Questioning rotary functionality in the bacterial flagellar system and proposing a murburn model for motility.

Bacterial flagellar system (BFS) was the primary example of a purported 'rotary-motor' functionality in a natural assembly. This mandates the translation of a circular motion of components inside into a linear displacement of the cell body outside, which is supposedly orchestrated with the following features of the BFS: (i) A chemical/electrical differential generates proton motive force (pmf, including a trans-membrane potential, TMP), which is electro-mechanically transduced by inward movement of protons via BFS. (ii) Membrane-bound proteins of BFS serve as stators and the slender filament acts as an external propeller, culminating into a hook-rod that pierces the membrane to connect to a 'broader assembly of deterministically movable rotor'. We had disclaimed the purported pmf/TMP-based respiratory/photosynthetic physiology involving Complex V, which was also perceived as a 'rotary machine' earlier. We pointed out that the murburn redox logic was operative therein. We pursue the following similar perspectives in BFS-context: (i) Low probability for the evolutionary attainment of an ordered/synchronized teaming of about two dozen types of proteins (assembled across five-seven distinct phases) towards the singular agendum of rotary motility. (ii) Vital redox activity (not the gambit of pmf/TMP!) powers the molecular and macroscopic activities of cells, including flagella. (iii) Flagellar movement is noted even in ambiances lacking/countering the directionality mandates sought by pmf/TMP. (iv) Structural features of BFS lack component(s) capable of harnessing/achieving pmf/TMP and functional rotation. A viable murburn model for conversion of molecular/biochemical activity into macroscopic/mechanical outcomes is proposed herein for understanding BFS-assisted motility. HIGHLIGHTSThe motor-like functionalism of bacterial flagellar system (BFS) is analyzedProton/Ion-differential based powering of BFS is unviable in bacteriaUncouplers-sponsored effects were misinterpreted, resulting in a detour in BFS researchThese findings mandate new explanation for nano-bio-mechanical movements in BFSA minimalist murburn model for the bacterial flagella-aided movement is proposedCommunicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.

Synthesis of theories on cellular powering, coherence, homeostasis and electro-mechanics: Murburn concept and evolutionary perspectives.

If evolution was/is a fact, a simplified/unifying approach to explain cellular physiology is warranted. Such a perspective should agree with the thermodynamic, kinetic, structural, and operational-probabilistic considerations; without invoking overt intelligence or determinism, and must enable a synthesis from chaos. In this regard, we first list salient theories in cellular physiology for (i) powering (generation of chemical/heat energy), (ii) coherence (interconnectivity and workability as a unit), (iii) homeostasis (metabolizing and expelling of unfamiliar/unwanted materials, maintaining concentration/volume), and (iv) cellular electrical-mechanical activities. While doing so, we discuss the scopes and limitations of (a) the classical active-site affinity and recognition-based modality of lock-key and induced-fit enzyme-catalytic mechanisms established by Fischer/Koshland, (b) membrane-pump hypothesis acclaimed by biologists-physicians and historically championed by the British Nobel-laureates like Hodgkin-Huxley-Katz-Mitchell, and (c) association-induction hypothesis advocated by physicists-physiologists from various parts of the world, for example, Gilbert Ling (China-USA), Gerald Pollack (USA), Ludwig Edelmann (Germany), Vladimir Matveev (Russia), and so on. We apply murburn concept (from "mured burning," capturing the thesis that one-electron redox equilibriums involving diffusible reactive species play vital roles in maintaining life order) to amalgamate several core cellular functions and further discuss the prospects for establishing the continuum of the principles of physics in biology.

Na,K-ATPase: A murzyme facilitating thermodynamic equilibriums at the membrane-interface.

The redox metabolic paradigm of murburn concept advocates that diffusible reactive species (DRS, particularly oxygen-centric radicals) are mainstays of physiology, and not mere pathological manifestations. The murburn purview of cellular function also integrates the essential principles of bioenergetics, thermogenesis, homeostasis, electrophysiology, and coherence. In this context, any enzyme that generates/modulates/utilizes/sustains DRS functionality is called a murzyme. We have demonstrated that several water-soluble (peroxidases, lactate dehydrogenase, hemogoblin, etc.) and membrane-embedded (Complexes I-V in mitochondria, Photosystems I/II in chloroplasts, rhodopsin/transducin in rod cells, etc.) proteins serve as murzymes. The membrane protein of Na,K-ATPase (NKA, also known as sodium-potassium pump) is the focus of this article, owing to its centrality in neuro-cardio-musculo electrophysiology. Herein, via a series of critical queries starting from the geometric/spatio-temporal considerations of diffusion/mass transfer of solutes in cells to an update on structural/distributional features of NKA in diverse cellular systems, and from various mechanistic aspects of ion-transport (thermodynamics, osmoregulation, evolutionary dictates, etc.) to assays/explanations of inhibitory principles like cardiotonic steroids (CTS), we first highlight some unresolved problems in the field. Thereafter, we propose and apply a minimalist murburn model of trans-membrane ion-differentiation by NKA to address the physiological inhibitory effects of trans-dermal peptide, lithium ion, volatile anesthetics, confirmed interfacial DRS + proton modulators like nitrophenolics and unsaturated fatty acid, and the diverse classes of molecules like CTS, arginine, oximes, etc. These explanations find a pan-systemic connectivity with the inhibitions/uncouplings of other membrane proteins in cells.

The physiological role of complex V in ATP synthesis: Murzyme functioning is viable whereas rotary conformation change model is untenable.

Complex V or FoF1-ATPase is a multimeric protein found in bioenergetic membranes of cells and organelles like mitochondria/chloroplasts. The popular perception on Complex V deems it as a reversible molecular motor, working bi-directionally (breaking or making ATP) via a conformation-change based chemiosmotic rotary ATP synthesis (CRAS) mechanism, driven by proton-gradients or trans-membrane potential (TMP). In continuance of our pursuits against the CRAS model of cellular bioenergetics, herein we demonstrate the validity of the murburn model based in diffusible reactive (oxygen) species (DRS/DROS). Supported by new in silico derived data (that there are ∼12 adenosine nucleotide binding sites on the F1 bulb and not merely 3 sites, as perceived earlier), available structural information, known experimental observations, and thermodynamic/kinetic considerations (that de-solvation of protons from hydronium ions is facile), we deduce that Complex V serves as a physiological chemostat and a murzyme (enzyme working via murburn scheme, employing DRS). That is- Complex V uses ATP (via consumption at ε or proteins of F1 module) as a Michaelis-Menten substrate to serve as a pH-stat by inletting protons via the c-ring of Fo module. Physiologically, Complex V also functions as a murzyme by presenting ADP/Pi (or their reaction intermediates) on the αß bulb, thereby enabling greater opportunities for DRS/proton-assisted ATP formation. Thus, the murburn paradigm succeeds the CRAS hypothesis for explaining the role of oxygen in mitochondrial physiologies of oxidative phosphorylation, thermogenesis, TMP and homeostasis.Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.

Murburn model of vision: Precepts and proof of concept.

The classical paradigm of visual physiology comprises of the following features: (i) rod/cone cells located at the rear end of the retina serve as the primary transducers of incoming photo-information, (ii) cis-trans retinal (C20 H28 O) transformations on rhodopsin act as the transduction switch to generate a transmittable signal, (iii) signal amplification occurs via GDP-GTP exchange at transducin, and (iv) the amplified signal is relayed (as an action potential) as a flux-based ripple of Na-K ions along the axons of neurons. Fundamental physical principles, chemical kinetics, and awareness of architecture of eye/retina prompt a questioning of these classical assumptions. In lieu, based on experimental and in silico findings, a simple space-time resolved murburn model for the physiology of phototransduction in the retina is presented wherein molecular oxygen plays key roles. It is advocated that: (a) photo-induced oxygen to superoxide conversion serves as the key step in signal transduction in the visual cycle, (b) all photoactive cells of the retina serve as photoreceptors and rods/cones serve as the ultimate electron source in the retina (deriving oxygen and nutrients from retinal pigmented epithelium), (c) signal amplification is through superoxide mediated phosphorylation of GDP bound to inactive transducin, thereby activating a GDP-based cascade (a new mechanism for trimeric G-proteins), and (d) signal relay is primarily an electron movement along the neuron, from dendritic source to synaptic sink. In particular, we specify the roles for the various modules of transducin and GDP-based activation of phosphodiesterase-6 in the physiology of visual transduction.

Interaction of membrane-embedded cytochrome b-complexes with quinols: Classical Q-cycle and murburn model.

We recently proposed a diffusible reactive (oxygen) species (DRS/DROS) based function for cytochrome b complexes (CBC) and quinones (Q)/quinols (QH2 ) in the murburn model of bioenergetics. This proposal is in direct conflict with the classical purview of Q-cycle. Via extensive analyses of the structure-function correlations of membrane-quinones/quinols and proteins, we present qualitative and quantitative arguments to infer that the classical model cannot explain the energetics, kinetics, mechanism and probabilistic considerations. Therefore, it is proposed that Q-cycle is neither necessary nor feasible at CBCs. In contrast, we substantiate that the murburn model explains: (a) crucial structural data of CBCs, (b) why quinones/quinols are utilized in bioenergetic membranes, (c) how trans-membrane potential is generated owing to effective charge separation at CBCs, (d) mobility data of O2 , DRS, Q/QH2 , and (e) utility of other reaction/membrane components. Further, the murburn model also accommodates the absence of quinones in anaerobic Archaea, wherein methanophenazines are prevalent. The work mandates that the textbooks and research agendas are refreshed to reflect the new perception. SIGNIFICANCE: The current article must be seen as a critical and detailed analysis of the role and working mechanism of quinone (Q) /quinols (QH2 ) in bioenergetic membranes. In the classical model, QH2 are perceived as highly mobile electron-transport agents that bind and donate electrons to cytochrome b complexes (CBCs), using sophisticated electronic circuitries, in order to recycle Q and pump protons. The classical perception sees radicals (such as Q*-, O2 *-, etc., also called diffusible reactive species, DRS) as wasteful or toxic (patho) physiological manifestations. It is highlighted herein that QH2 has low mobility and matrix has little protons to pump. New insights from the structural analyses of diverse CBCs and quinols, in conjunction with murburn reaction thermodynamics suggest that the electrons from substrates/quinols are effectively utilized via DRS. This perception fits into a much broader analysis of 1 and 2 electron transfers in overall redox metabolism, as recently brought out by the murburn model, wherein DRS are considered obligatory ingredients of physiology. Thus, the findings mandate a reorientation in the pertinent research field.

Why do cells need oxygen? Insights from mitochondrial composition and function.

Mitochondrial membrane-embedded redox proteins are classically perceived as deterministic "electron transport chain" (ETC) arrays cum proton pumps; and oxygen is seen as an "immobile terminal electron acceptor." This is untenable because: (1) there are little free protons to be pumped out of the matrix; (2) proton pumping would be highly endergonic; (3) ETC-chemiosmosis-rotary ATP synthesis proposal is "irreducibly complex"/"non-evolvable" and does not fit with mitochondrial architecture or structural/distribution data of the concerned proteins/components; (4) a plethora of experimental observations do not conform to the postulates/requisites; for example, there is little evidence for viable proton-pumps/pH-gradient in mitochondria, trans-membrane potential (TMP) is non-fluctuating/non-trappable, oxygen is seen to give copious "diffusible reactive (oxygen) species" (DRS/DROS) in milieu, etc. Quite contrarily, the newly proposed murburn model's tenets agree with known principles of energetics/kinetics, and builds on established structural data and reported observations. In this purview, oxygen is needed to make DRS, the principal component of mitochondrial function. Complex V and porins respectively serve as proton-inlet and turgor-based water-exodus portals, thereby achieving organellar homeostasis. Complexes I to IV possess ADP-binding sites and their redox-centers react/interact with O2 /DRS. At/around these complexes, DRS cross-react or activate/oxidize ADP/Pi via fast thermogenic one-electron reaction(s), condensing to form two-electron stabilized products (H2 O2 /H2 O/ATP). The varied architecture and distribution of components in mitochondria validate DRS as (i) the coupling agent of oxidative reactions and phosphorylations, and (ii) the primary reason for manifestation of TMP in steady-state. Explorations along the new precepts stand to provide greater insights on mitochondrial function and pathophysiology.

The neglected functions of intrinsically disordered proteins and the origin of life.

The example of gelatine shows that extended proteins behave quite differently than globular ones: with water they form a gel. Historically the colloid view of protoplasm was discredited in favour of membrane-(pump)-theory (MPT), but unjustified. In his association-induction hypothesis Ling demonstrates that MPT is full of contradictions and that the colloid view has to be re-considered. In that case IDP's play a crucial role in this. What Ling calls the 'living state' consists of the unitary protoplasmic structure from which it was experimentally demonstrated that it can survive and keep Na+ and K+ concentrations without a delineating membrane. It consists of unfolded polypeptide chains whereby the repetitive backbone peptide groups orient and polarise many layers of water, in which Na+ and other solutes have reduced solubility and whereby the polypeptide ß- and ϒ-carboxyl-groups adsorb K+. This 'associated' state is the resting state: a coherent high-energy low-entropy meta-stable state. It can be kept by adsorbed ATP (NTP) eventually for years without consumption of ATP as demonstrated by Clegg on Artemia embryo's. Stimuli can transform this state into a lower-energy higher-entropy action state with dissociation of ADP and Pi and newly synthesised ATP can reinstall it. Rest-to-action and action-to-rest were shown to be real phase-shifts. Ling's theory is a complete quantitative theory with corroborated equations for solute distribution, transport, cell potentials and osmotic behaviour and describing the cell's energy cycle. IDP's are involved in all this. The new view on IDP's leads to new insights on the origin of life.

Coherent Behavior and the Bound State of Water and K(+) Imply Another Model of Bioenergetics: Negative Entropy Instead of High-energy Bonds.

Observations of coherent cellular behavior cannot be integrated into widely accepted membrane (pump) theory (MT) and its steady state energetics because of the thermal noise of assumed ordinary cell water and freely soluble cytoplasmic K(+). However, Ling disproved MT and proposed an alternative based on coherence, showing that rest (R) and action (A) are two different phases of protoplasm with different energy levels. The R-state is a coherent metastable low-entropy state as water and K(+) are bound to unfolded proteins. The A-state is the higher-entropy state because water and K(+) are free. The R-to-A phase transition is regarded as a mechanism to release energy for biological work, replacing the classical concept of high-energy bonds. Subsequent inactivation during the endergonic A-to-R phase transition needs an input of metabolic energy to restore the low entropy R-state. Matveev's native aggregation hypothesis allows to integrate the energetic details of globular proteins into this view.

A new list of functions of the cytoskeleton.

In classic cell physiology some major properties of life are ignored (coherent behaviour) or not fully integrated (colloid properties), resulting in a limited list of functions of the cytoskeleton. As part of a new paradigm for cell physiology a new list is presented with numerous extra functions, for which experimental evidence has so far accumulated.

Linking physiological mechanisms of coherent cellular behaviour with more general physical approaches towards the coherence of life.

Schrödinger pointed out that one of the most fundamental properties of life is its coherent behaviour. This property has been approached from a physiological point of view by Ling in his 'association-induction hypothesis' and extended by Pollack (gel-sol theory), by Chaplin and by Kaivarainen (detailed studies of cellular water). The question of coherence has also been attacked from general physics in three independent approaches: from non-linear thermodynamics (Fröhlich), from quantum field theory (Del Giudice and his group) and from quantum mechanics (Davydov). In this paper all these approaches are unified. The emerging picture constitutes a new paradigm of life.