Is there any purpose in classifying subtrochanteric fractures? The reproducibility of four classification systems.

INTRODUCTION: Classification systems are used for communication, planning treatment options, predicting outcomes and research purposes. The majority of subtrochanteric fractures are now treated with intramedullary nails and therefore questioning the need for classification. OBJECTIVES: To assess the intra- and inter-observer reproducibility of the Seinsheimer, AO and Russell-Taylor (RT) classification systems and to assess a new simple system (MCG). MATERIALS AND METHODS: The MCG system was developed to alert the surgeon to potential hazards: type 1-subtrochanteric fracture (ST#) with intact trochanters, type 2-ST# involving greater trochanter (entry point for nailing difficult), and type 3-ST# involving lesser trochanter (most unstable). Thirty-two anteroposterior and lateral radiographs of subtrochanteric fractures were classified independently for each of the 4 classification systems by 4 observers on 2 separate occasions. RESULTS: The intra- and inter-observer variation was poor in all systems (highest Kappa 0.35). MCG had the best reproducibility followed by RT, then AO and Seinsheimer. The data were re-analysed to determine whether the findings were due to the presence of too many subgroups and whether the observers could more accurately identify important individual subclassifications: Seinsheimer 3a, AO31-A3.1, RT 1 or 2, RT a or b, and MCG3. The MCG3 had the narrowest ranges for intra- and inter-observer reproducibility. CONCLUSIONS: The classification systems analysed in this study have poor reproducibility and seem to be of little value in predicting the outcome of intramedullary nailing as all of the fractures achieved union. The MCG system may be of some use in alerting the surgeon to potential problems.

The Kenya orthopaedic project: surgical outcomes of a travelling multidisciplinary team.

We report the results of six trauma and orthopaedic projects to Kenya in the last three years. The aims are to deliver both a trauma service and teaching within two hospitals; one a district hospital near Mount Kenya in Nanyuki, the other the largest public hospital in Kenya in Mombasa. The Kenya Orthopaedic Project team consists of a wide range of multidisciplinary professionals that allows the experience to be shared across those specialties. A follow-up clinic is held three months after each mission to review the patients. To our knowledge there are no reported outcomes in the literature for similar projects. A total of 211 operations have been performed and 400 patients seen during the projects. Most cases were fractures of the lower limb; we have been able to follow up 163 patients (77%) who underwent surgical treatment. We reflect on the results so far and discuss potential improvements for future missions.

Lumbosacral fusion using the Boucher technique in combination with a posterolateral bone graft.

This study evaluates the clinical and radiological results of using the facet screw fixation technique described by Boucher in combination with a posterolateral fusion rather than a posterior fusion for symptomatic degenerative disease of the lumbosacral junction. It is a retrospective review of 38 consecutive patients with an average follow-up of 28 months. Radiologically, all patients had a solid fusion. Clinically, 23 patients (60%) had excellent results, 11 patients (29%) good results, 3 patients (8%) fair results and 1 patient (3%) had a poor result. There were no neurological complications. The findings support the view that the Boucher technique of facet joint fixation in combination with a posterolateral fusion is a safe and effective method of dealing with chronic symptoms relating to degenerative changes at the lumbosacral junction. The authors stress the importance of patient selection and attention to operative technique if the clinical results are to correlate with the results of fusion.

The relationship between the strength of supination of the forearm and rotation of the shoulder.

In children with obstetric brachial plexus palsy (OBPP) who develop an internal rotation deformity of the shoulder, release of subscapularis improves the range of external rotation of the shoulder and the strength of supination of the forearm. We studied the strength of supination in 35 healthy adult volunteers at 45 degrees of both internal and external rotation. The mean and maximum torques were greater in external than internal rotation by 8.7% and 7.5%, respectively. This was highly significant (p < 0.0001). The increased strength of supination in external rotation is probably because the maximum power of biceps, particularly the long head, may be exerted in this position. In children the difference may be even greater due to anatomical differences causing the dramatic increases in the strength of supination after surgery for OBPP. In adults our findings suggest that the supination exercises which are undertaken after injury or surgery to the forearm or wrist should be performed in external rotation.