Parallel Chirality Inductions in Möbius Zn(II) Hexaphyrin Transformation Networks.

Networked chemical transformations are key features of biological systems, in which complex multicomponent interactions enable the emergence of sophisticated functions. Being interested in chirality induction phenomena with dynamic Möbius π-systems, we have designed a pair of Möbius [28]hexaphyrin ligands in order to investigate mixtures rather than isolated molecules. Thus, a hexaphyrin bearing a chiral amino arm was first optimized and found to bind a ZnOAc moiety, triggering an impressive quasi-quantitative chirality induction over the Möbius π-system. Second, this amino-type hexaphyrin was mixed with a second hexaphyrin bearing a chiral carboxylate arm, affording at first ill-defined coordination assemblies in the presence of zinc. In contrast, a social self-sorting behavior occurred upon the addition of two exogenous achiral effectors (AcO- and BuNH2), leading to a well-defined 1:1 mixture of two Möbius complexes featuring a sole Möbius twist configuration (parallel chirality inductions). We next successfully achieved compartmentalized switching, i.e., a single-component transformation from such a complex mixture. The BuNH2 effector was selectively protected with Boc2O, owing to a lower reactivity of the arm's NH2 function intramolecularly bound to zinc, and subsequent addition of BuNH2 restored the initial mixture, retaining parallel chirality inductions (five cycles). By changing the nature and twist configuration of only one of the two complexes, at initial state or by switching, this approach enables a "two-channel" tuning of the chiroptical properties of the ensemble. Such multiple dynamic chirality inductions, controlled by selective metal-ligand recognition and chemical reactivity, set down the basis for Möbius-type stereoselective transformation networks with new functions.

Möbius ZnII -Hexaphyrins Bearing a Chiral Coordinating Arm: A Chiroptical Switch Featuring P/M Twist Inversion Controlled by Achiral Effectors.

By their conformational flexibility, Möbius aromatic hexaphyrins provide a dynamic chirality attractive to develop stimuli responsive systems such as chiroptical switches. A regular [28]hexaphyrin has been equipped with a chiral coordinating arm to achieve transfer of chirality from a fix stereogenic element to the dynamic Möbius one. The arm allows straightforward formation of labile monometallic ZnII complexes with an exogenous ligand, either a carboxylato or an amino with opposite inwards/outwards orientations relative to the Möbius ring. As a corollary, the chiral coordinating arm is constrained over the ring or laterally, inducing opposite P and M Möbius configurations with unprecedented high stereoselectivity (diast. excess greater than 95 %). By tuning the transfer of chirality, these achiral effectors generate electronic circular dichroism spectra with bisignate Cotton effect of opposite signs. Switching between distinct chiroptical states was ultimately achieved in mild conditions owing to ligand exchange, with high robustness (10 cycles).

Functional Myoglobin Model Composed of a Strapped Porphyrin/Cyclodextrin Supramolecular Complex with an Overhanging COOH That Increases O2/CO Binding Selectivity in Aqueous Solution.

A water-soluble strapped iron(III)tetraarylporphyrin (FeIIIPor-1) bearing two propylpyridinium groups at the side chains and a carboxylic acid group at the overhanging position of the strap was synthesized to mimic the function of myoglobin with the distal polar functionality in aqueous solution. FeIIIPor-1 forms a stable 1:1 inclusion complex with a per-O-methylated ß-cyclodextrin dimer having a pyridine linker (Py3OCD), providing a hydrophobic environment and a proximal fifth ligand to stabilize the O2-complex. The ferrous complex (FeIIPorCD-1) binds both O2 and CO in aqueous solution. The O2 and CO binding affinities (P1/2O2 and P1/2CO) and half-life time (t1/2) of the O2 complex of FeIIPorCD-1 are 6.3 and 0.021 Torr, and 7 h, respectively, at pH 7 and 25 °C. The control compound without the strap structure (FeIIPorCD-2) has similar oxygen binding characteristics (P1/2O2 = 8.0 Torr), but much higher CO binding affinity (P1/2CO = 3.8 × 10-4 Torr), and longer t1/2 (30 h). The O2 and CO kinetics indicate that the strapped structure in FeIIPorCD-1 inhibits the entrance of these gaseous ligands into the iron(II) center, as evidenced by lower konO2 and konCO values. Interestingly, the CO complex of FeIIPorCD-1 is significantly destabilized (relatively larger koffCO), while the koffO2 value is much smaller than that of FeIIPorCD-2, resulting in significantly increased O2/CO selectivity (reduced M value, where M = P1/2O2/P1/2CO = 320) in FeIIPorCD-1 compared to FeIIPorCD-2 (M = 21000).

Interconversion between Möbius chiroptical states sustained by hexaphyrin dynamic coordination.

Harnessing the chiroptical properties of molecular Möbius rings is motivated by fundamental aspects while challenged by synthetic difficulties. Focusing on Möbius aromatic Zn(ii) hexaphyrin complexes, interconversion between two chiral states was achieved through binding and release of an amino ligand (forward/backward stimuli), leading to different chiroptical switching phenomena (amplification, on-off, inversion). The amine either supplies the chirality or behaves as an achiral effector regulating the Zn(ii)-binding of a second (chiral) carboxylato ligand. These results highlight the Möbius [28]hexaphyrin scaffold as an attractive chiral switchable unit.

Match-mismatch effects in two-fold transfer of chirality within a Möbius metallo-receptor.

Two-fold transfer of chirality has been investigated in a Möbius Zn(ii) hexaphyrin metallo-receptor able to bind simultaneously two different chiral molecules. Match/mismatch effects influence the dynamic stereoselective twisting of the π-system, and allow tuning of the induced chiroptical activity. Such allosteric control is attractive for building chirality sensing systems.

Orchestrating Communications in a Three-Type Chirality Totem: Remote Control of the Chiroptical Response of a Möbius Aromatic System.

Among the various types of chirality (central, axial, helical, planar, etc.), that inherent to Möbius topology remains almost unexplored, partly due to the difficulty to access Möbius compounds. Over the past decade, [28]hexaphyrins have been revealed to be among the best candidates to build on Möbius aromaticity. Whereas their flexibility needs to be controlled to get P/M twist enantioselectivity, it could be of great interest to sustain dynamic chirality transfer. In this context, we report herein the first example of a Möbius aromatic ring capped by a cavity, consisting of a Möbius [28]hexaphyrin doubly linked to an α-cyclodextrin. This unique design affords a "totem" of three different chirality elements arising from the cyclodextrin (fix central chirality), the bridging pattern (dynamic planar chirality), and the hexaphyrin (dynamic topological chirality). Chirality transfers (as shown in the TOC graphic) are characterized by a stereospecific planar-to-topological communication (diastereomeric excess >95%; the highest asymmetric selectivity reported to date for a Möbius ring) combined to a stereoselective central-to-planar communication (up to 60% diastereomeric excess). Interestingly, the stereoselectivity is remotely controlled by coordination of an achiral effector to the hexaphyrin, increasing up to 5 times the chiroptical response of the Möbius aromatic π-system. These results highlight the advantageous use of dynamic chirality transfers to further incorporate Möbius chirality and aromaticity into all kinds of stimuli-responsive devices.

Acid-base controlled multiple conformation and aromaticity switches in tren-capped hexaphyrins.

Upon protonation, a tren-capped hexaphyrin undergoes successive rectangular-to-Möbius and Möbius-to-triangular conformational isomerizations, with concomitant antiaromaticity-to-aromaticity reversal. This affords different cage environments leading ultimately to a "crypto-bowl-shape" hexaphyrin hosting a trifluoroacetate counterion.

HgII -Mediated TlI -to-TlIII Oxidation in Dynamic PbII /Tl Porphyrin Complexes.

Compared with their purely organic counterparts, molecular switches that are based on metal ion translocations have been underexplored, and more particularly, it remains challenging to control the translocation of several particles in multisite receptors. Recently, bimetallic complexes that undergo double translocation processes have been developed with bis-strapped porphyrin ligands. To implement a redox control for these systems, we have investigated the formation of heterobimetallic lead/thallium complexes, with thallium in the +I and +III oxidation states. Two different complexes were characterized: 1) a PbII /TlI complex, in which both metal ions interact with the N-core on its different sides, and 2) a PbII /TlIII complex with TlIII selectively bound to the N-core and PbII selectively bound to the strap opposite to TlIII . These two complexes undergo interconversion between their two degenerate forms (same coordination of the metal ions but on opposite sides) by different intra or intermolecular translocation pathways. In addition, conversion of the PbII /TlI complex into its PbII /TlIII counterpart was achieved by addition of a stoichiometric amount of HgII salt as a sacrificial electron acceptor. These results further contribute to the elaboration of devices that feature redox-controlled compartmentalized double translocations.

Cyclodextrin-Sandwiched Hexaphyrin Hybrids: Side-to-Side Cavity Coupling Switched by a Temperature- and Redox-Responsive Central Device.

Access to allosteric enzyme mimics that ideally associate communicating compartments for catalysis and regulation is still challenging. Whereas a sandwich "cavity-catalyst-cavity" approach, developed mainly with cyclodextrins and porphyrins, appears promising, its counterpart with hexaphyrins featuring rich conformation, aromaticity, and coordination behavior has not been prospected at all. We thus developed sandwich hybrids made of two cyclodextrins triply linked on each side of a hexaphyrin. The latter displays switchable oxidation states with interconvertible conformations (28π antiaromatic and 26π aromatic, each adopting rectangular and dumbbell forms). These four states are connected by two orthogonal switches under redox [aromaticity] and thermal [shape] control. This leads to twin compartmentalized confined spaces either locked or unlocked depending on the conformation of the hexaphyrin, and the reversibility of the lock↔unlock transition relies on the aromaticity of the hexaphyrin. The sandwiched heteroannulene thus behaves as an unprecedented dual-responsive double-latched device. Such hybrid systems open interesting perspectives in the allosteric regulation of receptors, catalysts, and machineries.

Tren-Capped Hexaphyrin Zinc Complexes: Interplaying Molecular Recognition, Möbius Aromaticity, and Chirality.

Over the past decade, the hexaphyrin skeleton has emerged as a multifaceted frame exhibiting strong interplay between topology, aromaticity, and metal coordination, opening new research areas beyond porphyrins. However, molecular recognition with hexaphyrins has been underexplored, mainly because of the lack of general synthetic strategies leading to sophisticated molecular hosts. Here we have developed a straightforward approach for capping the heteroannulene frame with tripodal units (e.g., tris(2-aminoethyl)amine [tren]) through postsynthetic modification of a readily accessible meso-(2-aminophenyl) tris-substituted platform. The resulting tren-capped hexaphyrins, obtained in three steps from a 5-(aryl)dipyrromethane precursor, display remarkable features: (i) Considering the 28π-conjugated system, instantaneous and site-selective Zn(II) metalation at the level of a dipyrrin versus tren unit triggers a planar-to-singly twisted conformational change and hence a Hückel antiaromatic-to-Möbius aromatic transformation. In spite of the tripodal linkage, a smooth twist and efficient π overlap are preserved. (ii) Selective and cooperative binding of both an acetato ligand and an amino ligand to zinc occurs in distinct confined environments, reminiscent of substrate discrimination at the buried metal centers of metalloenzymes. The ligand binding pockets are allosterically tuned by monoprotonation of the tren unit. (iii) Substantial chiral induction of the molecular twist is achieved using chiral amino ligands (diastereomeric excess up to 77%, the highest reported to date for a Möbius compound), to which is associated a strong chiroptical signature in circular dichroism. These results provide unprecedented insights into molecular recognition with hexaphyrins, paving the way to innovative Möbius-type molecular hosts for sensing and catalysis.

Designing 'Totem' C2 -Symmetrical Iron Porphyrin Catalysts for Stereoselective Cyclopropanations.

The catalytic activity of the iron(III) C2 chiral porphyrin Fe(2)(OMe) in alkene cyclopropanation is herein reported. The catalyst promoted the reaction of differently substituted styrenes with diazo derivatives with trans-diastereoselectivities and enantioselectivities up to 99:1 and 87 %, respectively. In addition, high TON and TOF values (up to 10 000 and 120 000 h(-1) , respectively) were observed indicating good activity and stability of the catalyst in optimized experimental conditions. The study of the cyclopropanation reaction revealed that the porphyrin skeleton is composed of two 'totem' parts which were independently responsible for the observed enantio- and diastereoselectivities. To further our research we also investigated the catalytic role of the methoxy axial ligand coordinated to the iron atom. The molecular structure of Fe(2)(OMe) was optimized by DFT calculations which were also employed to achieve a better understanding of the mechanistic details of the carbene transfer reaction.

Protonated hexaphyrin-cyclodextrin hybrids: molecular recognition tuned by a kinetic-to-thermodynamic topological adaptation.

Protonation study of [26/28]hexaphyrin-capped cyclodextrins revealed a temperature controlled conformational transition of the cap. The hexaphyrin undergoes a rectangular-to-triangular shape-shifting which strongly modifies the shape of the confined environment featured by the hybrids, and ultimately affects the encapsulation of the counterions. It provides an attractive access to innovative allosteric host-guest systems.

Spontaneous Tl(I)-to-Tl(III) oxidation in dynamic heterobimetallic Hg(II)/Tl(I) porphyrin complexes.

Strapped heterobimetallic Hg(II)/Tl(I) porphyrin complexes, with both metal ions bridged by the N-core in a dynamic way, undergo spontaneous Tl(I)-to-Tl(III) oxidation leading to a mono-Tl(III) complex and a mixed valence Tl(I)/Tl(III) bimetallic complex. It provides a new opportunity to tune metal ion translocations in bimetallic porphyrin systems.

Hexaphyrin-Cyclodextrin Hybrids: A Nest for Switchable Aromaticity, Asymmetric Confinement, and Isomorphic Fluxionality.

Conformational control over the highly flexible π-conjugated system of expanded porphyrins is a key step toward the fundamental understanding of aromaticity and for the development of molecular electronics. We have synthesized unprecedented hexaphyrin-cyclodextrin (HCD) capped hybrids in which the hexaphyrin part is constrained in a planar rectangular conformation in either a 26 or a 28 π-electron oxidation state ([26]/[28]HCD). These structures display strong aromaticity and antiaromaticity, respectively, exhibit markedly different chiroptical properties, and are interconvertible upon the addition of DDQ or NaBH(OAc)3, thus affording a rare switchable aromatic-antiaromatic system with a free-base expanded porphyrin. Conformational analysis revealed discrimination of the two coordination sites of the hexaphyrin, one of which was coupled to a confined asymmetric environment, and fluxional behavior consisting of apparent rotation of the hexaphyrin cap through a shape-shifting mechanism.

Sunlight-driven formation and dissociation of a dynamic mixed-valence thallium(III)/thallium(I) porphyrin complex.

Inspired by a Newton's cradle device and interested in the development of redox-controllable bimetallic molecular switches, a mixed-valence thallium(III)/thallium(I) bis-strap porphyrin complex, with Tl(III) bound out of the plane of the N core and Tl(I) hung to a strap on the opposite side, was formed by the addition of TlOAc to the free base and exposure to indirect sunlight. In this process, oxygen photosensitization by the porphyrin allows the oxidation of Tl(I) to Tl(III). The bimetallic complex is dynamic as the metals exchange their positions symmetrically to the porphyrin plane with Tl(III) funneling through the macrocycle. Further exposure of the complex to direct sunlight leads to thallium dissociation and to total recovery of the free base. Hence, the porphyrin plays a key role at all stages of the cycle of the complex: It hosts two metal ions, and by absorbing light, it allows the formation and dissociation of Tl(III). These results constitute the basis for the further design of innovative light-driven bimetallic molecular devices.

A pentanuclear lead(II) complex based on a strapped porphyrin with three different coordination modes.

We have previously described Pb(II) and Bi(III) bimetallic complexes with overhanging carboxylic acid strapped porphyrins in which one metal ion is bound to the N-core ("out-of-plane", OOP), whereas the second one is bound to the strap ("hanging-atop", HAT). In such complexes, the hemidirected coordination sphere of a HAT Pb(II) cation provides sufficient space for an additional binding of a neutral ligand (e.g., DMSO). Interestingly, investigations of the HAT metal coordination mode in a single strap porphyrin show that a HAT Pb(II) can also interact via intermolecular coordination bonds, allowing the self-assembly of two bimetallic complexes. In the pentanuclear Pb(II) complex we are describing in this Article, three different coordination modes were found. The OOP Pb(II) remains inert toward the supramolecular assembling process, whereas the HAT Pb(II) cation, in addition to its intramolecular carboxylate and regular exogenous acetate groups, coordinates an additional exogenous acetate. These two acetates are shared with a third lead(II) cation featuring a holo-directed coordination sphere, from which a centro-symmetric complex is assembled. Density functional theory calculations show some electron-density pockets in the vicinity of the hemidirected HAT Pb(II) atoms, which are associated with the presence of a stereochemically active lone pair of electrons. On the basis of the comparison with other HAT Pb(II) and Bi(III) systems, the "volume" of this lone pair correlates well with the bond distance distributions and the number of the proximal oxygen atoms tethered to the post-transition metal cation. It thus follows the order 6-coordinate Bi(III) > 6-coordinate Pb(II) > 5-coordinate Pb(II).

Heterobimetallic porphyrin complexes displaying triple dynamics: coupled metal motions controlled by constitutional evolution.

A bis-strap porphyrin ligand (1), with an overhanging carboxylic acid group on each side of the macrocycle, has been investigated toward the formation of dynamic libraries of bimetallic complexes with Hg(II), Cd(II), and Pb(II). Highly heteroselective metalation processes occurred in the presence of Pb(II), with Hg(II) or Cd(II) bound out-of-plane to the N-core and "PbOAc" bound to a carboxylate group of a strap on the opposite side. The resulting complexes, 1(Hg)·PbOAc and 1(Cd)·PbOAc, display three levels of dynamics. The first is strap-level (interactional dynamics), where the PbOAc moiety swings between the left and right side of the strap owing to a second sphere of coordination with lateral amide functions. The second is ligand-level (motional dynamics), where 1(Hg)·PbOAc and 1(Cd)·PbOAc exist as two degenerate states in equilibrium controlled by a chemical effector (AcO(-)). The process corresponds to a double translocation of the metal ions according to an intramolecular migration of Hg(II) or Cd(II) through the N-core, oscillating between the two equivalent overhanging carbonyl groups, coupled to an intermolecular pathway for PbOAc exchanging between the two equivalent overhanging carboxylate groups (N-core(up) ⇆ N-core(down) coupled to strap(down) ⇆ strap(up), i.e., coupled motion #1 in the abstract graphic). The third is library-level (constitutional dynamics), where a dynamic constitutional evolution of the system was achieved by the successive addition of two chemical effectors (DMAP and then AcO(-)). It allowed shifting equilibrium forward and backward between 1(Hg)·PbOAc and the corresponding homobimetallic complexes 1(Hg2)·DMAP and 1(Pb)·PbOAc. The latter displays a different ligand-level dynamics, in the form of an intraligand coupled migration of the Pb(II) ions (N-core(up) ⇆ strap(up) coupled to strap(down) ⇆ N-core(down), i.e., coupled motion #2 in the abstract graphic). In addition, the neutral "bridged" complexes 1HgPb and 1CdPb, with the metal ions on opposite sides both bound to the N-core and to a carboxylate of a strap, were structurally characterized. These results establish an unprecedented approach in supramolecular coordination chemistry, by considering the reversible interaction of a metal ion with the porphyrin N-core as a new source of self-organization processes. This work should provide new inspirations for the design of innovative adaptative materials and devices.

Highly diastereoselective cyclopropanation of α-methylstyrene catalysed by a C2-symmetrical chiral iron porphyrin complex.

A new chiral iron porphyrin-based catalyst performed α-methylstyrene stereoselective cyclopropanation with excellent yields (up to 99%), enantio- and diastereoselectivities (ee(trans) up to 87%, trans/cis ratios up to 99 : 1) and outstanding TON and TOF values (up to 20,000 and 120,000 h(-1) respectively).

Formation and dynamic behavior of mono- and bimetallic cadmium(II) porphyrin complexes: allosteric control of coupled intraligand metal migrations.

The complexation behavior of a bis-strapped porphyrin ligand (1) towards Cd(II) has been investigated by (1)H and (113)Cd NMR spectroscopy with the help of X-ray diffraction structures. The presence of an overhanging carboxylic acid group on each side of the macrocycle is responsible for the instantaneous insertion of the metal ion(s) at room temperature, and allows the formation of bimetallic species with unusual coordination modes at the origin of unique dynamic behaviors. In the absence of base, a C2-symmetric bimetallic complex (1Cd2 ) is readily formed, in which the porphyrin acts as a bridging ligand. Both Cd(II) ions are bound to the N core and to a COO(-) group of a strap. In contrast, the presence of a base induces a two-step binding process with the successive formation of mono and bimetallic species (1(Cd) and 1(Cd)·CdOAc). Formally, a Cd(II) ion is first inserted into the N core and experiences a strong out-of-plane (OOP) displacement due to the binding of an overhanging carbonyl group in an apical position. A second Cd(II) ion then binds exclusively to the strap on the opposite side, in a so-called hanging-atop (HAT) coordination mode. These two complexes display a fluxional behavior that relies on intraligand migration processes of the metal ion(s). In 1(Cd), the Cd(II) ion exchanges between the two equivalent overhanging apical ligands by funneling through the porphyrin ring. In 1(Cd)·CdOAc, the two Cd(II) ions exchange their coordination mode (HAT↔OOP) in a concerted way while staying on their respective side of the macrocycle, in a so-called Newton's cradle-like motion. The intramolecular pathway was notably evidenced by variable temperature (113) Cd heteronuclear NMR experiments. This coupled motion of the Cd(II) cations is under allosteric control; the addition of an acetate anion (the allosteric effector) to the "resting" C2-symmetric complex 1Cd2 affords the dissymmetric complex 1(Cd)·CdOAc and triggers equilibrium between its two degenerate states. The rate of the swinging motion further depends on the concentration of AcO(-), with a higher concentration leading to a slower motion. As compared with the related Pb(II) and Bi(III) bimetallic complexes, the Newton's cradle-like motion proceeds faster with the smaller Cd(II) ion. These results open the way to novel multistable devices and switches.

Acid-base-controlled stereoselective metalation of overhanging carboxylic acid porphyrins: consequences for the formation of heterobimetallic complexes.

Overhanging carboxylic acid porphyrins have revealed promising ditopic ligands offering a new entry in the field of supramolecular coordination chemistry of porphyrinoids. Notably, the adjunction of a so-called hanging-atop (HAT) Pb(II) cation to regular Pb(II) porphyrin complexes allowed a stereoselective incorporation of the N-core bound cation, and an allosterically controlled Newton's cradle-like motion of the two Pb(II) ions also emerged from such bimetallic complexes. In this contribution, we have extended this work to other ligands and metal ions, aiming at understanding the parameters that control the HAT Pb(II) coordination. The nature of the N-core bound metal ion (Zn(II), Cd(II)), the influence of the deprotonation state of the overhanging COOH group and the presence of a neutral ligand on the opposite side (exogenous or intramolecular), have been examined through (1)H NMR spectroscopic experiments with the help of radiocrystallographic structures and DFT calculations. Single and bis-strap ligands have been considered. They all incorporate a COOH group hung over the N-core on one side. For the bis-strap ligands, either an ester or an amide group has been introduced on the other side. In the presence of a base, the mononuclear Zn(II) or Cd(II) complexes incorporate the carbonyl of the overhanging carboxylate as apical ligand, decreasing its availability for the binding of a HAT Pb(II). An allosteric effector (e.g., 4-dimethylaminopyridine (DMAP), in the case of a single-strap ligand) or an intramolecular ligand (e.g., an amide group), strong enough to compete with the carbonyl of the hung COO(-), is required to switch the N-core bound cation to the opposite side with concomitant release of the COO(-), thereby allowing HAT Pb(II) complexation. In the absence of a base, Zn(II) or Cd(II) binds preferentially the carbonyl of the intramolecular ester or amide groups in apical position rather than that of the COOH. This better preorganization, with the overhanging COOH fully available, is responsible for a stronger binding of the HAT Pb(II). Thus, either allosteric or acid-base control is achieved through stereoselective metalation of Zn(II) or Cd(II). In the latter case, according to the deprotonation state of the COOH group, the best electron-donating ligand is located on one or the other side of the porphyrin (COO(-)>CONHR>COOR>COOH): the lower affinity of COOH for Zn(II) and Cd(II), the higher for a HAT Pb(II). These insights provide new opportunities for the elaboration of innovative bimetallic molecular switches.