A validation study of data in the National Tonsil Surgery Register in Sweden: high agreement with medical records ensures that data can be used to monitor clinical practices and outcomes.

BACKGROUND: The ambition of the National Tonsil Surgery Register in Sweden (NTSRS) is to improve otorhinolaryngological care by monitoring trends in the clinical practices, complications, and outcomes of tonsil surgery. The NTSRS collects data from both surgeons and patients and provides the participating clinics with daily updated data on a publicly available website. On the website, national and local results can be compared and monitored. The use of NTSRS data necessitates that the data is valid, but the NTSRS has not yet been validated. With approximately half of the registered patients responding to the postoperative questionnaires, an analysis of responders and non-responders is also necessary. The aim of this study was to assess the criterion validity of NTSRS data. Another aim was to compare the characteristics and rates of complications between postoperative questionnaire responders and non-responders. METHODS: Data in the NTSRS were compared with data in electronic medical records. The 200 most recent surgeries, up to 31 Dec 2019, in each of 11 surgical units were included. Criterion validity was analysed in terms of observed agreement, Cohens kappa, Gwet's AC1, and positive and negative agreement. The sign test was used to analyse systematic differences between the NTSRS and the medical records. Comparisons of rates between groups were made with Fisher's exact test, the chi-square test, and Fisher's non-parametric permutation test. RESULTS: A total of 1991 registrations were included in the study. All variables showed very high observed agreement ranging from 0.91 to 1.00, and all variables had AC1 values corresponding to almost perfect agreement. The analysis of questionnaire responders and non-responders showed no statistically significant differences regarding age, indication, or type of surgery. The proportion of women was higher in the responder group. The rate of reoperation due to bleeding was higher in the responder group, but there were no differences regarding other complications. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study show that data in the NTSRS have criterion validity. The NTSRS is thus well suited for monitoring the clinical practices and outcomes of tonsil surgery. The quality of the data also implies that the registry can be used in both clinical improvement projects and research.

Practice, complications and outcome in Swedish tonsil surgery 2009-2018. An observational longitudinal national cohort study.

Background: To assure a high quality in tonsil surgery, it is necessary to monitor trends in clinical practice, complications and outcome.Aims/objectives: To describe rates and trends regarding indications, methods, techniques, complications, and outcome of tonsil surgery.Material and method: 98 979 surgeries from the National Tonsil Surgery Register 2009-2018. Groups were categorised by indication and method.Results: The proportion of patients undergoing tonsillotomy with adenoidectomy due to obstruction-snoring (mean age 5.3 y.) increased from 2009-2018. Hot tonsillectomy, but not tonsillotomy, techniques were related to a higher risk for postoperative bleeding. The use of cold techniques increased for all types of surgeries. The rates of patients reporting contact due to postoperative pain were associated with indication and method, with the lowest rate reported for tonsillotomy (4.5% in 2018) and the highest for tonsillectomy (34.5% in 2009). The rate of patients reporting that their symptoms were gone 6 months after surgery decreased.Conclusions and significance: All hot tonsillectomy techniques should be avoided as they are related to a higher risk for postoperative bleeding. The high rate of postoperative contacts due to pain after tonsillectomy indicates a need for improvement in pain management. The declining rates of symptom relief must be investigated further.