Plant cover and biomass change on extensive green roofs over a decade and ten lessons learned.

Green roofs are well studied for the environmental, social, and economic services these provide. As a result, green roofs are widespread and within the common vernacular of city residents. Green roof bylaws and construction standards are present in many cities in North America, rooting the presence of this green infrastructure within urban landscapes. Although examples of green roofs constructed decades ago exist, rarely are green roofs monitored over such long periods, and in ways that allow for experimentation, analysis, and conclusions about performance or function. In this study we present findings on plant cover and biomass from a green roof testing facility in Toronto, Canada that was monitored for over a decade. We examine the contributions of growing media, planting, and irrigation in the first seven years (2011-2021) of the eleven-year monitoring period. We found that during this maintenance phase period (2011-2017), plant cover and biomass was highest in modules planted with Sedum, included organic media, and were irrigated, whereas non-irrigated modules planted with forbs and grasses had the poorest performance regardless of media type. Following the stoppage of irrigation, and the post maintenance phase (2017-2021), modules initially planted with Sedum continued to sustain cover and biomass whereas planted forbs and grasses mostly disappeared, and these treatments were overtaken by Sedum. Our findings demonstrate that with irrigation, plantings of forbs and grasses can sustain plant cover and biomass. However, Sedum buffers against major changes to environmental conditions or abrupt changes to maintenance, adding insurance against failure of extensive green roofs.

Biochar and vegetation effects on discharge water quality from organic-substrate green roofs.

Green roofs have been increasingly used to improve stormwater management, but poor vegetation performance on roof systems, varying with vegetation type, can degrade discharge quality. Biochar has been suggested as an effective substrate additive for green roofs to improve plant performance and discharge quality. However, research on the effects of biochar and vegetation on discharge quality in the long term is lacking and the underlying mechanisms involved are unclear. We examined the effects of biochar amendment and vegetation on discharge quality on organic-substrate green roofs with pre-grown sedum mats and direct-seeded native plants for three years and investigated the key factors influencing discharge quality. Sedum mats reduced the leaching of nutrients and particulate matter by 6-64% relative to native plants, largely due to the higher initial vegetation cover of the former. Biochar addition to sedum mat green roofs resulted in the best integrated water quality due to enhanced plant cover and sorption effects. Structural equation modeling revealed that nutrient leaching was primarily influenced by rainfall depth, time, vegetation cover, and substrate pH. Although biochar-amended sedum mats showed better discharge quality from organic-substrate green roofs, additional ecosystem services may be provided by native plants, suggesting future research to optimize plant composition and cover and biochar properties for sustainable green roofs.

Decoupling factors affecting plant diversity and cover on extensive green roofs.

Supplemental irrigation systems are often specified on green roofs to ensure plant cover and growth, both important components of green roof performance and aesthetics. Properties of the growing media environment too can alter the assemblage of plant species able to thrive. In this study we determine how plant cover, above ground biomass and species diversity are influenced by irrigation and growing media. Grass and forb vegetative cover and biomass were significantly greater in organic based growing media but there was no effect of supplemental irrigation, with two warm season grasses dominating in those treatments receiving no supplemental irrigation. On the other hand, plant diversity declined without irrigation in organic media, and having no irrigation in inorganic growing media resulted in almost a complete loss of cover. Sedum biomass was less in inorganic growing media treatments and species dominance shifted when growing media organic content increased. Our results demonstrate that supplemental irrigation is required to maintain plant diversity on an extensive green roof, but not necessarily plant cover or biomass. These results provide evidence that planting extensive green roofs with a mix of plant species can ensure the survival of some species; maintaining cover and biomass when supplemental irrigation is turned off to conserve water, or during extreme drought.