Using Maslow's hierarchy to highlight power imbalances between visiting health professional student volunteers and the host community: An applied qualitative study.

BACKGROUND: Health professional students from high-income countries increasingly participate in short-term experiences in global health (STEGH) conducted abroad. One common criticism of STEGH is the inherent power differential that exists between visiting learners and the local community. To highlight this power differential, this paper explores perceived benefits as described by volunteer and community respondents and applies Maslow's hierarchy of needs to commonly identified themes in each respondent group. METHODS: A semistructured survey was used to collect qualitative responses from both volunteers and community members located in a Dominican Republic community, that is, a hotspot for traditionally conducted STEGH. Thematic analysis identified themes of perceived benefits from both respondent groups; each group's common themes were then classified and compared within Maslow's hierarchy of needs. RESULTS: Each respondent group identified resource provision as a perceived benefit of STEGH, but volunteer respondents primarily focused on the provision of highly-skilled, complex resources while community respondents focused on basic necessities (food, water, etc.) Volunteer respondents were also the only group to also mention spiritual/religious/life experiences, personal skills development, and relationships as perceived benefits. Applying Maslow's hierarchy thus demonstrates a difference in needs: community respondents focused on benefits that address deficiency needs at the bottom of the hierarchy while volunteers focused on benefits addressing self-transcendence/actualization needs at the top of the hierarchy. CONCLUSIONS: The perceived difference in needs met by STEGH between volunteers and the host community within Maslow's hierarchy may drive an inherent power differential. Refocusing STEGH on the relationship level of the hierarchy (i.e., focusing on partnerships) might help mitigate this imbalance and empower host communities.

Health and Social Needs in Three Migrant Worker Communities around La Romana, Dominican Republic, and the Role of Volunteers: A Thematic Analysis and Evaluation.

Objective. For decades, Haitian migrant workers living in bateyes around La Romana, Dominican Republic, have been the focus of short-term volunteer medical groups from North America. To assist these efforts, this study aimed to characterize various health and social needs that could be addressed by volunteer groups. Design. Needs were assessed using semistructured interviews of community and professional informants, using a questionnaire based on a social determinants of health framework, and responses were qualitatively analysed for common themes. Results. Key themes in community responses included significant access limitations to basic necessities and healthcare, including limited access to regular electricity and potable water, lack of health insurance, high out-of-pocket costs, and discrimination. Healthcare providers identified the expansion of a community health promoter program and mobile medical teams as potential solutions. English and French language training, health promotion, and medical skills development were identified as additional strategies by which teams could support community development. Conclusion. Visiting volunteer groups could work in partnership with community organizations to address these barriers by providing short-term access to services, while developing local capacity in education, healthcare, and health promotion in the long-term. Future work should also carefully evaluate the impacts and contributions of such volunteer efforts.

Coalicion de Salud Comunitaria (COSACO): using a Healthy Community Partnership framework to integrate short-term global health experiences into broader community development.

BACKGROUND: There is growing concern that short-term experiences in global health experiences (STEGH), undertaken by healthcare providers, trainees, and volunteers from high income countries in lower and middle income countries, risk harming the community by creating a parallel system of care separate from established community development efforts. At the same time, the inclusion of non-traditional actors in health planning has been the basis of the development of many Healthy Community Partnerships (HCP) being rolled out in Canada and the United States. These partnerships aim to bring all stakeholders with a role to play in health to the table to align efforts, goals and programs towards broad community health goals. RESULTS: This methodology paper reports on the process used in La Romana, Dominican Republic, in applying a modified HCP framework. This project succeeded at bringing visiting STEGH organizations into a coalition with key community partners and supported attempts to embed the work of STEGH within longer-term, established development plans. CONCLUSIONS: In presenting the work and process and lessons learned, the hope is that other communities that encounter significant investment from STEGH groups, and will gain the same benefits that were seen in La Romana with regards to improved information exchange, increased cross-communication between silos, and the integration of STEGH into the work of community partners.

Short-term global health education programs abroad: disease patterns observed in Haitian migrant worker communities around La Romana, Dominican Republic.

The possibility of encountering rare tropical disease presentations is commonly described as a benefit derived by developed world medical trainees participating in clinical service-oriented short-term global health experiences in the developing world. This study describes the health status of a population served by a short-term experience conducted by a North American institute, and the results of a retrospective review are used to identify commonly encountered diseases and discuss their potential educational value. Descriptive analysis was conducted on 1,024 encounter records collected over four unique 1-week-long trips by a North American institution serving Haitian migrant workers in La Romana, Dominican Republic. The top five diagnoses seen in the clinic were gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD), hypertension (HTN), upper respiratory infections, otitis media, and fungal skin infection. On occasion, diagnoses unique to an indigent tropical population were encountered (e.g., dehydration, malnutrition, parasites, and infections.). These findings suggest a similarity between frequently encountered diagnoses on a short-term clinical service trip in Dominican Republic and primary care presentations in developed world settings, which challenges the assumption that short-term service experiences provide exposure to rare tropical disease presentations. These findings also represent additional data that can be used to better understand the health and healthcare planning among this vulnerable population of Haitian migrant workers.

Private sector contributions and their effect on physician emigration in the developing world.

The contribution made by the private sector to health care in a low- or middle-income country may affect levels of physician emigration from that country. The increasing importance of the private sector in health care in the developing world has resulted in newfound academic interest in that sector's influences on many aspects of national health systems. The growth in physician emigration from the developing world has led to several attempts to identify both the factors that cause physicians to emigrate and the effects of physician emigration on primary care and population health in the countries that the physicians leave. When the relevant data on the emerging economies of Ghana, India and Peru were investigated, it appeared that the proportion of physicians participating in private health-care delivery, the percentage of health-care costs financed publicly and the amount of private health-care financing per capita were each inversely related to the level of physician expatriation. It therefore appears that private health-care delivery and financing may decrease physician emigration. There is clearly a need for similar research in other low- and middle-income countries, and for studies to see if, at the country level, temporal trends in the contribution made to health care by the private sector can be related to the corresponding trends in physician emigration. The ways in which private health care may be associated with access problems for the poor and therefore reduced equity also merit further investigation. The results should be of interest to policy-makers who aim to improve health systems worldwide.

La contribution apportée par le secteur privé aux soins de santé dans les pays à revenu faible ou intermédiaire peut modifier les taux d'émigration des médecins de ces pays. L'importance croissante du secteur privé dans les soins de santé dans les pays en voie de développement a suscité un regain d'intérêt académique dans les influences de ce secteur sur de nombreux aspects des systèmes de santé nationaux. La croissance de l'émigration des médecins des pays en voie de développement a conduit à plusieurs tentatives d'identifier à la fois les facteurs qui incitent les médecins à émigrer et les effets de l'émigration des médecins sur les soins primaires et la santé de la population dans les pays qu'ils quittent. Lorsque les données pertinentes sur les économies émergentes du Ghana, de l'Inde et du Pérou ont été étudiées, il est apparu que la proportion de médecins qui participent à la prestation des soins privés, le pourcentage de dépenses de santé financées publiquement et le montant du financement des soins de santé privés par habitant ont été chacun inversement proportionnels au taux d'expatriation des médecins. Ainsi, la prestation et le financement de soins de santé privés peuvent réduire l'émigration des médecins. Il existe clairement un besoin de recherches similaires dans d'autres pays à revenus faible et intermédiaire, ainsi que d'études pour voir si, au niveau du pays, les tendances temporelles de la contribution aux soins de santé par le secteur privé peuvent être liées aux tendances correspondantes de l'émigration des médecins. Les façons dont les soins de santé privés peuvent être associés à des problèmes d'accès pour les pauvres et, par conséquent l'équité réduite, méritent également une enquête plus approfondie. Les résultats devraient intéresser les décideurs politiques qui visent à améliorer les systèmes de santé à travers le monde.

La aportación del sector privado a la atención sanitaria en un país de ingresos medios o bajos puede repercutir en los índices de emigración de médicos de dicho país. La importancia creciente del sector privado en la atención sanitaria en los países en desarrollo ha suscitado un nuevo interés entre los académicos respecto a las influencias de dicho sector sobre muchos aspectos de los sistemas sanitarios nacionales. El aumento de la emigración de médicos procedentes de países en desarrollo ha conducido a varios intentos de identificar, por un lado, los factores implicados en la emigración de médicos y, por otro lado, los efectos de la emigración de médicos sobre la atención primaria y la salud de la población de los países de donde parten los médicos. Tras investigar la información pertinente sobre las economías emergentes de Ghana, India y Perú, se halló una relación inversa entre el índice de médicos expatriados y cada uno de los siguientes factores: la proporción de médicos que prestan atención sanitaria dentro del sector sanitario privado, el porcentaje de los costes sanitarios financiados con fondos públicos y la cuantía de la financiación per cápita del sector sanitario privado. Por consiguiente, parece ser que la prestación de servicios sanitarios por parte del sector privado y la financiación pueden reducir la emigración de médicos. Resulta evidente la necesidad de realizar investigaciones similares en otros países de renta media y baja, así como estudios que esclarezcan si, a escala nacional, se pueden vincular las tendencias temporales de la contribución por parte del sector privado con las correspondientes tendencias de la emigración de médicos. Cómo la sanidad privada puede relacionarse con los problemas de acceso para los pobres y, por lo tanto, con la reducción de la equidad, merece asimismo mayor investigación. Los resultados podrían ser de interés para los responsables políticos que aspiren a mejorar los sistemas sanitarios a escala mundial.

Educator perceptions of the relationship between education innovations and improved health.

BACKGROUND: Education innovations by health professions faculty are shaped by faculty conceptualizations of the pathway between their innovations and changes in health of communities. AIMS: We aimed to explore how existing theories about the relationship between education and health are attended to, interpreted, and applied by faculty in different national contexts. METHODS: We compared existing theoretical frameworks to perceptions of "front line" faculty. Fellows in Brazil- and India-based FAIMER faculty development programs were asked via questionnaires about the contribution of their education innovation projects to health improvements. RESULTS: Faculty identified pathways to improved societal health via increased quality, and to a lesser extent relevance, of education. Relationships between increased quantity of education and improved health were focused on faculty development. Faculty from both countries noted the value for health outcomes of innovations that affect networks and partnerships with other institutions. Faculty from India identified pathways to improved societal health via changes to instructional more than institutional processes. CONCLUSIONS: Results indicate where there are gaps in existing theories, a need to raise awareness about potential pathways to improving health via education changes, and opportunities for more detailed understanding of mechanisms of change via in-depth research.