Pervasive gene deregulation underlies adaptation and maladaptation in trimethoprim-resistant E. coli.

IMPORTANCE: Bacteria employ a number of mechanisms to adapt to antibiotics. Mutations in transcriptional regulators alter the expression levels of genes that can change the susceptibility of bacteria to antibiotics. Two-component signaling proteins are a major class of signaling molecule used by bacteria to regulate transcription. In previous work, we found that mutations in MgrB, a feedback regulator of the PhoQP two-component system, conferred trimethoprim tolerance to Escherichia coli. Here, we elucidate how mutations in MgrB have a domino-like effect on the gene regulatory network of E. coli. As a result, pervasive perturbation of gene regulation ensues. Depending on the environmental context, this pervasive deregulation is either adaptive or maladaptive. Our study sheds light on how deregulation of gene expression can be beneficial for bacteria when challenged with antibiotics, and why regulators like MgrB may have evolved in the first place.

Adaptive laboratory evolution of antimicrobial resistance in bacteria for genetic and phenotypic analyses.

Adaptive laboratory evolution (ALE) of bacteria has the potential to provide many insights like revealing novel mechanisms of resistance and elucidating the impact of drug combinations and concentrations on AMR evolution. Here, we describe a step-by-step ALE protocol for the model bacterium Escherichia coli that can be easily adapted to answer questions related to evolution and genetics of AMR in diverse bacteria. Key issues to consider when designing ALE experiments as well as some downstream mutation mapping analyses are described. For complete details on the use and execution of this protocol, please refer to Patel and Matange (2021)1 and Matange et al. (2019).2.

Adaptation and compensation in a bacterial gene regulatory network evolving under antibiotic selection.

Gene regulatory networks allow organisms to generate coordinated responses to environmental challenges. In bacteria, regulatory networks are re-wired and re-purposed during evolution, though the relationship between selection pressures and evolutionary change is poorly understood. In this study, we discover that the early evolutionary response of Escherichia coli to the antibiotic trimethoprim involves derepression of PhoPQ signaling, an Mg2+-sensitive two-component system, by inactivation of the MgrB feedback-regulatory protein. We report that derepression of PhoPQ confers trimethoprim-tolerance to E. coli by hitherto unrecognized transcriptional upregulation of dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR), target of trimethoprim. As a result, mutations in mgrB precede and facilitate the evolution of drug resistance. Using laboratory evolution, genome sequencing, and mutation re-construction, we show that populations of E. coli challenged with trimethoprim are faced with the evolutionary 'choice' of transitioning from tolerant to resistant by mutations in DHFR, or compensating for the fitness costs of PhoPQ derepression by inactivating the RpoS sigma factor, itself a PhoPQ-target. Outcomes at this evolutionary branch-point are determined by the strength of antibiotic selection, such that high pressures favor resistance, while low pressures favor cost compensation. Our results relate evolutionary changes in bacterial gene regulatory networks to strength of selection and provide mechanistic evidence to substantiate this link.

Highly Contingent Phenotypes of Lon Protease Deficiency in Escherichia coli upon Antibiotic Challenge.

Evolutionary trajectories and mutational landscapes of drug-resistant bacteria are influenced by cell-intrinsic and extrinsic factors. In this study, I demonstrated that loss of the Lon protease altered susceptibility of Escherichia coli to trimethoprim and that these effects were strongly contingent on the drug concentration and genetic background. Lon, an AAA+ ATPase, is a bacterial master regulator protease involved in cytokinesis, suppression of transposition events, and clearance of misfolded proteins. I show that Lon deficiency enhances intrinsic drug tolerance at sub-MIC levels of trimethoprim. As a result, loss of Lon, though disadvantageous under drug-free conditions, has a selective advantage at low concentrations of trimethoprim. At high drug concentrations, however, Lon deficiency is detrimental for E. coli I show that the former is explained by suppression of drug efflux by Lon, while the latter can be attributed to SulA-dependent hyperfilamentation. On the other hand, deletion of lon in a trimethoprim-resistant mutant E. coli strain (harboring the Trp30Gly dihydrofolate reductase [DHFR] allele) directly potentiates resistance by enhancing the in vivo stability of mutant DHFR. Using extensive mutational analysis at 3 hot spots of resistance, I show that many resistance-conferring mutations render DHFR prone to proteolysis. This trade-off between gaining resistance and losing in vivo stability limits the number of mutations in DHFR that can confer trimethoprim resistance. Loss of Lon expands the mutational capacity for acquisition of trimethoprim resistance. This paper identifies the multipronged action of Lon in trimethoprim resistance in E. coli and provides mechanistic insight into how genetic backgrounds and drug concentrations may alter the potential for antimicrobial resistance evolution.IMPORTANCE Understanding the evolutionary dynamics of antimicrobial resistance is vital to curb its emergence and spread. Being fundamentally similar to natural selection, the fitness of resistant mutants is a key parameter to consider in the evolutionary dynamics of antimicrobial resistance (AMR). Various intrinsic and extrinsic factors modulate the fitness of resistant bacteria. This study demonstrated that Lon, a bacterial master regulator protease, influences drug tolerance and resistance. Lon is a key regulator of several fundamental processes in bacteria, including cytokinesis. I demonstrated that Lon deficiency produces highly contingent phenotypes in E. coli challenged with trimethoprim and can expand the mutational repertoire available to E. coli to evolve resistance. This multipronged influence of Lon on drug resistance provides an illustrative instance of how master regulators shape the response of bacteria to antibiotics.

Deorphanizing NUDIX hydrolases from Trypanosoma: tantalizing links with metabolic regulation and stress tolerance.

An explosion of sequence information in the genomics era has thrown up thousands of protein sequences without functional assignment. Though our ability to predict function based on sequence alone is improving steadily, we still have a long way to go. Proteins with common evolutionary origins carry telling sequence signatures, which ought to reveal their biological roles. These sequence signatures have allowed us to classify proteins into families with similar structures, and possibly, functions. Yet, evolution is a perpetual tinkerer, and hence, sequence signatures alone have proved inadequate in understanding the physiological activities of proteins. One such enigmatic family of enzymes is the NUDIX ( nu cleoside di phosphate linked to a moiety X ) hydrolase family that has over 80000 members from all branches of the tree of life. Though MutT, the founding member of this family, was identified in 1954, we are only now beginning to understand the diversity of substrates and biological roles that these enzymes demonstrate. In a recent article by Cordeiro et al. in Bioscience Reports [Biosci. Rep. (2019)], two members of this protein family from the human pathogen Trypanosoma brucei were deorphanized as being polyphosphate hydrolases. The authors show that of the five NUDIX hydrolases coded by the T. brucei genomes, TbNH2 and TbNH4, show in vitro hydrolytic activity against inorganic polyphosphate. Through classical biochemistry and immunostaining microscopy, differences in their substrate specificities and sub-cellular localization were revealed. These new data provide a compelling direction to the study of Trypanosome stress biology as well as our understanding of the NUDIX enzyme family.

Adaptation Through Lifestyle Switching Sculpts the Fitness Landscape of Evolving Populations: Implications for the Selection of Drug-Resistant Bacteria at Low Drug Pressures.

Novel genotypes evolve under selection through mutations in pre-existing genes. However, mutations have pleiotropic phenotypic effects that influence the fitness of emerging genotypes in complex ways. The evolution of antimicrobial resistance is mediated by selection of mutations in genes coding for antibiotic-target proteins. Drug-resistance is commonly associated with a fitness cost due to the impact of resistance-conferring mutations on protein function and/or stability. These costs are expected to prohibit the selection of drug-resistant mutations at low drug pressures. Using laboratory evolution of rifampicin resistance in Escherichia coli, we show that when exposed intermittently to low concentration (0.1 × minimal inhibitory concentration) of rifampicin, the evolution of canonical drug resistance was indeed unfavorable. Instead, these bacterial populations adapted by evolving into small-colony variants that displayed enhanced pellicle-forming ability. This shift in lifestyle from planktonic to pellicle-like was necessary for enhanced fitness at low drug pressures, and was mediated by the genetic activation of the fim operon promoter, which allowed expression of type I fimbriae. Upon continued low drug exposure, these bacteria evolved exclusively into high-level drug-resistant strains through mutations at a limited set of loci within the rifampicin-resistance determining region of the rpoB gene. We show that our results are explained by mutation-specific epistasis, resulting in differential impact of lifestyle switching on the competitive fitness of different rpoB mutations. Thus, lifestyle-alterations that are selected at low selection pressures have the potential to modify the fitness effects of mutations, change the genetic structure, and affect the ultimate fate of evolving populations.

Trade-offs with stability modulate innate and mutationally acquired drug resistance in bacterial dihydrofolate reductase enzymes.

Structural stability is a major constraint on the evolution of protein sequences. However, under strong directional selection, mutations that confer novel phenotypes but compromise structural stability of proteins may be permissible. During the evolution of antibiotic resistance, mutations that confer drug resistance often have pleiotropic effects on the structure and function of antibiotic-target proteins, usually essential metabolic enzymes. In the present study, we show that trimethoprim (TMP)-resistant alleles of dihydrofolate reductase from Escherichia coli (EcDHFR) harboring the Trp30Gly, Trp30Arg or Trp30Cys mutations are significantly less stable than the wild-type, making them prone to aggregation and proteolysis. This destabilization is associated with a lower expression level, resulting in a fitness cost and negative epistasis with other TMP-resistant mutations in EcDHFR. Using structure-based mutational analysis, we show that perturbation of critical stabilizing hydrophobic interactions in wild-type EcDHFR enzyme explains the phenotypes of Trp30 mutants. Surprisingly, though crucial for the stability of EcDHFR, significant sequence variation is found at this site among bacterial dihydrofolate reductases (DHFRs). Mutational and computational analyses in EcDHFR and in DHFR enzymes from Staphylococcus aureus and Mycobacterium tuberculosis demonstrate that natural variation at this site and its interacting hydrophobic residues modulates TMP resistance in other bacterial DHFRs as well, and may explain the different susceptibilities of bacterial pathogens to TMP. Our study demonstrates that trade-offs between structural stability and function can influence innate drug resistance as well as the potential for mutationally acquired drug resistance of an enzyme.

Revisiting bacterial cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterases: cyclic AMP hydrolysis and beyond.

Cyclic-3',5'-adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) is a universal second messenger that regulates vital activities in bacteria and eukaryotes. Enzymes that hydrolyze cAMP, called phosphodiesterases (PDEs), negatively regulate the levels of this messenger molecule and are therefore crucial for signal 'termination'. In this minireview, I shall summarize the available literature on bacterial cAMP-PDEs, with particular emphasis on enzymes belonging to the ubiquitously encoded Class III PDE family exemplified by CpdA from Escherichia coli and Rv0805 from Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Using available biochemical, structural and biological information, I shall make a case for re-examining the functions of these enzymes as merely regulators of intrabacterial cAMP levels and suggest that some members of this class may have evolved cAMP-independent functions as well. Finally, I shall highlight the major lacunae in our understanding of these enzymes and present unanswered questions in the area.

Metallophosphoesterases: structural fidelity with functional promiscuity.

Calcineurin-like metallophosphoesterases (MPEs) form a large superfamily of binuclear metal-ion-centre-containing enzymes that hydrolyse phosphomono-, phosphodi- or phosphotri-esters in a metal-dependent manner. The MPE domain is found in Mre11/SbcD DNA-repair enzymes, mammalian phosphoprotein phosphatases, acid sphingomyelinases, purple acid phosphatases, nucleotidases and bacterial cyclic nucleotide phosphodiesterases. Despite this functional diversity, MPEs show a remarkably similar structural fold and active-site architecture. In the present review, we summarize the available structural, biochemical and functional information on these proteins. We also describe how diversification and specialization of the core MPE fold in various MPEs is achieved by amino acid substitution in their active sites, metal ions and regulatory effects of accessory domains. Finally, we discuss emerging roles of these proteins as non-catalytic protein-interaction scaffolds. Thus we view the MPE superfamily as a set of proteins with a highly conserved structural core that allows embellishment to result in dramatic and niche-specific diversification of function.

Linking carbon metabolism to carotenoid production in mycobacteria using Raman spectroscopy.

Bacteria can utilize multiple sources of carbon for growth, and for pathogenic bacteria like Mycobacterium tuberculosis, this ability is crucial for survival within the host. In addition, phenotypic changes are seen in mycobacteria grown under different carbon sources. In this study, we use Raman spectroscopy to analyze the biochemical components present in M. smegmatis cells when grown in three differently metabolized carbon sources. Our results show that carotenoid biosynthesis is enhanced when M. smegmatis is grown in glucose compared to glycerol and acetate. We demonstrate that this difference is most likely due to transcriptional upregulation of the carotenoid biosynthesis operon (crt) mediated by higher levels of the stress-responsive sigma factor SigF. Moreover, we find that increased SigF and carotenoid levels correlate with greater resistance of glucose-grown cells to oxidative stress. Thus, we demonstrate the use of Raman spectroscopy in unraveling unknown aspects of mycobacterial physiology and describe a novel effect of carbon source variation on mycobacteria.

The non-catalytic "cap domain" of a mycobacterial metallophosphoesterase regulates its expression and localization in the cell.

Despite highly conserved core catalytic domains, members of the metallophosphoesterase (MPE) superfamily perform diverse and crucial functions ranging from nucleotide and nucleic acid metabolism to phospholipid hydrolysis. Unique structural elements outside of the catalytic core called "cap domains" are thought to provide specialization to these enzymes; however, no directed study has been performed to substantiate this. The cap domain of Rv0805, an MPE from Mycobacterium tuberculosis, is located C-terminal to its catalytic domain and is dispensable for the catalytic activity of this enzyme in vitro. We show here that this C-terminal extension (CTE) mediates in vivo localization of the protein to the cell membrane and cell wall as well as modulates expression levels of Rv0805 in mycobacteria. We also demonstrate that Rv0805 interacts with the cell wall of mycobacteria, possibly with the mycolyl-arabinogalactan-peptidoglycan complex, by virtue of its C terminus, a hitherto unknown property of this MPE. Using a panel of mutant proteins, we identify interactions between active site residues of Rv0805 and the CTE that determine its association with the cell wall. Finally, we show that Rv0805 and a truncated mutant devoid of the CTE produce different phenotypic effects when expressed in mycobacteria. Our study thus provides a detailed dissection of the functions of the cap domain of an MPE and suggests that the repertoire of cellular functions of MPEs cannot be understood without exploring the modulatory effects of these subdomains.

Genomic mapping of cAMP receptor protein (CRP Mt) in Mycobacterium tuberculosis: relation to transcriptional start sites and the role of CRPMt as a transcription factor.

Chromatin immunoprecipitation identified 191 binding sites of Mycobacterium tuberculosis cAMP receptor protein (CRP(Mt)) at endogenous expression levels using a specific α-CRP(Mt) antibody. Under these native conditions an equal distribution between intragenic and intergenic locations was observed. CRP(Mt) binding overlapped a palindromic consensus sequence. Analysis by RNA sequencing revealed widespread changes in transcriptional profile in a mutant strain lacking CRP(Mt) during exponential growth, and in response to nutrient starvation. Differential expression of genes with a CRP(Mt)-binding site represented only a minor portion of this transcriptional reprogramming with ∼ 19% of those representing transcriptional regulators potentially controlled by CRP(Mt). The subset of genes that are differentially expressed in the deletion mutant under both culture conditions conformed to a pattern resembling canonical CRP regulation in Escherichia coli, with binding close to the transcriptional start site associated with repression and upstream binding with activation. CRP(Mt) can function as a classical transcription factor in M. tuberculosis, though this occurs at only a subset of CRP(Mt)-binding sites.

Overexpression of the Rv0805 phosphodiesterase elicits a cAMP-independent transcriptional response.

The Rv0805 gene in Mycobacterium tuberculosis encodes a metallophosphoesterase which shows cAMP-hydrolytic activity. Overexpression of Rv0805 has been used as a tool to lower intracellular cAMP levels and thereby elucidate the roles of cAMP in mycobacteria. Here we show that levels of cAMP in M. tuberculosis were lowered by only ∼30% following overexpression of Rv0805, and transcript levels of a number of genes, which include those associated with virulence and the methyl citrate cycle, were altered. The genes that showed altered expression were distinct from those differentially regulated in a strain deleted for the cAMP-receptor protein (CRP(Mt)), consistent with the relatively low dependence on cAMP of CRP(Mt) binding to DNA. Using mutants of Rv0805 we show that the transcriptional signature of Rv0805 overexpression is a combination of catalysis-dependent and independent effects, and that the structurally flexible C-terminus of Rv0805 is crucial for the catalysis-independent effects of the protein. Our study demonstrates the dissociation of Rv0805 and cAMP-regulated gene expression, and reveals alternate functions for this phosphodiesterase from M. tuberculosis.

Signalling mechanisms in Mycobacteria.

The importance of inter- and intracellular signal transduction in all forms of life cannot be underestimated. A large number of genes dedicated to cellular signalling are found in almost all sequenced genomes, and Mycobacteria are no exception. What appears to be interesting in Mycobacteria is that well characterized signalling mechanisms used by bacteria, such as the histidine-aspartate phosphorelay seen in two-component systems, are found alongside signalling components that closely mimic those seen in higher eukaryotes. This review will describe the important contribution made by researchers in India towards the identification and characterization of proteins involved in two-component signalling, protein phosphorylation and cyclic nucleotide metabolism.

A mycobacterial cyclic AMP phosphodiesterase that moonlights as a modifier of cell wall permeability.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis utilizes many mechanisms to establish itself within the macrophage, and bacterially derived cAMP is important in modulating the host cellular response. Although the genome of M. tuberculosis is endowed with a number of mammalian-like adenylyl cyclases, only a single cAMP phosphodiesterase has been identified that can decrease levels of cAMP produced by the bacterium. We present the crystal structure of the full-length and sole cAMP phosphodiesterase, Rv0805, found in M. tuberculosis, whose orthologs are present only in the genomes of slow growing and pathogenic mycobacteria. The dimeric core catalytic domain of Rv0805 adopts a metallophosphoesterase-fold, and the C-terminal region builds the active site and contributes to multiple substrate utilization. Localization of Rv0805 to the cell wall is dependent on its C terminus, and expression of either wild type or mutationally inactivated Rv0805 in M. smegmatis alters cell permeability to hydrophobic cytotoxic compounds. Rv0805 may therefore play a key role in the pathogenicity of mycobacteria, not only by hydrolyzing bacterial cAMP, but also by moonlighting as a protein that can alter cell wall functioning.