How Surfaces Affect Hybridization Kinetics.

Hybridization between nucleic acid strands immobilized on a solid support with partners in solution is widely practiced in bioanalytical technologies and materials science. An important fundamental aspect of understanding these reactions is the role played by immobilization in the dynamics of duplex formation and disassembly. This report reviews and analyzes literature kinetic data to identify commonly observed trends and to correlate them with probable molecular mechanisms. The analysis reveals that while under certain conditions impacts from immobilization are minimal so that surface and solution hybridization kinetics are comparable, it is more typical to observe pronounced offsets between the two scenarios. In the forward (hybridization) direction, rates at the surface commonly decrease by one to two decades relative to solution, while in the reverse direction rates of strand separation at the surface can exceed those in solution by tens of decades. By recasting the deviations in terms of activation barriers, a consensus of how immobilization impacts nucleation, zipping, and strand separation can be conceived within the classical mechanism in which duplex formation is rate limited by preassembly of a nucleus a few base pairs in length, while dehybridization requires the cumulative breakup of base pairs along the length of a duplex. Evidence is considered for how excess interactions encountered on solid supports impact these processes.

Size-Controllable Gold Nanopores with High SERS Activity.

Nanopore structures have been successfully employed in next-generation DNA sequencing. For more complicated protein which normally contains 20 different amino acids, identifying the fluctuation of ionic current caused by different amino acids appears inadequate for protein sequencing. Therefore, it is highly desirable to develop size-controllable nanopores with optical activity that can provide additional structural information. Herein, we discovered the novel nanopore properties of the self-assembled ultramicroelectrodes originally developed by Bard and co-workers. Using a slightly modified method, the self-assembly of 7 ± 1 nm gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) can be precisely controlled to form a gold nanoporous sphere (GPS) on the tip of a glass capillary. Different dithiol linker molecules (1,3-propanedithiol, C3; 1,6-hexanedithiol, C6; and 1,9-nonanedithiol, C9) reproducibly led to rather similar nanopore sizes (5.07 ± 0.02, 5.13 ± 0.02, and 5.25 ± 0.01 nm), respectively. The GPS nanostructures were found to exhibit high ionic current rectification as well as surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) activity due to the presence of nanopores and numerous "hot spots" among the cross-linked AuNPs on the surface of GPS. The rectification effect of the small nanopores was observed even under high concentration of electrolyte (290 mM), along with SERS enhancement factors well above 1 × 105. The GPS nanostructures were successfully applied for SERS-based detection of glutathione from a single HeLa cell.

Electrostatic Cycling of Hybridization Using Nonionic DNA Mimics.

This study demonstrates efficient electrostatic control of surface hybridization through use of morpholinos, a charge-neutral DNA mimic, as the immobilized "probes". In addition to being compatible with low ionic strengths, use of uncharged probes renders the field interaction specific to the nucleic acid analyte. In contrast to DNA probes, morpholino probes enable facile cycling between hybridized and dehybridized states within minutes. Impact of ionic strength and temperature on the effectiveness of electrostatics to direct progress of hybridization is evaluated. Optimal electrostatic control is found when stability of probe-analyte duplexes is set so that electrostatics can efficiently switch between the forward (hybridization) and reverse (dehybridization) directions.

Diagnostic Applications of Morpholinos and Label-Free Electrochemical Detection of Nucleic Acids.

Diagnostic applications of morpholinos take advantage of their unique properties including backbone charge neutrality, a weak impact of ionic strength on their hybridization behavior, and their resistance to enzymatic degradation. This chapter overviews how these properties have advanced transduction and other capabilities useful for the analysis of nucleic acids. In many cases, the benefits stem from electrostatic mechanisms; for example, use of low ionic strengths improves sensitivity of detection while decreasing background signals because only the nucleic acid analyte is charged. While most literature reports focus on in vitro assays in buffer, morpholinos have been also used for biodistribution measurements of species such as fungal rRNA and miRNA. After reviewing the diagnostic applications of morpholinos, the chapter describes preparation of morpholino monolayers on metal supports for electrochemical diagnostics and the procedure for performing label-free detection of DNA from changes in surface capacitance.

Effects of Chain-Chain Associations on Hybridization in DNA Brushes.

Hybridization of solution nucleic acids to DNA brushes is widely encountered in diagnostic and materials science applications. Typically, brush chain lengths of ten or more nucleotides are used to provide the needed sequence specificity and binding affinity. At these lengths, coincidental occurrence of complementary regions is expected to lead to associations between the nominally single-stranded brush chains due to intra- or interchain base pairing. This report investigates how these associations impact the brushes' hybridization activity toward complementary "target" sequences. Brushes were prepared from 20-mer chains with four-nucleotide-long "adhesive regions" through which neighboring chains could interact. The affinity and position of the adhesive region along the chain backbone were varied. DNA brushes were exposed to complementary solution targets, and the corresponding melting transitions were measured to estimate free energies of the brush-target hybridization. These results revealed that higher affinity adhesive regions more extensively suppressed brush hybridization relative to hybridization in solution. Associations near the middle of the chains were found to be more penalizing than those at the immobilized or the free end of the chains. Provided that the brush chains were close enough to associate, changes in brush density did not exert a significant effect on hybridization thermodynamics within the investigated coverage window. Comparison of the DNA brush results with those from commercial Affymetrix single-nucleotide-polymorphism (SNP) microarrays revealed agreement in the impact of chain associations on hybridization.

Integration of Multiplexed Microfluidic Electrokinetic Concentrators with a Morpholino Microarray via Reversible Surface Bonding for Enhanced DNA Hybridization.

We describe a microfluidic concentration device to accelerate the surface hybridization reaction between DNA and morpholinos (MOs) for enhanced detection. The microfluidic concentrator comprises a single polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) microchannel onto which an ion-selective layer of conductive polymer poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene)-poly(styrenesulfonate) ( PEDOT: PSS) was directly printed and then reversibly surface bonded onto a morpholino microarray for hybridization. Using this electrokinetic trapping concentrator, we could achieve a maximum concentration factor of ∼800 for DNA and a limit of detection of 10 nM within 15 min. In terms of the detection speed, it enabled faster hybridization by around 10-fold when compared to conventional diffusion-based hybridization. A significant advantage of our approach is that the fabrication of the microfluidic concentrator is completely decoupled from the microarray; by eliminating the need to deposit an ion-selective layer on the microarray surface prior to device integration, interfacing between both modules, the PDMS chip for electrokinetic concentration and the substrate for DNA sensing are easier and applicable to any microarray platform. Furthermore, this fabrication strategy facilitates a multiplexing of concentrators. We have demonstrated the proof-of-concept for multiplexing by building a device with 5 parallel concentrators connected to a single inlet/outlet and applying it to parallel concentration and hybridization. Such device yielded similar concentration and hybridization efficiency compared to that of a single-channel device without adding any complexity to the fabrication and setup. These results demonstrate that our concentrator concept can be applied to the development of a highly multiplexed concentrator-enhanced microarray detection system for either genetic analysis or other diagnostic assays.

Surface vs. solution hybridization: effects of salt, temperature, and probe type.

Hybridization thermodynamics on solid supports are compared with those in solution for two types of hybridization probe, DNA and uncharged morpholino oligonucleotides of identical sequences. Trends in hybridization affinity are discussed with respect to ionic strength, temperature, and surface behavior.

Enhancing the speed of morpholino-DNA biosensor by electrokinetic concentration of DNA in a microfluidic chip.

Electrokinetic methods that conveniently concentrate charged analytes by orders of magnitude are highly attractive for nucleic acid assays where they can bypass the complexity and costs of enzyme-based amplification. The present study demonstrates an electrokinetic concentration device incorporating charge-neutral morpholino (MO) probes: as DNA analyte is concentrated in a microfluidic channel using ion concentration polarization (ICP) it is simultaneously hybridized to spots of complementary MO probes immobilized on the channel floor. This approach is uniquely favored by the match between the optimum buffer ionic strength of approximately 10mM for both MO-DNA surface hybridization and electrokinetic concentration. The simple and easily scalable poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) microfluidic device was fabricated using soft lithography and contact printing of a conductive polymer, poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene)-polystyrene sulfonate ( PEDOT: PSS) as a cation-selective membrane material. Using the microfluidic concentrator, we could increase the concentration of DNA by three orders of magnitude in less than 5 min at an electric field of 75 Vcm(-1). The 1000-fold increase in concentration of DNA led to an increase in the speed of MO-DNA hybridization by two orders of magnitude and enabled a detection sensitivity of ~1 nM within 15 min of concentration. Using the proposed microfluidic concentrator, we also demonstrated a rapid hybridization with a binary DNA mixture, containing a fully complementary and a non-complementary sequence to mimic molecular backgrounds present in real DNA samples.

Multimodal electrochemical sensing of transcription factor-operator complexes.

Interactions of proteins with nucleic acids arise at all levels of cellular function, from chromosomal packing to biological regulation. These interactions can be analyzed in a high-throughput fashion by immobilizing the DNA sequences of interest, possibly numbering in the thousands, at discrete locations on a solid support and identifying those sequences that a protein analyte binds. Ideally, such surface assays would use unlabeled analyte to simplify protocols and avoid the possibility of perturbing the protein/DNA interaction. The present study compares three electrochemical modalities for simultaneously detecting binding of unlabeled transcription factor proteins to immobilized DNA duplexes based on (i) changes in the duplex diffusive motions, (ii) variations in the surface potential, and (iii) variations in the interfacial charging impedance, all of which can be conveniently derived from AC voltammetry traces. Cro protein from bacteriophage lambda is used as a model transcription factor. Specific binding of protein was successfully detected through modalities (i) and (ii), but not (iii). The effectiveness of these techniques is compared as a function of sampling frequency and protein concentration. Binding of 15 kDa Cro slowed down rotational diffusion of immobilized duplexes approximately 3-fold, and induced up to 5 mV changes in the surface potential. Moreover, by assessing Cro binding to bacteriophage operators of variable affinity, the study illustrates how contrast between specific and nonspecific interactions impacts detection.

Electrochemical measurements of DNA melting on surfaces.

Thermal denaturation, or melting, measurements are a classic technique for analysis of thermodynamics of nucleic base driven associations in solution, as well as of interactions between nucleic acids and small molecule ligands such as drugs or carcinogens. Performed on surface-immobilized DNA films, this well-established technique can help understand how energetics of surface hybridization relate to those in solution, as well as provide high-throughput platforms for screening of small molecule ligands. Here we describe methods for measuring DNA melting transitions at solid/liquid interfaces with focus on the role of immobilization chemistry, including a common "immobilization-through-self-assembly" approach that is effective at moderate temperatures, and a thermo-stable approach based on polymer-supported DNA monolayers that can be used at elevated temperatures. We also discuss conditions necessary for reversible measurements, as signified by superimposition of the association (cooling) and dissociation (heating) transitions of immobilized DNA strands.

Physico-chemical foundations underpinning microarray and next-generation sequencing experiments.

Hybridization of nucleic acids on solid surfaces is a key process involved in high-throughput technologies such as microarrays and, in some cases, next-generation sequencing (NGS). A physical understanding of the hybridization process helps to determine the accuracy of these technologies. The goal of a widespread research program is to develop reliable transformations between the raw signals reported by the technologies and individual molecular concentrations from an ensemble of nucleic acids. This research has inputs from many areas, from bioinformatics and biostatistics, to theoretical and experimental biochemistry and biophysics, to computer simulations. A group of leading researchers met in Ploen Germany in 2011 to discuss present knowledge and limitations of our physico-chemical understanding of high-throughput nucleic acid technologies. This meeting inspired us to write this summary, which provides an overview of the state-of-the-art approaches based on physico-chemical foundation to modeling of the nucleic acids hybridization process on solid surfaces. In addition, practical application of current knowledge is emphasized.

Label-free DNA microarray bioassays using a near-field scanning microwave microscope.

A near-field scanning microwave microscope (NSMM) is used to readout and visualize homemade 10-mer oligonucleotide microarrays and an Agilent 60-mer DNA microarray as a realistic test of NSMM applicability to multiplexed sequence analysis. Sensitive characterization of DNA coverage and high resolution mapping of DNA spots in the microarray were realized by measuring the change of microwave reflection coefficient (S11) at about 4 GHz operating frequency. Hybridization between target (free) and capture (immobilized) sequences leads to changes in the microwave reflection coefficient, which were measured by the NSMM. These changes are caused by hybridization-induced modification of the dielectric permittivity profile of the DNA film. The dynamic range based on analysis of the 10-mer microarrays is over 3 orders of magnitude with the detection limit estimated below 0.01 strands/µm². The NSMM method should be readily capable of detecting target coverages down to 98% of probe coverage. We also directly image the patterned DNA microarray by NSMM with a 2 µm resolution. The complementary optical image of the DNA microarray visualized by using a relative fluorescent intensity metric agrees well with the NSMM results.

Charge-neutral morpholino microarrays for nucleic acid analysis.

A principal challenge in microarray experiments is to facilitate hybridization between probe strands on the array with complementary target strands from solution while suppressing any competing interactions that the probes and targets may experience. Synthetic DNA analogs, whose hybridization to targets can exhibit qualitatively different dependence on experimental conditions than for nucleic acid probes, open up an attractive alternative for improving selectivity of array hybridization. Morpholinos (MOs), a class of uncharged DNA analogs, are investigated as microarray probes instead of DNA. MO microarrays were fabricated by contact printing of amino-modified probes onto aldehyde slides. In addition to covalent immobilization, MOs were found to efficiently immobilize through physical adsorption; such physically adsorbed probes could be removed by post-printing washes with surfactant solutions. Hybridization of double-stranded DNA targets to MO microarrays revealed a hybridization maximum at intermediate ionic strengths. The decline in hybridization at lower ionic strengths was attributed to an electrostatic barrier accumulated from hybridized DNA targets, whereas at higher ionic strengths it was attributed to stabilization of target secondary structure in solution. These trends, which illustrate ionic strength tuning of forming on-array relative to solution secondary structure, were supported by a stability analysis of MO/DNA and DNA/DNA duplexes in solution.

Melting thermodynamics of reversible DNA/ligand complexes at interfaces.

A variety of solution methods exist for analysis of interactions between small molecule ligands and nucleic acids; however, accomplishing this task economically at the scale of hundreds to thousands of sequences remains challenging. Surface assays offer a prospective solution through array-based multiplexing, capable of mapping out the full sequence context of a DNA/ligand interaction in a single experiment. However, relative to solution assays, accurate quantification of DNA/ligand interactions in a surface format must contend with limited understanding of molecular activities and interactions at a solid-liquid interface. We report a surface adaptation of a solution method in which shifts in duplex stability, induced by ligand binding and quantified from melting transitions, are used for thermodynamic analysis of DNA/ligand interactions. The results are benchmarked against solution calorimetric data. Equilibrium operation is confirmed through superposition of denaturation/hybridization transitions triggered by heating and cooling. The antibiotic compound netropsin, which undergoes electrostatic and sequence-specific minor groove interactions with DNA, is used as a prototypical small molecule. DNA/netropsin interactions are investigated as a function of ionic strength and drug concentration through electrochemical tracing of surface melt transitions. Comparison with solution values finds excellent agreement in free energy, though reliable separation into enthalpic and entropic contributions proves more difficult. The results establish key guidelines for analysis of DNA-ligand interactions via reversible melting denaturation at surfaces.

Thermostable DNA immobilization and temperature effects on surface hybridization.

Monolayer films of nucleic acids on solid supports are encountered in a range of diagnostic and bioanalytical applications. These applications often rely on elevated temperatures to improve performance; moreover, studies at elevated temperatures can provide fundamental information on layer organization and functionality. To support such applications, this study compares thermostability of oligonucleotide monolayers immobilized to gold by first coating the gold with a nanometer-thick film (an "anchor layer") of a polymercaptosiloxane, to which DNA oligonucleotides are subsequently tethered through maleimide-thiol conjugation, with thermostability of monolayers formed via widely used attachment through a terminal thiol moiety on the DNA. The temperature range covered is from 25 to 90 °C. After confirming stability of immobilization and, more importantly, retention of hybridization activity even under the harshest conditions investigated, these thermostable films are used to demonstrate measurements of (1) reversible surface melting transitions and (2) temperature dependence of competitive hybridization, when fully matched and mismatched sequences compete for binding to immobilized DNA oligonucleotides. The competitive hybridization experiments reveal a pronounced impact of temperature on rates of approach to equilibrium, with kinetic freezing into nonequilibrium states close to room temperature and rapid approach to equilibrium at elevated temperatures. Modeling of competitive surface hybridization equilibria using thermodynamic parameters derived from surface melting transitions of the individual sequences is also discussed.

Kinetic mechanisms in morpholino-DNA surface hybridization.

Morpholinos (MOs) are DNA analogues whose uncharged nature can bring fundamental advantages to surface hybridization technologies such as DNA microarrays, by using MOs as the immobilized, or "probe", species. Advancement of MO-based diagnostics, however, is challenged by limited understanding of the surface organization of MO molecules and of how this organization impacts hybridization kinetics and thermodynamics. The present study focuses on hybridization kinetics between monolayers of MO probes and DNA targets as a function of the instantaneous extent of hybridization (i.e., duplex coverage), total probe coverage, and ionic strength. Intriguingly, these experiments reveal distinct kinetic stages, none of which are consistent with Langmuir kinetics. The initial stage, in which duplex coverage remains relatively sparse, indicates confluence of two effects: blockage of target access to unhybridized probes by previously formed duplexes and deactivation of the solid support due to consumption of probe molecules. This interpretation is consistent with a surface organization in which unhybridized MO probes localize near the solid support, underneath a layer of MO-DNA duplexes. As duplex coverage builds, provided saturation is not reached first, the initial stage can transition to an unusual regime characterized by near independence of hybridization rate on duplex coverage, followed by a prolonged approach to equilibrium. The possible origins of these more complex latter behaviors are discussed. Comparison with published data for DNA and peptide nucleic acid (PNA) probes is carried out to look for universal trends in kinetics. This comparison reveals qualitative similarities when comparable surface organization of probes is expected. In addition, MO monolayers are found capable of a broad range of reactivities that span reported values for PNA and DNA probes.

Gene expression analysis with an integrated CMOS microarray by time-resolved fluorescence detection.

DNA microarrays have proven extraordinarily powerful for differential expression studies across thousands of genes in a single experiment. Microarrays also have the potential for clinical applications, including the detection of infectious and immunological diseases and cancer, if they can be rendered both reliable and cost-effective. Here we report the first practical application of an active microarray based on integrated circuit technology, completely obviating the need for external measurement instrumentation while employing protocols compatible with traditional fluorescence-based surface bioassays. In a gene expression biodosimetry study, we determine the differential activity of genes from leucocytes in irradiated human blood. Quantum dots are used as fluorescence labels to realize filterless, time-gated fluorescence detection on an active complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor (CMOS) microarray with 100-pM sensitivity. Improvements in surface chemistry should allow sensitivities that approach the microarray hardware limit of less than 10 pM. Techniques for covalent attachment of DNA capture strands to the CMOS active microarrays allow integrated sensors to be placed in immediate proximity to hybridized analyte strands, maximizing photon collection efficiencies.

Capacitive monitoring of morpholino-DNA surface hybridization: experimental and theoretical analysis.

Impedance and cyclic voltammetry methods, complemented by Poisson-Boltzmann (PB) modeling, are used to study hybridization of DNA analyte strands to monolayers of morpholino oligomers (MOs) immobilized by one end to mercaptopropanol-passivated gold electrodes. MOs, like peptide nucleic acids (PNAs), are uncharged molecules that recognize nucleic acids following conventional base-pairing rules. The capacitive response to hybridization, determined from real-time impedance measurements, is analyzed with emphasis on understanding the underlying structural changes and on providing a foundation for label-free diagnostics. The capacitive response is correlated with the instantaneous surface molecular populations by labeling DNA and MO strands with ferrocene tags and using cyclic voltammetry to monitor their respective coverages in real-time. This approach allows analysis of hybridization-induced changes in interfacial capacitance as a function of duplex coverage, the DC bias used for readout, buffer molarity, and probe coverage. The results indicate that unhybridized MO layers exist in a compact state on the solid support. For hybridized layers, the intrinsic signal per hybridization event is strongly enhanced at low ionic strengths but, interestingly, does not depend on the readout bias in the sampled range negative of the capacitive minimum. A PB model incorporating an effective medium description of the hybridizing films is used to establish how hybridization-derived changes in dielectric composition and charge distribution at the surface translate into experimentally observed variations in interfacial capacitance.

A comparison of five bioconjugatable ferrocenes for labeling of biomolecules.

Five electroactive ferrocene tags for labelling of biomolecules are contrasted with regard to conjugation reactivity with amine and thiol moieties, stability to loss of electrochemical activity, and impact of molecular structure on the redox potential of the free and DNA-conjugated forms.

Molecular mechanisms in morpholino-DNA surface hybridization.

Synthetic nucleic acid mimics provide opportunity for redesigning the specificity and affinity of hybridization with natural DNA or RNA. Such redesign is of great interest for diagnostic applications where it can enhance the desired signal against a background of competing interactions. This report compares hybridization of DNA analyte strands with morpholinos (MOs), which are uncharged nucleic acid mimics, to the corresponding DNA-DNA case in solution and on surfaces. In solution, MO-DNA hybridization is found to be independent of counterion concentration, in contrast to DNA-DNA hybridization. On surfaces, when immobilized MO or DNA "probe" strands hybridize with complementary DNA "targets" from solution, both the MO-DNA and DNA-DNA processes depend on ionic strength but exhibit qualitatively different behaviors. At lower ionic strengths, MO-DNA surface hybridization exhibits hallmarks of kinetic limitations when separation between hybridized probe sites becomes comparable to target dimensions, whereas extents of DNA-DNA surface hybridization are instead consistent with limits imposed by buildup of surface (Donnan) potential. The two processes also fundamentally differ at high ionic strength, under conditions when electrostatic effects are weak. Here, variations in probe coverage have a much diminished impact on MO-DNA than on DNA-DNA hybridization for similarly crowded surface conditions. These various observations agree with a structural model of MO monolayers in which MO-DNA duplexes segregate to the buffer interface while unhybridized probes localize near the solid support. A general perspective is presented on using uncharged DNA analogues, which also include compounds such as peptide nucleic acids (PNA), in surface hybridization applications.