Mechanism of poly(A) signal transduction to RNA polymerase II in vitro.

Termination of transcription by RNA polymerase II usually requires the presence of a functional poly(A) site. How the poly(A) site signals its presence to the polymerase is unknown. All models assume that the signal is generated after the poly(A) site has been extruded from the polymerase, but this has never been tested experimentally. It is also widely accepted that a "pause" element in the DNA stops the polymerase and that cleavage at the poly(A) site then signals termination. These ideas also have never been tested. The lack of any direct tests of the poly(A) signaling mechanism reflects a lack of success in reproducing the poly(A) signaling phenomenon in vitro. Here we describe a cell-free transcription elongation assay that faithfully recapitulates poly(A) signaling in a crude nuclear extract. The assay requires the use of citrate, an inhibitor of RNA polymerase II carboxyl-terminal domain phosphorylation. Using this assay we show the following. (i) Wild-type but not mutant poly(A) signals instruct the polymerase to stop transcription on downstream DNA in a manner that parallels true transcription termination in vivo. (ii) Transcription stops without the need of downstream elements in the DNA. (iii) cis-antisense inhibition blocks signal transduction, indicating that the signal to stop transcription is generated following extrusion of the poly(A) site from the polymerase. (iv) Signaling can be uncoupled from processing, demonstrating that signaling does not require cleavage at the poly(A) site.

Assembly of the cleavage and polyadenylation apparatus requires about 10 seconds in vivo and is faster for strong than for weak poly(A) sites.

We have devised a cis-antisense rescue assay of cleavage and polyadenylation to determine how long it takes the simian virus 40 (SV40) early poly(A) signal to commit itself to processing in vivo. An inverted copy of the poly(A) signal placed immediately downstream of the authentic one inhibited processing by means of sense-antisense duplex formation in the RNA. The antisense inhibition was gradually relieved when the inverted signal was moved increasing distances downstream, presumably because cleavage and polyadenylation occur before the polymerase reaches the antisense sequence. Antisense inhibition was unaffected when the inverted signal was moved upstream. Based on the known rate of transcription, we estimate that the cleavage-polyadenylation process takes between 10 and 20 s for the SV40 early poly(A) site to complete in vivo. Relief from inhibition occurred earlier for shorter antisense sequences than for longer ones. This indicates that a brief period of assembly is sufficient for the poly(A) signal to shield itself from a short (50- to 70-nucleotide) antisense sequence but that more assembly time is required for the signal to become immune to the longer ones (approximately 200 nucleotides). The simplest explanation for this target size effect is that the assembly process progressively sequesters more and more of the RNA surrounding the poly(A) signal up to a maximum of about 200 nucleotides, which we infer to be the domain of the mature apparatus. We compared strong and weak poly(A) sites. The SV40 late poly(A) site, one of the strongest, assembles several times faster than the weaker SV40 early or synthetic poly(A) site.

Poly(A)-driven and poly(A)-assisted termination: two different modes of poly(A)-dependent transcription termination.

We mapped the elements that mediate termination of transcription downstream of the chicken betaH- and betaA-globin gene poly(A) sites. We found no unique element and no segment of 3'-flanking DNA to be significantly more effective than any other. When we replaced the native 3'-flanking DNA with bacterial DNA, it too supported transcription termination. Termination in the bacterial DNA depended on a functional poly(A) signal, which apparently compelled termination to occur in the downstream DNA with little regard for its sequence. We also studied premature termination by poorly processive polymerases close to the promoter. The rate of premature termination varied for different DNA sequences. However, the efficiencies of poly(A)-driven termination and promoter-proximal premature termination varied similarly on different DNAs, suggesting that poly(A)-driven termination functions by returning the transcription complex to a form which resembles a prior state of low processivity. The poly(A)-driven termination described here differs dramatically from the poly(A)-assisted termination previously described for the simian virus 40 (SV40) early transcription unit. In the SV40 early transcription unit, essentially no termination occurs downstream of the poly(A) site unless a special termination element is present. The difference between the betaH-globin and SV40 modes of termination is governed by sequences in the upstream DNA. For maximum efficiency, the betaH-globin poly(A) signal required the assistance of upstream enhancing sequences. Moreover, the SV40 early poly(A) signal also drove termination in betaH-globin style when it was placed in a betaH-globin sequence context. These studies were facilitated by a rapid, improved method of run-on transcription analysis, based on the use of a vector containing two G-free cassettes.

Nucleosome spacing is compressed in active chromatin domains of chick erythroid cells.

We have cleaved the chromatin of embryonic and adult chicken erythroid cells using a novel nuclease that is capable of resolving clearly the nucleosomes of active chromatin. We found that in active chromatin, nucleosomes are spaced up to 40 base pairs closer together than in inactive chromatin. This was true for both "housekeeping" and "luxury" genes and was observed whether the digestion was carried out on isolated nuclei in vitro or by activating the endogenous nuclease in vivo. The close spacing extended several kilobases into flanking chromatin, indicating that this is a domain property of active chromatin, not just a characteristic of regions disrupted by transcription. A simple interpretation of our results is that the nucleosomes of active chromatin are mobile in vivo and, not being constrained by linker histones, freely move closer together.

HMG proteins 14 and 17 become cross-linked to the globular domain of histone H3 near the nucleosome core particle dyad.

HMG proteins were derivatized with the photoactivatable cross-linker N-succinimidyl 3-((4-azidophenyl)dithio)propionate and then allowed to associate with nucleosome core particles. Following photolysis, peptide mapping of the principal dimeric adducts was carried out. Cross-linking occurred primarily from a central location in the HMGs to a central location in H3. The positions of these cross-links, considered along with other data from the literature, show that HMG proteins 14 and 17 make important contacts to H3 near the front face of the nucleosome. This raises the possibility that HMGs 14 and 17 participate in the reported conformational transition which exposes the H3 sulfhydryls of active nucleosomes.

Active beta-globin gene transcription occurs in methylated, DNase I-resistant chromatin of nonerythroid chicken cells.

We report active, inappropriate transcription of the chicken beta A-globin gene in normal fibroblasts, cultured MSB cells, and brain. We were unable to detect ovalbumin gene transcription in these same tissues. Most of the globin gene transcripts were found to be truncated near the beginning of the gene, suggesting the existence of a premature termination process that is preferentially active under conditions of inappropriate transcription. The inappropriately transcribed beta A-globin gene chromatin remained DNase I resistant and highly methylated. Thus, the DNase I-sensitive conformation of erythrocyte beta A chromatin was correlated not with beta A transcription per se but with beta A expression. Although both transcribed and nontranscribed genes within the globin domain exhibited the same DNase I sensitivity in erythrocyte nuclei, a housekeeping gene active in erythrocytes exhibited a different level of DNase I sensitivity. However, this gene exhibited the same level of DNase I sensitivity in both erythrocytes and a cultured cell line. These observations are consistent with the proposal (G. Blobel, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 82:8527-8529, 1985) that the DNase I sensitivity of a gene may reflect properties of chromatin related to cotranscriptional and posttranscriptional aspects of mRNA production rather than to transcription per se.

The DNase I sensitive state of "active" globin gene chromatin resists trypsin treatments which disrupt chromatin higher order structure.

Active genes in higher eukaryotes reside in chromosomal domains which are more sensitive to digestion by DNase I than the surrounding inactive chromatin. Although it is widely assumed that some modification of higher order structure is important to the preferential DNase I sensitivity of active chromatin, this has so far not been tested. Here we show that the structural distinction between DNase I sensitive and resistant chromatin is remarkably stable to digestion by trypsin. Chick embryonic red blood cell nuclei were subjected to increasing levels of trypsin digestion and then assayed in the following three ways: (1) by gel electrophoresis for histone cleavage, (2) by sedimentation and nuclease digestion for loss of higher order structure, and (3) by dot-blot hybridization to globin and ovalbumin probes for disappearance of preferential DNase I sensitivity. We have found that chromatin higher order structure is lost concomitantly with the cleavage of histones H1, H5, and H3. In contrast, the preferential sensitivity of the globin domain to DNase I persists until much higher concentrations of trypsin, and indeed is not completely abolished even by the highest levels of trypsin we have used. We therefore conclude that the structural distinction of active chromatin, recognized by DNase I, does not reside at the level of higher order structure.

Chicken globin gene transcription is cell lineage specific during the time of the switch.

Posttranscriptional silencing of embryonic globin gene expression occurs during hemoglobin switching in chickens [Landes, G.M., Villeponteau, B., Pribyl, T.M., & Martinson, H.G. (1982) J. Biol. Chem. 257, 11008-11014]. Here we use Percoll density gradients to fractionate the red blood cells of 5-9-day embryos in order to determine the cellular source and the timing of this posttranscriptional process. By means of nuclear "run-on" transcription in vitro we show that it is within mature primitive cells that production of embryonic globin mRNA is terminated posttranscriptionally. In contrast, young definitive cells produce little (or no) embryonic globin mRNA because of regulation at the transcriptional level. Thus the lineage specificity of embryonic and adult globin gene expression is determined transcriptionally, and the post-transcriptional process described by Landes et al. is a property of the senescing primitive cells, not a mechanism operative in the hemoglobin switch. This conclusion is supported by [3H]leucine incorporation experiments on Percoll-fractionated cells which reveal no posttranscriptional silencing of the embryonic genes during the early stages of the switch. In the course of our studies we have noticed a strong transcriptional pause near the second exon of the globin genes which is induced by 5,6-dichloro-1-beta-D-ribofuranosylbenzimidazole (DRB) and which resembles a natural pause near that position.

Transcription termination at the chicken beta H-globin gene.

We characterized the transcription termination region of the chicken beta H-globin gene. First we located the region by nuclear runon transcription in vitro. Then we sequenced and subcloned it into a chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) expression vector for assay in vivo. The region of beta H termination contains two interesting elements located about 1 kilobase downstream of the beta H gene poly(A) site. Either element alone can block CAT expression if inserted between the promoter and the poly(A) site of the cat gene in pRSVcat. The first element in the termination region is an unusually large inverted repeat in the DNA (delta G = -71 kcal). The second element, 200 base pairs further downstream, is an RNA polymerase II promoter which directs transcription back upstream on the complementary strand. This transcription converges on and collides with that from the beta H gene at or near the inverted repeat where transcription from both directions stops. We propose that the inverted repeat is a strong pause site which positions the converging polymerases for mutual site-specific termination.

Gamma rays and bleomycin nick DNA and reverse the DNase I sensitivity of beta-globin gene chromatin in vivo.

The active beta-globin genes in chicken erythrocytes, like all active genes, reside in large chromatin domains which are preferentially sensitive to digestion by DNase I. We have recently proposed that the special structure of chromatin in active domains is maintained by torsional stress in the DNA (Villeponteau et al., Cell 39:469-478, 1984). This hypothesis predicts that nicking of the DNA within any such chromosomal domain in vivo will relax the DNA and lead to loss of the special DNase I-sensitive state. Here we have tested this prediction by using gamma irradiation and bleomycin treatment to cleave DNA within intact chicken embryo erythrocytes. Both treatments cause reversal of DNase I sensitivity. Moreover, reversal occurs at approximately one nick per 150 kilobase pairs for both agents despite their entirely unrelated modes of cell penetration and DNA attack. These results suggest that the domain of DNase I sensitivity surrounding the beta-globin genes comprises 150 kilobase pairs of chromatin under torsional stress and that a single DNA nick in this region is sufficient to reverse the DNase I sensitivity throughout the entire domain.

Ribonucleotide-induced helical alteration in DNA prevents nucleosome formation.

Several polynucleotides that assume an A-form helical structure in solution are unable to form nucleosomes. We attempted to establish a relationship between the ease of the A-form----B-form helix transition and ease of nucleosome formation by reconstituting nucleosomes using ribosubstituted DNA containing various levels of ribonucleotides. Instead we discovered that, when riboadenosine is substituted for deoxyriboadenosine, even one ribonucleotide per 125 base pairs of DNA reduces nucleosome formation and that DNA containing greater than 5% ribonucleotide is completely unable to form nucleosomes. Ribosubstituted DNA restriction fragments exhibited altered mobility on native 6% polyacrylamide gels, indicating an altered helical structure (probably bending). The effects on both nucleosome formation and gel mobility are nucleotide specific and are correlated, being greatest for riboadenosine and decreasing in the order riboadenosine greater than riboguanosine greater than ribocytosine. The results are consistent with the hypothesis that the rate of nucleosome formation can be drastically reduced by isolated local perturbations, such as kinking or bending, in the helical structure of DNA.

Novobiocin induces the in vivo cleavage of active gene sequences in intact cells.

When the topoisomerase II inhibitor, novobiocin, is administered to embryonic chicken red blood cells, it induces the in vivo release of an endogenous nuclease which cleaves specifically within internucleosomal spacer DNA and within nuclease-hypersensitive sites in the active chromatin of intact cells. This in vivo released nuclease activity is induced by novobiocin only in metabolically active immature red blood cells. Little induction occurs in mature erythrocytes and no induction occurs in cells previously treated with 2,4-dinitrophenol. Although novobiocin is required to induce release and/or activation of the nuclease, the activity of the nuclease, once activated, is independent of novobiocin. Analysis of the cleaved DNA in drug-treated immature cells demonstrates that the novobiocin-induced nuclease has an unusual blunt-ended double-stranded mode of cleavage. Because of its special properties and apparent chromatin related function in vivo, the novobiocin-induced nuclease activity offers a novel and useful in vivo and in vitro probe of chromatin structure.

Contact site of histones 2A and 2B in chromatin and in solution.

Irradiation of isolated nuclei or of a complex of histones 2A (H2A) and 2B (H2B) with ultraviolet light produces a covalent cross-link between H2A and H2B. Sequence analysis of the peptides isolated from the H2A-H2B dimer formed in solution and in nuclei demonstrated that both dimers are produced through the covalent linkage of Tyr-40 of H2B and Pro-26 of H2A. Tyrosyl residues proximal to Tyr-40 did not produce a cross-link with H2A, thereby indicating that strict conformational parameters are required for production of the H2A-H2B cross-link. We conclude that the precise juxtaposition of Tyr-40 of H2B and Pro-26 of H2A in this region of the H2A/H2B contact site is not altered upon interaction of these histones with H3 and H4 (tetramer), DNA, or other chromosomal components during nucleosome assembly.

Role of histone tyrosines in nucleosome formation and histone-histone interaction.

We have studied the functional properties of iodinated histones. Isolated, denatured histones were iodinated at trace levels and then renatured together with carrier histones and high molecular weight DNA to form nucleohistone. Nucleosomes were prepared from the reconstitute using micrococcal nuclease, and the relative representations of the individual iodinated tyrosines of the histones in the reconstituted nucleosomes were determined. Our principal findings are 1) that denatured histones can be iodinated at any tyrosine without interfering in subsequent nucleosome reconstitution and 2) that the resulting reconstituted nucleosomes nevertheless possess histone cores of altered stability, being either more or less stable depending on the particular tyrosine which is iodinated. We show that tyrosines 37, 40, and 42 of H2B are protected from iodination in intact core particles, as expected since these tyrosines lie within the H2B-H2A binding site. Yet iodination of these tyrosines in denatured H2B does not interfere with nucleosome assembly. However, the histone cores isolated from these reconstituted nucleosomes are of diminished stability as assayed by Sephadex column chromatography in 2 M salt. In contrast, iodination of tyrosines 83 and 121 of H2B, as well as iodination of the tyrosines of H2A, increases the stability of the histone octamer core. Iodination of H4 tyrosine 72 is without effect on histone octamer stability. Tyrosine iodination constitutes a profound amino acid alteration in the context of the absolute evolutionary conservation of most histone tyrosines. For example, all H2Bs sequenced to date, from fungi to mammals, possess tyrosines at positions 37, 40, and 42. Our results suggest that the immutability of these tyrosines reflects some sophisticated function of the nucleosome histone core beyond the assembly and mere maintenance of a compact structure.

Transcriptional properties of chick embryonic erythroid nuclei in vitro.

Chick embryo red blood cells express the embryonic globin and the rRNA genes before 5 days of development but only the adult globin genes and no rRNA after 12 days of development. We have isolated nuclei from the red blood cells of these developmental stages and allowed them to transcribe in vitro. We have analyzed the overall transcriptional properties of these nuclei, the overall activities of RNA polymerases I and II and the sequence-specific activity of RNA polymerase II in the beta-globin domain using cloned genomic hybridization probes. Among our findings are the following. 1) Erythroid nuclei of 5-day embryos are more transcriptionally active than those at 12 days. 2) RNA polymerase I is a very active at 5 days but is off by 12 days. 3) A template-independent activity which yields labeled RNA is present in the red cell nuclei of 12-day but not 5-day embryos. 4) Between 5 and 12 days of development transcriptional modulation delineates embryonic and adult beta-globin domains. 5) These domains exceed the boundaries of the genes themselves by several kilobases. 6) All transcripts which hybridize to sequences in the beta-globin gene region, including repeat sequence transcripts, are transcribed by RNA polymerase II.

Hemoglobin switching in chickens. Is the switch initiated post-transcriptionally?

We have investigated the transcriptional specificity of chick embryo erythroid nuclei as a function of developmental age during progression of the hemoglobin switch. Nuclei were allowed to transcribe in vitro in the presence of high specific activity [alpha-32P]CTP and the radioactive transcripts were hybridized to a collection of plasmid clones spanning the beta-like globin gene region of the chicken genome. The results reveal locus-specific waves of transcription appearing during the interval between 5 and 12 days of incubation. The last wave, which comes in at 12 days, is highly specialized in transcription of the adult beta-globin gene locus. The most interesting wave of transcription occurs at 6-7 days. The most actively transcribed gene in the early part of this wave is the embryonic rho gene. As the wave progresses, the rho gene activity gradually gives way to beta gene transcription. Definitive red blood cells, which would be synthesizing little rho globin protein at this stage, appear to be responsible for the rho gene transcription. These results and additional data which we present indicate that during the initial stages of the hemoglobin switch the embryonic globin genes are silenced post-transcriptionally.

Nucleosomes will not form on double-stranded RNa or over poly(dA).poly(dT) tracts in recombinant DNA.

We have been unable to "force" double-stranded RNA to fold into nucleosome-like structures using several different histone-RNA "reconstitution" procedures. Even if the histones are first stabilized in octameric form by dimethylsuberimidate cross-linking they are still unable to form specific complexes with the RNA. Moreover double-stranded RNA is unable to induce histones to assemble into octamers although we confirm that the non-nucleic acid homopolymer, polyglutamic acid, has this ability. We have also determined, using pyrimidine tract analysis, that nucleosomes will not form over a sufficiently long segment of poly(dA).poly(dT) in a recombinant DNA molecule. Thus nucleosomes cannot fold DNA containing an 80 base pair poly(dA).poly(dT) segment but a 20 base pair segment can be accommodated in nucleosomes fairly well. Segments of intermediate length can be accommodated but are clearly selected against. Poly(dA).poly(dT) differs only slightly from natural DNA in helix structure. Therefore either this homopolymer resists folding, or nucleosomes are very exacting in the nucleic acid steroid parameters they will tolerate. Such constraints may be relevant to nucleosome positioning in chromatin.

Iodination of nucleosomes at low ionic strength: conformational changes in H4 and stabilization by H1.

Radioactive iodine has been used to probe the relative reactivities of nucleosomal H4 tyrosine residues under various conditions of subphysiological ionic strength. We observe that tyrosine 72 of H4, which is not reactive over the range 20-150 mM NaCl, becomes the predominant site of iodination within H4 when nucleosomes are subjected to conditions of very low ionic strength. Conversely, the other H4 tyrosine residues, which are reactive within nucleosomes in solutions of moderate ionic strength (20-150 mM NaCl), become nonreactive when the ionic strength is reduced. This "flip-flop" in the H4 iodination pattern is the manifestation of a reversible nucleosomal conformational change. A method is presented which enables the conformational status of H4 in nucleosomes to be determined by simply electrophoresing the histones on a Triton gel after probing nucleosomes with labeled iodine. Using this technique, we demonstrate that the presence of H1 on one side of the nucleosome stabilizes a histone core domain on the other side so that all four tyrosines of H4 are maintained in their physiological ionic strength conformation even under conditions of no added salt.

Structure of nucleosome core particles containing uH2A (A24).

We have purified uH2A (A24) and reconstituted it, in place of H2A, into high molecular weight nucleohistone containing the core histones and DNA. uH2A-containing core particles were then prepared by nuclease digestion and studies on these particles were carried out. We show that two uH2A molecules can be accommodated within a core particle. We also show that the presence of two uH2A molecules in a core particle does not alter significantly either the pattern or the rate of DNase I digestion as compared to both reconstituted and native core particles. Finally, we show that HMG proteins 14 and 17 can bind to uH2A-containing core particles. We conclude that uH2A has little influence on structure at the level of individual nucleosomes.