Development and Validation of a New Robust Detection Method for Low-Content DNA Using ΔΔCq-Based Real-Time PCR with Optimized Standard Plasmids as a Control Sample.

Real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) is the gold standard for DNA detection in many fields, including food analysis. However, robust detection using a real-time PCR for low-content DNA samples remains challenging. In this study, we developed a robust real-time PCR method for low-content DNA using genetically modified (GM) maize at concentrations near the limit of detection (LOD) as a model. We evaluated the LOD of real-time PCR targeting two common GM maize sequences (P35S and TNOS) using GM maize event MON863 containing a copy of P35S and TNOS. The interlaboratory study revealed that the LOD differed among laboratories partly because DNA input amounts were variable depending on measurements of DNA concentrations. To minimize this variability for low-content DNA samples, we developed ΔΔCq-based real-time PCR. In this study, ΔCq and ΔΔCq are as follows: ΔCq = Cq (P35S or TNOS) - Cq (SSIIb; maize endogenous gene), ΔΔCq = ΔCq (analytical sample) - ΔCq (control sample at concentrations near the LOD). The presence of GM maize was determined based on ΔΔCq values. In addition, we used optimized standard plasmids containing SSIIb, P35S, and TNOS with ΔCq equal to the MON863 genomic DNA (gDNA) at concentrations near the LOD as a control sample. A validation study indicated that at least 0.2% MON863 gDNA could be robustly detected. Using several GM maize certified reference materials, we have demonstrated that this method was practical for detecting low-content GM crops and thus for validating GM food labeling. With appropriate standards, this method would be applicable in many fields, not just food.

Development and Interlaboratory Validation of a Novel Reproducible Qualitative Method for GM Soybeans Using Comparative Cq-Based Analysis for the Revised Non-GMO Labeling System in Japan.

Many countries have implemented the labeling system of genetically modified organisms (GMO). In Japan, the regulatory threshold for non-GMO labeling will be revised and restricted to undetectable by April 2023. The practical criterion for the revised system is based on the limit of detection (LOD). However, determining whether the commingling of GMO levels exceeds the LOD is challenging because GM contents close to the LOD are usually below the limit of quantification. In this study, we developed a qualitative method based on comparative Cq-based analysis targeting cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter and GM soybean MON89788 event-specific sequences that could be applicable to the revised non-GMO labeling. ΔCq values between the target and endogenous sequences were calculated, and the ΔΔCq value obtained was used as a criterion to determine analytical samples with GM contents exceeding the threshold. To improve the reproducibility of the method, we used a standard plasmid that yields equivalent and stable ΔCq values comparable with those obtained from LOD samples. The developed method was validated with an interlaboratory study. The new qualitative detection concept would be useful for ensuring robust and reproducible results among laboratories, particularly for detecting low-copy-number DNA samples.

Simple, Precise, and Less Biased GMO Quantification by Multiplexed Genetic Element-Specific Digital PCR.

BACKGROUND: To provide the consumer with choices of genetically modified organisms (GMO) or non-GMO, official food labeling systems were established in many countries. Because the threshold GMO content values were set to distinguish between "non-GMO" and "GMO" designations, GMO content quantification methods are required for ensuring the appropriateness of labeling. OBJECTIVE: As the number of GMOs is continuously increasing around the world, we set out to develop a low-cost, simple and less biased analytical strategy to cover all necessary detection targets. METHODS: Digital PCR methods are advantageous compared to the conventional quantitative real-time PCR methods. We developed a digital PCR-based GMO quantification method to evaluate the GMO content in maize grains. To minimize the analytical workload, we adopted multiplex digital PCR targeting the 35S promoter and the nopaline synthase terminator, which are genetic elements commonly introduced in many GMOs. RESULTS: Our method is significantly simpler and more precise than the conventional real-time PCR-based methods. Additionally, we found that this method enables quantification of the copy number of GMO DNA without double counting multiple elements (35S promoter and nopaline synthase terminator) tandemly placed in a recombinant DNA construct. CONCLUSION: This is the first report on the development of a genetically modified maize quantification method using a multiplexed genetic element-specific digital PCR method. The tandem effect we report here is quite useful for reducing the bias in the analytical results. HIGHLIGHTS: Multiplexed genetic element-specific digital PCR can simplify weight-based GMO quantification and thus should prove useful in light of the continuous increase in the number of GM events.

[Evaluation of a Species-specific, Stable, and Endogenous Sequence of Eggplant (Solanum melongena) using LAMP for the Detection of Genetically Modified Eggplants].

Species-specific endogenous reference sequences are indispensable in the development of methods to detect genetically modified (GM) crops for food and feed. We analyzed a partial sequence derived from the ß-fructosidase gene among several solanaceous species and developed a new eggplant specific detection method using loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP). LAMP is a rapid, specific, and cost-effective technique. The species-specificity and stability of the developed method were evaluated using 18 eggplant cultivars and other crops including solanaceous plants. The limit of detection was also evaluated. The developed method showed high specificity for eggplants and stability among the eggplant cultivars tested. These results suggested that the developed method would be useful as a positive control for the detection of GM eggplants with LAMP.

Development of a Novel Detection Method Targeting an Ultrashort 25 bp Sequence Found in Agrobacterium-Mediated Transformed GM Plants.

Agrobacterium-mediated transformation is the most commonly used technique for plant genetic engineering. During the transformation, a T-DNA region, which is flanked by the right border (RB) and the left border, is transferred to plant nuclear chromosomes. Simultaneously, a sequence adjacent to the RB on T-DNA is frequently transferred to plant genomes together with the intentionally introduced recombinant DNA. We developed a novel polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-mediated detection method targeting this region. The conserved sequence of the region found in genetically modified (GM) crops is only 25 bp in length. To detect this ultrashort 25 bp sequence near the RB region, we designed a primer set consisting of a 12-base forward primer and a 13-base reverse primer. The predicted band was detected from GM crops by optimizing the PCR conditions. We used lateral flow DNA chromatography for rapid and inexpensive detection. The developed method would be applicable for screening the GM crops generated by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation.

Development and Testing of an Individual Kernel Detection System for Genetically Modified Soybean Events in Non-identity-preserved Soybean Samples.

A genetically modified (GM) soybean kernel detection system using combination of DNA preparation from individual soybean kernels and event-specific real-time PCR was developed to simultaneously identify GM soybean events authorized for food after safety assessments in Japan. Over 100 kernels in the non-identity-preserved soybean samples imported from the United States of America (two U.S.A. lots) and Brazil (one lot) were randomly selected and examined. In total, 98 and 96% of the two independent U.S.A. lots, and 100% of the Brazilian lot contained GM soybean kernels. Herbicide-tolerant events, MON89788 (trade name Genuity® Roundup Ready 2 Yield™), GTS 40-3-2 (trade name Roundup Ready™ soybean) and A2704-12 (trade name Liberty Link® soybean), were detected similarly in both U.S.A. lots. In the Brazilian lot, in addition to GTS 40-3-2, a stacked GM event, MON87701 × MON89788, having insect-resistance and herbicide-tolerance, was detected. There were no unauthorized GM soybeans comingled, and the ratio of GM soybean events detected was consistent with statistical reports on the cultivated GM soybean events in both countries.

Detection of 30 bp DNA fragments with a sensitive modified Southern blot analysis.

To evaluate crops generated by new breeding techniques, it is important to confirm the removal of recombinant DNAs (rDNAs) derived from foreign genes including unintentionally introduced short rDNA(s). We attempted to develop a sensitive detection method for such short rDNAs using Southern blot analysis and performed a model study targeting single-copy endogenous genes in plants. To increase the detection sensitivity, the general protocol for Southern blot analysis was modified. In the model study, we used endogenous-gene-targeting probes in which complementary sequences were serially replaced by dummy sequences, and detected complementary sequences as well as 30 bp. We further evaluated the sensitivity using short rDNAs derived from GM sequences as pseudoinsertions, and the results demonstrated that rDNA-insertions as small as 30 bp could be detected. The results suggested that unintentionally introduced rDNA-insertions were 30 bp or more in length could be detected by the Southern blot analysis.

[Evaluation of Conversion Factors for Genetically Modified Maize Quantification].

To quantify the amount of authorized GM maize or soybean, conversion factor (Cf) values are required for converting the copy number ratio of GM sequence to an endogenous sequence into weight-based GMO amounts. Cf values are available for the several latest real-time PCR instruments such as QuantStudio5, QuantStudio12K Flex, LightCycler 96, and LightCycler 480 for GM soybeans but not for GM maize. For the quantification of GM maize, we experimentally determined the Cf values targeting Cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter (P35S), GA21 construct specific, MIR604 event specific and MIR162 event specific sequences using the four real-time PCR instruments.

Development of a novel method for specific detection of genetically modified Atlantic salmon, AquAdvantage, using real-time polymerase chain reaction.

Genetically modified (GM) Atlantic salmon, AquAdvantage (AquAd), was the first GM animal approved officially for human consumption. Many countries monitor the use of this product under their GM regulations, but a pragmatic system for AquAd-specific detection is needed. Here, we developed a real-time polymerase chain reaction method with high sensitivity for detection of AquAd in foods. This method showed high specificity for the AquAd transgene and the detection limit was 12.5-25 targeted DNA copies per test reaction. An inter-laboratory study using the method developed demonstrated reproducibility at >0.1% (w/w) AquAd content.

Rapid DNA template preparation directly from a rice sample without purification for loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) of rice genes.

Rapid DNA template preparation directly from a single rice (Oryza sativa) grain or rice flour of its equivalent weight was developed for loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP). LAMP efficiency using DNA extract obtained from consecutive addition of alkaline lysis reagent (25 mM NaOH, 0.2 mM EDTA) and neutralizing reagent (40 mM Tris-HCl [pH 5]) was comparable to that using an equivalent amount of purified DNA as template. The stability of the prepared DNA extract was confirmed for up to six-day storage at room temperature. Without using any special laboratory devices, the developed method enabled a rapid, simple, and low-cost DNA template preparation method for reliable LAMP testing to detect rice genes.

Data representing applicability of developed growth hormone 1 (GH1) gene detection method for detecting Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) at high specificity to processed salmon commodities.

This article is referred to the research article entitled "Development of a novel method for specific detection of genetically modified Atlantic salmon, AquAdvantage, using real-time polymerase chain reaction" by Soga et al. (2020). Applicability of the developed growth hormone 1 (GH1) and 18S ribosomal DNA (18S rDNA) detection methods using real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) for detecting Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) to processed food commodities was examined. DNAs extracted and purified from 24 commodities labelled to include salmon as an ingredient were used as template. Yield and purity of DNAs obtained and Cq values from real-time PCR analyses were provided.

Novel Bioprinting Application for the Production of Reference Material Containing a Defined Copy Number of Target DNA.

Nucleic acid amplification methods, such as polymerase chain reaction (PCR), are extensively used in many applications to detect target DNA because of their high sensitivity, good reproducibility, and wide dynamic range of quantification. However, analytical quality control when detecting low copy number target DNA is often missing because of a lack of appropriate reference materials. Recent advances in analytical sciences require a method to accurately quantify DNA at the single molecule level. Herein, we have developed a novel method to produce reference material containing a defined copy number of target DNA (referred to as "cell number-based DNA reference material"). In this method, a suspension of cells carrying a single target DNA sequence was ejected by an inkjet head, and the number of cells in each droplet was counted using highly sensitive cameras. The resulting solutions contained a defined copy number of target DNA and could be used as reference materials. The use of the newly developed reference material was compared with that of diluted solutions of target DNA to evaluate the performance of qualitative real-time PCR in terms of the limit of detection (LOD). Our results demonstrated that cell number-based DNA reference material provides more accurate information regarding performance quality. The reference material produced by this method is a promising tool to evaluate assay performance.

[Detection of DNA in Highly Processed Foods].

Highly processed foods, including soy sauce, cornflakes, starch sugar, beet sugar and vegetable oil, are not currently subject to genetically modified (GM) food labeling, because DNA could not be detected in these food products. Here we re-examined the method of DNA extraction from starch syrup, beet sugar and vegetable oil using commercially available DNA extraction kits. We found that DNA was not stably detected by PCR targeting a species-specific endogenous plant gene. The reason for this may have been that the DNA yield was below the detection limit, because PCR inhibition was not observed.

Rapid Screening Detection of Genetically Modified Crops by Loop-Mediated Isothermal Amplification with a Lateral Flow Dipstick.

We developed a novel loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP)-based detection method using lateral flow dipstick chromatography for genetically modified (GM) soybean and maize events. The single-stranded tag hybridization (STH) for the chromatography printed-array strip (C-PAS) system was used for detections targeting the cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter, mannose-6-phosphate isomerase gene, Pisum sativum ribulose 1, 5-bisphosphate carboxylase terminator, a common sequence between the Cry1Ab and Cry1Ac genes, and a GA21-specific sequence. The STH C-PAS system was applicable for multiplex analyses to perform simultaneous detections. The limit of detection was 0.5% or less for each target. By using the developed method, the LAMP amplification was visually detected. Moreover, the detection could be carried out without any expensive instruments, even for the DNA amplification steps, by virtue of the isothermal reaction. We demonstrated that the rapid and useful method developed here would be applicable for screening GM crops.

Development and evaluation of rapid screening detection methods for genetically modified crops using loop-mediated isothermal amplification.

We developed new loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP)-based detection methods for the screening of genetically modified (GM) maize and soybean events. The LAMP methods developed targeted seven sequences: cauliflower mosaic virus 35S promoter; 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase gene from Agrobacterium tumefaciens strain CP4 (cp4epsps); phosphinothricin acetyltransferase (pat) gene; mannose-6-phosphate isomerase gene; Pisum sativum ribulose 1, 5-bisphosphate carboxylase terminator; a common sequence between Cry1Ab and Cry1Ac genes; and a GA21 construct-specific sequence. We designed new specific primer sets for each target, and the limit of detection (LOD) was evaluated using authorized GM maize and soybean events. LODs for each target were ≤ 0.5%. To make the DNA extraction process simple and rapid, we also developed a direct LAMP detection scheme using crude cell lysates. The entire process, including pretreatments and detection, could be completed within 1 h.

Highly Sensitive GMO Detection Using Real-Time PCR with a Large Amount of DNA Template: Single-Laboratory Validation.

Current genetically modified organism (GMO) detection methods allow for sensitive detection. However, a further increase in sensitivity will enable more efficient testing for large grain samples and reliable testing for processed foods. In this study, we investigated real-time PCR-based GMO detection methods using a large amount of DNA template. We selected target sequences that are commonly introduced into many kinds of GM crops, i.e., 35S promoter and nopaline synthase (NOS) terminator. This makes the newly developed method applicable to a wide range of GMOs, including some unauthorized ones. The estimated LOD of the new method was 0.005% of GM maize events; to the best of our knowledge, this method is the most sensitive among the GM maize detection methods for which the LOD was evaluated in terms of GMO content. A 10-fold increase in the DNA amount as compared with the amount used under common testing conditions gave an approximately 10-fold reduction in the LOD without PCR inhibition. Our method is applicable to various analytical samples, including processed foods. The use of other primers and fluorescence probes would permit highly sensitive detection of various recombinant DNA sequences besides the 35S promoter and NOS terminator.

Quantification of DNA fragmentation in processed foods using real-time PCR.

DNA analysis of processed foods is performed widely to detect various targets, such as genetically modified organisms (GMOs). Food processing often causes DNA fragmentation, which consequently affects the results of PCR analysis. In order to assess the effects of DNA fragmentation on the reliability of PCR analysis, we investigated a novel methodology to quantify the degree of DNA fragmentation. We designed four real-time PCR assays that amplified 18S ribosomal RNA gene sequences common to various plants at lengths of approximately 100, 200, 400, and 800 base pairs (bp). Then, we created an indicator value, "DNA fragmentation index (DFI)", which is calculated from the Cq values derived from the real-time PCR assays. Finally, we demonstrated the efficacy of this method for the quality control of GMO detection in processed foods by evaluating the relationship between the DFI and the limit of detection.

A set of tetra-nucleotide core motif SSR markers for efficient identification of potato (Solanum tuberosum) cultivars.

Simple sequence repeat (SSR) is a popular tool for individual fingerprinting. The long-core motif (e.g. tetra-, penta-, and hexa-nucleotide) simple sequence repeats (SSRs) are preferred because they make it easier to separate and distinguish neighbor alleles. In the present study, a new set of 8 tetra-nucleotide SSRs in potato (Solanum tuberosum) is reported. By using these 8 markers, 72 out of 76 cultivars obtained from Japan and the United States were clearly discriminated, while two pairs, both of which arose from natural variation, showed identical profiles. The combined probability of identity between two random cultivars for the set of 8 SSR markers was estimated to be 1.10 × 10-8, confirming the usefulness of the proposed SSR markers for fingerprinting analyses of potato.

Development and Evaluation of Event-Specific Quantitative PCR Method for Genetically Modified Soybean MON87701.

A real-time PCR-based analytical method was developed for the event-specific quantification of a genetically modified (GM) soybean event, MON87701. First, a standard plasmid for MON87701 quantification was constructed. The conversion factor (Cf) required to calculate the amount of genetically modified organism (GMO) was experimentally determined for a real-time PCR instrument. The determined Cf for the real-time PCR instrument was 1.24. For the evaluation of the developed method, a blind test was carried out in an inter-laboratory trial. The trueness and precision were evaluated as the bias and reproducibility of relative standard deviation (RSDr), respectively. The determined biases and the RSDr values were less than 30 and 13%, respectively, at all evaluated concentrations. The limit of quantitation of the method was 0.5%, and the developed method would thus be applicable for practical analyses for the detection and quantification of MON87701.

Interlaboratory validation data on real-time polymerase chain reaction detection for unauthorized genetically modified papaya line PRSV-YK.

This article is referred to research article entitled "Whole genome sequence analysis of unidentified genetically modified papaya for development of a specific detection method" (Nakamura et al., 2016) [1]. Real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) detection method for unauthorized genetically modified (GM) papaya (Carica papaya L.) line PRSV-YK (PRSV-YK detection method) was developed using whole genome sequence data (DDBJ Sequenced Read Archive under accession No. PRJDB3976). Interlaboratory validation datasets for PRSV-YK detection method were provided. Data indicating homogeneity of samples prepared for interlaboratory validation were included. Specificity and sensitivity test data for PRSV-YK detection method were also provided.