High-resolution sperm typing of meiotic recombination in the mouse MHC Ebeta gene.

Meiotic crossovers detected by pedigree analysis in the mouse MHC cluster into hotspots. To explore the properties of hotspots, we subjected the class II E(beta) gene to high-resolution sperm crossover analysis. We confirm the presence of a highly localized hotspot 1.0-1.6 kb wide in the second intron of E(beta) and show that it is flanked by DNA which is almost completely recombinationally inert. Mice heterozygous for haplotype s and another MHC haplotype show major haplotype-dependant variation in crossover rate but always the same hotspot, even in crosses including the highly diverged p haplotype. Crossovers in reciprocal orientations occur at similar rates but show different distributions across the hotspot, with the position of centre points in the two orientations shifted on average by 400 bp. This asymmetry results in crossover products showing biased gene conversion in favour of hotspot markers from the non-initiating haplotype, and supports the double-strand break repair model of recombination, with haplotype s as the most efficient crossover initiator. The detailed behaviour of the E(beta) hotspot, including evidence for highly localized recombination initiation, is strikingly similar to human hotspots.

Monitoring spontaneous and induced human mutation by RAPD-PCR: a response to Weinberg et al. (2001).

Weinberg et al. (2001, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 268, 1001-1005) have recently reported a major increase in mutation rate in the children of Chernobyl liquidators as a result of their fathers' exposure to ionizing radiation. If correct, this would provide dramatic evidence for radiation-induced mutation in humans, and would raise major concerns over the genetic effects of radiation. However, mutants were mainly detected using random amplified polymorphic DNA-PCR, an unreliable technology. These mutants were not validated and had no obvious molecular basis. They may, instead, have arisen as PCR artefacts or through non-paternity or sample mix-up. Unless these mutants can be validated, we recommend that Weinberg et al. withdraw their remarkable claims.

Intensely punctate meiotic recombination in the class II region of the major histocompatibility complex.

There is considerable interest in understanding patterns of linkage disequilibrium (LD) in the human genome, to aid investigations of human evolution and facilitate association studies in complex disease. The relative influences of meiotic crossover distribution and population history on LD remain unclear, however. In particular, it is uncertain to what extent crossovers are clustered into 'hot spots, that might influence LD patterns. As a first step to investigating the relationship between LD and recombination, we have analyzed a 216-kb segment of the class II region of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) already characterized for familial crossovers. High-resolution LD analysis shows the existence of extended domains of strong association interrupted by patchwork areas of LD breakdown. Sperm typing shows that these areas correspond precisely to meiotic crossover hot spots. All six hot spots defined share a remarkably similar symmetrical morphology but vary considerably in intensity, and are not obviously associated with any primary DNA sequence determinants of hot-spot activity. These hot spots occur in clusters and together account for almost all crossovers in this region of the MHC. These data show that, within the MHC at least, crossovers are far from randomly distributed at the molecular level and that recombination hot spots can profoundly affect LD patterns.

Attempts to detect retrotransposition and de novo deletion of Alus and other dispersed repeats at specific loci in the human genome.

Dispersed repeat elements contribute to genome instability by de novo insertion and unequal recombination between repeats. To study the dynamics of these processes, we have developed single DNA molecule approaches to detect de novo insertions at a single locus and Alu-mediated deletions at two different loci in human genomic DNA. Validation experiments showed these approaches could detect insertions and deletions at frequencies below 10(-6) per cell. However, bulk analysis of germline (sperm) and somatic DNA showed no evidence for genuine mutant molecules, placing an upper limit of insertion and deletion rates of 2 x 10(-7) and 3 x 10(-7), respectively, in the individuals tested. Such re-arrangements at these loci therefore occur at a rate lower than that detectable by the most sensitive methods currently available.

The application of minisatellite variant repeat mapping by PCR (MVR-PCR) in a paternity case showing false exclusion due to STR mutation.

A boy and a girl with their mother brought a paternity suit against an alleged but deceased father. We tested six conventional genetic markers, the AmpliType PM+ DQA1 and twelve STR loci the children and mother together with the alleged paternal grandparents. We also DNA typed the bloodstain found later in the alleged father's medical record. Only the result at D3S1358 in a nineplex STR system excluded the alleged father from parentage of the boy, whereas all markers were inclusive for the girl. Accordingly, we performed sequence analysis at D3S1358 to confirm the presence of a paternal exclusion or mutation. The sequence analysis indicated that the boy's allele 17 could have originated from either of the alleged father's allele 16 or 18 by a single-step mutation associated with slippage mutation in STR loci. We carried out minisatellite variant repeat mapping by PCR (MVR-PCR) at loci D1S8 (MS32) and D7S21 (MS31A) and mapped allele haplotypes of all individuals except the deceased alleged father. The MVR-PCR analysis showed that the boy has no inconsistency with the relationship between the alleged grandparents, and was very effective at increasing the paternity index (PI) value. We conclude that there is biological relationship between not only the girl but also the boy and the alleged father.

Length of uninterrupted repeats determines instability at the unstable mouse expanded simple tandem repeat family MMS10 derived from independent SINE B1 elements.

Mouse expanded simple tandem repeats (ESTRs) provide highly informative loci for analyzing spontaneous and induced germline mutation. We have conducted an extensive sequence database search and identified 17 new members of the highly unstable rodent-specific ESTR family called MMS10. This family has arisen by independent expansions of a common GGCAGA repeat unit from within a subset of both ancestral and modern SINE B1 elements during the course of mouse evolution. Analysis of the interspersion patterns of variant repeats along alleles of 20 of these MMS10 loci revealed two distinct classes of tandem arrays: one composed of uninterrupted GGCAGA repeats and the second with generally larger arrays interrupted by variant units. Surveys of allelic diversity at 11 representative members of these two classes of loci in various laboratory strains and BXD recombinant inbred lines revealed that the level of repeat instability was positively correlated with the length of uninterrupted repeats. Turnover processes at MMS10 loci, therefore, appear similar to the type of mechanism observed at human microsatellites. The MMS10 family thus provides a potentially useful murine model for studying dynamic mutation at simple tandem repeats.

Influence of allele lineage on the role of the insulin minisatellite in susceptibility to type 1 diabetes.

The insulin minisatellite or variable number of tandem repeats locus (INS VNTR) is the best candidate for the type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM) susceptibility locus IDDM2. Small class I alleles associate with predisposition to T1DM, whereas large class III alleles associate with dominant protection. We have analysed variant repeat distribution within the minisatellite and combined this with flanking haplotypes to define five new ancestral allele lineages. Class III alleles divide into two highly diverged lineages, IIIA and IIIB, which correspond perfectly to the previously defined Protective (PH) and Very Protective (VPH) haplotypes, respectively. Class I alleles are divided into three newly defined lineages, IC+, ID+ and ID-, by a combination of variant repeat distributions and flanking haplotypes. All class I alleles are equally predisposing to T1DM except for ID- alleles which are protective when transmitted from ID-/III heterozygous fathers. Similar results have been previously reported for alleles of 42 repeats in length (allele 814) which represent a subset of the ID- lineage. Division of class ID- alleles into those of 42 repeats and those of other sizes suggested that this protective effect was a feature of all ID- alleles, irrespective of size. ID- alleles are only clearly distinguished from all other alleles by an MSPI(-) variant within IGF2 downstream of the minisatellite, suggesting that the apparent role of the minisatellite in susceptibility to T1DM may be modified by neighbouring haplotype and therefore that IDDM2 could have a multi-locus aetiology.

No correlation between germline mutation at repeat DNA and meiotic crossover in male mice exposed to X-rays or cisplatin.

To test the hypothesis that mouse germline expanded simple tandem repeat (ESTR) mutations are associated with recombination events during spermatogenesis, crossover frequencies were compared with germline mutation rates at ESTR loci in male mice acutely exposed to 1Gy of X-rays or to 10mg/kg of the anticancer drug cisplatin. Ionising radiation resulted in a highly significant 2.7-3.6-fold increase in ESTR mutation rate in males mated 4, 5 and 6 weeks after exposure, but not 3 weeks after exposure. In contrast, irradiation had no effect on meiotic crossover frequencies assayed on six chromosomes using 25 polymorphic microsatellite loci spaced at approximately 20cM intervals and covering 421cM of the mouse genome. Paternal exposure to cisplatin did not affect either ESTR mutation rates or crossover frequencies, despite a report that cisplatin can increase crossover frequency in mice. Correlation analysis did not reveal any associations between the paternal ESTR mutation rate and crossover frequency in unexposed males and in those exposed to X-rays or cisplatin. This study does not, therefore, support the hypothesis that mutation induction at mouse ESTR loci results from a general genome-wide increase in meiotic recombination rate.

Are DNA profiles breed-specific? A pilot study in pigs.

In this study, DNA fingerprints from 32 unrelated domestic pigs were analysed and screened for breed-specificity. Three breed groups were analysed: Chinese Meishan, Large White and a collection of other European breeds. Ninety-three distinct and variable bands were used to estimate genetic distances between the animals. Between the groups these individual genetic distances substantially exceeded those within a group. Linear discriminant analysis showed that the 23 most common DNA fragments revealed sufficient breed-specificity as to assign each pig correctly to its breed or breed group. These findings, although based on a small sample, indicate that selective use of minisatellite variation in pigs appears to be a valuable novel approach toward the development of breed DNA profiles and the resolution of breed relationships.

Induction of minisatellite mutations in the mouse germline by low-dose chronic exposure to gamma-radiation and fission neutrons.

Germline mutation induction at mouse minisatellite loci by paternal low-dose (0.125-1 Gy) exposure to chronic (1.66 x 10(-4) Gy min(-1)) low-linear energy transfer (low-LET) gamma-irradiation and high-LET fission neutrons (0.003 Gy min(-1)) was studied at pre-meiotic stages of spermatogenesis. Both types of radiation produced linear dose-response curves for mutation of the paternal allele. In contrast to previous results using higher doses, the pattern of induction of minisatellite mutation after chronic gamma-irradiation was similar to acute (0.5 Gy min(-1)) exposure to X-rays, indicating that the elevated mutation rate was independent of the ability of the cell to repair damage induced immediately or over a period of up to 100 h. Chronic exposure to fission neutrons was more effective than acute or chronic low-LET exposure (relative biological effectiveness, RBE=3.36). The data also provide strong support for the previous conclusion that increases in minisatellite mutation rate are not caused by radiation-induced DNA damage at minisatellite loci themselves, but rather from damage induced by ionising radiation elsewhere in the genome/cell.

Minisatellite mutation frequency in human sperm following radiotherapy.

Screening pedigrees for inherited minisatellite length changes provides an efficient means of monitoring repeat DNA instability but has given rise to apparently contradictory results regarding the effects of radiation on the human germline. To explore this further in individuals with known radiation doses and to potentially gain information on the timing of mutation induction, we have used an extremely sensitive single molecule approach to quantify the frequencies of mutation at the hypervariable minisatellites B6.7 and CEB1 in the sperm of three seminoma patients following hemipelvic radiotherapy. Scattered radiation doses to the testicles were monitored and pre-treatment sperm DNA was compared with sperm derived from irradiated pre-meiotic, meiotic and post-meiotic cells. We show no evidence for mutation induction in any of the patients and discuss this finding in the context of previous population studies using minisatellites as reporter systems, one of which provided evidence for radiation-induced germline mutation.

Distinguishing minisatellite mutation from non-paternity by MVR-PCR.

Minisatellite variant repeat (MVR) mapping using the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) was devised to map the interspersion pattern of subtle variant repeats along minisatellite tandem arrays. MVR-PCR has revealed enormous diversity of allele structures at several loci, far more than can be resolved by allele length analysis. We have reported the application of MVR-PCR at minisatellite MS32 (D1S8) and MS31A (D7S21) in a paternity case lacking a mother and showed that it resulted in higher paternity probabilities than for a set of 12 other DNA markers including six STRs. Hypervariable minisatellites like MS32 and MS3lA can however, show significant germline mutation rates to new length alleles which can generate false exclusions in paternity cases although paternity cases showing mutant paternal alleles at more than one locus will be rare when several MVR loci are examined. Detailed knowledge of mutation processes coupled with MVR analysis of allele structure can help distinguish mutation from non-paternity. We now show how similar mutant alleles are to their progenitors using both real and simulated data, and demonstrate how MVR-PCR can be used to identify mutant paternal allele in paternity cases showing apparent exclusions.

Meiotic recombination and flanking marker exchange at the highly unstable human minisatellite CEB1 (D2S90).

Unequal crossover has long been suspected to play a role in the germline-specific instability of tandem-repeat DNA, but little information exists on the dynamics and processes of unequal exchange. We have therefore characterized new length alleles associated with flanking-marker exchange at the highly unstable human minisatellite CEB1, which mutates in the male germline by a complex process often resulting in the gene conversion-like transfer of repeats between alleles. DNA flanking CEB1 is rich in single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and shows extensive haplotype diversity, consistent with elevated recombinational activity near the minisatellite. These SNPs were used to recover mutant CEB1 molecules associated with flanking-marker exchange, directly from sperm DNA. Mutants with both proximal and distal flanking-marker exchange were shown to contribute significantly to CEB1 turnover and suggest that the 5' end of the array is very active in meiotic unequal crossover. Coconversions involving the interallelic transfer of repeats plus immediate flanking DNA were also common, were also polarized at the 5' end of CEB1, and appeared to define a conversion gradient extending from the repeat array into adjacent DNA. Whereas many mutants associated with complete exchange resulted in simple recombinant-repeat arrays that show reciprocity, coconversions were highly gain-biased and were, on average, more complex, with allele rearrangements similar to those seen in the bulk of sperm mutants. This suggests distinct recombination-processing pathways producing, on the one hand, simple crossovers in CEB1 and, on the other hand, complex conversions that sometimes extend into flanking DNA.

Crossover breakpoint mapping identifies a subtelomeric hotspot for male meiotic recombination.

Segregation analysis of CEPH and other pedigrees yielded six paternal crossover breakpoints in the approximately 85 kb interval between the minisatellite loci D16S309 (MS205) and D16S83 (EKMDA2) in 16p13.3. Three crossovers were mapped to within the same small (<3 kb) interval, which does not co-localize with any tandem repeat array or expressed sequence. Haplotyping of loci harbouring single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers in this interval confirmed the exchange of flanking markers in the three recombinant individuals. Sequence analysis revealed the presence of recombination-associated motifs and binding sites for the protein translin. Haplotyping of 108 individuals from three European populations at four loci harbouring SNPs showed substantial linkage equilibrium across this interval. Hence molecular and population genetic data are consistent with the presence of an intense male-specific recombination hotspot at this locus.

Allele diversity and germline mutation at the insulin minisatellite.

Previous analysis of germline mutation at highly unstable GC-rich minisatellites with continuous allele size distributions revealed similar meiotic recombinational mechanisms operating at all loci investigated. The insulin minisatellite has been studied intensively due to its associations with diabetes, polycystic ovary syndrome, obesity and birth size. Its bimodal allele size distribution in Caucasians suggests a much lower mutation rate and possible differences in the mutation process compared with highly unstable minisatellites. Mutation at the insulin minisatellite therefore was studied both indirectly from allele diversity surveys and directly by recovering de novo mutants from sperm DNA. Structural analysis of variant repeat distributions in 876 alleles identified 189 different alleles, almost all of which could be assigned to one of three very distinct lineages. Variation within a lineage was minor and due mainly to the gain or loss of one or a few repeat units. These events most probably arise by mitotic replication slippage at a frequency of perhaps 10(-3)per gamete. Sperm DNA analysis revealed a second class of mutation occurring at a frequency of approximately 2 x 10(-5)that involved highly complex intra- and inter-allelic rearrangements very similar to those seen at unstable minisatellites. These complex rearrangements were not seen in somatic DNA and are probably meiotic in origin. Minisatellite homozygosity did not reduce the frequency of these mutants in sperm. The insulin minisatellite therefore appears to evolve by two distinct processes: one involving slippage-like events and the second resulting in complex recombinational turnover of allele structure.

High resolution analysis of haplotype diversity and meiotic crossover in the human TAP2 recombination hotspot.

Little is known about the nature of recombination hotspots in the human genome and the relationship between crossover activity and patterns of linkage disequilibrium. We have therefore used both haplotype analysis and direct detection of crossovers in sperm to characterize a putative recombination hotspot in the TAP2 gene within the class II region of the MHC. Haplotype diversity provided evidence for a localized hotspot within intron 2 of this gene. Sperm DNA typing using allele-specific PCR primers to selectively amplify recombinant TAP2 molecules revealed a highly localized meiotic crossover hotspot approximately 1.2 kb long, unusually abundant in sequence polymorphisms and flanked by DNA much less active in recombination. Sperm crossover appeared to be fully reciprocal, and almost all crossover products were simple, involving a single exchange between adjacent heterozygous markers. This hotspot appears to be much more active in female than male meiosis. No primary sequence similarities could be found between any of the very few well defined crossover hotspots in the human genome, all of which show recombinationally active domains 1-2 kb long. Direct comparison of recombination frequency and haplotype diversity in TAP2 showed that linkage disequilibrium measures were a poor predictor of crossover frequency in this region, with non-recombining markers sometimes in free association and with examples of pairs of markers spanning the recombination hotspot showing substantial or even absolute linkage disequilibrium.

Somatic versus germline mutation processes at minisatellite CEB1 (D2S90) in humans and transgenic mice.

The most variable human minisatellites show extreme germline instability dominated by complex intra-allelic rearrangements plus a lower frequency of inter-allelic transfers of repeat units. In contrast, little is known about somatic instability at such loci. We have therefore used single-molecule PCR to analyze mutation at minisatellite CEB1 (D2S90) in human blood DNA. Somatic mutants were rare and involved only relatively simple intra-allelic events, with no bias toward expansions, in sharp contrast to the complex gain-biased rearrangements seen in sperm. Somatic and germline mutation processes were further analyzed in mice transgenic for a cosmid insert containing CEB1. Mutant molecules in transgenic sperm and blood were detected but only at the low frequencies seen in human blood and arose mainly by simple duplications and deletions as seen for somatic mutations in human. These data suggest distinct pathways for germline and somatic CEB1 mutations with germline instability involving recombination-based repair of meiotic double-strand breaks and somatic mutation arising by replication slippage or mitotic recombination. The problem of transferring germline-specific features of minisatellite instability from human to mouse suggests, with other recent observations, that long-range chromatin conformation may be required for the recombination-based mode of germline instability at human minisatellites.

Chimaeric and constitutive DNA fingerprints in the common marmoset (Callithrix jacchus).

Marmosets normally produce dizygotic twins sharing placental blood vessels and exchanging bone marrow cells. Each individual is therefore likely to be a blood chimaera. To date, marmosets had only been DNA fingerprinted using blood samples and probes 33.6 and 33.15, resulting in highly similar fingerprints among litter mates and little variation between other individuals, thereby limiting this method's use for individual identification and parentage testing. In this study, novel probes were applied to detect greater polymorphism and to produce individual-specific DNA fingerprints. As expected, blood DNA profiles of twins and triplets were virtually identical, confirming chimaerism in this tissue and identifying litter mates. Furthermore, these profiles were sufficiently variable to distinguish between sibs from different litters and between all other individuals. To produce individual-specific DNA fingerprints, the use of DNA extracted from tissues poor in leukocytes was essential. The findings demonstrate that, despite extensive blood chimaerism, marmoset colonies can be effectively DNA fingerprinted for indicidual identification, zygosity testing, and relationship studies.