Mouse models of cell death.

Cell death is critical for the development and orderly maintenance of cellular homeostasis in metazoans. Developmental genetics in model systems, including Caenorhabditis elegans and Drosophila melanogaster, have helped to identify and order the components of cell-death pathways. An even more complex network of apoptotic pathways has evolved in higher organisms that possess homologs within each set of cell-death regulators. Whereas biochemical studies provide details of molecular mechanisms, genetic models reveal the essential physiologic roles. Transgenic and gene-ablated mice have helped to elucidate mammalian apoptotic pathways and identify the principal effect of each cell death regulator. Here, we review the details of the apoptotic machinery as revealed by mice deficient in critical components of cell-death pathways; we concentrate on cell-death regulators classified as members of the caspase and Bcl2 families or, broadly, as adaptors and mitochondrial released factors.

Analysis of C-MYC function in normal cells via conditional gene-targeted mutation.

Germline inactivation of c-myc in mice causes embryonic lethality. Therefore, we developed a LoxP/Cre-based conditional mutation approach to test the role of c-myc in mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) and mature B lymphocytes. Cre expression resulted in reduced proliferation of wild-type MEFs, but c-Myc-deficient MEFs showed a further reduction. In contrast to fibroblasts, Cre expression had no apparent affect on wild-type B cell proliferation. Deletion of both c-Myc genes in B cells led to severely impaired proliferation in response to anti-CD40 plus IL-4. However, treated cells did upregulate several early activation markers but not CD95 or CD95 ligand. We discuss these findings with respect to potential c-Myc functions in proliferation and apoptosis and also discuss potential limitations in the Cre-mediated gene inactivation approach.

N-myc can functionally replace c-myc in murine development, cellular growth, and differentiation.

Members of the myc family of cellular oncogenes have been implicated as transcriptional regulators in pathways that govern cellular proliferation and death. In addition, N-myc and c-myc are essential for completion of murine embryonic development. However, the basis for the evolutionary conservation of myc gene family has remained unclear. To elucidate this issue, we have generated mice in which the endogenous c-myc coding sequences have been replaced with N-myc coding sequences. Strikingly, mice homozygous for this replacement mutation can survive into adulthood and reproduce. Moreover, when expressed from the c-myc locus, N-myc is similarly regulated and functionally complementary to c-myc in the context of various cellular growth and differentiation processes. Therefore, the myc gene family must have evolved, to a large extent, to facilitate differential patterns of expression.

Cloning and functional characterization of the early-lymphocyte-specific Pb99 gene.

The Pb99 gene is specifically expressed in pre-B cells and thymocytes and not in mature B and T cells or nonlymphoid tissues, implying that it may function in early lymphoid development. We have previously described the cloning of an incomplete cDNA for Pb99. Here we report the isolation of full-length cDNAs and genomic clones for the murine Pb99 gene and the mapping of its location to mouse chromosome 8. Sequence analyses of different Pb99 cDNA clones suggest that there may be at least three forms of the Pb99 protein generated by differential processing of the Pb99 transcript. The cDNA with the longest open reading frame encodes a putative protein that has seven hydrophobic domains similar to those of seven membrane-spanning proteins, such as the classical G protein-coupled receptors. To directly address the role of the Pb99 protein in lymphoid development, Pb99-deficient mice were generated by gene targeting, and lymphocyte development in these mice was analyzed.

A critical role for DNA end-joining proteins in both lymphogenesis and neurogenesis.

XRCC4 was identified via a complementation cloning method that employed an ionizing radiation (IR)-sensitive hamster cell line. By gene-targeted mutation, we show that XRCC4 deficiency in primary murine cells causes growth defects, premature senescence, IR sensitivity, and inability to support V(D)J recombination. In mice, XRCC4 deficiency causes late embryonic lethality accompanied by defective lymphogenesis and defective neurogenesis manifested by extensive apoptotic death of newly generated postmitotic neuronal cells. We find similar neuronal developmental defects in embryos that lack DNA ligase IV, an XRCC4-associated protein. Our findings demonstrate that differentiating lymphocytes and neurons strictly require the XRCC4 and DNA ligase IV end-joining proteins and point to the general stage of neuronal development in which these proteins are necessary.

Generation of normal lymphocytes derived from N-myc-deficient embryonic stem cells.

Myc family proteins are thought to be transcription factors involved in regulation of cell growth and differentiation. N-myc is expressed at the pre-B cell stage of B cell differentiation and is dramatically induced by the pre-B cell growth factor, IL-7. To test the idea that N-myc plays an important role in lymphocyte development, we assayed the effect of a null N-myc mutation on the differentiation of B and T lineage cells. Homozygous, mutant embryonic stem (ES) cells were injected into blastocysts derived from recombination activating gene (RAG-2)-deficient mice. Since RAG-2 mutant mice fail to develop mature lymphocytes, later-stage lymphocytes that are present in chimeric mice are ES cell derived. Surprisingly, nearly normal numbers of mature T and B cells derived from N-myc-deficient ES cells were found in peripheral lymphoid organs of chimeric mice. Lymphocytes were judged to be functional based on responses to mitogens and production of serum IgM and multiple IgG isotypes in chimeric animals. We discuss these findings in relation to N-myc function in lymphocyte development and possible redundancy with other myc genes.

Defective B cell development and function in Btk-deficient mice.

Mutations in the Bruton's tyrosine kinase (Btk) gene have been linked to severe early B cell developmental blocks in human X-linked agammaglobulinemia (XLA), and to milder B cell activation deficiencies in murine X-linked immune deficiency (Xid). To elucidate unequivocally potential Btk functions in mice, we generated mutations in embryonic stem cells, which eliminated the ability to encode Btk pleckstrin homology or kinase domains, and assayed their effects by RAG2-deficient blastocyst complementation or introduction into the germline. Both mutations block expression of Btk protein and lead to reduced numbers of mature conventional B cells, severe B1 cell deficiency, serum IgM and IgG3 deficiency, and defective responses in vitro to various B cell activators and in vivo to immunization with thymus-independent type II antigens. These results prove that lack of Btk function results in an Xid phenotype and further suggest a differential requirement for Btk during the early stages of murine versus human B lymphocyte development.

Embryonic lethality in mice homozygous for a targeted disruption of the N-myc gene.

The N-myc gene encodes a putative transcription factor that is thought to function in the regulation of gene expression during cell differentiation and/or growth. To examine the role of N-myc during development, we have used targeted mutagenesis in embryonic stem cells to produce a mouse line that carries an N-myc null allele. Mice homozygous for the mutation died between 10.5 and 12.5 days of gestation. Histological analysis of mutant embryos revealed that organs and tissues expected at these stages of development were present. However, multiple defects were observed, primarily in tissues and organs that normally express N-myc. In particular, mutant hearts were underdeveloped, often retaining the S-shape more typical of 9-day-old embryos. In addition, cranial and spinal ganglia were reduced in size and/or cellularity. Most of the noted defects were more consistent with a role of N-myc in proliferation of precursor populations than with a block in differentiation per se, at least at these early stages. These results demonstrate that N-myc plays an essential role during development and clearly confirm that N-myc has a physiological function that is distinct from that of the other myc-family genes.

Normal recombination substrate VH to DJH rearrangements in pre-B cell lines from scid mice.

To further analyze the VDJ recombination defect in lymphoid pre-B cells from mice with severe combined immune deficiency (scid mice), we have assayed the ability of Abelson murine leukemia virus (A-MuLV) transformed pre-B cells from scid mice to rearrange a recombination substrate in which inverted VH to DJH joins activate a selectable (gpt) gene. In unselected populations, substrate rearrangements occurred frequently, but were aberrant and probably analogous to the aberrant rearrangements observed at endogenous scid Ig gene loci. In contrast, populations of scid pre-B lines selected for gpt activity within the substrate contained mostly "normal" VH to DJH joins within the introduced substrate. These findings demonstrate that scid pre-B cells can make normal joins at low efficiency and are discussed with respect to the potential mechanism of the scid defect and the occurrence of Igs in leaky scid mice.

High-frequency disruption of the N-myc gene in embryonic stem and pre-B cell lines by homologous recombination.

Identification of gene function has often relied on isolation of mutant cells in which expression of the gene was inactivated. Gene targeting by homologous recombination in tissue culture now may provide a technology to rapidly and directly produce such mutant mammalian cells. We demonstrate that selection of embryonic stem and pre-B cell lines for expression of a promoterless construct containing murine N-myc genomic sequences fused to a gene encoding neomycin resistance allows highly efficient recovery of variants in which the endogenous N-myc gene is disrupted. The high frequency of N-myc gene disruption by this method should permit targeted disruption of both allelic N-myc copies in various cell lines to study N-myc function.

Biased expression of JH-proximal VH genes occurs in the newly generated repertoire of neonatal and adult mice.

We have previously demonstrated a dramatic preference for utilization of the most JH-proximal VH gene segments in the newborn liver versus adult spleen. We now examine in detail the relative expression of different VH gene families throughout ontogeny and in immunodeficient mice to gain insight into factors that cause the shift in VH usage. We find that the relative expression of VH gene families remains constant and biased throughout fetal and neonatal liver development. In addition, the primary VH repertoire expressed in neonatal spleen displays a similarly biased, position-dependent VH repertoire. The pattern of VH gene expression begins to change at 5-7 d postnatally and reaches the adult randomized pattern at approximately 2 wk of age. We also find biased expression of JH-proximal VH gene families in adult bone marrow and in spleens of adult leaky scid mice, suggesting that the spontaneously generated repertoire of adult mice is similar to that observed in neonates. Together, these data suggest that a position-dependent repertoire is generated in differentiating pre-B cells at all stages of ontogeny, at least in part, as a result of preferential rearrangement of proximal VH gene segments. Therefore, mechanisms subsequent to V gene rearrangement, such as regulatory interactions and antigen selection, must play a major role in normalizing the repertoire.

Isolation of scid pre-B cells that rearrange kappa light chain genes: formation of normal signal and abnormal coding joins.

Consistent with an ordered immunoglobulin (Ig) gene assembly process during precursor (pre-) B cell differentiation, we find that most Abelson murine leukemia virus (A-MuLV)-transformed pre-B cells derived from scid (severe combined immune deficient) mice actively form aberrant rearrangements of their Ig heavy chain locus but do not rearrange endogenous kappa light chain variable region gene segments. However, we have identified several scid A-MuLV transformants that transcribe the germline Ig kappa light chain constant region and actively rearrange the kappa variable region gene locus. In one case progression to the stage of kappa light chain gene rearrangement did not require expression of Ig mu heavy chains; furthermore, this progression could not be efficiently induced following expression of mu heavy chains from an introduced vector. As observed in pre-B cell lines from normal mice, attempted V kappa-to-J kappa rearrangements in scid transformants occur by inversion at least as frequently as by deletion. The inverted rearrangements result in retention of both products of the recombination event in the chromosome, thus allowing their examination. scid kappa coding sequence joins are aberrant and analogous in structure to previously described scid heavy chain coding joins. In contrast, the recognition signals that flank involved coding segments frequently are joined precisely back-to-back in normal fashion. The scid VDJ recombinase defect therefore does not significantly impair recognition of, site-specific cutting at, or juxtaposition and appropriate ligation of signal sequences. Our finding that the scid defect prevents formation of correct coding but not signal joins distinguishes these events mechanistically.

The effect of the scid mutation on mechanism and control of immunoglobulin heavy and light chain gene rearrangement.

Most Abelson murine leukemia virus (A-MuLV)-transformed cell lines derived from scid (severe combined immune deficient) mice actively rearrange their endogenous immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy (H), but not light (L) chain variable region genes. Such cell lines express germline VH segments and other RNA transcripts that are characteristically produced by early precursor (pre)-B lymphocytes, but do not express high levels of transcripts from the germline kappa (k) constant region (C kappa) locus. However, we have derived scid A-MuLV transformants that express germline C kappa transcripts and attempt kappa gene assembly. In one case kappa gene expression and rearrangement occurred in the absence of mu H chain expression, and in another was not induced efficiently by introduction of a mu-expression vector. Although the vast majority of scid H and L chain coding sequence joins are grossly aberrant, scid A-MuLV transformants can form normal coding joints at a very low frequency. In contrast, these cells form generally normal signal sequence joins at an approximately normal efficiency. Thus, these findings mechanistically distinguish coding and signal join formation. Subcloning analyses suggest that scid A-MuLV transformants that do not attempt chromosomal coding sequence joining may have a relative survival advantage, and therefore that these events may often result in unrepaired chromosomal breakage and cell death.

The scid defect affects the final step of the immunoglobulin VDJ recombinase mechanism.

Abelson murine leukemia virus-transformed precursor B lymphocytes from scid (severe combined immunodeficient) mice, like A-MuLV transformants from normal mice, actively rearrange segments of their Ig heavy chain variable region gene locus during growth in culture. Targeting of recombination to appropriate segments appears normal in these lines as evidenced by initial rearrangement of sequences from within the D and JH locus to form aberrant "DJH" rearrangements and secondary rearrangement of sequences from within the VH locus to the aberrant "DJH" intermediates. A detailed analysis of the joints in these rearrangements indicates that the VDJ recombinase in scid pre-B cells can correctly recognize heptamernonamer signal sequences and perform precise endonucleolytic scissions at these sequences. We propose that the scid defect involves the inability of scid precursor lymphocytes to join correctly the cleaved ends of the coding strands of variable region gene segments.

Developmentally regulated and strain-specific expression of murine VH gene families.

We have devised a simple assay that provides an instantaneous representation of VH family usage in primary and peripheral lymphoid tissues. This assay lacks complex manipulations out of the animal and thus minimizes the risk of in vitro artifacts. We have used this assay to demonstrate a dramatic preference for utilization of the most JH-proximal VH segments in the newborn liver of BALB/c and C57BL/6 mice. Furthermore, we find that VH segments from across the entire VH locus are utilized early in development, but at frequencies directly related to their JH proximity. A major shift away from the position-dependent VH repertoire of the neonate is seen in unprimed or polyclonally-activated adult spleen cells, in which relative utilization of the various VH families is related to family size. We also report consistent strain-specific differences in the expression of certain VH families. Our data indicate that a position-dependent VH repertoire is generated in differentiating pre-B lymphocytes (probably reflecting constraints imposed by the immunoglobulin gene assembly process), and that mechanisms that operate subsequent to rearrangement then randomize this position-dependent repertoire in a strain-specific manner.

Control of recombination events during lymphocyte differentiation. Heavy chain variable region gene assembly and heavy chain class switching.

Our recent studies have focused on the organization of immunoglobulin genes in mice and humans and the mechanism and control of the recombination events that are involved in their assembly and expression. This report describes our progress in this area with particular focus on elucidating factors that influence the generation of the antibody repertoire in normal and diseased states. We present a detailed analysis of the organization of the human VH locus, studies that help to elucidate the nature of the recombination defect in mice with severe combined immunodeficiency, and studies of transgenic mice that focus on the mechanism that regulates tissue-specific variable region gene assembly. In addition, we also characterize mechanisms that control the heavy chain class-switch process. Although the latter process apparently involve a recombination system distinct from that involved in variable region assembly, we find that the two recombination events appear to be controlled by similar mechanisms.

Antigen-specific B cells efficiently present low doses of antigen for induction of T cell proliferation.

Previous experiments suggested a role for specific B cells in the induction of antigen (SRBC)-specific T cell proliferation. Two models were proposed: in the first, B cells directly presented antigen to T cells; alternatively, B cells secreted antibody, which opsonized antigen for presentation by macrophages. Experiments to distinguish between these possibilities are presented here. Three lines of evidence support the conclusion that antigen is presented directly by specific B cells. First, nonimmune splenic adherent cells (SAC), which efficiently induced proliferation of appropriately primed T cells to antigens such as OVA and GAT, were unable to induce SRBC-specific proliferation. Secondly, a slope analysis of the logarithmic plot of T cell proliferation vs the number of irradiated B cells suggested that two cells were limiting within the presenting population. The addition of IL 1 or SAC reduced the slope to 1 (although in serum-free conditions, the addition of IL 1, but not SAC, reduced the slope of the line). Specificity of the B cells for the antigen continued to be required in the presence of exogenous IL 1 or SAC. These results suggested that presentation by specific B cells and the amount of IL 1 were the limiting requirements for the induction of SRBC-specific T cell proliferation. The third line of evidence was the demonstration of a restricted interaction between T cells and B cells. The addition of irradiated, allogeneic SRBC-specific B cells to T cell lines and syngeneic SAC failed to support proliferative responses. We further show that a GAT-specific T cell clone was triggered to proliferate by either SAC or B cells, but that antigen-specific B cells were necessary at low doses of antigen. This finding is important in two respects. First, the T cell clone previously has been shown to act as a helper; secondly, when low doses of antigen are used, the requirement for priming of the B cells to the specific antigen is true for a soluble, as well as a particulate, antigen. We propose that at low (physiologic) doses of antigen, presentation to secondary T cells takes place mainly at the surface of antigen-specific B cells. At high doses of antigen,h presentation can also be accomplished by nonspecific cells such as other B cells, macrophages, or dendritic cells.

Role of antigen-specific B cells in the induction of SRBC-specific T cell proliferation.

In this study, we ask whether antigen presentation can be effected by antigen-activated B cells. Antigen-dependent in vitro proliferation of T cells from mice primed with SRBC or HoRBC occurs in the presence of B cells primed to the relevant antigen. B cells prepared from lymph nodes of mice primed with irrelevant antigens are not effective antigen-presenting cells for RBC-specific T cell proliferation over a wide range of SRBC doses. This is true even when both RBC and the antigen to which the B cells are primed are included in the culture. In contrast, B cells specific for a hapten determinant coupled to SRBC are able to support proliferation of T cells specific for SRBC determinants. We conclude from these data that antigen-specific B cells play a role in the induction of T cell proliferative responses to SRBC and HoRBC antigens. Two models are proposed: either B cells, upon antigen interaction with surface antibody, are able to act as accessory cells to induce Ia-dependent proliferation of immune T cells; or B cells augment the T cell proliferative response by secretion of antibody, leading to opsonization of the antigen for macrophage uptake and presentation.