RESUMEN
A placebo-controlled randomized clinical trial was conducted in six centres to compare the effects of a 14 day treatment with either 50 micrograms ethinyl oestradiol daily or 2.5 mg oestrone sulphate daily, on depot medroxyprogesterone acetate (DMPA)-induced prolonged bleeding. Out of 1035 women admitted to the study, 278 requested treatment and were given ethinyl oestradiol (n = 90), oestrone sulphate (n = 91) or placebo (n = 97). Ethinyl oestradiol was successful in stopping the bleeding episode in 93% of cases, compared with oestrone sulphate and placebo which had success rates of 76 and 74% respectively. However, the relative advantage of ethinyl oestradiol was marginal, with an average reduction of 1 bleeding day and 3 spotting days compared with the other two groups. Immediately after treatment, women given ethinyl oestradiol had less bleeding but a more unpredictable pattern than the other two groups. In the long term, there were no differences between the bleeding patterns or the discontinuation rates for any reason in the three groups, and the most important single reason for discontinuation in those groups remained 'menstrual problems'. In summary, the study showed that treatment of DMPA-induced prolonged bleeding with ethinyl oestradiol had a limited short-term effect but no beneficial effect on the acceptability of DMPA as a contraceptive method. Treatment with oestrone sulphate was no different from placebo.
PIP: The findings of a multicenter clinical trial challenge the practice of estrogen treatment of the prolonged or irregular vaginal bleeding associated with depot medroxyprogesterone acetate (DMPA) contraceptive use. Included in the study were 1035 DMPA users (mean age, 27 years) from Alexandria, Egypt; Bangkok, Thailand; Chiang Mai, Thailand; Jakarta, Indonesia; Karachi, Pakistan; and Manila, Philippines. 456 (44%) of these women experienced a bleeding episode lasting more than 7 days during their first 6 months of DMPA use. Of these, only 278 (61%) requested treatment. These 278 women were randomly allocated to receive 50 mcg of ethinyl estradiol (n = 90), 2.5 mg of estrone sulfate (n = 91), or placebo (n = 97) daily for 14 days. The treatment stopped the bleeding episode for 93% of women in the ethinyl estradiol group, 76% of those in the estrone sulfate group, and 74% of women receiving a placebo. The ethinyl estradiol advantage was marginal, however. On average, women treated with ethinyl estradiol had their bleeding episode shortened by 1 bleeding day and 3 spotting days. Immediately after treatment, women given ethinyl estradiol had less bleeding and spotting days than their counterparts in the 2 other groups, but demonstrated a more unpredictable pattern, including a greater range of lengths of bleeding/spotting-free intervals. Three months after treatment, there were no differences between the 3 groups in vaginal bleeding patterns.
