How a highly acidic SH3 domain folds in the absence of its charged peptide target.

Charged residues on the surface of proteins are critical for both protein stability and interactions. However, many proteins contain binding regions with a high net-charge that may destabilize the protein but are useful for binding to oppositely charged targets. We hypothesized that these domains would be marginally stable, as electrostatic repulsion would compete with favorable hydrophobic collapse during folding. Furthermore, by increasing the salt concentration we predict that these protein folds would be stabilized by mimicking some of the favorable electrostatic interactions that take place during target binding. We varied the salt and urea concentrations to probe the contributions of electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions for the folding of the 60-residue yeast SH3 domain found in Abp1p. The SH3 domain was significantly stabilized with increased salt concentrations according to the Debye-Huckel limiting law. Molecular dynamics and NMR show that sodium ions interact with all 15 acidic residues but do little to change backbone dynamics or overall structure. Folding kinetics experiments show that the addition of urea or salt primarily affects the folding rate, indicating that almost all the hydrophobic collapse and electrostatic repulsion occurs in the transition state. After the transition state formation, modest yet favorable short-range salt-bridges are formed along with hydrogen bonds, as the native state fully folds. Thus, hydrophobic collapse offsets electrostatic repulsion to ensure this highly charged binding domain can still fold and be ready to bind to its charged peptide targets, a property that is likely evolutionarily conserved over one billion years. Statement for broader audience: Some protein domains are highly charged because they are adapted to bind oppositely charged proteins and nucleic acids. However, it is unknown how these highly charged domains fold as during folding there will be significant repulsion between like-charges. We investigate how one of these highly charged domains folds in the presence of salt, which can screen the charge repulsion and make folding easier, allowing us to understand how folding occurs despite the protein’s high charge. Supplementary material: Supplementary material document containing additional details on protein expression methods, thermodynamics and kinetics equations, and the effect of urea on electrostatic interactions, as well as 4 supplemental figures and 4 supplemental data tables. ( Supplementary_Material.docx ), 15 pages Supplemental excel file containing covariation data across AbpSH3 orthologs ( FileS1.xlsx ).

How a highly acidic SH3 domain folds in the absence of its charged peptide target.

Charged residues on the surface of proteins are critical for both protein stability and interactions. However, many proteins contain binding regions with a high net charge that may destabilize the protein but are useful for binding to oppositely charged targets. We hypothesized that these domains would be marginally stable, as electrostatic repulsion would compete with favorable hydrophobic collapse during folding. Furthermore, by increasing the salt concentration, we predict that these protein folds would be stabilized by mimicking some of the favorable electrostatic interactions that take place during target binding. We varied the salt and urea concentrations to probe the contributions of electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions for the folding of the yeast SH3 domain found in Abp1p. The SH3 domain was significantly stabilized with increased salt concentrations due to Debye-Huckel screening and a nonspecific territorial ion-binding effect. Molecular dynamics and NMR show that sodium ions interact with all 15 acidic residues but do little to change backbone dynamics or overall structure. Folding kinetics experiments show that the addition of urea or salt primarily affects the folding rate, indicating that almost all the hydrophobic collapse and electrostatic repulsion occur in the transition state. After the transition state formation, modest yet favorable short-range salt bridges are formed along with hydrogen bonds, as the native state fully folds. Thus, hydrophobic collapse offsets electrostatic repulsion to ensure this highly charged binding domain can still fold and be ready to bind to its charged peptide targets, a property that is likely evolutionarily conserved over 1 billion years.

Three segment ligation of a 104 kDa multi-domain protein by SrtA and OaAEP1.

NMR spectroscopy is an excellent tool for studying protein structure and dynamics which provides a deeper understanding of biological function. As the size of the biomolecule of interest increases, it can become advantageous to dilute the number of observed signals in the NMR spectrum to decrease spectral overlap and increase resolution. One way to limit the number of resonances in the NMR data is by selectively labeling a smaller domain within the larger macromolecule, a process called segmental isotopic labeling. Many examples of segmental isotopic labeling have been described where two segments of a protein are ligated together by chemical or enzymatic means, but there are far fewer descriptions of a three or more segment ligation reaction. Herein, we describe an enzymatic segmental labeling scheme that combines the widely used Sortase A and more recently described OaAEP1 for a two site ligation strategy. In preparation to study proposed long-range allostery in the 104 kDa DNA damage repair protein Rad50, we ligated side-chain methyl group labeled Zn Hook domain between two long segments of otherwise unlabeled P.furiosus Rad50. Enzymatic activity data demonstrated that the scars resulting from the ligation reactions did not affect Rad50 function within the Mre11-Rad50 DNA double strand break repair complex. Finally, methyl-based NMR spectroscopy confirmed the formation of the full-length ligated protein. Our strategy highlights the strengths of OaAEP1 for segmental labeling, namely faster reaction times and a smaller recognition sequence, and provides a straightforward template for using these two enzymes in multisite segmental labeling reactions.

Structural features of Dnase1L3 responsible for serum antigen clearance.

Autoimmunity develops when extracellular DNA released from dying cells is not cleared from serum. While serum DNA is primarily digested by Dnase1 and Dnase1L3, Dnase1 cannot rescue autoimmunity arising from Dnase1L3 deficiencies. Dnase1L3 uniquely degrades antigenic forms of cell-free DNA, including DNA complexed with lipids and proteins. The distinct activity of Dnase1L3 relies on its unique C-terminal Domain (CTD), but the mechanism is unknown. We used multiple biophysical techniques and functional assays to study the interplay between the core catalytic domain and the CTD. While the core domain resembles Dnase1, there are key structural differences between the two enzymes. First, Dnase1L3 is not inhibited by actin due to multiple differences in the actin recognition site. Second, the CTD augments the ability of the core to bind DNA, thereby facilitating the degradation of complexed DNA. Together, these structural insights will inform the development of Dnase1L3-based therapies for autoimmunity.

LRET-derived HADDOCK structural models describe the conformational heterogeneity required for DNA cleavage by the Mre11-Rad50 DNA damage repair complex.

The Mre11-Rad50-Nbs1 protein complex is one of the first responders to DNA double-strand breaks. Studies have shown that the catalytic activities of the evolutionarily conserved Mre11-Rad50 (MR) core complex depend on an ATP-dependent global conformational change that takes the macromolecule from an open, extended structure in the absence of ATP to a closed, globular structure when ATP is bound. We have previously identified an additional 'partially open' conformation using luminescence resonance energy transfer (LRET) experiments. Here, a combination of LRET and the molecular docking program HADDOCK was used to further investigate this partially open state and identify three conformations of MR in solution: closed, partially open, and open, which are in addition to the extended, apo conformation. Mutants disrupting specific Mre11-Rad50 interactions within each conformation were used in nuclease activity assays on a variety of DNA substrates to help put the three states into a functional perspective. LRET data collected on MR bound to DNA demonstrate that the three conformations also exist when nuclease substrates are bound. These models were further supported with small-angle X-ray scattering data, which corroborate the presence of multiple states in solution. Together, the data suggest a mechanism for the nuclease activity of the MR complex along the DNA.

Electrostatic Interactions between CSTF2 and pre-mRNA Drive Cleavage and Polyadenylation.

Nascent pre-mRNA 3'-end cleavage and polyadenylation (C/P) involves numerous proteins that recognize multiple RNA elements. Human CSTF2 binds to a downstream U- or G/U-rich sequence through its RNA recognition motif (RRM) regulating C/P. We previously reported the only known disease-related CSTF2 RRM mutant (CSTF2D50A) and showed that it changed the on-rate of RNA binding, leading to alternative polyadenylation in brains of mice carrying the same mutation. In this study, we further investigated the role of electrostatic interactions in the thermodynamics and kinetics of RNA binding for the CSTF2 RRM and the downstream consequences for regulation of C/P. By combining mutagenesis with NMR spectroscopy and biophysical assays, we confirmed that electrostatic attraction is the dominant factor in RRM binding to a naturally occurring U-rich RNA sequence. Moreover, we demonstrate that RNA binding is accompanied by an enthalpy-entropy compensation mechanism that is supported by changes in pico-to-nanosecond timescale RRM protein dynamics. We suggest that the dynamic binding of the RRM to U-rich RNA supports the diversity of sequences it encounters in the nucleus. Lastly, in vivo C/P assays demonstrate a competition between fast, high affinity RNA binding and efficient, correct C/P. These results highlight the importance of the surface charge of the RRM in RNA binding and the balance between nascent mRNA binding and C/P in vivo.

Biochemical and structural characterization of analogs of MRE11 breast cancer-associated mutant F237C.

The MRE11-RAD50-NBS1 (MRN) protein complex plays a vital role in DNA double strand break sensing, signaling, and repair. Mutation in any component of this complex may lead to disease as disrupting DNA double strand break repair has the potential to cause translocations and loss of genomic information. Here, we have investigated an MRE11 mutation, F237C, identified in a breast cancer tumor. We found that the analogous mutant of Pyrococcus furiosus Mre11 diminishes both the exonuclease and endonuclease activities of Mre11 in vitro. Solution state NMR experiments show that this mutant causes structural changes in the DNA-bound Mre11 for both exo- and endonuclease substrates and causes the protein to become generally more rigid. Moreover, by comparing the NMR data for this cancer-associated mutant with two previously described Mre11 separation-of-nuclease function mutants, a potential allosteric network was detected within Mre11 that connects the active site to regions responsible for recognizing the DNA ends and for dimerization. Together, our data further highlight the dynamics required for Mre11 nuclease function and illuminate the presence of allostery within the enzyme.

The dynamic nature of the Mre11-Rad50 DNA break repair complex.

The Mre11-Rad50-Nbs1/Xrs2 protein complex plays a pivotal role in the detection and repair of DNA double strand breaks. Through traditional and emerging structural biology techniques, various functional structural states of this complex have been visualized; however, relatively little is known about the transitions between these states. Indeed, it is these structural transitions that are important for Mre11-Rad50-mediated DNA unwinding at a break and the activation of downstream repair signaling events. Here, we present a brief overview of the current understanding of the structure of the core Mre11-Rad50 complex. We then highlight our recent studies emphasizing the contributions of solution state NMR spectroscopy and other biophysical techniques in providing insight into the structures and dynamics associated with Mre11-Rad50 functions.

A missense mutation in the CSTF2 gene that impairs the function of the RNA recognition motif and causes defects in 3' end processing is associated with intellectual disability in humans.

CSTF2 encodes an RNA-binding protein that is essential for mRNA cleavage and polyadenylation (C/P). No disease-associated mutations have been described for this gene. Here, we report a mutation in the RNA recognition motif (RRM) of CSTF2 that changes an aspartic acid at position 50 to alanine (p.D50A), resulting in intellectual disability in male patients. In mice, this mutation was sufficient to alter polyadenylation sites in over 1300 genes critical for brain development. Using a reporter gene assay, we demonstrated that C/P efficiency of CSTF2D50A was lower than wild type. To account for this, we determined that p.D50A changed locations of amino acid side chains altering RNA binding sites in the RRM. The changes modified the electrostatic potential of the RRM leading to a greater affinity for RNA. These results highlight the significance of 3' end mRNA processing in expression of genes important for brain plasticity and neuronal development.

A Survey of Reported Disease-Related Mutations in the MRE11-RAD50-NBS1 Complex.

The MRE11-RAD50-NBS1 (MRN) protein complex is one of the primary vehicles for repairing DNA double strand breaks and maintaining the genomic stability within the cell. The role of the MRN complex to recognize and process DNA double-strand breaks as well as signal other damage response factors is critical for maintaining proper cellular function. Mutations in any one of the components of the MRN complex that effect function or expression of the repair machinery could be detrimental to the cell and may initiate and/or propagate disease. Here, we discuss, in a structural and biochemical context, mutations in each of the three MRN components that have been associated with diseases such as ataxia telangiectasia-like disorder (ATLD), Nijmegen breakage syndrome (NBS), NBS-like disorder (NBSLD) and certain types of cancers. Overall, deepening our understanding of disease-causing mutations of the MRN complex at the structural and biochemical level is foundational to the future aim of treating diseases associated with these aberrations.

Maturation of the functional mouse CRES amyloid from globular form.

The epididymal lumen contains a complex cystatin-rich nonpathological amyloid matrix with putative roles in sperm maturation and sperm protection. Given our growing understanding for the biological function of this and other functional amyloids, the problem still remains: how functional amyloids assemble including their initial transition to early oligomeric forms. To examine this, we developed a protocol for the purification of nondenatured mouse CRES, a component of the epididymal amyloid matrix, allowing us to examine its assembly to amyloid under conditions that may mimic those in vivo. Herein we use X-ray crystallography, solution-state NMR, and solid-state NMR to follow at the atomic level the assembly of the CRES amyloidogenic precursor as it progressed from monomeric folded protein to an advanced amyloid. We show the CRES monomer has a typical cystatin fold that assembles into highly branched amyloid matrices, comparable to those in vivo, by forming ß-sheet assemblies that our data suggest occur via two distinct mechanisms: a unique conformational switch of a highly flexible disulfide-anchored loop to a rigid ß-strand and by traditional cystatin domain swapping. Our results provide key insight into our understanding of functional amyloid assembly by revealing the earliest structural transitions from monomer to oligomer and by showing that some functional amyloid structures may be built by multiple and distinctive assembly mechanisms.

Mutation of Conserved Mre11 Residues Alter Protein Dynamics to Separate Nuclease Functions.

Naked and protein-blocked DNA ends occur naturally during immune cell development, meiosis, and at telomeres as well as from aborted topoisomerase reactions, collapsed replication forks, and other stressors. Damaged DNA ends are dangerous in cells and if left unrepaired can lead to genomic rearrangement, loss of genetic information, and eventually cancer. Mre11 is part of the Mre11-Rad50-Nbs1 complex that recognizes DNA double-strand breaks and has exonuclease and endonuclease activities that help to initiate the repair processes to resolve these broken DNA ends. In fact, these activities are crucial for proper DNA damage repair pathway choice. Here, using Pyrococcus furiosus Mre11, we question how two Mre11 separation-of-function mutants, one previously described but the second first described here, maintain endonuclease activity in the absence of exonuclease activity. To start, we performed solution-state NMR experiments to assign the side-chain methyl groups of the 64-kDa Mre11 nuclease and capping domains, which allowed us to describe the structural differences between Mre11 bound to exo- and endonuclease substrates. Then, through biochemical and biophysical characterization, including NMR structural and dynamics studies, we compared the two mutants and determined that both affect the dynamic features and double-stranded DNA binding properties of Mre11, but in different ways. In total, our results illuminate the structural and dynamic landscape of Mre11 nuclease function.

Adjacent mutations in the archaeal Rad50 ABC ATPase D-loop disrupt allosteric regulation of ATP hydrolysis through different mechanisms.

DNA damage is the driving force for mutation and genomic instability, which can both lead to cell death or carcinogenesis. DNA double strand breaks are detected and processed in part by the Mre11-Rad50-Nbs1 protein complex. Although the Mre11-Rad50-Nbs1 complex is essential, several spontaneous mutations have been noted in various cancers. One of these mutations, within a conserved motif of Rad50, resulted in an outlier curative response in a clinical trial. We show through biochemical and biophysical characterization that this cancer-associated mutation and a second mutation to the adjacent residue, previously described in a breast cancer patient, both have gain-of-function Rad50 ATP hydrolysis activity that results not from faster association of the ATP-bound form but faster dissociation leading to less stable Rad50 dimer. This disruption impairs the regulatory functions of the protein complex leading to a loss of exonuclease activity from Mre11. Interestingly, these two mutations affect Rad50 structure and dynamics quite differently. These studies describe the relationship between function, structure, and molecular motions in improperly regulated Rad50, which reveal the underlying biophysical mechanism for how these two cancer-associated mutations affect the cell.

The Functional Mammalian CRES (Cystatin-Related Epididymal Spermatogenic) Amyloid is Antiparallel ß-Sheet Rich and Forms a Metastable Oligomer During Assembly.

An amyloid matrix composed of several family 2 cystatins, including the reproductive cystatin CRES, is an integral structure in the mouse epididymal lumen and has proposed functions in sperm maturation and protection. Understanding how CRES amyloid assembles in vitro may provide clues on how the epididymal amyloid matrix forms in vivo. We therefore purified full-length CRES under nondenaturing conditions and followed its aggregation from monomer to amyloid under conditions that may approximate those in the epididymal lumen. CRES transitioned into a metastable oligomer that was resistant to aggregation and only over extended time formed higher-ordered amyloids. High protein concentrations facilitated oligomer assembly and also were required to maintain the metastable state since following dilution the oligomer was no longer detected. Similar to other amyloid precursors, the formation of CRES amyloids correlated with a loss of α-helix and a gain of ß-sheet content. However, CRES is unique in that its amyloids are rich in antiparallel ß-sheets instead of the more common parallel ß-sheets. Taken together, our studies suggest that early metastable oligomers may serve as building blocks for functional amyloid assembly and further reveal that antiparallel ß-sheet-rich amyloids can be functional forms.

A DNA aptamer reveals an allosteric site for inhibition in metallo-ß-lactamases.

The hydrolysis of ß-lactam antibiotics by ß-lactamase enzymes is the most prominent antibiotic resistance mechanism for many pathogenic bacteria. Out of this broad class of enzymes, metallo-ß-lactamases are of special clinical interest because of their broad substrate specificities. Several in vitro inhibitors for various metallo-ß-lactamases have been reported with no clinical efficacy. Previously, we described a 10-nucleotide single stranded DNA aptamer (10-mer) that inhibits Bacillus cereus 5/B/6 metallo-ß-lactamase very effectively. Here, we find that the aptamer shows uncompetitive inhibition of Bacillus cereus 5/B/6 metallo-ß-lactamase during cefuroxime hydrolysis. To understand the mechanism of inhibition, we report a 2.5 Å resolution X-ray crystal structure and solution-state NMR analysis of the free enzyme. Chemical shift perturbations were observed in the HSQC spectra for several residues upon titrating with increasing concentrations of the 10-mer. In the X-ray crystal structure, these residues are distal to the active site, suggesting an allosteric mechanism for the aptamer inhibition of the enzyme. HADDOCK molecular docking simulations suggest that the 10-mer docks 26 Å from the active site. We then mutated the three lysine residues in the basic binding patch to glutamine and measured the catalytic activity and inhibition by the 10-mer. No significant inhibition of these mutants was observed by the 10-mer as compared to wild type. Interestingly, mutation of Lys50 (Lys78; according to standard MBL numbering system) resulted in reduced enzymatic activity relative to wild type in the absence of inhibitor, further highlighting an allosteric mechanism for inhibition.

Increasing the buffering capacity of minimal media leads to higher protein yield.

We describe a general and simple modification to the standard M9 minimal medium recipe that leads to an approximate twofold increase in the yield of heterologously expressed proteins in Escherichia coli BL21(DE3) bacteria. We monitored the growth of bacteria transformed with plasmids for three different test proteins in five minimal media with different concentrations of buffering salts and/or initial media pH. After purification of the over-expressed proteins, we found a clear correlation between the protein yield and change in media pH over time, where the minimal media that were the most buffered and therefore most resistant to change in pH produced the most protein. And in all three test protein cases, the difference in yield was nearly twofold between the best and worst buffering media. Thus, we propose that increasing the buffering capacity of M9 minimal media will generally lead to a similar increase for most of the proteins currently produced by this standard protein expression protocol. Moreover, we have qualitatively found that this effect also extends to deuterated M9 minimal media growths, which could lead to significant cost savings in these preparations.

Methyl-Based NMR Spectroscopy Methods for Uncovering Structural Dynamics in Large Proteins and Protein Complexes.

NMR spectroscopy is particularly adept at site-specifically monitoring dynamic processes in proteins, such as protein folding, domain movements, ligand binding, and side-chain rotations. By coupling the favorable spectroscopic properties of highly dynamic side-chain methyl groups with transverse-relaxation-optimized spectroscopy (TROSY), it is now possible to routinely study such dynamic processes in high-molecular-weight proteins and complexes approaching 1 MDa. In this Perspective, we describe many elegant methyl-based NMR experiments that probe slow (second) to fast (picosecond) dynamics in large systems. To demonstrate the power of these methods, we also provide interesting examples of studies that utilized each methyl-based NMR technique to uncover functionally important dynamics. In many cases, the NMR experiments are paired with site-directed mutagenesis and/or other biochemical assays to put the dynamics and function into context. Our vision of the future of structural biology involves pairing methyl-based NMR spectroscopy with biochemical studies to advance our knowledge of the motions large proteins and macromolecular complexes use to choreograph complex functions. Such studies will be essential in elucidating the critical structural dynamics that underlie function and characterizing alterations in these processes that can lead to human disease.

The structural basis of CstF-77 modulation of cleavage and polyadenylation through stimulation of CstF-64 activity.

Cleavage and polyadenylation (C/P) of mRNA is an important cellular process that promotes increased diversity of mRNA isoforms and could change their stability in different cell types. The cleavage stimulation factor (CstF) complex, part of the C/P machinery, binds to U- and GU-rich sequences located downstream from the cleavage site through its RNA-binding subunit, CstF-64. Less is known about the function of the other two subunits of CstF, CstF-77 and CstF-50. Here, we show that the carboxy-terminus of CstF-77 plays a previously unrecognized role in enhancing C/P by altering how the RNA recognition motif (RRM) of CstF-64 binds RNA. In support of this finding, we also show that CstF-64 relies on CstF-77 to be transported to the nucleus; excess CstF-64 localizes to the cytoplasm, possibly via interaction with cytoplasmic RNAs. Reverse genetics and nuclear magnetic resonance studies of recombinant CstF-64 (RRM-Hinge) and CstF-77 (monkeytail-carboxy-terminal domain) indicate that the last 30 amino acids of CstF-77 increases the stability of the RRM, thus altering the affinity of the complex for RNA. These results provide new insights into the mechanism by which CstF regulates the location of the RNA cleavage site during C/P.

A dynamic allosteric pathway underlies Rad50 ABC ATPase function in DNA repair.

The Mre11-Rad50 protein complex is an initial responder to sites of DNA double strand breaks. Many studies have shown that ATP binding to Rad50 causes global changes to the Mre11-Rad50 structure, which are important for DNA repair functions. Here we used methyl-based NMR spectroscopy on a series of mutants to describe a dynamic allosteric pathway within Rad50. Mutations result in changes in the side chain methyl group chemical environment that are correlated with altered nanosecond timescale dynamics. We also observe striking relationships between the magnitude of chemical shift perturbations and Rad50 and Mre11 activities. Together, these data suggest an equilibrium between a ground state and an "active" dimerization competent state of Rad50 that has locally altered structure and dynamics and is poised for ATP-induced dimerization and eventual ATP hydrolysis. Thus, this sparsely populated intermediate is critical for Mre11-Rad50-directed DNA double strand break repair.

ClpB N-terminal domain plays a regulatory role in protein disaggregation.

ClpB/Hsp100 is an ATP-dependent disaggregase that solubilizes and reactivates protein aggregates in cooperation with the DnaK/Hsp70 chaperone system. The ClpB-substrate interaction is mediated by conserved tyrosine residues located in flexible loops in nucleotide-binding domain-1 that extend into the ClpB central pore. In addition to the tyrosines, the ClpB N-terminal domain (NTD) was suggested to provide a second substrate-binding site; however, the manner in which the NTD recognizes and binds substrate proteins has remained elusive. Herein, we present an NMR spectroscopy study to structurally characterize the NTD-substrate interaction. We show that the NTD includes a substrate-binding groove that specifically recognizes exposed hydrophobic stretches in unfolded or aggregated client proteins. Using an optimized segmental labeling technique in combination with methyl-transverse relaxation optimized spectroscopy (TROSY) NMR, the interaction of client proteins with both the NTD and the pore-loop tyrosines in the 580-kDa ClpB hexamer has been characterized. Unlike contacts with the tyrosines, the NTD-substrate interaction is independent of the ClpB nucleotide state and protein conformational changes that result from ATP hydrolysis. The NTD interaction destabilizes client proteins, priming them for subsequent unfolding and translocation. Mutations in the NTD substrate-binding groove are shown to have a dramatic effect on protein translocation through the ClpB central pore, suggesting that, before their interaction with substrates, the NTDs block the translocation channel. Together, our findings provide both a detailed characterization of the NTD-substrate complex and insight into the functional regulatory role of the ClpB NTD in protein disaggregation.