the concentrations of amino acids, peptides, and low-molecular-weight proteins present in serum samples. We conclude that, in the case of several clinically relevant diagnostic molecules and their combinations, the potential exists for 2D-IR to complement IR absorption methods as the benefits of the second frequency dimension offered by 2D-IR spectroscopy outweigh the added technical complexity of the measurement.

Experimental observation of nanophase segregation in aqueous salt solutions around the predicted liquid-liquid transition in water.

The liquid-liquid transition in supercooled liquid water, predicted to occur around 220 K, is controversial due to the difficulty of studying it caused by competition from ice crystallization (the so-called "no man's land"). In aqueous solutions, it has been predicted to give rise to phase separation on a nanometer scale between a solute-rich high-density phase and a water-rich low-density phase. Here we report direct experimental evidence for the formation of a nanosegregated phase in eutectic aqueous solutions of LiCl and LiSCN where the presence of crystalline water can be experimentally excluded. Femtosecond infrared and Raman spectroscopies are used to determine the temperature-dependent structuring of water, the solvation of the SCN- anion, and the size of the phase segregated domains.

Time-Resolved Temperature-Jump Infrared Spectroscopy at a High Repetition Rate.

Time-resolved temperature-jump infrared absorption spectroscopy at a 0.5 to 1 kHz repetition rate is presented. A 1 kHz neodymium-doped yttrium aluminum garnet (Nd:YAG) laser pumping an optical parametric oscillator provided >70 µJ, 3.75 µm pump pulses, which delivered a temperature jump via excitation of the O-D stretch of a D2O solution. A 10 kHz train of mid-infrared probe pulses was used to monitor spectral changes following the temperature jump. Calibration with trifluoroacetic acid solution showed that a temperature jump of 10 K lasting for tens of microseconds was achieved, sufficient to observe fast processes in functionally relevant biomolecular mechanisms. Modeling of heating profiles across ≤10 µm path length cells and subsequent cooling dynamics are used to describe the initial <100 ns cooling at the window surface and subsequent, >10 µs cooling dynamics of the bulk solution.

Two-dimensional infrared spectroscopy: an emerging analytical tool?

Ultrafast two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectroscopy has provided valuable insights into biomolecular structure and dynamics, but recent progress in laser technology and data analysis methods have demonstrated the potential for high throughput 2D-IR measurements and analytical applications. Using 2D-IR as an analytical tool requires a different approach to data collection and analysis compared to pure research applications however and, in this review, we highlight progress towards usage of 2D-IR spectroscopy in areas relevant to biomedical, pharmaceutical and analytical molecular science. We summarise the technical and methodological advances made to date and discuss the challenges that still face 2D-IR spectroscopy as it attempts to transition from the state-of-the-art laser laboratory to the standard suite of analytical tools.

2D-Infrared Spectroscopy of Proteins in Water: Using the Solvent Thermal Response as an Internal Standard.

Ultrafast two-dimensional infrared (2D-IR) spectra can now be obtained in a matter of seconds, opening up the possibility of high-throughput screening applications of relevance to the biomedical and pharmaceutical sectors. Determining quantitative information from 2D-IR spectra recorded on different samples and different instruments is however made difficult by variations in beam alignment, laser intensity, and sample conditions. Recently, we demonstrated that 2D-IR spectroscopy of the protein amide I band can be performed in aqueous (H2O) rather than deuterated (D2O) solvents, and we now report a method that uses the magnitude of the associated thermal response of H2O as an internal normalization standard for 2D-IR spectra. Using the water response, which is temporally separated from the protein signal, to normalize the spectra allows significant reduction of the impact of measurement-to-measurement fluctuations on the data. We demonstrate that this normalization method enables creation of calibration curves for measurement of absolute protein concentrations and facilitates reproducible difference spectroscopy methodologies. These advances make significant progress toward the robust data handling strategies that will be essential for the realization of automated spectral analysis tools for large scale 2D-IR screening studies of protein-containing solutions and biofluids.