Extended intralesional curettage preferred over resection-arthrodesis for giant cell tumour of the distal radius.

BACKGROUND: Distal radius giant cell tumour (GCT) is known to be associated with distinct management difficulties, including high rates of local recurrence and lung metastases compared to other anatomic locations. Multiple treatment options exist, each with different outcomes and complications. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: To compare oncological and functional outcomes and complications following treatment of patients with distal radius GCT by extended intralesional curettage (EIC) or resection-arthrodesis. METHODS: Patients operated on for distal radius GCT were identified from prospectively collected databases at four Canadian musculoskeletal oncology specialty centres. There were 57 patients with a mean age of 35.4 years (range 17-57). Thirteen tumours were Campanacci grade 2, and 40 were Grade 3 (4 unknown). Twenty patients presented with an associated pathologic fracture. There were 34 patients treated by EIC and 23 by en bloc resection and wrist arthrodesis. All resections were performed for grade 3 tumours. The mean follow-up was 86 months (range 1-280). RESULTS: There were a total of 11 (19%) local recurrences: 10 of 34 (29%) in the EIC group compared to only 1 of 23 (4%) in the resection-arthrodesis group (p = 0.028). For the 10 patients with local recurrence following initial treatment by EIC, 7 underwent repeat EIC, while 3 required resection-arthrodesis. The one local recurrence following initial resection was managed with repeat resection-arthrodesis. Six of the 11 local recurrences followed treatment of Campanacci grade 3 tumours, while 4 were in grade 2 lesions and in one case of recurrence the grade was unknown. There were no post-operative complications after EIC, whereas 7 patients (30%) had post-operative complications following resection-arthrodesis including 4 infections, one malunion, one non-union and one fracture (p = 0.001). The mean post-operative Musculoskeletal Tumor Society score was 33.5 in the curettage group compared to 27 in the resection group (p = 0.001). The mean Toronto Extremity Salvage Score was 98.3% following curettage compared to 91.5% after resection (p = 0.006). No patients experienced lung metastasis or death. CONCLUSIONS: EIC is an effective alternative to wide resection-arthrodesis following treatment of distal radius GCT, with the advantage of preserving the distal radius and wrist joint function, but with a higher risk of local recurrence. Most local recurrences following initial treatment by EIC could be managed with iterative curettage and joint preservation. Wide excision and arthrodesis were associated with a significantly lower risk of tumour recurrence but was technically challenging and associated with more frequent post-operative complications. EIC was associated with better functional scores. Resection should be reserved for the most severe grade 3 tumours and recurrent and complex cases not amenable to treatment with EIC and joint salvage. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III, retrospective comparative trial.

Early Improvement in Pain and Functional Outcome but Not Quality of Life After Surgery for Metastatic Long Bone Disease.

BACKGROUND: Bone metastases represent the most frequent cause of cancer-related pain, affecting health-related quality of life and creating a substantial burden on the healthcare system. Although most bony metastatic lesions can be managed nonoperatively, surgical management can help patients reduce severe pain, avoid impending fracture, and stabilize pathologic fractures. Studies have demonstrated functional improvement postoperatively as early as 6 weeks, but little data exist on the temporal progress of these improvements or on the changes in quality of life over time as a result of surgical intervention. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) Do patients' functional outcomes, pain, and quality of life improve after surgery for long bone metastases? (2) What is the temporal progress of these changes to 1 year after surgery or death? (3) What is the overall and 30-day rate of complications after surgery for long bone metastases? (4) What are the oncologic outcomes including overall survival and local disease recurrence for this patient population? METHODS: A multicenter, prospective study from three orthopaedic oncology centers in Quebec, Canada, was conducted between 2008 and 2016 to examine the improvement in function and quality of life after surgery for patients with long bone metastases. During this time, 184 patients out of a total of 210 patients evaluated during this period were enrolled; of those, 141 (77%) had complete followup at a minimum of 2 weeks (mean, 23 weeks; range, 2-52 weeks) or until death, whereas another 35 (19%) were lost to followup but were not known to have died before the minimum followup interval was achieved. Pathologic fracture was present in 34% (48 of 141) of patients. The median Mirel's score for those who underwent prophylactic surgery was 10 (interquartile range, 10-11). Surgical procedures included intramedullary nailing (55), endoprosthetic replacement (49), plate osteosynthesis (31), extended intralesional curettage (four), and allograft reconstruction (two). Seventy-seven percent (108 of 141) of patients received radiotherapy. The Musculoskeletal Tumor Society (MSTS), Toronto Extremity Salvage Score (TESS), Brief Pain Inventory (BPI) form, and Quality Of Life During Serious Illness (QOLLTI-P) form were administered pre- and postoperatively at 2 weeks, 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, and 1 year. Analysis of variance followed by post hoc analysis was conducted to test for significance between pre- and postoperative scores. The Kaplan-Meier estimate was used to calculate overall survivorship and local recurrence-free survival. A p value of < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. RESULTS: MSTS and BPI pain scores improved at 2 weeks when compared with preoperative scores (MSTS: 39% ± 24% pre- versus 62% ± 19% postoperative, mean difference [MD] 23, 95% confidence interval [CI], 16-32, p < 0.001; BPI: 52% ± 21% pre- versus 30% ± 21% postoperative, MD 22, 95% CI, 16-32, p < 0.001). Continuous and incremental improvement in TESS, MSTS, and BPI scores was observed temporally at 6 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, and 1 year; for example, the TESS score improved from 44% ± 24% to 73% ± 21% (MD 29, p < 0.001, 95% CI, 19-38) at 6 months. We did not detect a difference in quality of life as measured by the QOLLTI-P score (6 ± 1 pre- versus 7 ± 4 postoperative, MD 1, 95% CI, -0.4 to 3, p = 0.2). The overall and 30-day rates of systemic complications were 35% (49 of 141) and 14% (20 of 141), respectively. The Kaplan-Meier estimates for overall survival were 70% (95% CI, 62.4-78) at 6 months and 41% (95% CI, 33-49) at 1 year. Local recurrence-free survival was 17 weeks (95% CI, 11-24). CONCLUSIONS: Surgical management of metastatic long bone disease substantially improves patients' functional outcome and pain as early as 2 weeks postoperatively and should be considered for impending or pathologic fracture in patients whose survival is expected to be longer than 2 weeks provided that there are no immediate contraindications. Quality of life in this patient population did not improve, which may be a function of patient selection, concomitant chemoradiotherapy regimens, disease progression, or terminal illness, and this merits further investigation. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level II, therapeutic study.

Forearm soft tissue sarcoma: tumors characteristics and oncologic outcomes following limb salvage surgery.

BACKGROUND: Complex anatomy of the forearm may impact on local control and survivals of soft tissue sarcoma. Little is known about characteristics and oncologic outcomes following surgical treatment. METHODS: Demographic and tumor data of 117 patients with forearm soft tissue sarcoma were collected and analyzed. Following limb salvage, survivals, and prognostic factors were studied. RESULTS: Seventy-three patients were males (62%) and 53 (45%) were referred after unplanned excision. Pleomorphic undifferentiated sarcoma was most frequent (45%). The average tumor size was 5.1 cm and grade III histology was mostly identified (53%). With radiotherapy, local recurrence occurs in 8 patients (7%) and 30 patients (24%) developed metastasis. Overall survival, disease free survival, local recurrence free survival, and metastasis free survival were 83%, 74%, 93%, and 74%, respectively. Better survival was found for grade I (80% vs. 60%) and small size (<5 cm) (72% vs. 47%). Large size tumor, extra-compartmental site, extramuscular, and virgin tumor were positive predictors of metastasis. CONCLUSION: Soft tissue sarcomas of the forearm are often referred after unplanned excision. Limb salvage was achieved for most and local recurrence remained low in context of radiotherapy. Metastatic progression remained frequent. Low grade and small size were predictors of survival.

Para-iliac actinomycetoma presenting as sarcoma, a late complication of appendicitis: A case report.

INTRODUCTION: Actinomycosis is known to mimic several types of neoplasms, leading to morbid surgical interventions. PRESENTATION OF CASE: We report the particular case of an extensive right para-iliac actinomycetoma presenting as a sarcoma, which to our knowledge has not yet been described in the literature, in a patient with previous ruptured appendicitis. Thanks to the collaborative work between the orthopedic and general surgeons, pathologist and microbiologist, the diagnosis of actinomycosis was made pre-operatively, saving this 15-year-old patient from a tumor resection protocol. DISCUSSION: Actinomycetomas have often been reported to present in the same way as several abdominal and gynecological neoplasms, and on rare occasions been described as mimicking other soft-tissue sarcomas, leading to unnecessary morbid tumor resection protocols. The most common cause of abdominal actinomycosis is perforated appendicitis, and may present several years later. CONCLUSION: While faced with a soft tissue mass transgressing tissue planes and possibly extending to the region of the right lower quadrant, especially with a history of previous perforated appendicitis, one should consider the possibility of an abscess caused by pathogens of intestinal origin, including the gram positive anaerobe Actinomycosis israelii. Failure to actively search for this pathogen, which is not detectable with routine staining techniques and may take up to 1-2 weeks to isolate, may lead to unnecessary morbid surgical procedures.

Effectiveness of pamidronate as treatment of symptomatic osteonecrosis occurring in children treated for acute lymphoblastic leukemia.

BACKGROUND: Osteonecrosis (ON) is a severe complication of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) treatments. Recent studies suggest that bisphosphonates might reduce pain and loss of motor function in patients with ON. We assessed the effects of pamidronate compared to standard care in patients with symptomatic ON (sON) and studied whether steroids might be continued after diagnosis of ON in some patients. METHODS: We evaluated 17 patients with sON as complication of primary ALL treatment between 2000 and 2008. Fourteen patients were treated with pamidronate. Mobility and pain control were monitored in all patients. Affected joints were classified by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) at ON diagnosis and after 6-72 months. RESULTS: Out of 220 patients with ALL, 17 (7.7%) patients developed sON. The median age at ALL diagnosis was 11 years (range: 2.7-16.6 years) and sON occurred a median of 13.4 months (range: 2.5-34 months) after ALL diagnosis. Affected joints were hip, knee and ankle. MRI scans showed 7 severe, 4 moderate, and 6 mild ON lesions. Fourteen patients showed improvement in pain (77% of patients) and motor function (59% of patients), even though corticoids were reintroduced in 4 patients. MRI demonstrated improvement, stability or worsening in 6, 3, and 5 cases, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Pamidronate seems to be effective in the management of pain and motor function recovery in sON. Further studies are needed to provide evidence as to whether bisphosphonates can be recommended for the treatment or the prevention of ON in childhood ALL patients.

Adverse effect of older age on the recurrence of soft tissue sarcoma of the extremities and trunk.

PURPOSE: To examine the effect of age on the recurrence of soft tissue sarcoma in the extremities and trunk. PATIENTS AND METHODS: This was a multicenter study that included 2,385 patients with median age at surgery of 57 years. The end points considered were local recurrence and metastasis. Cox proportional hazards models were used to estimate hazard ratios across the age ranges with and without adjustment for known confounding factors. RESULTS: Older patients presented with tumors that were larger (P < .001) and of higher grade (P < .001). The proportion of positive margins increased significantly as patients age (P < .001), but radiation therapy was relatively underused in patients older than age 60 years. The 5-year cumulative incidences of local recurrence were 7.2% (95% CI, 4% to 11.7%) for patients age 30 years or younger and 12.9% (95% CI, 9.1% to 17.5%) for patients age 75 years or older. The corresponding 5-year cumulative incidences of metastasis were 17.5% (95% CI, 12.1% to 23.7%) and 33.9% (95% CI, 28.1% to 39.8%) for the same groups. Regression models showed that age was significantly associated with local recurrence (P < .001) and metastasis (P < .001) in nonadjusted models. After adjusting for imbalance in presentation and treatment variables, age remained significantly associated with local recurrence (P = .031) and metastasis (P = .019). CONCLUSION: Older patients have worse outcomes because they tend to present with worse tumors and are treated less aggressively. However, there remained a significant increase in the risk of both local and systemic recurrence associated with increasing age that could not be explained by tumor or treatment characteristics.

Case series. Soft-tissue sarcoma of the foot.

BACKGROUND: We reviewed cases of soft-tissue sarcoma of the foot to gain insight into the presentation, treatments and outcomes for this rare disease and to determine whether limb-salvage surgery yields reasonable functional and oncological outcomes. METHODS: We reviewed the cases of 16 patients treated by 2 of us (R.T. and M.I.) for soft-tissue sarcoma of the foot over a 15-year period. We extracted the following information from each patient's medical record: disease status at presentation, prior treatment, histological diagnosis, American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) stage, details of treatment, oncological outcome and functional outcome. Functional outcome was assessed with the Toronto Extremity Salvage Score (TESS) and the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society (MSTS 1987). RESULTS: Follow-up averaged 6 (range 2­15) years. Eight patients presented after unplanned excision. Histological diagnosis was synovial sarcoma for 7 of 16 patients.The tumours were evenly distributed among the hindfoot, midfoot and forefoot. Most patients (n = 13) presented with AJCC stage II or III disease. Amputation was necessary for 3 patients, whereas limb salvage was possible for the other 13. Free tissue transfer (n = 9) and radiation therapy (n = 12) were used in most cases. Surgical margins were microscopically positive in 4 of the 13 patients treated with limb salvage.Local disease recurred in 2 patients. Lung metastases occurred in 4 patients. At last follow-up, 11 of 16 patients were alive without disease, 2 with disease and 3 had died of their disease. Functional assessment with MSTS 1987 and the TESS averaged 28%and 90%, respectively, after limb salvage. CONCLUSION: In this series, we found that, first, patients frequently presented after unplanned excision, and this may have led to worse oncological outcomes compared with patients who presented primarily. Second, limb salvage was usually possible, but it required accepting marginal resections, relying on free tissue transfer to obtain coverage and using radiation therapy to obtain local control. Third, this combination yielded an acceptable local control rate and very good functional outcomes.

Local recurrence after initial multidisciplinary management of soft tissue sarcoma: is there a way out?

BACKGROUND: Multimodality treatment of primary soft tissue sarcoma by expert teams reportedly affords a low incidence of local recurrence. Despite advances, treatment of local recurrence remains difficult and is not standardized. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: We (1) determined the incidence of local recurrence from soft tissue sarcoma; (2) compared characteristics of the recurrent tumors with those of the primary ones; (3) evaluated local recurrences, metastases and death according to treatments; and (4) explored the relationship between the diagnosis of local recurrence and the occurrence of metastases. METHODS: From our prospective database, we identified 618 soft tissue sarcomas. Thirty-seven of the 618 patients (6%) had local recurrence. Leiomyosarcoma was the most frequent diagnosis (eight of 37). The mean delay from original surgery was 22 months (range, 2-75 months). Mean size was 4.8 cm (range, 0.4-28.0 cm). Median followup after local recurrence was 16 months (range, 0-98 months). RESULTS: Recurrent tumors had a tendency toward becoming deeper seated and higher graded. Nineteen of the 37 patients with recurrence underwent limb salvage (nine free flaps) and six had an amputation. Twenty-two (59%) had metastases, including 10 occurring after the local recurrence event at an average delay of 21 months (range, 1-34 months). Six patients developed additional local recurrences, with no apparent difference in risk between amputation (two of six) and limb salvage (four of 19). CONCLUSIONS: Patients with a local recurrence of a soft tissue sarcoma have a poor prognosis. Limb salvage and additional radiotherapy remain possible but with substantial complications. Amputation did not prevent additional local recurrence or death.

Outcomes in patients with popliteal sarcomas.

BACKGROUND: Soft-tissue sarcoma involving the popliteal fossa remains challenging because it is difficult to achieve wide margins with limb salvage in this location. Adjuvant therapy is frequently necessary, and limb function can be adversely affected. We reviewed our experience with these tumours. METHODS: Our prospective tumour database served to identify all patients with popliteal sarcomas treated at the McGill University Health Centre and the Maisonneuve-Rosemont Hospital between 1994 and 2005. We assessed oncologic and functional outcomes as well as complications. RESULTS: Our study included 18 patients (12 women and 6 men). The mean age was 54 (range 16-84) years. The mean duration of follow-up was 55 (range 4-126) months. Frequent histologic diagnoses were liposarcoma (n = 6), synovial sarcoma (n = 4) and leiomyosarcoma (n = 3). Tumour size varied from 2 to 21 cm (median 11 cm). American Joint Committee on Cancer staging was as follows: 4 patients had stage IIa disease, 3 patients had stage IIb, 10 patients had stage III and 1 patient had stage IV disease. Treatment consisted of limb salvage in 15 patients and amputation in 3. Fourteen patients had radiotherapy, 4 had chemotherapy, and 3 needed partial sciatic nerve resection. Margins were negative in 7 of 18 patients and microscopically positive in 11 patients. Complications included wound infections in 3 patients and thrombophlebitis in 2 patients. Of the patients undergoing limb-salvaging procedures, 1 experienced local recurrences after limb salvage (7%), and 5 experienced lung metastases (20%). Local recurrence was always associated with positive margins, whereas metastases occurred only in patients without local recurrence. The mean Musculoskeletal Tumor Society 1987 score was 33 (range 24-35). The mean Toronto Extremity Salvage Score results was 82.4 (range 63.8-100). At latest follow-up, 6 patients had died of disease, 1 was alive with disease, and 11 (61%) patients remained free of disease. CONCLUSION: Despite the high rate of microscopically positive margins, the local recurrence rate was 7%. Amputation did not prevent death. We found function to be good to excellent in most patients who had limb-salvaging surgery.

Experience with cemented large segment endoprostheses for tumors.

Published reports dealing with tumor prosthesis have yet to establish a clear advantage of using either cemented or cementless implants. We examined the outcome and complications with modular cemented implants in 135 patients identified from our database to strengthen the argument for routine use of cemented constructs. The minimum followup was 1.4 months (mean, 57 months; median, 47 months; range, 1.4-157 months). The majority of patients (104) had sarcoma. The complications included: 11 infections, three of which underwent amputation and one a stem revision; eight local recurrences, five of which underwent amputation; three hip dislocations; and three incidents of shoulder instability. One periprosthetic femur fracture was stabilized operatively. There was no aseptic loosening or stem fracture. The 5-year survival rates for distal femoral and proximal humeral replacements were 84% and 70%; the 10-year survival rates were 79% and 59%. The 5-year survival rates for proximal femur and proximal tibia replacements were 78% and 37%. Average Musculoskeletal Tumor Society 1987 scores and Toronto Extremity Salvage Scores were 21.5 and 73% for proximal femur, 28.1 and 67% for distal femur, and 21 and 78% for proximal humerus. The survival of the endoprostheses related to site of bone resection. Cemented constructs of modern design in the context of tumor surgery provide good short-term results.

Cemented rotating hinge endoprosthesis for limb salvage of distal femur tumors.

UNLABELLED: We retrospectively ascertained the outcomes and complications with a cemented rotating hinge implant. Implant failure was defined as amputation of the affected limb and revision of part or all of the components. We included 77 consecutive distal femoral replacements performed between 1989 and 2004. The mean age was 42 years (range, 12-87 years) and the mean length of followup was 52 months (range, 1.5-157 months). Five-year implant survival was 84% and 10-year survival was 79%. There were 67 bone sarcomas, two soft tissue sarcomas and eight metastatic carcinomas. At followup, 54 patients had no evidence of disease, 16 were alive with disease, and seven were dead from disease. Six patients had deep infection, two of which required amputations. There were five local recurrences; three needed amputation and two soft-tissue excisions only. Three patients sustained a tibial bearing fracture and one required replacement of loose bumper. No revision was performed for stem loosening, stem fracture, or bushing wear. Musculoskeletal Tumor Society 1987 scores averaged 30 and Toronto Extremity Salvage Scores averaged 77.6 at latest followup. Cemented endoprosthesis is a reliable procedure after resection of the distal femur for tumors. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic study, level IV (case series).

Iliosacral resection for primary bone tumors: is pelvic reconstruction necessary?

UNLABELLED: Iliosacral resection for primary bone tumors creates a large unstable pelvic ring defect, the treatment of which remains controversial. We did this study to determine if skeletal reconstruction of such defects is necessary. Sixteen patients whose data were collected prospectively had iliosacral resection with a minimum followup of 12 months. The surgical and functional results of patients who had skeletal reconstruction (n = 4) were compared with the results of patients who did not have iliosacral repair (n = 12) using a case-control design. Function was evaluated by assessing impairment using the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society 1987 and 1993 rating scales, and disability was measured using the Toronto Extremity Salvage Score. Although all four iliosacral arthrodeses initially healed, one allograft used for reconstruction fractured and another was removed because of progressive lumbosacral spinal instability. Patients treated without pelvic reconstruction had fewer operative complications. Although the Toronto Extremity Salvage Score and the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society 1987 and 1993 scores were similar for both patient groups, those patients who were treated without reconstruction were less likely to require the use of an ambulatory assistive device, less likely to require narcotics or have chronic pain, and more likely to return to work. These results suggest that reconstruction of the skeletal defect to restore pelvic stability after iliosacral resection is not mandatory. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic study, Level III-1 (case-control study). See the Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Outcome after pelvic sarcoma resection reconstructed with saddle prosthesis.

UNLABELLED: We retrospectively reviewed 27 patients who had saddle prosthetic reconstruction for pelvic sarcoma from 1991 to 2001 with a mean followup of 45 months. Functional outcome was assessed with Musculoskeletal Tumor Society Scores of 1987 and 1993 and the Toronto Extremity Salvage score. Survival, recurrences, and complications were recorded. Seven (26%) patients had Type II (periacetabular) pelvic resection and 20 had Types II and III (periacetabular and pubis) pelvic resection. Eleven patients had chemotherapy treatment. None received radiation therapy. At final followup 14 patients were free of disease, 11 patients died, and two patients were alive with disease. The survival rate was 60%. Twenty-two percent had local recurrence, and 22% had metastasis. The mean Musculoskeletal Tumor Society Score 93 score in 17 patients was 50.8% +/- 21.7%, the mean Musculoskeletal Tumor Society Score 87 score was 15.3 +/- 6.1, and the mean Toronto Extremity Salvage score was 64.4% +/- 17.2%. Infection occurred in 10 patients; six were deep infections. There were five nerve palsies. Heterotopic ossification occurred in 10 patients, fracture occurred in six patients, and dislocation occurred in six patients. Limb shortening was progressive until it stabilized at 12 months, and ultimately ranged between 1 and 6 cm. Five patients were retired, five had full-time employment, and six were disabled. Reconstruction with the saddle prosthesis after resection for pelvic sarcoma is associated with substantial morbidity. However, the functional results seem to confer an advantage when compared with the considerable disability incurred after hemipelvectomy. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic study, Level IV-1 (case series without control group). See the Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Pathologic fractures in children.

Fractures through bone tumors are often difficult to treat. We reviewed our combined experience with this problem in children, as well as the existing literature, to formulate management guidelines. For this study, prospective databases (1987 to 2002) from three referral centers were screened for pathologic fractures occurring under the age of 14 years. One hundred five patients presented with fracture through unicameral bone cyst, nonossifying fibroma, fibrous dysplasia, aneurysmal bone cyst and osteosarcoma. Seventeen patients were excluded. The most common primary locations were the proximal humerus and proximal femur. Pathologic fracture through nonossifying fibroma had the best outcome; union occurred with nonsurgical treatment in all cases. Unicameral bone cyst required surgical treatment to avoid persistence of the cyst and refracture. However fracture healing was predictable without surgical treatment. Proximal femoral lesions tended to heal in malunion if not fixed surgically. Aneurysmal bone cyst required surgical treatment for the lesion to heal and to allow the fracture to heal as well. Percutaneous sclerotherapy may be the treatment of choice for many of these lesions. Fibrous dysplasia allows fracture healing with nonoperative therapy. Progressive deformity requires followup and surgical correction. Malignant lesions presenting a pathologic fracture are best managed by initial nonoperative therapy during investigation and neoadjuvant therapy when possible, followed by definitive treatment.

Giant cell tumor of long bone: a Canadian Sarcoma Group study.

A multicentric retrospective study of giant cell tumor of bone was conducted among Canadian surgeons. The hypothesis was that no differences would be found in health status, function, or recurrence rate irrespective to the nature of filling material or adjuvant used in patients treated with curettage. One hundred eighty-six cases were collected. There were 96 females and 90 males. The mean age of the patients was 36 years (range, 14-72 years), the minimum followup was 24 months, and the median followup was 60 months. Sixty-two percent of the tumors involved the knee region. One hundred fifty-eight were primary tumors and 28 were recurrences. Campanacci grading was as follows: Grade 1, seven patients; Grade 2, 100 patients; Grade 3, 76 patients; and unknown in three patients. Fifty-six patients had a pathologic fracture. Resection was done in 38 patients and 148 patients had curettage. The latter was supplemented with high speed burring in 135 patients, cement in 64 patients, various combinations of autograft or allograft bone in 61 patients, phenol in 37 patients, and liquid nitrogen in 10 patients. Structural allografts were used in 25 patients. The overall recurrence rate was 17%, 18% after curettage, and 16% after resection. Patients with primary tumors treated with curettage had a 10% recurrence rate. For recurrent lesions treated by curettage, the recurrence rate was 35%. The nature of the filling material used or the type of adjuvant method used or any combination of both failed to show any statistical impact on the recurrence risk. The results from the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society rating from 1987 were significantly lower in patients who sustained a displaced fracture. Results from the bodily pain section of the Short Form-36 also were found to be lower when a pathologic fracture was present. Results from the Musculoskeletal Tumor Society Rating 1987, the Short Form-36, and the Toronto Extremity Salvage Score did not show differences when either cement or bone graft were used after curettage.